What do you think?
Rate this book
240 pages, Hardcover
First published March 11, 2008
I was attracted to this book since I enjoy musicals, but I didn't enjoy it as much as expected. Emily and Philip have been traveling into the city for the past few years just to see their favorite musical, Aurora. When the show is about to be canceled, Emily is desperate to save it, and will go to any lenghts to do so. However, the book fell short of my expectations.
I thought that the theater aspect of the plot was different, and clever. It did seem like Wood tried to include a romance just to attract YA readers- this was a problem in other books I've read before, when the author tries to include romance that doesn't make sense just for the sake of including it. Thïs is one of those times. It's like, "Hey, Philip, do you think we're ready for a relationship?" "No, not yet." Cue a different topic. The romance that never happened was awkward and didn't fit with the plot at all- nothing from the story would have been lost. Which brings me to my next point: Wood tried too hard to make Philip comform to a standard of a gay theater geek when he didn't really seem that way. Heads up, Wood: not all theater lovers are gay. While not homophobic, the assumptions made about his character are cliche and fairly rude. Finally, it seemed like Wood tried to add too many subplots which were confusing to keep track of, especially near the end when everything came together.
Again, I enjoyed the theater aspect, including the references to shows, and especially the bio-style epilogue at the end. However, the novel falls short in many important areas, and I feel that Wood could improve as a storyteller. A decent effort, and maybe worth a read for a theater lover, but nothing stellar here I'm afraid.