What do you think?
Rate this book
Ivory Carver #1
Mother Earth Father Sky
In a time before history, in a harsh and beautiful land near the top of the world, womanhood comes cruelly and suddenly to beautiful, young Chagak. Surviving the brutal massacre of her tribe, she sets out across the icy waters off America's northwest coast on an astonishing odyssey that will reveal to Chagak powerful secrets of the earth and sky... and the mysteries of love and loss.
390 pages, Mass Market Paperback
First published January 1, 1990
393 people are currently reading
6604 people want to read
About the author
Sue Harrison
30 books284 followersSue Harrison is the author of six critically acclaimed and internationally bestselling novels. Mother Earth Father Sky, My Sister the Moon and Brother Wind make up The Ivory Carver Trilogy, an epic adventure set in prehistoric Alaska. Song of the River, Cry of the Wind and Call Down the Stars comprise The Storyteller Trilogy. Sue’s young adult book, SISU, was released by Thunder Bay Press . Her newest novel, The Midwife's Touch, first book in The Wish Thief Trilogy was released in February 2023. It was chosen as an Upper Peninsula of Michigan Notable Book and selected as a semi-finalist in the Society of Midland Author's 2024 Adult Fiction Awards. In 2025, her middle-grade readers chapter book, Rescuing Crash, the Good Dog was released by Modern History Press.
Sue Harrison was born in Lansing, Michigan. The first of five children, she was raised in the town of Pickford in Michigan’s Upper Peninsula where she lives with her husband, a retired high school principal. They are blessed with a daughter and a son, a daughter-in-law and two grandchildren.
A graduate of Pickford High School, Harrison graduated summa cum laude from Lake Superior State University with a B.A. in English Language and Literature. She was named Lake Superior State University’s Distinguished Alumna in 1992, and served eight years on the university’s Board of Regents.
Harrison’s first novel, Mother Earth Father Sky, was published in 1990 by Doubleday (hardcover) and Avon (paperback). It was nominated in the states of Michigan and Washington for the Reader’s Choice Award among high school students, and was one of ten books chosen for “Battle of the Books,” a statewide student reading competition in Alaska. The novel as had success in both the adult and young adult markets, and was a national bestseller. It was selected by the American Library Association as one of 1991′s Best Books for Young Adults.
Harrison’s second novel, My Sister the Moon, (Doubleday/Avon 1992) has also received recognition by reading and school groups throughout the United States and was a Baker and Taylor top ten in library sales. Both Mother Earth Father Sky and My Sister the Moon were Main Selections of the Literary Guild Book Club and alternate selections of the Doubleday Book Club. Brother Wind, Harrison’s third novel was released in hardcover by William Morrow, October 1994, and in 1995 as an Avon paperback. The novel was chosen as an alternate selection by both the Literary Guild and Doubleday Book Clubs. Song of the River and Cry of the Wind were both published by Avon Hardcover/Avon paperback, a division of Hearst Books. The third book of The Storyteller Trilogy, Call down the stars was published by Morrow/Avon in 2001 and 2002. It was featured alternate of the Literary Guild and Doubleday Book Clubs.
Harrison’s books have also been published in Canada, Great Britain, Australia, New Zealand, The Netherlands, Belgium, Sweden, Germany, Italy, Spain, Iceland, Denmark, Norway, Austria, Portugal, Japan, France, Finland, and South America.
Harrison is represented by Victoria Skurnick of the Levine Greenberg Rostan Literary Agency.
Sue Harrison was born in Lansing, Michigan. The first of five children, she was raised in the town of Pickford in Michigan’s Upper Peninsula where she lives with her husband, a retired high school principal. They are blessed with a daughter and a son, a daughter-in-law and two grandchildren.
A graduate of Pickford High School, Harrison graduated summa cum laude from Lake Superior State University with a B.A. in English Language and Literature. She was named Lake Superior State University’s Distinguished Alumna in 1992, and served eight years on the university’s Board of Regents.
Harrison’s first novel, Mother Earth Father Sky, was published in 1990 by Doubleday (hardcover) and Avon (paperback). It was nominated in the states of Michigan and Washington for the Reader’s Choice Award among high school students, and was one of ten books chosen for “Battle of the Books,” a statewide student reading competition in Alaska. The novel as had success in both the adult and young adult markets, and was a national bestseller. It was selected by the American Library Association as one of 1991′s Best Books for Young Adults.
Harrison’s second novel, My Sister the Moon, (Doubleday/Avon 1992) has also received recognition by reading and school groups throughout the United States and was a Baker and Taylor top ten in library sales. Both Mother Earth Father Sky and My Sister the Moon were Main Selections of the Literary Guild Book Club and alternate selections of the Doubleday Book Club. Brother Wind, Harrison’s third novel was released in hardcover by William Morrow, October 1994, and in 1995 as an Avon paperback. The novel was chosen as an alternate selection by both the Literary Guild and Doubleday Book Clubs. Song of the River and Cry of the Wind were both published by Avon Hardcover/Avon paperback, a division of Hearst Books. The third book of The Storyteller Trilogy, Call down the stars was published by Morrow/Avon in 2001 and 2002. It was featured alternate of the Literary Guild and Doubleday Book Clubs.
Harrison’s books have also been published in Canada, Great Britain, Australia, New Zealand, The Netherlands, Belgium, Sweden, Germany, Italy, Spain, Iceland, Denmark, Norway, Austria, Portugal, Japan, France, Finland, and South America.
Harrison is represented by Victoria Skurnick of the Levine Greenberg Rostan Literary Agency.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 304 reviews
March 9, 2015
Mother Earth Father Sky is the first book in a trilogy that takes us into the lives of an ancient North American people in Alaska. If that sounds boring, don’t be fooled.
To be honest, I hardly know what to say about this book. At the writing of this review (first posted on my blog), having just finished reading it I’m barely back to the here-and-now, and the story of Chagak is still fresh in my mind. To say that Sue Harrison wrote an amazing prehistoric fiction novel scarcely describes what she masterfully accomplished. Over the course of nine years she studied, researched and lived in her creative mind the tale of a long ago culture in Alaska, focusing on one Aleut woman’s struggle to survive and overcome a very harsh reality. That woman, Chagak, lived in a primitive time consisting of warrior tribes, legends, crude customs, myths, and magic, but also love, family ties, and community. The author made it all come alive through the power of the written word in a very easy-to-read style. I was held from the beginning of this book to its last page – left wanting to read more about the people I had come to know.
This book is not newly released but was published in 1990. I was fortunate to be gifted a copy and I’m so glad to have received it. If you come across Mother Earth Father Sky and you are not offended by the cruel reality and graphic descriptions of the belief system of prehistoric man, then do grab the opportunity to read this book.
To be honest, I hardly know what to say about this book. At the writing of this review (first posted on my blog), having just finished reading it I’m barely back to the here-and-now, and the story of Chagak is still fresh in my mind. To say that Sue Harrison wrote an amazing prehistoric fiction novel scarcely describes what she masterfully accomplished. Over the course of nine years she studied, researched and lived in her creative mind the tale of a long ago culture in Alaska, focusing on one Aleut woman’s struggle to survive and overcome a very harsh reality. That woman, Chagak, lived in a primitive time consisting of warrior tribes, legends, crude customs, myths, and magic, but also love, family ties, and community. The author made it all come alive through the power of the written word in a very easy-to-read style. I was held from the beginning of this book to its last page – left wanting to read more about the people I had come to know.
This book is not newly released but was published in 1990. I was fortunate to be gifted a copy and I’m so glad to have received it. If you come across Mother Earth Father Sky and you are not offended by the cruel reality and graphic descriptions of the belief system of prehistoric man, then do grab the opportunity to read this book.
May 27, 2015
Set in 7056 BC, this was a fascinating look at the prehistoric inhabitants of the Aleutian Islands. I learned quite a bit about their customs, beliefs and hardships, which is what I liked most about this book. I loved reading about the survival skills and the respect the people had towards nature and all its gifts. I admired the young teenage girl, Chagak, who lost her entire family during a massacre of her village at the beginning of the book. She showed such strength and determination. The old man, Shuganan, was an interesting character, with his spiritual and mystical aura. He was a man of peace, rather than violence, and his abundance of wisdom helped Chagak grow even more as a woman. I recommend this book to anyone interested in historical fiction and Native American culture. 3.5 stars rounded to 4 stars.
August 14, 2012
This is the first book in one of my most favorite series in the world. And the first time I truly fell in love with a book. I read this when I was a teenager and I still often go back to reread it. In fact, this may be my favorite story (the trilogy as a whole) - I was fortunate to have a good boyfriend who bought me the three hardcovers signed by the author especially for my birthday!
Chagak, the main character, lives in a world about 9000 years ago in the frigid Aleutian islands off the coast of Alaska. The story is based on her fictional life set in a very real primitive culture. Her people survive through harsh winters, rogue waves, volcanic activity, tribal fighting and any other hazard imaginable. It is an unusual experience to have this culture so richly painted and to see life through this young woman's eyes. She is a quiet heroine - she is not a warrior princess or doesn't possess any special powers - she is just a strong young woman who adapts to her difficult circumstances and not only survives, but thrives, growing from a girl to a woman.
The writing is good that you have vivid images of the setting in your head, you can feel the softness of the clothing, and almost taste the prepared foods. You get a very real sense of the culture without judging them at the same time. The story makes you want to know more of this time and this area. And I definitely recommend finishing this trilogy as it only gets better...
Chagak, the main character, lives in a world about 9000 years ago in the frigid Aleutian islands off the coast of Alaska. The story is based on her fictional life set in a very real primitive culture. Her people survive through harsh winters, rogue waves, volcanic activity, tribal fighting and any other hazard imaginable. It is an unusual experience to have this culture so richly painted and to see life through this young woman's eyes. She is a quiet heroine - she is not a warrior princess or doesn't possess any special powers - she is just a strong young woman who adapts to her difficult circumstances and not only survives, but thrives, growing from a girl to a woman.
The writing is good that you have vivid images of the setting in your head, you can feel the softness of the clothing, and almost taste the prepared foods. You get a very real sense of the culture without judging them at the same time. The story makes you want to know more of this time and this area. And I definitely recommend finishing this trilogy as it only gets better...
November 27, 2020
A decent stone age novel, at last! I have to say I really rather enjoyed this one. It opened strongly, grabbing onto my interest, and it kept a hold of it by adding more twists and obstacles that got me desperately rooting for the protagonist, Chagak, and wanting to find out the resolution. The descriptions are vivid without being overly long – and in this respect Mother Earth Father Sky is, I would say, better than Clan of the Cave Bear. Speaking of Clan of the Cave Bear, I think the two books are definitely comparable in quality – and when I say that I refer only to the first book, not the later books in Jean Auel’s series. Both feature compelling plots with plenty of obstacles to overcome, although this book may have the edge in being more concisely expressed.
However, that said, I didn’t think Mother Earth Father Sky was amazing. In the final third of the book the protagonists have overcome the most pressing obstacles in their path, and it’s an easier ride to the end; likewise I had less reason to worry about what was happening. There was never any doubt in my mind that As a result, I admit I switched off a bit and found myself skimming a little at the end. Still, I’m pleased at last to have found a stone age novel that isn’t dry as dust, filled with purple prose, or containing New Age pseudoscience – it’s been a long time of searching.
7 out of 10.
However, that said, I didn’t think Mother Earth Father Sky was amazing. In the final third of the book the protagonists have overcome the most pressing obstacles in their path, and it’s an easier ride to the end; likewise I had less reason to worry about what was happening. There was never any doubt in my mind that As a result, I admit I switched off a bit and found myself skimming a little at the end. Still, I’m pleased at last to have found a stone age novel that isn’t dry as dust, filled with purple prose, or containing New Age pseudoscience – it’s been a long time of searching.
7 out of 10.
January 28, 2008
I read this book about 15 years ago and loved it. The author spent 4 years researching the Aleut people and then put together a fabulous trilogy. Her writing is excellent-visual, and I fell right into the book. I had trouble finding the books, but Sue Harrison has a website now so you can order directly from her. I have just finished reading, and it was as good as I remembered.
November 27, 2015
3 1/2 stars
This is a story of Chagak, a young woman who at the brink of womanhood, loses her entire tribe to a group of killers known as the Short Ones. Along with her infant brother she tries to find a way to survive. Woman are not hunters in this civilization, their “spirit” is not strong enough, so when Chagak lands on a beach that belongs to an old man called Shuganan, her hopes of survival increases.
Shuganan is an outcast, a man with the power of capturing spirits in little figurines and is clearly in need of companionship and family.
Chagak fills the role of surrogate granddaughter admirably but their lives are harsh and difficult and full of tragedy. The descriptions of hunting, housing and honouring spirits formed a central part of the story however I would have liked to understand the dynamics and politics between the different tribes better.
Perhaps that will be elaborated on in the sequel.
Its impossible not to compare this to The Clan of the Cave Bear as both are novels are set in prehistoric time. I think Clan is a faster paced and slightly more interesting in its elaborative details however Chagak was portrayed in a more honest light than Ayla (from The Clan of the Cave Bear) who always seemed to magically know how to do anything.
I don't want to give away too much information, but the book is worth the read if you have an interest in prehistoric novels.
PS: My advice is to listen to it on audio rather than reading the printed version.
This is a story of Chagak, a young woman who at the brink of womanhood, loses her entire tribe to a group of killers known as the Short Ones. Along with her infant brother she tries to find a way to survive. Woman are not hunters in this civilization, their “spirit” is not strong enough, so when Chagak lands on a beach that belongs to an old man called Shuganan, her hopes of survival increases.
Shuganan is an outcast, a man with the power of capturing spirits in little figurines and is clearly in need of companionship and family.
Chagak fills the role of surrogate granddaughter admirably but their lives are harsh and difficult and full of tragedy. The descriptions of hunting, housing and honouring spirits formed a central part of the story however I would have liked to understand the dynamics and politics between the different tribes better.
Perhaps that will be elaborated on in the sequel.
Its impossible not to compare this to The Clan of the Cave Bear as both are novels are set in prehistoric time. I think Clan is a faster paced and slightly more interesting in its elaborative details however Chagak was portrayed in a more honest light than Ayla (from The Clan of the Cave Bear) who always seemed to magically know how to do anything.
I don't want to give away too much information, but the book is worth the read if you have an interest in prehistoric novels.
PS: My advice is to listen to it on audio rather than reading the printed version.
June 3, 2021
(review in English below)
Tenho pena de não ter tido tempo para escrever algo consistente sobre todos os livros desta trilogia.
Apesar de se tornar algo repetitiva nalguns aspectos (sobretudo nas referências às construções, ferramentas, utensílios, alimentação, etc.), a história nunca perde o ritmo, havendo sempre algo a acontecer que nos prende a atenção e nos mantém preocupad@s com o destino dos personagens.
Embora possa tornar-se um pouco cansativo, recomendo ler os 3 livros de seguida, pois são muitas personagens, de várias tribos diferentes, que estabelecem relações e se movimentam entre as diferentes povoações, tornando o acompanhamento da acção por vezes desafiante.
Gostei mais dos dois primeiros volumes, provavelmente por se centrarem mais em personagens femininas e nos seus problemas e preocupações, mas também na sua força e resiliência.
Recomendo esta trilogia especialmente a quem se interesse por ficção pré-histórica, pois parece estar baseado numa pesquisa extensa e rigorosa do modo de viver dos povos do Alasca nesta época (cerca de 7000 anos a.C).
I regret not having had the time to write something consistent about all books in this trilogy.
While somewhat repetitive regarding some aspects (mostly when talking about the constructions, tools, food, etc.), the story keeps the pace; there's always something happening that draws you in and keeps you wondering about the characters' fate.
Although it may become a bit tiresome, I would recommend reading all 3 books in a row, because there's a lot of characters from several tribes, establishing relationships and moving from one settlement to another, which makes it sometimes difficult to keep up with what's going on.
I enjoyed the first two books more, probably due to the fact that they focus more on female characters, their problems and worries, but also their strength and resilience.
I recommend this trilogy especially to those who are interested in pre-historical fiction, as it seems to be based in extensive and thorough research on the way of living of Alaskan people at this time (around 7000 BC).
Tenho pena de não ter tido tempo para escrever algo consistente sobre todos os livros desta trilogia.
Apesar de se tornar algo repetitiva nalguns aspectos (sobretudo nas referências às construções, ferramentas, utensílios, alimentação, etc.), a história nunca perde o ritmo, havendo sempre algo a acontecer que nos prende a atenção e nos mantém preocupad@s com o destino dos personagens.
Embora possa tornar-se um pouco cansativo, recomendo ler os 3 livros de seguida, pois são muitas personagens, de várias tribos diferentes, que estabelecem relações e se movimentam entre as diferentes povoações, tornando o acompanhamento da acção por vezes desafiante.
Gostei mais dos dois primeiros volumes, provavelmente por se centrarem mais em personagens femininas e nos seus problemas e preocupações, mas também na sua força e resiliência.
Recomendo esta trilogia especialmente a quem se interesse por ficção pré-histórica, pois parece estar baseado numa pesquisa extensa e rigorosa do modo de viver dos povos do Alasca nesta época (cerca de 7000 anos a.C).
I regret not having had the time to write something consistent about all books in this trilogy.
While somewhat repetitive regarding some aspects (mostly when talking about the constructions, tools, food, etc.), the story keeps the pace; there's always something happening that draws you in and keeps you wondering about the characters' fate.
Although it may become a bit tiresome, I would recommend reading all 3 books in a row, because there's a lot of characters from several tribes, establishing relationships and moving from one settlement to another, which makes it sometimes difficult to keep up with what's going on.
I enjoyed the first two books more, probably due to the fact that they focus more on female characters, their problems and worries, but also their strength and resilience.
I recommend this trilogy especially to those who are interested in pre-historical fiction, as it seems to be based in extensive and thorough research on the way of living of Alaskan people at this time (around 7000 BC).
January 30, 2021
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
This is a piece of “prehistoric fiction” that’s been sitting on my ebook shelf for a pretty long time and I don’t know why I took so long to read it. There were a lot native Aleutian words with a heroine who tugged at my heartstrings. A very little bit of looking up and I discovered that this author was a student of Native American languages and actually researched at an archaeological dig on an island in the Bering Sea. The story is set circa 7000 B.C. (Ice Age North America) and Harrison quickly establishes a world of First Men, Short Ones and Whale Hunters, and then takes you on journey with Chagak as she traverses her cold world with her baby brother, the only two survivors from her village that was raided by a war-like tribe. This is the first of a trilogy and lucky for me, I have all three books. I’m starting the next one today.
This is a piece of “prehistoric fiction” that’s been sitting on my ebook shelf for a pretty long time and I don’t know why I took so long to read it. There were a lot native Aleutian words with a heroine who tugged at my heartstrings. A very little bit of looking up and I discovered that this author was a student of Native American languages and actually researched at an archaeological dig on an island in the Bering Sea. The story is set circa 7000 B.C. (Ice Age North America) and Harrison quickly establishes a world of First Men, Short Ones and Whale Hunters, and then takes you on journey with Chagak as she traverses her cold world with her baby brother, the only two survivors from her village that was raided by a war-like tribe. This is the first of a trilogy and lucky for me, I have all three books. I’m starting the next one today.
September 7, 2013
Being a fantasy lover, I chose this book to take a break from my usual genre. I remembered liking "Island of the Blue Dolphins" and "Sweetgrass" as a child -- so I thought I would like this one. Though, my interest was low in the beginning, I'm so glad I stuck with it. Nearing the final pages, I can't put it down. I will go on to the next book. If you're looking for a change, I highly recommend the step out of your comfort zone to Chagak's world. Enjoy!
October 6, 2012
I won't summarize this book since others have written some very good synopses already. I'll just talk about what grabbed me.
Harrison's rich prose describes a civilization she has obviously researched very carefully. I was caught up right away in the lives of a Native American tribe and enjoying the read when BANG! the end of the first chapter one stuns you as though someone swung a whalebone club over your head. From then on, the tension never lets up as the main character Chagak struggles to survive: first for her brother, then for the old man who becomes her surrogate grandfather, then for her own child.
This book is not only a pleasure to read, it's an education. I haven't studied anthropology much, or the lives of the Pacific NW tribes who live in the Aleutian islands. This book brings home the beauty and dangers of the islands. Chagak and her people are amazingly resourceful, making use of every plant and animal available to them. They are always keenly aware that the sea and wind can turn on them in a moment, robbing them of their homes and lives. By the end of the book, I felt so much respect for these early people, for their ingenuity and self-sufficiency, their knowledge of nature.
Harrison's rich prose describes a civilization she has obviously researched very carefully. I was caught up right away in the lives of a Native American tribe and enjoying the read when BANG! the end of the first chapter one stuns you as though someone swung a whalebone club over your head. From then on, the tension never lets up as the main character Chagak struggles to survive: first for her brother, then for the old man who becomes her surrogate grandfather, then for her own child.
This book is not only a pleasure to read, it's an education. I haven't studied anthropology much, or the lives of the Pacific NW tribes who live in the Aleutian islands. This book brings home the beauty and dangers of the islands. Chagak and her people are amazingly resourceful, making use of every plant and animal available to them. They are always keenly aware that the sea and wind can turn on them in a moment, robbing them of their homes and lives. By the end of the book, I felt so much respect for these early people, for their ingenuity and self-sufficiency, their knowledge of nature.
August 3, 2019
Me ha gustado especialmente la labor antropológica realizada por la autora, tanto para dotar a los personajes de motivaciones adecuadas a la psique de gente de su era, como para situarlos en una cultura lingüística y material verosímil.
July 3, 2025
Une histoire très intéressante et éducative sur les peuples autochtones qui habitaient les îles Aléoutiennes il y a 8000 ans. L'autrice a fait beaucoup de recherches pour construire son récit, on apprend sur leur mode de vie, la façon qu'ils construisaient leurs outils/habitations/vêtements, leur alimentation, leurs croyances spirituelles et leur traditions.
C'est une histoire très émouvante, j'ai été touchée par l'histoire de Chagak et je ne pouvais la sortir de mon esprit.
C'est une histoire très émouvante, j'ai été touchée par l'histoire de Chagak et je ne pouvais la sortir de mon esprit.
February 16, 2025
Beautifully written story about a woman, Chagak living in Alaska during the Ice Age in the prehistoric Aleut tribes. Sue Harrison paints a clear picture in your head about this time.
February 15, 2020
I picked this book up from a free library while traveling in South Africa, and had never heard of it and would likely never have picked it up in the shop. There is a bit of fun in reading something that is very much out of your wheelhouse, chosen for you by happenstance.
This is a tale of life on the Aleutian Islands of 7000 BCE at the end of the Ice Age. The story is very intimate and tightly focused on the many trials and tragedies of Chagak, a young woman who suffers from some very difficult and cruel losses early in her life. I was quite surprised by many of the specific events that occurred, Harrison doesn't shy away from showcasing violence and general misery. Interestingly, Chagak's people and most of the other tribes of the islands are largely peaceful, and aren't prepared in the least for the arrival of the Short Ones, a tribe who have adopted a novel culture of raiding and murder (a strange activity that other people, mystified, refer to as "hunting men"), a shift that unfortunately seems to point towards developments in the future of humankind.
The book has a strong feminist streak throughout, but in a more realistic and nuanced manner than something like The Clan of the Cave Bear for instance. Chagak is a strong and resilient heroine, but she is definitely constrained by a culture that values men much more highly than women, and where she must constantly deal with male power in her life. Harrison does a great job of looking at the (fictional/hypothetical) details of a late Ice Age life which is strongly influenced by modern Aleut life (in fact, other than the element of the Short Ones violent raiding culture being a new development, there doesn't particularly seem any reason that this book is set in 7000 BCE rather than at any time prior to European contact many thousands of years later).
Overall this was an enjoyable, engaging read... Happy I happened to pick it up!
This is a tale of life on the Aleutian Islands of 7000 BCE at the end of the Ice Age. The story is very intimate and tightly focused on the many trials and tragedies of Chagak, a young woman who suffers from some very difficult and cruel losses early in her life. I was quite surprised by many of the specific events that occurred, Harrison doesn't shy away from showcasing violence and general misery. Interestingly, Chagak's people and most of the other tribes of the islands are largely peaceful, and aren't prepared in the least for the arrival of the Short Ones, a tribe who have adopted a novel culture of raiding and murder (a strange activity that other people, mystified, refer to as "hunting men"), a shift that unfortunately seems to point towards developments in the future of humankind.
The book has a strong feminist streak throughout, but in a more realistic and nuanced manner than something like The Clan of the Cave Bear for instance. Chagak is a strong and resilient heroine, but she is definitely constrained by a culture that values men much more highly than women, and where she must constantly deal with male power in her life. Harrison does a great job of looking at the (fictional/hypothetical) details of a late Ice Age life which is strongly influenced by modern Aleut life (in fact, other than the element of the Short Ones violent raiding culture being a new development, there doesn't particularly seem any reason that this book is set in 7000 BCE rather than at any time prior to European contact many thousands of years later).
Overall this was an enjoyable, engaging read... Happy I happened to pick it up!
August 28, 2013
Find this and other reviews at: http://flashlightcommentary.blogspot....
Prehistories are for a hard sell for me. I don't know why, but they are difficult for me to get into so when I manage to find one that holds my interest, I tend to take notice which brings me to Mother Earth Father Sky by Sue Harrison.
Like Song of the River, this piece is character heavy, but what is so remarkable is how distinct, well-rounded and realistic each cast member feels. I can't imagine what goes into painting the motivations, personality and emotional struggles of so characters so vividly, but Harrison's effort certainly isn't wasted. In point of fact, I feel the authentic quality of her cast is what makes not just this piece, but her entire body of work so exceptional.
Speaking of relatable characters, I should probably mention my attraction to Chagak. Her path is a difficult one, but as a woman who had to overcome sexual abuse, I really admire Harrison for creating a character that doesn't allow the experience to define her life. I've seen authors attempt this story line before, but can honestly say few have pulled it off as well.
Strong characterization isn't the only aspect of Harrison's work worth mentioning. Her books are long, but they are also overflowing with cultural history. I might be going out on a limb, but I think it safe to say Harrison puts as much into her research as she does developing her plot lines and her cast. Her understanding and respect for the indigenous people of North America emanates from every page, making her work as intriguing as it is entertaining.
All told, Mother Earth Father Sky is a beautiful story of perseverance and strength amidst incredible hardship, as notable for its content as its flawless presentation.
Prehistories are for a hard sell for me. I don't know why, but they are difficult for me to get into so when I manage to find one that holds my interest, I tend to take notice which brings me to Mother Earth Father Sky by Sue Harrison.
Like Song of the River, this piece is character heavy, but what is so remarkable is how distinct, well-rounded and realistic each cast member feels. I can't imagine what goes into painting the motivations, personality and emotional struggles of so characters so vividly, but Harrison's effort certainly isn't wasted. In point of fact, I feel the authentic quality of her cast is what makes not just this piece, but her entire body of work so exceptional.
Speaking of relatable characters, I should probably mention my attraction to Chagak. Her path is a difficult one, but as a woman who had to overcome sexual abuse, I really admire Harrison for creating a character that doesn't allow the experience to define her life. I've seen authors attempt this story line before, but can honestly say few have pulled it off as well.
Strong characterization isn't the only aspect of Harrison's work worth mentioning. Her books are long, but they are also overflowing with cultural history. I might be going out on a limb, but I think it safe to say Harrison puts as much into her research as she does developing her plot lines and her cast. Her understanding and respect for the indigenous people of North America emanates from every page, making her work as intriguing as it is entertaining.
All told, Mother Earth Father Sky is a beautiful story of perseverance and strength amidst incredible hardship, as notable for its content as its flawless presentation.
July 5, 2023
Content warning: rape, murder of children, genocide
DNF at 44% because it was depressing af and not worth it.
Okay, I understand the concept of having a character become triumphant after experiencing trauma, but at some point enough is enough. The comparisons to Jean Auel's "Clan of the Cave Bear" are relatively apt, but what Auel understood was that the tragedies of Ayla's life needed to be balanced by small victories and periods of peace.
Chagak doesn't get to experience that, though. The story begins happily enough; at age thirteen, Chagak is now considered a woman and becomes betrothed to a desirable hunter in her tribe. Cut to: her entire village is being brutally massacred by strangers.
Chagak watches with horror as her mother tosses her baby brother out of their home in a desperate attempt to save his life before she and Chagak's sister are cut down and then immolate themselves to avoid further torture. After spending several days burying the dead, Chagak finds her baby brother alive but in bad shape and takes him with her in search of her grandfather's tribe, the Whale Hunters.
She lands in a small bay where she encounters Shuganan, a mysterious old, arthritic man who carves priceless statues in his hermitage. Shuganan tries to heal baby Pup, but Chagak's tiny brother dies from internal injuries sustained from his fall.
Things seem to be going well until Man-Who-Kills, one of the men who massacred her people shows up.
The book continues its downward spiral of violence, despair, and trauma. Every page is Chagak and Shuganan enduring some new depravity or torture, culminating in a graphic and violent rape. Repeatedly, relief seems within their grasp only to be snatched away. The trauma is relentless, and the completely unbalanced and unpleasant narrative is not worth reading.
DNF at 44% because it was depressing af and not worth it.
Okay, I understand the concept of having a character become triumphant after experiencing trauma, but at some point enough is enough. The comparisons to Jean Auel's "Clan of the Cave Bear" are relatively apt, but what Auel understood was that the tragedies of Ayla's life needed to be balanced by small victories and periods of peace.
Chagak doesn't get to experience that, though. The story begins happily enough; at age thirteen, Chagak is now considered a woman and becomes betrothed to a desirable hunter in her tribe. Cut to: her entire village is being brutally massacred by strangers.
Chagak watches with horror as her mother tosses her baby brother out of their home in a desperate attempt to save his life before she and Chagak's sister are cut down and then immolate themselves to avoid further torture. After spending several days burying the dead, Chagak finds her baby brother alive but in bad shape and takes him with her in search of her grandfather's tribe, the Whale Hunters.
She lands in a small bay where she encounters Shuganan, a mysterious old, arthritic man who carves priceless statues in his hermitage. Shuganan tries to heal baby Pup, but Chagak's tiny brother dies from internal injuries sustained from his fall.
Things seem to be going well until Man-Who-Kills, one of the men who massacred her people shows up.
The book continues its downward spiral of violence, despair, and trauma. Every page is Chagak and Shuganan enduring some new depravity or torture, culminating in a graphic and violent rape. Repeatedly, relief seems within their grasp only to be snatched away. The trauma is relentless, and the completely unbalanced and unpleasant narrative is not worth reading.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
September 22, 2009
In a time before history, in a harsh and beautiful land near the top of the world, womanhood comes cruelly and suddenly to beautiful, young Chagak. Surviving
the brutal massacre of her tribe, she sets out across the icy waters off Ameria's northwest coast on an astonishing odyssey that will reveal to Chagak powerful
secrets of the earth and sky... and the mysteries of love and loss.
At first I compared this book to the Clan of the Cave Bear series, but with a more realistic heroine. But those comparisons began to fade in my mind as I read, and I am greatful they did. this is a refreshing look at the life of a prehistoric troop of people and how they were ordinary in many ways. Definitely recommended for historical fiction nuts like myself.
the brutal massacre of her tribe, she sets out across the icy waters off Ameria's northwest coast on an astonishing odyssey that will reveal to Chagak powerful
secrets of the earth and sky... and the mysteries of love and loss.
At first I compared this book to the Clan of the Cave Bear series, but with a more realistic heroine. But those comparisons began to fade in my mind as I read, and I am greatful they did. this is a refreshing look at the life of a prehistoric troop of people and how they were ordinary in many ways. Definitely recommended for historical fiction nuts like myself.
July 24, 2014
The first book in the "Ivory Carver Trilogy". Wonderfully written and totally engaging.
Read this excerpt"
"See me," Chagak wanted to shout to the spirits, to the great mountain Aka that watched over their village. "This girl is woman now. Surely, in her rejoicing you will bring our hunters back from the sea. Surely you will not let us become a village of women and children." But only men were allowed to call to the spirits. So Chagak stretched out her arms but held back the words that pressed full and tight between her tongue and the roof of her mouth.
Read this excerpt"
"See me," Chagak wanted to shout to the spirits, to the great mountain Aka that watched over their village. "This girl is woman now. Surely, in her rejoicing you will bring our hunters back from the sea. Surely you will not let us become a village of women and children." But only men were allowed to call to the spirits. So Chagak stretched out her arms but held back the words that pressed full and tight between her tongue and the roof of her mouth.
July 25, 2012
Book 1 of the Ivory Carver Trilogy. The journey begins and by goodness it's a powerful one. There is no other writer like Sue Harrison out there. I love this trilogy.
My Sister The Moon - is book 2 in the trilogy - and even better...
Brother Wind -last book in the Ivory Carver Trilogy, closes the story up.
If your looking for a new way to have a story told to you,then Sue Harrison is the author to do it. You wouldn't ever regret reading this trilogy.
My Sister The Moon - is book 2 in the trilogy - and even better...
Brother Wind -last book in the Ivory Carver Trilogy, closes the story up.
If your looking for a new way to have a story told to you,then Sue Harrison is the author to do it. You wouldn't ever regret reading this trilogy.
August 2, 2020
Loved this book I want to read the next one right away
August 22, 2020
I like the "prehistoric fiction" genre, but there aren't that many books that fall under it. This is not bad but not that great either, especially when compared with The Clan Of The Cave Bear.
January 26, 2021
Absolutely amazing, felt like I was living inside the book, its a very fast paced read from the first word. I highly recommend this book!
May 26, 2021
I read this entire series in high school and was obsessed. Another I need to revisit.
May 9, 2025
This was incredible and a reading experience like no other! I should have done a reading eras challenge because this book takes place in the 7000s BC!! The author did so much research, it’s evident from all of the detail of Chagak’s people’s lives; how they lived, hunted, ate, etc.. There were some parts that were difficult to read, especially with the violence and the deaths that were a frequent part of life back then. One could never become too comfortable, it was all about surviving. There were many beautiful moments of strength and emotional ones too. I cried a handful of times. It was just incredible and I learned so much. I will be continuing this series! 5 stars!! 🧡
May 12, 2022
New to Alaska in 1995, I found several interesting books set in the Last Frontier. Mother Earth Father Sky grabbed my attention and refused to let go until the last page. Caught up in the traumatic life events of Chagak (spoiler alert: If rape is an issue for you, don't read this book), I turned each page hoping she would find relief and safety. The wise shaman attempted to protect her. She discovered her inner strength and the reader witnessed her grow from a girl to a woman to a mother. If you are looking for a story with exceptional detail about life in the Aleutians with drama and a heart-gripping storyline, this book is for you. When I finished Mother Earth Father Sky, I immediately moved on to My Sister the Moon but could not finish it. The violence toward women became too much for my heart to take. Mother Earth Father Sky is a solid stand-alone book.
January 3, 2019
Rating: 3.3 / 5
There are many things I appreciated about this book. Chagak and Shuganan, for one thing, were both excellent characters, well-developed and excellent representations of the elder-youth relationship in tribal tradition. The elder is the one who teaches and protects, whereas the youth does the physical labour and learns from the elder. I loved their relationship, especially in how isolated it was and how quickly they are able to coexist peacefully together on their beach.
Another thing to praise is the setting of both place and time, with uses of native words to describe things, and in-depth descriptions of how things are made and prepared. I was fascinated not only by how vivid and accurate everything seemed, but also how Harrison undertook to delve into a prehistoric world and showcase the timelessness of native tradition and culture, and how it hasn't changed for the most part in hundreds of years because, honestly, there's no need for change. Unlike the European attitude of always wanting "more", the native of tribes from North America are more concerned with what they need, and so do not look to conquer and innovate everything they see. It's really refreshing to have a story set so far back that you realize that none of these things matter, there's no pollution in the world, no minor detail that could impact the lives of everyone; just simple being.
And yet, about halfway through this story, I encountered a detail that, while probably accurate to the time and place, from a narrative standpoint I nevertheless felt was unnecessary. And, since this is quite the spoiler, I'll explain my disdain for it below: (Warning for swearing ahead.)
So, anyways, all in all a rounded 3-star rating. This book fulfilled some expectations and disappointed others. Moving on!
There are many things I appreciated about this book. Chagak and Shuganan, for one thing, were both excellent characters, well-developed and excellent representations of the elder-youth relationship in tribal tradition. The elder is the one who teaches and protects, whereas the youth does the physical labour and learns from the elder. I loved their relationship, especially in how isolated it was and how quickly they are able to coexist peacefully together on their beach.
Another thing to praise is the setting of both place and time, with uses of native words to describe things, and in-depth descriptions of how things are made and prepared. I was fascinated not only by how vivid and accurate everything seemed, but also how Harrison undertook to delve into a prehistoric world and showcase the timelessness of native tradition and culture, and how it hasn't changed for the most part in hundreds of years because, honestly, there's no need for change. Unlike the European attitude of always wanting "more", the native of tribes from North America are more concerned with what they need, and so do not look to conquer and innovate everything they see. It's really refreshing to have a story set so far back that you realize that none of these things matter, there's no pollution in the world, no minor detail that could impact the lives of everyone; just simple being.
And yet, about halfway through this story, I encountered a detail that, while probably accurate to the time and place, from a narrative standpoint I nevertheless felt was unnecessary. And, since this is quite the spoiler, I'll explain my disdain for it below: (Warning for swearing ahead.)
So, anyways, all in all a rounded 3-star rating. This book fulfilled some expectations and disappointed others. Moving on!
April 20, 2014
Mother Earth, Father Sky is an engaging book with a story line that remains heavy through out much of the book. As a young woman, just come of age, the main character is looking forward to marriage when she becomes a witnesses to the slaughter of her entire village, save all but her youngest brother. After burying everyone, she sets off to find her grandfather's tribe, The Whale Hunters.
But her journey is side-tracked when she spends the night on a beach where she discovers an elderly, but wise and mysterious man and stays. Her youngest brother, just an infant, soon dies for lack of food.
Before long, in a cruel turn of events, she is reunited with a man who was one of the murdering band that killed her family, from a tribe she learns is called The Short Ones. She is eventually forced to marry him.
By the time she and the old man manage to kill him, she has been impregnated by him in a savage introduction to sex on her wedding night and remains undecided for some time as to whether she will allow this child to live or not.
But live the child does and eventually she saves the motherless son of a guest to their island by becoming his wet nurse. In an effort to warn the Whale Hunters of their impending danger from the Short Ones, she, the old man and their guests travel to this other tribe, where new challenges, dangers and another vicious encounter with The Short Ones transpires.
Yes, there was a point where I could barely stand the tragic events that followed, one on the heels of the other for what seemed like forever.
But the depth of character given the young woman, the old man and several other main players in the story, and the many insights into the culture, beliefs and lifestyle of the people who inhabited the region was a strong enticement to keep going. The reader's tenacity is eventually rewarded as, after further hardships, our protagonist reaches satisfying decisions and a better life.
One of the most interesting theories put forth in the book is the story of how The Short Ones came to be the first tribe to become hunters and killers of men rather than just animals.
Other fascinating facts about how extremely resourceful and "green", to use one of today's buzzwords, the people of that time had become, gives us a good look at how a world with very little in the way of tools, was utilized so fully that pretty much nothing went to waste.
Likewise, the astonishing number of skills a child developed by the age of manhood or womanhood, [Age 12 to 13]was remarkable. Not to mention their grasp of the nature of life and their understanding of the plants and animals around them was pretty much complete by the time they entered adolescence, which was, for them, actually adulthood.
In the end, we have a story populated by people whose lives we could barely be expected to relate to. And yet, so richly are they fleshed out by the author, that like me, you'll probably find people that you know today who's personalities and moral fiber are seen in these prehistoric people.
Humans may have evolved tremendously, but it would seem that certain elements of human nature have been around forever.
And therein lies the ability of Mother Earth,Father Sky to bring us characters we can truly relate to and empathize with.
But her journey is side-tracked when she spends the night on a beach where she discovers an elderly, but wise and mysterious man and stays. Her youngest brother, just an infant, soon dies for lack of food.
Before long, in a cruel turn of events, she is reunited with a man who was one of the murdering band that killed her family, from a tribe she learns is called The Short Ones. She is eventually forced to marry him.
By the time she and the old man manage to kill him, she has been impregnated by him in a savage introduction to sex on her wedding night and remains undecided for some time as to whether she will allow this child to live or not.
But live the child does and eventually she saves the motherless son of a guest to their island by becoming his wet nurse. In an effort to warn the Whale Hunters of their impending danger from the Short Ones, she, the old man and their guests travel to this other tribe, where new challenges, dangers and another vicious encounter with The Short Ones transpires.
Yes, there was a point where I could barely stand the tragic events that followed, one on the heels of the other for what seemed like forever.
But the depth of character given the young woman, the old man and several other main players in the story, and the many insights into the culture, beliefs and lifestyle of the people who inhabited the region was a strong enticement to keep going. The reader's tenacity is eventually rewarded as, after further hardships, our protagonist reaches satisfying decisions and a better life.
One of the most interesting theories put forth in the book is the story of how The Short Ones came to be the first tribe to become hunters and killers of men rather than just animals.
Other fascinating facts about how extremely resourceful and "green", to use one of today's buzzwords, the people of that time had become, gives us a good look at how a world with very little in the way of tools, was utilized so fully that pretty much nothing went to waste.
Likewise, the astonishing number of skills a child developed by the age of manhood or womanhood, [Age 12 to 13]was remarkable. Not to mention their grasp of the nature of life and their understanding of the plants and animals around them was pretty much complete by the time they entered adolescence, which was, for them, actually adulthood.
In the end, we have a story populated by people whose lives we could barely be expected to relate to. And yet, so richly are they fleshed out by the author, that like me, you'll probably find people that you know today who's personalities and moral fiber are seen in these prehistoric people.
Humans may have evolved tremendously, but it would seem that certain elements of human nature have been around forever.
And therein lies the ability of Mother Earth,Father Sky to bring us characters we can truly relate to and empathize with.
August 18, 2013
Like earlier stated, I was given this book to read and give my unbiased and honest opinion.
This is the first book of the Ivory Carver Trilogy and I am drooling to read the next two! Eeeek! I'm not really sure what the next two books are about (be it Chagak or other characters). I would really like to learn more about Blue Shell. I want her to have her happily ever after and we all know she deserves better then stupid the stupid and cowardly husband she has now. He is not only weak and cowardly, but he is mean and hurts her. I really liked Blue Shell and I hope in the next two books she gets her HEA.
Some people label this as a "YA" novel. I don't see it at all...its rather graphic at some points and I don't think I would let a child under 14 read this...so I guess 14+ are Young Adults. IDK. It did win an award for Best Book for YA in 1991. Soooo I guess parents don't mind, but there are a few scenes are rather graphic....but oh well...what do I know....
Anyways....
I LOVED THIS BOOK! It was so hard to put it down, but I had no choice due to me being so busy the last week and change. It was SUCH a good read. At some points I was so into the text I thought I was watching a movie and I would give commentary and Boyfriend would look at me strange, so I would have to inform him what happened and give him the back-story. Sue Harrison just sucked me up into this world from page one. Yes, there was a LOT of details, but it was necessary to understand the world and get a good grasp on the ancient society. I especially am grateful for the wonderful details included, because my knowledge on the Aleut tribes is limited. I know a lot about many tribes, but my knowledge base in pretty much nonexist. However, due to Sue Harrison not only did I learn a lot, but I have done my own research after the book was done. It's so great when an author makes you want to learn more.
The characters were well written. Chagak was a strong woman and I applaud her. She went through some emotional stuff for being a young adult herself. She had just became a woman and she lost EVERYTHING. So sad. So, so sad. I felt really connected with Chagak (and Blue Shell for some reason). Which is odd that I emotionally connected with more then one character.
In the end, I adored this book. This book is defiantly up for "Top Book of the Year" for me. Haha. Can't wait to read more in the trilogy and in this time period. It was wonderfully written and I can't really think of anything negative at this point in time. I do, however, disagree that this is shoved in with the YA genre as well as the HF due to the few scenes that are pretty graphic. Oh well. I do recommend this to those that love Historical Fiction, Native History, history (in general), and for those looking to shake up their reading shelves. I shall stamp this with 5 stars. Woot! Woot!
Favorite Character(s): Chagak, Blue Shell, Crooked Nose, Seal Stalker, and Many Whales
Not-so Favorite Character(s): Blue Shell's husband & Man-who-Kills (I wonder why....)
This is the first book of the Ivory Carver Trilogy and I am drooling to read the next two! Eeeek! I'm not really sure what the next two books are about (be it Chagak or other characters). I would really like to learn more about Blue Shell. I want her to have her happily ever after and we all know she deserves better then stupid the stupid and cowardly husband she has now. He is not only weak and cowardly, but he is mean and hurts her. I really liked Blue Shell and I hope in the next two books she gets her HEA.
Some people label this as a "YA" novel. I don't see it at all...its rather graphic at some points and I don't think I would let a child under 14 read this...so I guess 14+ are Young Adults. IDK. It did win an award for Best Book for YA in 1991. Soooo I guess parents don't mind, but there are a few scenes are rather graphic....but oh well...what do I know....
Anyways....
I LOVED THIS BOOK! It was so hard to put it down, but I had no choice due to me being so busy the last week and change. It was SUCH a good read. At some points I was so into the text I thought I was watching a movie and I would give commentary and Boyfriend would look at me strange, so I would have to inform him what happened and give him the back-story. Sue Harrison just sucked me up into this world from page one. Yes, there was a LOT of details, but it was necessary to understand the world and get a good grasp on the ancient society. I especially am grateful for the wonderful details included, because my knowledge on the Aleut tribes is limited. I know a lot about many tribes, but my knowledge base in pretty much nonexist. However, due to Sue Harrison not only did I learn a lot, but I have done my own research after the book was done. It's so great when an author makes you want to learn more.
The characters were well written. Chagak was a strong woman and I applaud her. She went through some emotional stuff for being a young adult herself. She had just became a woman and she lost EVERYTHING. So sad. So, so sad. I felt really connected with Chagak (and Blue Shell for some reason). Which is odd that I emotionally connected with more then one character.
In the end, I adored this book. This book is defiantly up for "Top Book of the Year" for me. Haha. Can't wait to read more in the trilogy and in this time period. It was wonderfully written and I can't really think of anything negative at this point in time. I do, however, disagree that this is shoved in with the YA genre as well as the HF due to the few scenes that are pretty graphic. Oh well. I do recommend this to those that love Historical Fiction, Native History, history (in general), and for those looking to shake up their reading shelves. I shall stamp this with 5 stars. Woot! Woot!
Favorite Character(s): Chagak, Blue Shell, Crooked Nose, Seal Stalker, and Many Whales
Not-so Favorite Character(s): Blue Shell's husband & Man-who-Kills (I wonder why....)
January 10, 2022
I first read this book about a decade ago, and remember really loving it. After seeing it in a second hand bookstore, I decided I would pick it up and read it again, since I couldn't remember exactly what it was about.
We follow Chagak, a Native American teen girl in the Aleutian Islands (the islands reaching off the coast of modern day Alaska) and her struggles with losing her entire village to violence. She meets an old carver named Shuganan and they live together until a Short One (member of the tribe that destroyed her village) arrives. The book also follows a man named Kayugh and his small tribe, who have also suffered tragedy, and who eventually meet up with Chagak.
The description of the setting and the their way of life felt seamless and well woven into the narrative, to the point that it felt natural and unforced, unlike Jane Auel's work where she will spend several pages talking about the creation of a canoe. A step by step manual isn't necessary in the creation of a chigadax (rather like a jacket) but just enough description to know how it's put together, what it looks like and what it's made of (it's made of seal skin, feathers, and is woven together by sinew and intestine, and comes together in the front, for example).
The reason I have reduced the rating from a 5 to a 4 is almost entirely due to the section of the book where Man-Who-Kills is keeping Shuganan and Chagak captive and torturing them for an extended period of time. They try to outsmart him and escape, and talk about killing him, but can never actually do it until it's almost too late. It's frustrating and tiresome.
The rest of the book is actually quite wonderful and a fast read. The only other rather loathsome character is Gray Bird, who plays a rather major role in the next book. I truly enjoy immersing myself in these Native American historical fictions. The very fact that 7000 years ago there were people living in the freezing Aleutian islands is crazy to me, and gives me an entirely new appreciation for how most of us live today.
We follow Chagak, a Native American teen girl in the Aleutian Islands (the islands reaching off the coast of modern day Alaska) and her struggles with losing her entire village to violence. She meets an old carver named Shuganan and they live together until a Short One (member of the tribe that destroyed her village) arrives. The book also follows a man named Kayugh and his small tribe, who have also suffered tragedy, and who eventually meet up with Chagak.
The description of the setting and the their way of life felt seamless and well woven into the narrative, to the point that it felt natural and unforced, unlike Jane Auel's work where she will spend several pages talking about the creation of a canoe. A step by step manual isn't necessary in the creation of a chigadax (rather like a jacket) but just enough description to know how it's put together, what it looks like and what it's made of (it's made of seal skin, feathers, and is woven together by sinew and intestine, and comes together in the front, for example).
The reason I have reduced the rating from a 5 to a 4 is almost entirely due to the section of the book where Man-Who-Kills is keeping Shuganan and Chagak captive and torturing them for an extended period of time. They try to outsmart him and escape, and talk about killing him, but can never actually do it until it's almost too late. It's frustrating and tiresome.
The rest of the book is actually quite wonderful and a fast read. The only other rather loathsome character is Gray Bird, who plays a rather major role in the next book. I truly enjoy immersing myself in these Native American historical fictions. The very fact that 7000 years ago there were people living in the freezing Aleutian islands is crazy to me, and gives me an entirely new appreciation for how most of us live today.
August 12, 2013
Originally published in 1985 this is the first book in a trilogy. I have been on a wonderful ride lately with books that have grabbed my attention right away and kept it till the every end. Books about young girls, their struggles, their fears as they grow up very quickly in tragic circumstances. Mother End Father Sky is set in a time period that I rarely read and I am happy to say that my wonderful reading streak is still going strong.
Taking place in prehistoric Alaska, this book did not disappoint! Not only was it a really good read but an educational one as well. The rich detail into the history of the land, the way of life and the cultural lifestyle of the different villages shows that the author did a ton of research to make this novel. And I have so much respect for authors that spend so much time on research and delivering it such a believable and entertaining manner, which is what Sue Harrison has done here. I couldn't help but feel for Chagak, her future changing so drastically and the courage to survive. It wasn't just Chagak's circumstances, but the general way of life. I was able to feel the cold water, the bitter winds of paddling the seas. The amount of work that went into everyday life just to survive during that time period, gathering plants, skinning animals and saving every part for a specific purpose.
There were more characters, Shuganan, surrogate grandfather added a dose of mystery to the story along with glimpses of the spirit world and how it directed life back then.
Some say this is young adult and others adult fiction, definitely would appeal to both. A series that I plan to continue reading.
Taking place in prehistoric Alaska, this book did not disappoint! Not only was it a really good read but an educational one as well. The rich detail into the history of the land, the way of life and the cultural lifestyle of the different villages shows that the author did a ton of research to make this novel. And I have so much respect for authors that spend so much time on research and delivering it such a believable and entertaining manner, which is what Sue Harrison has done here. I couldn't help but feel for Chagak, her future changing so drastically and the courage to survive. It wasn't just Chagak's circumstances, but the general way of life. I was able to feel the cold water, the bitter winds of paddling the seas. The amount of work that went into everyday life just to survive during that time period, gathering plants, skinning animals and saving every part for a specific purpose.
There were more characters, Shuganan, surrogate grandfather added a dose of mystery to the story along with glimpses of the spirit world and how it directed life back then.
Some say this is young adult and others adult fiction, definitely would appeal to both. A series that I plan to continue reading.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 304 reviews