What do you think?
Rate this book
The Staff and the Sword #1
A Cast of Stones
An Epic Medieval Saga Fantasy Readers Will Love.
In the backwater village of Callowford, Errol Stone's search for a drink is interrupted by a church messenger who arrives with urgent missives for the hermit priest in the hills. Desperate for coin, Errol volunteers to deliver them but soon finds himself hunted by deadly assassins. Forced to flee with the priest and a small band of travelers, Errol soon learns he's joined a quest that could change the fate of his kingdom.
Protected for millennia by the heirs of the first king, the kingdom's dynasty is near an end and a new king must be selected. As tension and danger mount, Errol must leave behind his drunkenness and grief, learn to fight, and come to know his God in order to survive a journey to discover his destiny.
In the backwater village of Callowford, Errol Stone's search for a drink is interrupted by a church messenger who arrives with urgent missives for the hermit priest in the hills. Desperate for coin, Errol volunteers to deliver them but soon finds himself hunted by deadly assassins. Forced to flee with the priest and a small band of travelers, Errol soon learns he's joined a quest that could change the fate of his kingdom.
Protected for millennia by the heirs of the first king, the kingdom's dynasty is near an end and a new king must be selected. As tension and danger mount, Errol must leave behind his drunkenness and grief, learn to fight, and come to know his God in order to survive a journey to discover his destiny.
432 pages, Kindle Edition
First published February 1, 2013
494 people are currently reading
5508 people want to read
About the author
Patrick W. Carr
12 books655 followersPatrick Carr was born on an Air Force base in West Germany at the height of the cold war. He has been told this was not his fault. As an Air Force brat, he experienced a change in locale every three years until his father retired to Tennessee. Patrick saw more of the world on his own through a varied and somewhat eclectic education and work history. He graduated from Georgia Tech in 1984 and has worked as a draftsman at a nuclear plant, did design work for the Air Force, worked for a printing company, and consulted as an engineer. Patrick’s day gig for the last eighteen years has been teaching high school math in Nashville, TN. He currently makes his home in Nashville with his wonderfully patient wife, Mary. Patrick and Mary have four sons who are living their own adventures all across the country. Patrick thinks writing about himself in the third person is kind of weird.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 642 reviews
July 13, 2014
Update
I've finished this trilogy today and decided to post my full review of all 3 books here (spoiler free) since this is where it all started.
WOW! WOW! And WOW!
This is one of the best trilogies I've ever read. It's definitely in my top 3. I even decided to put a new category in my bookshelves for "favorite trilogies" just because of this book.
People! You need to trust me and read this.
Why?
Because it has everything a reader of fantasy/fiction loves. (Well, at least for me)
Mature writing. The writing for me was damn near flawless. The dialogue, descriptions of places, people and things were just right. Nothing too much, nothing too little. I could feel, see, hear and almost taste words coming off the pages.
Mature characters. There's always that book that promises a strong hero or heroine that always ends up as "annoying" and "forced". Well, not the case here -although the author never promised such, he nonetheless delivered such heroic characters that made me feel joyful, tearful and throw out few fist pumps.
I've never read such strong men who could show such a tender side at times, and have it not feel forced or awkward.
I've never read two heroines who were so strong and kick ass, yet.. Still very much ladies. That was brilliant.
Fast paced. I'm sure you've heard before how a book grips you from the first page to the last. Well, I'm here to repeat that cliche. Except, I'll say it differently. From the very first chapter I was Completely. Sucked. In. it lasted until the final page of the third book! It did not in anyway subside. At. All. This is one of those trilogies that you have to read the books back to back, because you just can't get the story or characters out of your head. Yes, it's that good.
Incredible story line. Now that would be a spoiler, so.... Not going there. Read the book(s) yes, all of them. :)
Romance. I see you romance readers -you dirty girls on my friends list- *points finger* thinking "woohoo! Smexy time!" It's not that kind of romance, but I promise you'll fall in love with the development. ;) trust me....
Perfect execution. This trilogy was well thought out. Everything came at just the right time. Information that was withheld, and driving me nuts with angst, was released just so... And it was spaced throughout the entire trilogy, not just BOOM! All at the end, and holy crap what an ending o_O
Angst. "Turn up the angst!" that was a quote from, Tom. My buddy reading partner in crime. Thanks for the BR, Tom. I'm so glad I had someone to vent to! Lol
Twists and turns. there was plenty of twists and turns throughout the series. Some you can see coming and others, not at all. Regardless, I was completely entertained.
Religious politics I found the religion and political aspect of this book amazing. At first, I wasn't sure what to expect. In fact, I wasn't even sure I wanted to read this because of that. Um... That would have been a HUGE MISTAKE! Don't make that your mistake. This is first and foremost... A fantasy, with a nice twist on religious power.
POVs. I have to throw this in here because I absolutely love how the POVs were introduced in this trilogy.
I wish more authors would do this!
I don't consider this a spoiler BTW but if you don't want to know about POVs, skip this last part.
Book one we're introduced to Errol. He is the main character and the POV -which is in 3rd person past tense- (my absolute favorite) is his through out book one. We're introduced to important,secondary characters as well. And I must say, I loved them. Sometimes secondary characters can be underdeveloped, however, not the case here.
Book two we get 2 POVs and I loved it because we're already very familiar with the other character and love them.
Book three -the most intense by far- we have 3 POVs and let me tell you. It was perfect!!
What a gem I found in these three books. Truly. I have found a new favorite fantasy author. I will be looking forward to his next book.
That is all, folks.. :) happy reading. And go read this book!
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
original post
This is the first book by this author that I've read, and I loved it! I'll definitely continue this series.
Great writing
Great story (seemed very original)
Great characters
It held my attention from beginning to end. I would say it was pretty fast paced. The world building is easy to follow as was the religious aspect.
I believe it's still free on amazon, but if it weren't, I'd definitely buy it.
http://www.amazon.com/Cast-Stones-Sta...
I've finished this trilogy today and decided to post my full review of all 3 books here (spoiler free) since this is where it all started.
WOW! WOW! And WOW!
This is one of the best trilogies I've ever read. It's definitely in my top 3. I even decided to put a new category in my bookshelves for "favorite trilogies" just because of this book.
People! You need to trust me and read this.
Why?
Because it has everything a reader of fantasy/fiction loves. (Well, at least for me)
Mature writing. The writing for me was damn near flawless. The dialogue, descriptions of places, people and things were just right. Nothing too much, nothing too little. I could feel, see, hear and almost taste words coming off the pages.
Mature characters. There's always that book that promises a strong hero or heroine that always ends up as "annoying" and "forced". Well, not the case here -although the author never promised such, he nonetheless delivered such heroic characters that made me feel joyful, tearful and throw out few fist pumps.
I've never read such strong men who could show such a tender side at times, and have it not feel forced or awkward.
I've never read two heroines who were so strong and kick ass, yet.. Still very much ladies. That was brilliant.
Fast paced. I'm sure you've heard before how a book grips you from the first page to the last. Well, I'm here to repeat that cliche. Except, I'll say it differently. From the very first chapter I was Completely. Sucked. In. it lasted until the final page of the third book! It did not in anyway subside. At. All. This is one of those trilogies that you have to read the books back to back, because you just can't get the story or characters out of your head. Yes, it's that good.
Incredible story line. Now that would be a spoiler, so.... Not going there. Read the book(s) yes, all of them. :)
Romance. I see you romance readers -you dirty girls on my friends list- *points finger* thinking "woohoo! Smexy time!" It's not that kind of romance, but I promise you'll fall in love with the development. ;) trust me....
Perfect execution. This trilogy was well thought out. Everything came at just the right time. Information that was withheld, and driving me nuts with angst, was released just so... And it was spaced throughout the entire trilogy, not just BOOM! All at the end, and holy crap what an ending o_O
Angst. "Turn up the angst!" that was a quote from, Tom. My buddy reading partner in crime. Thanks for the BR, Tom. I'm so glad I had someone to vent to! Lol
Twists and turns. there was plenty of twists and turns throughout the series. Some you can see coming and others, not at all. Regardless, I was completely entertained.
Religious politics I found the religion and political aspect of this book amazing. At first, I wasn't sure what to expect. In fact, I wasn't even sure I wanted to read this because of that. Um... That would have been a HUGE MISTAKE! Don't make that your mistake. This is first and foremost... A fantasy, with a nice twist on religious power.
POVs. I have to throw this in here because I absolutely love how the POVs were introduced in this trilogy.
I wish more authors would do this!
I don't consider this a spoiler BTW but if you don't want to know about POVs, skip this last part.
Book one we're introduced to Errol. He is the main character and the POV -which is in 3rd person past tense- (my absolute favorite) is his through out book one. We're introduced to important,secondary characters as well. And I must say, I loved them. Sometimes secondary characters can be underdeveloped, however, not the case here.
Book two we get 2 POVs and I loved it because we're already very familiar with the other character and love them.
Book three -the most intense by far- we have 3 POVs and let me tell you. It was perfect!!
What a gem I found in these three books. Truly. I have found a new favorite fantasy author. I will be looking forward to his next book.
That is all, folks.. :) happy reading. And go read this book!
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
original post
This is the first book by this author that I've read, and I loved it! I'll definitely continue this series.
Great writing
Great story (seemed very original)
Great characters
It held my attention from beginning to end. I would say it was pretty fast paced. The world building is easy to follow as was the religious aspect.
I believe it's still free on amazon, but if it weren't, I'd definitely buy it.
http://www.amazon.com/Cast-Stones-Sta...
March 15, 2017
A Cast of Stones by Patrick W. Carr started out interesting enough ... it even really captivated me at certain points; but it ended up just not being the greatest fantasy read for me, personally.
It starts out with a young man, named Errol, getting thrown out of a tavern. He shortly thereafter meets a church messenger, and agrees to go on an errand for the man. After all, it means he'll be paid. And pay means more ale. However, Errol gets much, much more than he bargained for; in fact, his world is thrown into chaos.
It was quite a story. After all, our POV character is a drunkard. And the world of A Cast of Stones is obviously well thought out. There's so much going on. Mysteries and secrets and stunning revelations. Vicious fighters, and greedy men abound. The king grows weak, and someone needs to take his place before it's too late. There was a lot of character development, which was great. The fighting scenes were done well - enough to have you quite interested; but not get tired of one fight after another. The plot, themes, world ... were intricate.
Perhaps that was part of the problem for me. I love fantasy. But at times it just gets too in-depth, and I'm suddenly in over my head, like, What are they even talking about? Can we move onto something else? *Ahem* Yeah.
I find that I don't really prefer books with just a male POV character. Why? Um, maybe because I'm a girl? I just understand women better! Most of the time. Anyway, as much as I grow to adore a lot of main characters that are guys (even Errol wasn't so bad); I end up getting a little weary of not having any female companionship. I love when there's a girl character that I really understand her emotions, and actions ... I relate to her. I can put myself in her shoes. And there was just Errol in A Cast of Stones. As I said, he was a good character, and went on quite a journey. I would even like to see more of him! But I just connect better with books that have some female main characters as well.
That being said, I do not understand Errol and his reactions to girls. He goes here and ... Wow, what a beautiful, amazing woman! Then he leaves and goes someone else, and meets another beautiful, amazing woman! And by the end of the books, there's at least three girls who are either pining after him, or he's pining after them. I don't know. After awhile, I'm feeling like, Okay, young man, guard your heart ... and protect theirs! I know Errol was young ... erm, sort of? ... and was still growing in a sense; coming out of being a drunkard. But it still frustrates me when the guy forgets the pretty girl he kissed that fast, because a new pretty girl is in his life. Ah. Rant over.
The lot casting unnerved me a little at times. It's kind of hard to judge who's really a good person. And is the church good? Also, there was some violence and gore, and perhaps some frightening scenes.
Overall, this book made a 3.5 stars. After finally connecting, I thought I'd enjoy it more; but then the end kind of fell flat for me. I'd still like to see what happens with Errol, so I plan to finish this series someday! *smiles*
It starts out with a young man, named Errol, getting thrown out of a tavern. He shortly thereafter meets a church messenger, and agrees to go on an errand for the man. After all, it means he'll be paid. And pay means more ale. However, Errol gets much, much more than he bargained for; in fact, his world is thrown into chaos.
It was quite a story. After all, our POV character is a drunkard. And the world of A Cast of Stones is obviously well thought out. There's so much going on. Mysteries and secrets and stunning revelations. Vicious fighters, and greedy men abound. The king grows weak, and someone needs to take his place before it's too late. There was a lot of character development, which was great. The fighting scenes were done well - enough to have you quite interested; but not get tired of one fight after another. The plot, themes, world ... were intricate.
Perhaps that was part of the problem for me. I love fantasy. But at times it just gets too in-depth, and I'm suddenly in over my head, like, What are they even talking about? Can we move onto something else? *Ahem* Yeah.
I find that I don't really prefer books with just a male POV character. Why? Um, maybe because I'm a girl? I just understand women better! Most of the time. Anyway, as much as I grow to adore a lot of main characters that are guys (even Errol wasn't so bad); I end up getting a little weary of not having any female companionship. I love when there's a girl character that I really understand her emotions, and actions ... I relate to her. I can put myself in her shoes. And there was just Errol in A Cast of Stones. As I said, he was a good character, and went on quite a journey. I would even like to see more of him! But I just connect better with books that have some female main characters as well.
That being said, I do not understand Errol and his reactions to girls. He goes here and ... Wow, what a beautiful, amazing woman! Then he leaves and goes someone else, and meets another beautiful, amazing woman! And by the end of the books, there's at least three girls who are either pining after him, or he's pining after them. I don't know. After awhile, I'm feeling like, Okay, young man, guard your heart ... and protect theirs! I know Errol was young ... erm, sort of? ... and was still growing in a sense; coming out of being a drunkard. But it still frustrates me when the guy forgets the pretty girl he kissed that fast, because a new pretty girl is in his life. Ah. Rant over.
The lot casting unnerved me a little at times. It's kind of hard to judge who's really a good person. And is the church good? Also, there was some violence and gore, and perhaps some frightening scenes.
Overall, this book made a 3.5 stars. After finally connecting, I thought I'd enjoy it more; but then the end kind of fell flat for me. I'd still like to see what happens with Errol, so I plan to finish this series someday! *smiles*
October 7, 2024
I've read this book at least six times and do not know where to begin on this review. Carr is a masterful weaver of words, worlds, and characters. He possesses a knack that yanks you into the story and keeps you there until the final page has been turned. Even after that, the tale remains with you.
Let's begin with the plot. It's been a few years since I first read A Cast of Stones, but I remember being hesitant. A drunkard for a main character? Why would I care about some inebriated sot who didn't know up from down?
I was was quickly proven wrong. Errol's story, heartbreaking, inspiring, and filled with adventure (most of which I personally wouldn't want to endure; I'm just saying this poor boy's been through so much) held me captive from the first page to the last. So much so that I immediately acquired the second and third books in this series. The plot is complicated yet simple at the same time; easy to guess what happens, yet filled with turns and twists and surprises. Keeping track of both major and secondary plot lines can be difficult, but Carr nailed it.
The characters, as well, are incredibly complex and three dimensional. Even the wretched nemeses, who I just wanted to throw in the river and let them flounder into oblivion. Errol is a lovable character. Martin and Luis need to be slapped upside the head at times, but they add a lot to the story. Liam, Cruk, Rale, Rokha, and the rest are delightful secondary characters for so many reasons. Even Naaman Ru, of whom I have a mixed opinion (again, trying to remember what I thought when I first read this book) brings a unique aspect.
I could go on for hours about the worldbuilding. Fantasy writers, you need to read this if for nothing else than the worldbuilding. It's incredible. I can tell where Carr drew inspiration from our world, but the spins and twists and interesting additions he made just bring these lands, these peoples, to life.
This is a Christian fantasy. The book reads like it comes from a Catholic point of view. I do not agree with a lot of what Catholics believe, but everything in this book is Biblical. That being said, it is, at times, difficult to tell if the Lord's name in vain is being used. But after really reading those passages, I don't think it is. Other readers might disagree.
I did find a few happenings to be mildly irritating. Errol is a naive ragamuffin, so for him to fall in love twice and almost in love once didn't fit with his character overall. And the kisses. Did he really need to be kissed? Twice? In my opinion, the answer is no. I didn't mind his interest in a certain character because it was natural and is progressing at a normal speed, but the others? I did not find that necessary.
Despite those issues, I thoroughly enjoyed this book.
A Cast of Stones is an excellent, captivating story that imparts important messages, provides a thrilling read, and sweeps you away into a land filled with danger, action, and heroism.
Let's begin with the plot. It's been a few years since I first read A Cast of Stones, but I remember being hesitant. A drunkard for a main character? Why would I care about some inebriated sot who didn't know up from down?
I was was quickly proven wrong. Errol's story, heartbreaking, inspiring, and filled with adventure (most of which I personally wouldn't want to endure; I'm just saying this poor boy's been through so much) held me captive from the first page to the last. So much so that I immediately acquired the second and third books in this series. The plot is complicated yet simple at the same time; easy to guess what happens, yet filled with turns and twists and surprises. Keeping track of both major and secondary plot lines can be difficult, but Carr nailed it.
The characters, as well, are incredibly complex and three dimensional. Even the wretched nemeses, who I just wanted to throw in the river and let them flounder into oblivion. Errol is a lovable character. Martin and Luis need to be slapped upside the head at times, but they add a lot to the story. Liam, Cruk, Rale, Rokha, and the rest are delightful secondary characters for so many reasons. Even Naaman Ru, of whom I have a mixed opinion (again, trying to remember what I thought when I first read this book) brings a unique aspect.
I could go on for hours about the worldbuilding. Fantasy writers, you need to read this if for nothing else than the worldbuilding. It's incredible. I can tell where Carr drew inspiration from our world, but the spins and twists and interesting additions he made just bring these lands, these peoples, to life.
This is a Christian fantasy. The book reads like it comes from a Catholic point of view. I do not agree with a lot of what Catholics believe, but everything in this book is Biblical. That being said, it is, at times, difficult to tell if the Lord's name in vain is being used. But after really reading those passages, I don't think it is. Other readers might disagree.
I did find a few happenings to be mildly irritating. Errol is a naive ragamuffin, so for him to fall in love twice and almost in love once didn't fit with his character overall. And the kisses. Did he really need to be kissed? Twice? In my opinion, the answer is no. I didn't mind his interest in a certain character because it was natural and is progressing at a normal speed, but the others? I did not find that necessary.
Despite those issues, I thoroughly enjoyed this book.
A Cast of Stones is an excellent, captivating story that imparts important messages, provides a thrilling read, and sweeps you away into a land filled with danger, action, and heroism.
February 18, 2017
A Cast of Stones is a Medieval-style fantasy with a Church, priests and monks as a major power in the kingdom. But other than the similarities to the religious background of Medieval Europe, the history and the magic of casting divine lots is unique enough that I felt like it took place in an unknown fantasy world. Although much was standard high fantasy fare (e.g. unknown peasant protagonist), this was still different enough to feel fresh to me.
The main character is a 'boy' of 18 who has been an alcoholic for several years. I found Errol hard to like at the beginning because he was always drowning himself in ale and didn't care too much about anything. But as the story progressed, he grew and changed, and I really began to enjoy his tale.
About half way through - once Errol came out of his alcohol-daze and began to understand what was going on around him - I had a hard time putting the book down. All-in-all, a quick, enjoyable fantasy, and I'm looking forward to the next one. This is the kind of find that makes reading galleys worthwhile.
**Received free arc for review.
The main character is a 'boy' of 18 who has been an alcoholic for several years. I found Errol hard to like at the beginning because he was always drowning himself in ale and didn't care too much about anything. But as the story progressed, he grew and changed, and I really began to enjoy his tale.
About half way through - once Errol came out of his alcohol-daze and began to understand what was going on around him - I had a hard time putting the book down. All-in-all, a quick, enjoyable fantasy, and I'm looking forward to the next one. This is the kind of find that makes reading galleys worthwhile.
**Received free arc for review.
April 28, 2016
When I first picked up saw this book, I thought it sounded interesting. When I won a copy through goodreads first reads, I was super excited. Some time between winning and getting my book, a friend told me the publishing company published religious books and I should beware because blah blah blah. Immediately I was thrown off balance. I have no problem reading books by religious authors -no matter their chosen religion- or even books about religion if in the mood for them. But I get very annoyed when I read a book for the story and spend how many pages getting stuff shoved down my throat while the author is up on their soap box preaching to the readers. I want a story and I want to be entertained. That said -and really this is directed at that friend and others who may have similar concerns- THIS BOOK IS NOT LIKE THAT. Sure religion is a big focal point in the world the characters live in, but the author handles it respectively. This book is so much more than that. To call it simply a christian book is not giving the author enough credit for this fascinating world and intriguing characters inside the pages. *glares pointedly at said friend*
Errol, oh what can I say about him. From page one, I was embarrassed by him. I didn't want to be in his head.
My wordless conversation with my book went something like this:
- Oh my god, really? How long is this book? *checks page count* *sigh*
- He's a drunk this early in the day? How old is he supposed to be?
- Yup let's get more money for alcohol.....why did I want to read this again?
- Author, I don't know you enough to give you the benefit of the doubt........ *blinks* Ooohhh! An assassin!
- *watches as Errol flees for his life* For a drunk, I think he's got more skills them me. *would have so totally fallen to her death*
*later on*
- Whoo hooo! You go Errol! Kick his butt! Yes! Whoo hoo!
- What!? Ah! You jerk! How dare you treat him that way! You cow, you!
*skips more time*
- *totally unaware she just read 400+ pages in a few hours* But why!?!? Why did it have to end? Just when it was getting good! I want more...
- When does the next book come out? ooo July supposedly...ok that's not a bad wait.
Somewhere along the way, Errol won my -what's the best word?- loyalty maybe? Respect for sure. When your the town drunk where can you go but up? Unless it's six feet under, but I digress. Watching Errol grow and learn was a wonderful adventure. I have liked characters and then turned around and hated them for something they did in a story. But I have never before disliked a character in the beginning only to love them in the end. And that is one of the things I love most about this book.
The story pretty much follows the standard fantasy hero's journey. Even so, there is so much woven into the story that it's easy to get lost and swept away in the pages. Without spoiling things I cannot make half the comments about the plot I wish to, except to say that I am looking forward to reading the next book.
Errol, oh what can I say about him. From page one, I was embarrassed by him. I didn't want to be in his head.
My wordless conversation with my book went something like this:
- Oh my god, really? How long is this book? *checks page count* *sigh*
- He's a drunk this early in the day? How old is he supposed to be?
- Yup let's get more money for alcohol.....why did I want to read this again?
- Author, I don't know you enough to give you the benefit of the doubt........ *blinks* Ooohhh! An assassin!
- *watches as Errol flees for his life* For a drunk, I think he's got more skills them me. *would have so totally fallen to her death*
*later on*
- Whoo hooo! You go Errol! Kick his butt! Yes! Whoo hoo!
- What!? Ah! You jerk! How dare you treat him that way! You cow, you!
*skips more time*
- *totally unaware she just read 400+ pages in a few hours* But why!?!? Why did it have to end? Just when it was getting good! I want more...
- When does the next book come out? ooo July supposedly...ok that's not a bad wait.
Somewhere along the way, Errol won my -what's the best word?- loyalty maybe? Respect for sure. When your the town drunk where can you go but up? Unless it's six feet under, but I digress. Watching Errol grow and learn was a wonderful adventure. I have liked characters and then turned around and hated them for something they did in a story. But I have never before disliked a character in the beginning only to love them in the end. And that is one of the things I love most about this book.
The story pretty much follows the standard fantasy hero's journey. Even so, there is so much woven into the story that it's easy to get lost and swept away in the pages. Without spoiling things I cannot make half the comments about the plot I wish to, except to say that I am looking forward to reading the next book.
March 22, 2014
This story centers around a very unlikely hero. Eroll is a drunk. His life consists of earning enough coin to spend his nights in the ale barrel. When he is unexpectedly thrust into a dangerous game of crown and church politics he is forced to rise above his weaknesses and become a new man.
I loved the protagonist of this book. We spend the entire story deep in his point of view, which makes him immediately sympathetic, despite his many flaws. Seeing his growth and transformation is a lot of fun.
The book features a very Christian-like religion. The similarity was clearly intentional and nicely done. The "magic system" of the book was closely linked into the theology of the world and draws inspiration from Christian spirituality. I enjoyed learning more about it as details were gradually let out through the progression of the book.
A Cast of Stones features strong characters who I grew attached to, and a thrilling plot. The book ties up its immediate conflicts but leaves plenty of room for sequels. I look forward to reading more in this world.
I loved the protagonist of this book. We spend the entire story deep in his point of view, which makes him immediately sympathetic, despite his many flaws. Seeing his growth and transformation is a lot of fun.
The book features a very Christian-like religion. The similarity was clearly intentional and nicely done. The "magic system" of the book was closely linked into the theology of the world and draws inspiration from Christian spirituality. I enjoyed learning more about it as details were gradually let out through the progression of the book.
A Cast of Stones features strong characters who I grew attached to, and a thrilling plot. The book ties up its immediate conflicts but leaves plenty of room for sequels. I look forward to reading more in this world.
December 28, 2024
I tend to enjoy novels that are character-focused, as opposed to action-driven, and this novel is a balance of both. The lead character's struggle with addiction is intriguing and even moving at times. For someone who isn't generally interested in fantasy beyond Narnia and Middle Earth, this book kept me until the end with twists that would always draw me back in just when my fantasy-adversion wanted to kick back in. Good stuff.
did-not-finish
February 12, 2018Well... this book was just confusing. I would be following along fine, and then I would feel like someone had skipped ahead one minute and expected me to still know what was going on. I decided to read something else.
February 5, 2013
Note: I received an ARC of this book from the LibraryThing Early Reviewers Program.
I enjoyed this book! Mr. Carr is a very talented writer. The story was imaginative and kept a nice pace, not too slow and not too fast and an easy read. The story line was easy to follow – maybe a little too easy (not really any surprises and was a little predictable). I was a little worried after receiving the book, reading that Mr. Carr was a member of a Christian writing group and that it was listed as a Christian fiction, that it might get out of my comfort zone but it stayed pretty typical for fantasy writing and did not become preachy at all. Actually knowing that it is listed as Christian fantasy may have spoiled it a bit for me at the beginning of the book as I was probably waiting for it but once I realized it wasn’t going to become anything that I wouldn’t normally read, I relaxed and enjoyed the read. There are a few typos/spelling errors that are now probably too late to fix. They are a little annoying, but nothing so bad that I wouldn't recommend the book.
I really enjoyed this story and the main character Errol has caught my interest and I look forward to continuing to read this series.
I enjoyed this book! Mr. Carr is a very talented writer. The story was imaginative and kept a nice pace, not too slow and not too fast and an easy read. The story line was easy to follow – maybe a little too easy (not really any surprises and was a little predictable). I was a little worried after receiving the book, reading that Mr. Carr was a member of a Christian writing group and that it was listed as a Christian fiction, that it might get out of my comfort zone but it stayed pretty typical for fantasy writing and did not become preachy at all. Actually knowing that it is listed as Christian fantasy may have spoiled it a bit for me at the beginning of the book as I was probably waiting for it but once I realized it wasn’t going to become anything that I wouldn’t normally read, I relaxed and enjoyed the read. There are a few typos/spelling errors that are now probably too late to fix. They are a little annoying, but nothing so bad that I wouldn't recommend the book.
I really enjoyed this story and the main character Errol has caught my interest and I look forward to continuing to read this series.
April 26, 2021
I really enjoyed this book! It started out slow, but picked up fairly quickly after the first two chapters. It was so inspiring to watch Errol grow from a drunkard to a fighting man and see the way he perseveres. I also very much appreciated how Carr gave Errol such a unique weapon. Whereas many fantasy books focus on the sword, this focused on the staff, giving it an almost exotic feel. If you enjoy fantasy or adventure, I recommend this book!
December 26, 2013
Excellent epic fantasy. Carr's "hero", Errol, is as unheroic as the village drunk--because that's what he is. Therefore he at least has an excuse for his early stupidity and unwillingness to get involved in the issues of the greater world. But, true to type, almost nothing is what it seems.
The entire narrative is written tightly from Errol's point of view. The reader may suspect more, but is told only what Errol sees, hears, smells and experiences. Unlike so much contemporary fantasy Carr provides meaningful motive for most of Errol's choices. And, even more rare, suitable guidance and opportunity to grow in the course of his high fantasy journey. There's good and evil out there, and choices matter.
All the more notable as the author's first published fiction.
A very good read.
The entire narrative is written tightly from Errol's point of view. The reader may suspect more, but is told only what Errol sees, hears, smells and experiences. Unlike so much contemporary fantasy Carr provides meaningful motive for most of Errol's choices. And, even more rare, suitable guidance and opportunity to grow in the course of his high fantasy journey. There's good and evil out there, and choices matter.
All the more notable as the author's first published fiction.
A very good read.
January 18, 2018
An unexpected 5 stars! I only give 5 stars if I know I would read the book over and over again. This is one of the most underrated books I have the good fortune to read. Don’t be wary to read this just because it’s classified as Christian book. It’s not preachy. I wouldn’t even know it’s a Christian book if not for goodreads. The hero reminded me so much of Cazaril from The Curse of Chalion. The type of hero that feels human. A hero you would root for and inspire you to be better. I would like to write more but I’m desperate for the second book so I leave you with this review in the hopes you would pick it up for yourself.
February 14, 2022
4.8
Okay, okay here me out: this book...this BOOK! This is what fantasy is made for!! Not gonna lie, it took me a little to get into to it bc I was just coming off of a book slump after reading the Maze Runner series (which is totally fair) but once I got into it, I couldn't put it down.
What I love the most is the unique magic system and storyline. I'm so tired of the cliches that riddle most fantasy books, but not here. The messages of light are strong as well and Errol is a wonderful mc!! .....and the ending.....omgosh I need the second one to come into the library like NOW!!
**
OVERVIEW
"The Fate of the Kingdom Awaits the Cast of Stones
In the backwater village of Callowford, roustabout Errol Stone is enlisted by a church messenger arriving with urgent missives for the hermit priest in the hills. Eager for coin, Errol agrees to what he thinks will be an easy task, but soon finds himself hunted by deadly assassins. Forced to flee with the priest and a small band of travelers, Errol soon learns he's joined a quest that could change the fate of his kingdom.
Protected for millennia by the heirs of the first king, the kingdom's dynasty nears its end and the selection of the new king begins--but in secret and shadow. As danger mounts, Errol must leave behind the stains and griefs of the past, learn to fight, and discover who is hunting him and his companions and how far they will go to stop the reading of the stones."
POSITIVE ELEMENTS
Positive messages of fighting for what's right and not letting your past define you.
SPIRITUAL ELEMENTS
Mentions of Deas (who appears to be their name for "God"). Church has a heavy influence in the story. Mentions of Deas' son (Jesus) coming and saving the world. Mentions of evil spirits and being (demon-like).
VIOLENCE
Several fights (no detail to semi-detailed). Errol learns how to use a staff. Description of pain, injury, bleeding and death. Ferral's are pretty horrifying beasts (demon-like). Mentions of assassins and murder. Errol is thrown out of a bar. Characters are shot at and hunted. Errol relives a memory of someone's death (semi-detailed).
SEXUAL CONTENT
Some mentions of people being suggestive (character immediately become uncomfortable and leave the situation). Mentions of women fawning over a man. A few kisses (not detailed). Mentions of feelings and touching (not inappropriate).
LANGUAGE
Clean. Some taunting and mentions of cursing (nothing said).
DRUGS/ALCOHOL
Errol is a drunk for a little over 1/4 of the book before he begins to fight his addiction (and is successful, I'm so proud of him <3). He later says that he's been in the ale-barrel for about 5 years. Several mentions of drinking and ale. Mentions of other drunkards. *Note: please don't let this put you off of reading this, it's really good and has such a positive message of healing
OTHER NOTES
An amazing story of finding your light and a wonderfully refreshing fantasy. Highly recommended ages 13+ for some violence and addiction. I'm so excited or "Hero's Lot"
**
~Happy Reading~
Okay, okay here me out: this book...this BOOK! This is what fantasy is made for!! Not gonna lie, it took me a little to get into to it bc I was just coming off of a book slump after reading the Maze Runner series (which is totally fair) but once I got into it, I couldn't put it down.
What I love the most is the unique magic system and storyline. I'm so tired of the cliches that riddle most fantasy books, but not here. The messages of light are strong as well and Errol is a wonderful mc!! .....and the ending.....omgosh I need the second one to come into the library like NOW!!
**
OVERVIEW
"The Fate of the Kingdom Awaits the Cast of Stones
In the backwater village of Callowford, roustabout Errol Stone is enlisted by a church messenger arriving with urgent missives for the hermit priest in the hills. Eager for coin, Errol agrees to what he thinks will be an easy task, but soon finds himself hunted by deadly assassins. Forced to flee with the priest and a small band of travelers, Errol soon learns he's joined a quest that could change the fate of his kingdom.
Protected for millennia by the heirs of the first king, the kingdom's dynasty nears its end and the selection of the new king begins--but in secret and shadow. As danger mounts, Errol must leave behind the stains and griefs of the past, learn to fight, and discover who is hunting him and his companions and how far they will go to stop the reading of the stones."
POSITIVE ELEMENTS
Positive messages of fighting for what's right and not letting your past define you.
SPIRITUAL ELEMENTS
Mentions of Deas (who appears to be their name for "God"). Church has a heavy influence in the story. Mentions of Deas' son (Jesus) coming and saving the world. Mentions of evil spirits and being (demon-like).
VIOLENCE
Several fights (no detail to semi-detailed). Errol learns how to use a staff. Description of pain, injury, bleeding and death. Ferral's are pretty horrifying beasts (demon-like). Mentions of assassins and murder. Errol is thrown out of a bar. Characters are shot at and hunted. Errol relives a memory of someone's death (semi-detailed).
SEXUAL CONTENT
Some mentions of people being suggestive (character immediately become uncomfortable and leave the situation). Mentions of women fawning over a man. A few kisses (not detailed). Mentions of feelings and touching (not inappropriate).
LANGUAGE
Clean. Some taunting and mentions of cursing (nothing said).
DRUGS/ALCOHOL
Errol is a drunk for a little over 1/4 of the book before he begins to fight his addiction (and is successful, I'm so proud of him <3). He later says that he's been in the ale-barrel for about 5 years. Several mentions of drinking and ale. Mentions of other drunkards. *Note: please don't let this put you off of reading this, it's really good and has such a positive message of healing
OTHER NOTES
An amazing story of finding your light and a wonderfully refreshing fantasy. Highly recommended ages 13+ for some violence and addiction. I'm so excited or "Hero's Lot"
**
~Happy Reading~
May 21, 2024
4.5 stars ⭐️ I’ll admit I started this book last year and then decided I wasn’t interested. But I’m very glad I decided to pick this book up again! I struggled through the first 100 pages or so but then I really started to get interested in the story. Errol’s struggle with drunkenness and how he overcame that struggle was very rewarding to read about. Also his weapon of choice being a staff was very cool. Made reading the fighting scenes even cooler! I did find it strange the mutal attraction between Adora and Errol. We never read about an introduction between the two the author just makes it seem like they already know one another. Nevertheless the less a very enjoyable read. Excited to read the next two books in the series.
December 17, 2017
This trilogy is my favorite trilogy of all time (at least, when it comes to books.) It is also my third favorite series of all time, so obviously on this reread I would give this book 5 stars and tell you why.
When I first heard of A Cast of Stones I pictured it as a typical Medieval fantasy book (which is in some ways) and thus wasn't super into reading it. BUT it was free on iBooks so I picked it up and well...the rest is history.
First are some minor issues I have with the story despite my immense love:
•This book MAJORLY needs a map. I can't even fathom why this book doesn't have a map. It seems absolutely necessary BUT ITS NOT HERE FOLKS. Apparently a map wasn't included because this world is an exact copy of England and its provinces with different names BUT STILL a map is needed my friends.
•God, Jesus, and the Holy Spirit (the trinity) are known deities in this book (they're called Deas, some name that starts with E that I can't remember and Aurae) but they're kinda glossed over like they're just there. I don't necessarily have a problem with this its just that this world very much screams Medieval Catholsim/the church at the time which I'm not a huge fan of in fantasy because I SEE IT SO MUCH. The church is a huge part of the way the main culture in the world runs but the roots of the church are kinda left on the sideline. I would think that the author would represent it that way because that's how it was in Medieval times but I would have also expected maybe the main character to think more deeply about it. I would expect that in a world where the church matters much that the main character would at least have a moment to think somewhat deeply about its roots. BUT NOPE.
•Another little squabble I have is with the world building. It's certainly an interesting world with many places and neat names but it all seems somewhat underdeveloped and complicated in places where we do have information (which is the main reason I chose to reread this.) Rereading this DID help and it might have been better had I HAD A MAP IN THE FIRST PLACE. (I seriously considered drawing my own map but would have probably gone mad in the process.)
BUT, my friends, here is why I love this book:
•The writing itself is excellent, and I would have never guessed that this was Carr's debut had I read it without knowing as such. The word choice, sentence flow, and dialogue is all written very well.
•This series includes a lot of adult characters. I'm not entirely sure this series is marketed as young adult, but I kinda assumed it was since the main character, Errol, is a teenager. (Well 19...but still.) But it is important to have adult characters because hey, adults actually do stuff. They aren't always A) useless or B) tyrannical leaders or C) there just so they can die to spurn the main teenage character on which is what a lot of YA novels would have us believe.
•Other than Martin, Luis, and Cruk (aka the main adult characters) there are some other interesting characters. My favorite side character is Rokah who is great because A) she's kick-butt awesome B) her sole propose is NOT to be the love interest for the main character. C) she's cunning and smart. D) she's witty and humorous. And E) she's surrounded by men but holds her own. SO BASICALLY I LOVE HER.
•Naaman Ru aka the caravan master is someone readers will enjoy hating.
•Errol Stone is the main character. He's a drunkard at the beginning of the story which is a rare but good representation to have in literature. His character development (including his journey to forsake his addiction) is superb. He is flawed and an impressive lead character. This would also be a good time to mention that he is my favorite male character. OF ALL TIME. Hands down. He's also immensely adorable and doesn't quite know what to do around the ladies. He has a dark past that haunts him but he's not a brooding bad boy either. ALSO. There's a prophecy about who's gonna be the next King and all BUT Errol's part in the story is very very very different and interesting.
This book and series as a whole is unique on sooooo many levels and here are some of the reasons:
•In about every fantasy book the characters battle with swords (there are swords for those of you who eat that kinda combat all up) but Errol uses a staff which is A) something I hadn't read before this and B) actually pretty dang interesting. Normally, when reading fantasy I kinda skim the combat scenes BUT IN THIS BOOK every single combat scene was actually a lot of fun to read about! It was interesting and unpredictable as well as thrilling.
•The magic is unique too. But it's also difficult to explain so all I'll say is it involves A) casting lots to tell the future. B) certain people who can cast and read lots. And C) it has rules to it and plays a huge part in the story. I'll leave it up to you to discover the magic in its entirety.
•The world building though underdeveloped at times is actually quite interesting in some portions. The names are my favorite part because literally every name of every place was great!
•The plot tends to move slower than most fantasy books, but I actually quite like the pace of this book. ALOT happens in the last fourth and brings the book to a cliffhanging end.
//"Some men are more easily broken by kindness than censure."//
When I first heard of A Cast of Stones I pictured it as a typical Medieval fantasy book (which is in some ways) and thus wasn't super into reading it. BUT it was free on iBooks so I picked it up and well...the rest is history.
First are some minor issues I have with the story despite my immense love:
•This book MAJORLY needs a map. I can't even fathom why this book doesn't have a map. It seems absolutely necessary BUT ITS NOT HERE FOLKS. Apparently a map wasn't included because this world is an exact copy of England and its provinces with different names BUT STILL a map is needed my friends.
•God, Jesus, and the Holy Spirit (the trinity) are known deities in this book (they're called Deas, some name that starts with E that I can't remember and Aurae) but they're kinda glossed over like they're just there. I don't necessarily have a problem with this its just that this world very much screams Medieval Catholsim/the church at the time which I'm not a huge fan of in fantasy because I SEE IT SO MUCH. The church is a huge part of the way the main culture in the world runs but the roots of the church are kinda left on the sideline. I would think that the author would represent it that way because that's how it was in Medieval times but I would have also expected maybe the main character to think more deeply about it. I would expect that in a world where the church matters much that the main character would at least have a moment to think somewhat deeply about its roots. BUT NOPE.
•Another little squabble I have is with the world building. It's certainly an interesting world with many places and neat names but it all seems somewhat underdeveloped and complicated in places where we do have information (which is the main reason I chose to reread this.) Rereading this DID help and it might have been better had I HAD A MAP IN THE FIRST PLACE. (I seriously considered drawing my own map but would have probably gone mad in the process.)
BUT, my friends, here is why I love this book:
•The writing itself is excellent, and I would have never guessed that this was Carr's debut had I read it without knowing as such. The word choice, sentence flow, and dialogue is all written very well.
•This series includes a lot of adult characters. I'm not entirely sure this series is marketed as young adult, but I kinda assumed it was since the main character, Errol, is a teenager. (Well 19...but still.) But it is important to have adult characters because hey, adults actually do stuff. They aren't always A) useless or B) tyrannical leaders or C) there just so they can die to spurn the main teenage character on which is what a lot of YA novels would have us believe.
•Other than Martin, Luis, and Cruk (aka the main adult characters) there are some other interesting characters. My favorite side character is Rokah who is great because A) she's kick-butt awesome B) her sole propose is NOT to be the love interest for the main character. C) she's cunning and smart. D) she's witty and humorous. And E) she's surrounded by men but holds her own. SO BASICALLY I LOVE HER.
•Naaman Ru aka the caravan master is someone readers will enjoy hating.
•Errol Stone is the main character. He's a drunkard at the beginning of the story which is a rare but good representation to have in literature. His character development (including his journey to forsake his addiction) is superb. He is flawed and an impressive lead character. This would also be a good time to mention that he is my favorite male character. OF ALL TIME. Hands down. He's also immensely adorable and doesn't quite know what to do around the ladies. He has a dark past that haunts him but he's not a brooding bad boy either. ALSO. There's a prophecy about who's gonna be the next King and all BUT Errol's part in the story is very very very different and interesting.
This book and series as a whole is unique on sooooo many levels and here are some of the reasons:
•In about every fantasy book the characters battle with swords (there are swords for those of you who eat that kinda combat all up) but Errol uses a staff which is A) something I hadn't read before this and B) actually pretty dang interesting. Normally, when reading fantasy I kinda skim the combat scenes BUT IN THIS BOOK every single combat scene was actually a lot of fun to read about! It was interesting and unpredictable as well as thrilling.
•The magic is unique too. But it's also difficult to explain so all I'll say is it involves A) casting lots to tell the future. B) certain people who can cast and read lots. And C) it has rules to it and plays a huge part in the story. I'll leave it up to you to discover the magic in its entirety.
•The world building though underdeveloped at times is actually quite interesting in some portions. The names are my favorite part because literally every name of every place was great!
•The plot tends to move slower than most fantasy books, but I actually quite like the pace of this book. ALOT happens in the last fourth and brings the book to a cliffhanging end.
//"Some men are more easily broken by kindness than censure."//
May 27, 2014
Wow, what a journey!
Everyone recognises Errol Stone as the village drunk, and he's not yet nineteen years old. His one ambition is to earn a bit of money for his next fix of ale, so he won't fall apart. When a strange messenger wants a secret parcel delivered to Pater Martin, the reclusive priest, Errol is quick to volunteer. He knows the pay will keep sobriety at bay for at least another week, but comes to wish he hadn't bothered.
He never expects to be plunged, unwittingly, into the dangerous tension of church and politics. Opening his mouth to remark that he can see writing on a strange carved stone is his first big mistake. He is whisked away as a pawn in some weird game he can't understand, along with Liam, the village good boy, who seems perfect in every way. While he can understand why Liam, who can apparently do no wrong, may be desirable, he's at a loss to figure out why he's being dragged along too.
It's satisfying to see a main character develop from a pathetic alcoholic and self-proclaimed waste of space to a sharp and quick-witted young man who must remain on his guard every moment. Every time I picked up the book and said, "I wonder what Errol's up to," it was bound to involve intense intrigue, adrenaline and many secrets. There are the secrets he kept himself, which gradually unfold helping us to understand why he became a drunk at the age of 14. Then there are other secrets which he remains clueless about. Even the friends who want to train him up to be a reader of cast lots don't know. We don't know either. It seems only the baddies know.
The great question keeping us turning the pages is often uttered from the mouths of many different characters. 'What makes you so important, boy?" If only we knew. At a loss to answer, Errol doesn't have a lot of time to think about it, between having to defend himself from vicious murder attempts.
At the finish, my first move was to get hold of the second book, 'The Hero's Lot' on my kindle, as quickly as possible. It feels as if I'm under a compulsion, as Errol was to get to the city of Erinon. This book should come with a warning, "Don't start unless you're prepared to put time aside for an epic trilogy." If the next two books are anything like this one, I'm sure it will be.
Everyone recognises Errol Stone as the village drunk, and he's not yet nineteen years old. His one ambition is to earn a bit of money for his next fix of ale, so he won't fall apart. When a strange messenger wants a secret parcel delivered to Pater Martin, the reclusive priest, Errol is quick to volunteer. He knows the pay will keep sobriety at bay for at least another week, but comes to wish he hadn't bothered.
He never expects to be plunged, unwittingly, into the dangerous tension of church and politics. Opening his mouth to remark that he can see writing on a strange carved stone is his first big mistake. He is whisked away as a pawn in some weird game he can't understand, along with Liam, the village good boy, who seems perfect in every way. While he can understand why Liam, who can apparently do no wrong, may be desirable, he's at a loss to figure out why he's being dragged along too.
It's satisfying to see a main character develop from a pathetic alcoholic and self-proclaimed waste of space to a sharp and quick-witted young man who must remain on his guard every moment. Every time I picked up the book and said, "I wonder what Errol's up to," it was bound to involve intense intrigue, adrenaline and many secrets. There are the secrets he kept himself, which gradually unfold helping us to understand why he became a drunk at the age of 14. Then there are other secrets which he remains clueless about. Even the friends who want to train him up to be a reader of cast lots don't know. We don't know either. It seems only the baddies know.
The great question keeping us turning the pages is often uttered from the mouths of many different characters. 'What makes you so important, boy?" If only we knew. At a loss to answer, Errol doesn't have a lot of time to think about it, between having to defend himself from vicious murder attempts.
At the finish, my first move was to get hold of the second book, 'The Hero's Lot' on my kindle, as quickly as possible. It feels as if I'm under a compulsion, as Errol was to get to the city of Erinon. This book should come with a warning, "Don't start unless you're prepared to put time aside for an epic trilogy." If the next two books are anything like this one, I'm sure it will be.
March 13, 2013
Praises to Deas for Patrick W. Carr, for this excellent and audacious novel!
Errol, a boy who has wandered far from the path and is a habitué for ale drowning within the barrel, agrees to carry a letter to the hermit priest (Martin) in the hills, for a coin which he already plans to use on ale to keep himself glazed for a week. Little does he realize that this action would change his entire life.
So begins an adventure which covers 432 pages of excitement and invaluable lessons. Errol meets clever and kind friends who help him along the way.
Through the entire book your gripping the book and bearing your teeth at anyone who tries to take it away from you, because it really is an intense read! Errol faces danger at every corner, deadly assassins, a malus, horrific monsters (ferrals) which you can hear snarling in your ears as you turn each page of the book.
The book, is filled with quite a bit of action, so it is understandable that someone who doesn't like action and violence, they would most likely not enjoy reading this book very much.
I loved the fact this was a Christian Fiction book, the churches, priests, abbots, and monks, were positively fascinating! Even if you aren't religious, I'd still say, this is a good book to read anyway, especially if you love fantasy fiction at all!
There are so many twists and turns in the plot making you wish you didn't have to eat and sleep to stay alive, because the only thing you want to do is finish the book!
I kept waiting for an anti-climax to the story, but it didn't come! There is hardly a moment of this book in which any fantasy lover would not enjoy!
I cannot wait for book two!
Errol, a boy who has wandered far from the path and is a habitué for ale drowning within the barrel, agrees to carry a letter to the hermit priest (Martin) in the hills, for a coin which he already plans to use on ale to keep himself glazed for a week. Little does he realize that this action would change his entire life.
So begins an adventure which covers 432 pages of excitement and invaluable lessons. Errol meets clever and kind friends who help him along the way.
Through the entire book your gripping the book and bearing your teeth at anyone who tries to take it away from you, because it really is an intense read! Errol faces danger at every corner, deadly assassins, a malus, horrific monsters (ferrals) which you can hear snarling in your ears as you turn each page of the book.
The book, is filled with quite a bit of action, so it is understandable that someone who doesn't like action and violence, they would most likely not enjoy reading this book very much.
I loved the fact this was a Christian Fiction book, the churches, priests, abbots, and monks, were positively fascinating! Even if you aren't religious, I'd still say, this is a good book to read anyway, especially if you love fantasy fiction at all!
There are so many twists and turns in the plot making you wish you didn't have to eat and sleep to stay alive, because the only thing you want to do is finish the book!
I kept waiting for an anti-climax to the story, but it didn't come! There is hardly a moment of this book in which any fantasy lover would not enjoy!
I cannot wait for book two!
February 6, 2018
I did not expect to enjoy A Cast of Stones as much as I did. I tried reading this a while ago and couldn't get into it, so I set it aside. I decided to try it again recently and this time around I really enjoyed it. Once I got a little bit into the story, I was intrigued and kept wanting to read more.
I thought the fantasy world was written very well. I felt like the characters and setting were real and believable. The plot was interesting and held my attention.
All in all, I liked A Cast of Stones a lot and recommend it. I'm looking forward to reading the next book.
*Disclosure of Material Connection: I received one or more of the products or services mentioned above for free in the hope that I would mention/review it on my blog. I was not required to give a positive review, only my honest opinion - which I've done. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own and I only recommend products or services I use personally and believe will be good for my readers. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CFR, Part 255: "Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.*
I thought the fantasy world was written very well. I felt like the characters and setting were real and believable. The plot was interesting and held my attention.
All in all, I liked A Cast of Stones a lot and recommend it. I'm looking forward to reading the next book.
*Disclosure of Material Connection: I received one or more of the products or services mentioned above for free in the hope that I would mention/review it on my blog. I was not required to give a positive review, only my honest opinion - which I've done. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own and I only recommend products or services I use personally and believe will be good for my readers. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CFR, Part 255: "Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.*
November 11, 2014
I really wanted to like this book. I heard so many great things about it, how it's what Christian speculative fiction fans have been waiting for...
I made it a few chapters and decided to pass on the rest of the book. The characters didn't really jump off the page, and the story world was rather sparse. What drove me to completely give up was the redundancy. The main character is a drunk--I get it. No need to reference it every third line. Overall it just felt that there was too much focus in areas like that, and not enough in building the story world.
I made it a few chapters and decided to pass on the rest of the book. The characters didn't really jump off the page, and the story world was rather sparse. What drove me to completely give up was the redundancy. The main character is a drunk--I get it. No need to reference it every third line. Overall it just felt that there was too much focus in areas like that, and not enough in building the story world.
December 12, 2016
Excellent Christian Fantasy
This fast-paced adventure centers around a most unlikely hero, chased by demons of his own making as well as those set against him by unseen enemies. There is plenty of intrique to go with the action, so that you never really know what is coming next. This is a great read you won't want to put down--I am eagerly awaiting the next book!
This fast-paced adventure centers around a most unlikely hero, chased by demons of his own making as well as those set against him by unseen enemies. There is plenty of intrique to go with the action, so that you never really know what is coming next. This is a great read you won't want to put down--I am eagerly awaiting the next book!
August 2, 2020
Since this is traditionally published, I'm going to keep this short.
I loved the characters and the setting. Worldbuilding was on point as was the development of the story. My complaints are just that his writing started a bit choppy, not SHOCKINGLY so but just that it made the story hard to get into. Also, while it was refreshing to see crushes that didn't develop into anything (your first crush isn't your true love, people), and while Errol's rather hilarious *I don't know what to do with beautiful women* infatuations were funny, it did feel cliche (though I could feel it develop into something deeper, so I might edit this part out later)
Still. It was an amazing first book with such fun spiritual themes to hopefully explore deeper! And also, I gotta say the world is super creative, and the story pulls you in as you continue with it.
Now for book 2....
I loved the characters and the setting. Worldbuilding was on point as was the development of the story. My complaints are just that his writing started a bit choppy, not SHOCKINGLY so but just that it made the story hard to get into. Also, while it was refreshing to see crushes that didn't develop into anything (your first crush isn't your true love, people), and while Errol's rather hilarious *I don't know what to do with beautiful women* infatuations were funny, it did feel cliche (though I could feel it develop into something deeper, so I might edit this part out later)
Still. It was an amazing first book with such fun spiritual themes to hopefully explore deeper! And also, I gotta say the world is super creative, and the story pulls you in as you continue with it.
Now for book 2....
July 19, 2025
I read this book in middle school (7th grade I think?) and truly I’ve been chasing the high ever since
I think this held up decently - now that I’m older, the mirroring of Catholicism is incredibly obvious, and definitely the female characters are less developed than I recall them being, but I still enjoyed, what can I say. I LOVE a montage moment, which is basically the entire second half of this book, and the nostalgia was PEAK
I think this held up decently - now that I’m older, the mirroring of Catholicism is incredibly obvious, and definitely the female characters are less developed than I recall them being, but I still enjoyed, what can I say. I LOVE a montage moment, which is basically the entire second half of this book, and the nostalgia was PEAK
December 10, 2017
It's taken me a rather long time to get through this, though the fault for that lies with me, and not the book itself. I enjoyed the story, and liked the mc, and I'm looking forward to seeing what happens in the sequels.
January 27, 2013
On occasion I have the urge to gush over-much. On this particular occasion, I'm nervous of throwing so much confetti about this book that it looks promotional instead of critical. I shall attempt to sound dignified, but really... when I happen upon a book like this, it's like discovering a stash of chocolate. There's some sqee-ing.
*ahem*
I like the writing style. There's no extra words. There's just the exact amount of words necessary to portray the landscape as touchable and the characters... as full of hidden layers. (Lots of secret, malicious, creepy layers.) No more.
The world is so believable, I feel like archaeologists will explain how they know this kingdom existed this way. The people Errol sees represent different parts of the world by their hair color or accent or something, giving me this grand scope of the old-style world. Errol is from a tiny village, though, so he sees details as if he's used to knowing every branch and rock and notes the differences in his travels.
Errol is cool. He doesn't seem very cool on the first page and I loved all the surprises as he changes and grows... so I don't want to give anything away... except... This book - I don't care if there are 400 pages - is not big enough to give me enough of Errol. Nope. He learns a lot. DO NOT SPOIL THIS BOOK by peaking ahead at everything he learns in this story!! Just say "no" to spoilers!! It's best to experience it all with him, from his intelligent, humble point of view.
The spiritual side of things feels just right, some kind of old-school religious structure that was good when it was first created, but it being corrupted at the time of this story. As priests, it's extra deceptive because it feels like they should be trustworthy. Some are. There's a dark side, too... the malas are downright freaky. Spiritual things willing to take over someone's body upon request. *shudder* There's things with teeth, too.
The danger is very real and this book is more of an introduction to a very big picture than any resolution. Although, the story is complete in itself, for the most part. It left me feeling rather desperate for the next book in the series and wondering just how many there are? 'Cause the scope is definitely (trilogy) epic.
My Rating: 4.65
*ahem*
I like the writing style. There's no extra words. There's just the exact amount of words necessary to portray the landscape as touchable and the characters... as full of hidden layers. (Lots of secret, malicious, creepy layers.) No more.
The world is so believable, I feel like archaeologists will explain how they know this kingdom existed this way. The people Errol sees represent different parts of the world by their hair color or accent or something, giving me this grand scope of the old-style world. Errol is from a tiny village, though, so he sees details as if he's used to knowing every branch and rock and notes the differences in his travels.
Errol is cool. He doesn't seem very cool on the first page and I loved all the surprises as he changes and grows... so I don't want to give anything away... except... This book - I don't care if there are 400 pages - is not big enough to give me enough of Errol. Nope. He learns a lot. DO NOT SPOIL THIS BOOK by peaking ahead at everything he learns in this story!! Just say "no" to spoilers!! It's best to experience it all with him, from his intelligent, humble point of view.
The spiritual side of things feels just right, some kind of old-school religious structure that was good when it was first created, but it being corrupted at the time of this story. As priests, it's extra deceptive because it feels like they should be trustworthy. Some are. There's a dark side, too... the malas are downright freaky. Spiritual things willing to take over someone's body upon request. *shudder* There's things with teeth, too.
The danger is very real and this book is more of an introduction to a very big picture than any resolution. Although, the story is complete in itself, for the most part. It left me feeling rather desperate for the next book in the series and wondering just how many there are? 'Cause the scope is definitely (trilogy) epic.
My Rating: 4.65
October 18, 2014
I finished this at 1:30 in the morning. Which actually doesn't necessarily mean anything for the book, because that's usually a pretty typical bed time for me. But in this case, I seriously couldn't put it down.
However, it wasn't always like that.
Okay, so for the first half of the story this book and I had a very delicate relationship. I would be interested, and then I would cease to care altogether and not pick it up for another week or so. I don't know why. Nothing was wrong with it. It appeared that we just weren't compatible. Which was another great mystery to me - there was nothing in the book that I found annoying or off putting.
But I guess it either grew on me, or my mood changed. Something. I don't know what. But something changed and I seriously couldn't put the book down. Not for my dog who constantly begged me to go back to sleep, not for my cat which simply wanted affection, not even to greet my sister as she slipped off to her room muttering about how my sleeping habits were insane.
The main character, Errol, was one of the best young adult characters I have ever read. He was extremely flawed and extremely real. He starts out as a character you morbidly pity, a character you do love, but only in a warped sort of way. You don't feel like that at the end. He grows up so much (and it's not always easy) and at the end you are just so dang proud of him. Or at least, I was.
This book is extremely fast paced, which I found rather refreshing. It always kept me on my toes, and those last couple chapters when things were starting to come together and make sense had me all tense and on the edge of the couch. I'm pretty sure my face looked something like this:
I'm even interested enough in this series that I'm going to read book two, which is a huge commitment for me.
If you find yourself not getting into it, at least read halfway through. It seemed to work for me. Because it gets really good, I promise.
However, it wasn't always like that.
Okay, so for the first half of the story this book and I had a very delicate relationship. I would be interested, and then I would cease to care altogether and not pick it up for another week or so. I don't know why. Nothing was wrong with it. It appeared that we just weren't compatible. Which was another great mystery to me - there was nothing in the book that I found annoying or off putting.
But I guess it either grew on me, or my mood changed. Something. I don't know what. But something changed and I seriously couldn't put the book down. Not for my dog who constantly begged me to go back to sleep, not for my cat which simply wanted affection, not even to greet my sister as she slipped off to her room muttering about how my sleeping habits were insane.
The main character, Errol, was one of the best young adult characters I have ever read. He was extremely flawed and extremely real. He starts out as a character you morbidly pity, a character you do love, but only in a warped sort of way. You don't feel like that at the end. He grows up so much (and it's not always easy) and at the end you are just so dang proud of him. Or at least, I was.
This book is extremely fast paced, which I found rather refreshing. It always kept me on my toes, and those last couple chapters when things were starting to come together and make sense had me all tense and on the edge of the couch. I'm pretty sure my face looked something like this:
I'm even interested enough in this series that I'm going to read book two, which is a huge commitment for me.
If you find yourself not getting into it, at least read halfway through. It seemed to work for me. Because it gets really good, I promise.
February 14, 2013
If you are looking for a well-written fantasy novel, then "A Cast of Stones" may just be for you. It's a fantasy that even your grandma will approve of (there's not fifty shades of anything in THIS book).
Featuring a world conceived with great imagination, Patrick W. Carr's "A Cast of Stones" is an epic fantasy tale sure to delight savvy readers. Once I'd read enough of the story to wrap myself around the world the author has invented, I found myself pleasantly surprised with the pacing of the story and the intense action scenes that unfolded. The deeper into the story I went, the more engaged I was until by the end I was entirely caught up in the plot to see what Errol was in for next! The author's descriptions are sharp and clear, and he displays a keen ability to bring a story to life, weaving together fantasy and mystery and intrigue. I love the character of Errol, one of those characters who you have immediate sympathy for, while also reflecting our own struggles in life to feel significant and that your life has worth. The book is fairly long at well over 400 pages, and perhaps could have been tightened up a bit (although I also admit it's hard to imagine what the author would take out). Overall it is a grand start to the author's writing career, and is worthy entertainment indeed.
I am definitely looking forward to what is coming next in the series. Readers who enjoy works by Stephen Lawhead will surely enjoy "A Cast of Stones". I give this book a solid recommendation and award it 4 out of 5 stars.
Book has been provided courtesy of Baker Publishing Group and Graf-Martin Communications, Inc. Available at your favourite bookseller from Bethany House, a division of Baker Publishing Group.
Featuring a world conceived with great imagination, Patrick W. Carr's "A Cast of Stones" is an epic fantasy tale sure to delight savvy readers. Once I'd read enough of the story to wrap myself around the world the author has invented, I found myself pleasantly surprised with the pacing of the story and the intense action scenes that unfolded. The deeper into the story I went, the more engaged I was until by the end I was entirely caught up in the plot to see what Errol was in for next! The author's descriptions are sharp and clear, and he displays a keen ability to bring a story to life, weaving together fantasy and mystery and intrigue. I love the character of Errol, one of those characters who you have immediate sympathy for, while also reflecting our own struggles in life to feel significant and that your life has worth. The book is fairly long at well over 400 pages, and perhaps could have been tightened up a bit (although I also admit it's hard to imagine what the author would take out). Overall it is a grand start to the author's writing career, and is worthy entertainment indeed.
I am definitely looking forward to what is coming next in the series. Readers who enjoy works by Stephen Lawhead will surely enjoy "A Cast of Stones". I give this book a solid recommendation and award it 4 out of 5 stars.
Book has been provided courtesy of Baker Publishing Group and Graf-Martin Communications, Inc. Available at your favourite bookseller from Bethany House, a division of Baker Publishing Group.
February 20, 2013
A Cast of Stones is an awesome medieval fantasy story. Thankfully when I turned the last page, I realised A Cast of Stones is the first in a series –there is more to come!
Errol Stone, the village drunk, takes a message to a hermit priest in the hills. His motivation was the coin he would receive for his effort. Instead of returning before nightfall with enough money to stay drunk for a week, he is hunted by an assassin on route and almost killed before he could deliver the message.
Errol’s life changes drastically when he has no option but to flee for his life, and join the quest that changes, not only his life, but the fate of the kingdom.
A Cast of Stones is a glorious fantasy story with plots twisting in directions you do not expect; the most unlikely become heroes, the villains are devious and tricky, then there are the priests, the guards and of course the king. There is enough danger and twists to keep you on edge, and enough wisdom to keep your hopes up.
I highly recommend A Cast of Stones. A Cast of Stones is a great book to read by all fantasy lovers. I invite those who do not care for the fantasy genre, but enjoy a good plot and like to dream of heroes, to put your toes into the water and to read A Cast of Stones.
The message I received from A Cast of Stones is –you are born with the calling God has placed on your life. No circumstances and no enemy will take your calling away. The enemy or circumstances can divert you from your chosen path, but it cannot destroy the calling.
Baker Publishing House Group / Bethany House Publishers as part of their media review bloggers program provided this eBook to me for free in exchange for this honest review.
Errol Stone, the village drunk, takes a message to a hermit priest in the hills. His motivation was the coin he would receive for his effort. Instead of returning before nightfall with enough money to stay drunk for a week, he is hunted by an assassin on route and almost killed before he could deliver the message.
Errol’s life changes drastically when he has no option but to flee for his life, and join the quest that changes, not only his life, but the fate of the kingdom.
A Cast of Stones is a glorious fantasy story with plots twisting in directions you do not expect; the most unlikely become heroes, the villains are devious and tricky, then there are the priests, the guards and of course the king. There is enough danger and twists to keep you on edge, and enough wisdom to keep your hopes up.
I highly recommend A Cast of Stones. A Cast of Stones is a great book to read by all fantasy lovers. I invite those who do not care for the fantasy genre, but enjoy a good plot and like to dream of heroes, to put your toes into the water and to read A Cast of Stones.
The message I received from A Cast of Stones is –you are born with the calling God has placed on your life. No circumstances and no enemy will take your calling away. The enemy or circumstances can divert you from your chosen path, but it cannot destroy the calling.
Baker Publishing House Group / Bethany House Publishers as part of their media review bloggers program provided this eBook to me for free in exchange for this honest review.
April 25, 2013
I came to this novel rather late, and noticed that it has a lot of glowing reviews. People acquainted with me will know I can have rather high standards, but really I just did not like this book very much almost from the outset.
There were some original elements in the story- the notion of the stone `lots' for instance though this could be problematic. Not all of the characters seemed to be particularly well developed, though a few of them were likable.
There were other issues too- the most notable being the writing style. I honestly have no intention of being nasty, making a personal attack on the author by writing this, and I apologize of it causes offense. In some places the book read as though it could have been written by a 15 year old. I know it was his first novel, and he did his best, but some of the descriptions of characters feelings and metaphors just left a lot to be desired.
Some of the religious elements of the story seemed a little dubious and questionable.
Bethany House is a major Christian publisher and so the book obviously comes under the umbrella of `Christian' fiction.
Yet the central notion of the `readers' who are `born with' the power to see what is written on lots seems to be one that is dubious. Basically, `lots' are round balls which readers use to help them make decisions or find out information by `fixing a picture' in their mind of the possibilities.
To me, it seemed a little like visualisation and appeared as though the readers were almost able to project their thoughts onto the lots.
Too see full review please visit my blog http://crossromance.blogspot.co.uk/20...
There were some original elements in the story- the notion of the stone `lots' for instance though this could be problematic. Not all of the characters seemed to be particularly well developed, though a few of them were likable.
There were other issues too- the most notable being the writing style. I honestly have no intention of being nasty, making a personal attack on the author by writing this, and I apologize of it causes offense. In some places the book read as though it could have been written by a 15 year old. I know it was his first novel, and he did his best, but some of the descriptions of characters feelings and metaphors just left a lot to be desired.
Some of the religious elements of the story seemed a little dubious and questionable.
Bethany House is a major Christian publisher and so the book obviously comes under the umbrella of `Christian' fiction.
Yet the central notion of the `readers' who are `born with' the power to see what is written on lots seems to be one that is dubious. Basically, `lots' are round balls which readers use to help them make decisions or find out information by `fixing a picture' in their mind of the possibilities.
To me, it seemed a little like visualisation and appeared as though the readers were almost able to project their thoughts onto the lots.
Too see full review please visit my blog http://crossromance.blogspot.co.uk/20...
January 26, 2016
I thoroughly enjoyed this single-point-of-view tale. It begins with the introduction of a staggering drunk as the main character—a not entirely likable character, but the reader can sympathize with him—and journeys with him to his surprising new position in the world. This advancement doesn’t come to Errol Stone easily; he has physical and emotional demons to overcome while he’s being chased by poison- and blade-toting villains. He makes some incredible faux pas, and he also does exactly the opposite. There is a lot going on his world that he doesn’t know or understand. Carr handles the mystery well, and the reader learns as Errol learns. This doesn’t prevent the revelation of several subplots that keep the action and suspense going—and the story is wonderfully complex.
The end is a little shaky, but not abysmal. It didn’t keep me from moving directly on to Book 2. The intriguing epilogue definitely helped in that respect.
Criticisms? There are a few typos and confusions about direction, number, and who a character is talking to — enough to make me read the passages twice, but not enough (by any means) to ruin the story. The book does have a virulent case of Comma Splicing, which I find annoying in general but, again, not enough to ruin the story. And… naming conventions are inconsistent, with some taken straight from our world, some slightly modified (Morgols, Soedes, Basqu — and Finn Maccol), and some original. What was going on there? Did I miss something?
Those nit-picking concerns aside, the book is a wonderful page-turner. Clean, gore-free (in spite of fight scenes), and an all-around good read.
The end is a little shaky, but not abysmal. It didn’t keep me from moving directly on to Book 2. The intriguing epilogue definitely helped in that respect.
Criticisms? There are a few typos and confusions about direction, number, and who a character is talking to — enough to make me read the passages twice, but not enough (by any means) to ruin the story. The book does have a virulent case of Comma Splicing, which I find annoying in general but, again, not enough to ruin the story. And… naming conventions are inconsistent, with some taken straight from our world, some slightly modified (Morgols, Soedes, Basqu — and Finn Maccol), and some original. What was going on there? Did I miss something?
Those nit-picking concerns aside, the book is a wonderful page-turner. Clean, gore-free (in spite of fight scenes), and an all-around good read.
June 10, 2015
Unique Story
This is a good story for young men. There is no sex or language but a great deal of fighting and action. The way the author describes Errol's craft with the staff was so superb it made me want to go out and learn how to brandish a staff of my own. There are many different kinds of villains, from oafs to assassins to corrupt abbots to violent "ferrals" and demonic "malus." The cast is huge. The author introduces dozens of characters that only serve a small role in the whole of the story. I did not care for the many different love interests, but the romance was only hinted at and helped to show Errol's transition from drunken boy to mature adult.
I had a very difficult time getting into the story, because I could not figure out what direction the author was heading. This is not entirely a bad thing. It kept me intrigued, as I am often faulted for guessing the plot too early and feeling let down when not surprised. The main character was very difficult to like in the beginning, but his weaknesses only made me grow to respect him. This is no trite rags to riches story but instead the story of a man in the gutter who pulls himself into the light and learns to walk when other men would cower. Errol truly became a lovable character.
The fantasy elements in the story are extremely unusual. The whole concept of casting lots for information disturbs me, but somehow it fits into the story world. I will definitely read the next book, because it ended on a cliff hanger and I still cannot predict where this is going. :)
This is a good story for young men. There is no sex or language but a great deal of fighting and action. The way the author describes Errol's craft with the staff was so superb it made me want to go out and learn how to brandish a staff of my own. There are many different kinds of villains, from oafs to assassins to corrupt abbots to violent "ferrals" and demonic "malus." The cast is huge. The author introduces dozens of characters that only serve a small role in the whole of the story. I did not care for the many different love interests, but the romance was only hinted at and helped to show Errol's transition from drunken boy to mature adult.
I had a very difficult time getting into the story, because I could not figure out what direction the author was heading. This is not entirely a bad thing. It kept me intrigued, as I am often faulted for guessing the plot too early and feeling let down when not surprised. The main character was very difficult to like in the beginning, but his weaknesses only made me grow to respect him. This is no trite rags to riches story but instead the story of a man in the gutter who pulls himself into the light and learns to walk when other men would cower. Errol truly became a lovable character.
The fantasy elements in the story are extremely unusual. The whole concept of casting lots for information disturbs me, but somehow it fits into the story world. I will definitely read the next book, because it ended on a cliff hanger and I still cannot predict where this is going. :)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 642 reviews