What do you think?
Rate this book
The Color of a Lie
In 1955, a Black family passes for white and moves to a “Whites Only” town in the suburbs. Caught between two worlds, a teen boy puts his family at risk as he uncovers racist secrets about his suburb. A new social justice thriller from the acclaimed author of This Is My America!
Calvin knows how to pass for white. He’s done it plenty of times before. For his friends in Chicago, when they wanted food but weren’t allowed in a restaurant. For work, when he and his dad would travel for the Green Book.
This is different.
After a tragedy in Chicago forces the family to flee, they resettle in an idyllic all-white suburban town in search of a better life. Calvin’s father wants everyone to embrace their new white lifestyles, but it’s easier said than done. Hiding your true self is exhausting — which leads Calvin across town where he can make friends who know all of him…and spend more time with his new crush, Lily. But when Calvin starts unraveling dark secrets about the white town and its inhabitants, passing starts to feel even more suffocating–and dangerous–than he could have imagined.
Expertly weaving together real historical events with important reflections on being Black in America, acclaimed author Kim Johnson powerfully connects readers to the experience of being forced to live a life-threatening lie or embrace an equally deadly truth.
Calvin knows how to pass for white. He’s done it plenty of times before. For his friends in Chicago, when they wanted food but weren’t allowed in a restaurant. For work, when he and his dad would travel for the Green Book.
This is different.
After a tragedy in Chicago forces the family to flee, they resettle in an idyllic all-white suburban town in search of a better life. Calvin’s father wants everyone to embrace their new white lifestyles, but it’s easier said than done. Hiding your true self is exhausting — which leads Calvin across town where he can make friends who know all of him…and spend more time with his new crush, Lily. But when Calvin starts unraveling dark secrets about the white town and its inhabitants, passing starts to feel even more suffocating–and dangerous–than he could have imagined.
Expertly weaving together real historical events with important reflections on being Black in America, acclaimed author Kim Johnson powerfully connects readers to the experience of being forced to live a life-threatening lie or embrace an equally deadly truth.
336 pages, Hardcover
First published June 11, 2024
69 people are currently reading
2152 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 217 reviews
January 18, 2025
✰ 3.25 stars ✰
“I’m the great pretender… I seem to be what I’m not, you see. I felt the mask I’d been wearing take over me. I knew who I was, and yet Levittown had twisted that all around.”
Set during the decade post-WWII of the Jim Crow era that cast a long and painful shadow of racial discrimination, Kim Johnson's YA historical thriller sheds light on a dark and complicated time of US history with a unique twist that kept the pacing intense and on high alert as the protagonist, seventeen-year-old Calvin Greene has to brave the challenging task of hiding the truth from his new peers that while his lighter than light skin tone may make him fit in with the all-white crowd, he is in fact Black. 😥 For Calvin and his family who move from Chicago to the all-white American dream Levittown, Pennsylvania in the hopes to put behind their own traumatic past, every day a risk hoping that no one will call them out for The Color of a Lie that they're aiming to pull off - 'but here, passing wasn’t playing. It was permanent.'
“He had a new plan: blending in—passing. He said he wanted peace, and the price was selling our souls and leaving behind a now-untraceable past.”
It is an unsettling fervor that prevails throughout as Calvin's narration gets swept into the tide of constantly being alert of never letting sleep his true self. It's a daunting task made more difficult when he witnesses the blatant prejudice his fellow peers have to endure. 😟 He is torn between protecting his own skin and enjoying the safety and exclusive white-privileges or finding the nerve to speak up for the hate that is buried deep into their skin. 'We can be anybody here. Anybody but Black.'It clashes with the past he left behind and his newly developing feelings for Lily, his Black classmate, who usually is the brunt of their hateful spiel. 😢
“I knew what it meant to pass—most often it meant that never the two worlds should meet. It was an unwritten rule to let them be.”
It was hard to see how Calvin struggled with losing that part of his identity - feeling like all the warnings of avoiding confrontation, was in fact stirring within him the resentment of keeping himself hidden - 'I felt like an imposter, a shell of myself.' But as he spends more and more time with the Black community, searching for the sense of belonging and acceptance, more and more sinister events take shape that show just how dangerous and permanent the resentment lingers. The writing strongly captured that powerful sense of fear and intimidation that made Calvin cautious and wary to always keep himself on guard -'fueled this country against us is as visible as skin color and as invisible as the soul.' For a community already so steeped in their own hateful views, it is those prevailing threats that come to light that reach a tipping point that all those involved will have to make a choice that is a matter of life or death. 🥺
“Not everyone can play white, Calvin. And not everyone would want to if they could.”
And sadly, it is that final stretch where my level of tolerance of credulity, if not patience, did reach my own breaking point. It is here we get to see man's true nature, regardless of the color of their skin. Desperate times call for desperate measures, one that sends a shock-wave over all those involved that topples over everything they'd ever believed in. 😞 But sadly, as the climax arose, I also started to feel that the writing was losing focus and sense of what it aimed to achieve. The sudden risks Calvin started to take seemed callous if not far-fetched. 'I’d come here not knowing what I wanted, but now I knew what I would do.' Some decisions were too unbelievable, and I did feel that the thriller part of the story did not reach a satisfying conclusion. 🙍🏻♀️ It was resolved in a too convenient, if not neat way that even left certain points unaddressed. The lighthearted and hopeful tone of the ending felt out of place in comparison to the darker events that had been cast. While I do get the need to emphasize change, I still would have liked a more closure to it, so that I could have felt just as settled, as well.
“I’m the great pretender… I seem to be what I’m not, you see. I felt the mask I’d been wearing take over me. I knew who I was, and yet Levittown had twisted that all around.”
Set during the decade post-WWII of the Jim Crow era that cast a long and painful shadow of racial discrimination, Kim Johnson's YA historical thriller sheds light on a dark and complicated time of US history with a unique twist that kept the pacing intense and on high alert as the protagonist, seventeen-year-old Calvin Greene has to brave the challenging task of hiding the truth from his new peers that while his lighter than light skin tone may make him fit in with the all-white crowd, he is in fact Black. 😥 For Calvin and his family who move from Chicago to the all-white American dream Levittown, Pennsylvania in the hopes to put behind their own traumatic past, every day a risk hoping that no one will call them out for The Color of a Lie that they're aiming to pull off - 'but here, passing wasn’t playing. It was permanent.'
“He had a new plan: blending in—passing. He said he wanted peace, and the price was selling our souls and leaving behind a now-untraceable past.”
It is an unsettling fervor that prevails throughout as Calvin's narration gets swept into the tide of constantly being alert of never letting sleep his true self. It's a daunting task made more difficult when he witnesses the blatant prejudice his fellow peers have to endure. 😟 He is torn between protecting his own skin and enjoying the safety and exclusive white-privileges or finding the nerve to speak up for the hate that is buried deep into their skin. 'We can be anybody here. Anybody but Black.'It clashes with the past he left behind and his newly developing feelings for Lily, his Black classmate, who usually is the brunt of their hateful spiel. 😢
“I knew what it meant to pass—most often it meant that never the two worlds should meet. It was an unwritten rule to let them be.”
It was hard to see how Calvin struggled with losing that part of his identity - feeling like all the warnings of avoiding confrontation, was in fact stirring within him the resentment of keeping himself hidden - 'I felt like an imposter, a shell of myself.' But as he spends more and more time with the Black community, searching for the sense of belonging and acceptance, more and more sinister events take shape that show just how dangerous and permanent the resentment lingers. The writing strongly captured that powerful sense of fear and intimidation that made Calvin cautious and wary to always keep himself on guard -'fueled this country against us is as visible as skin color and as invisible as the soul.' For a community already so steeped in their own hateful views, it is those prevailing threats that come to light that reach a tipping point that all those involved will have to make a choice that is a matter of life or death. 🥺
“Not everyone can play white, Calvin. And not everyone would want to if they could.”
And sadly, it is that final stretch where my level of tolerance of credulity, if not patience, did reach my own breaking point. It is here we get to see man's true nature, regardless of the color of their skin. Desperate times call for desperate measures, one that sends a shock-wave over all those involved that topples over everything they'd ever believed in. 😞 But sadly, as the climax arose, I also started to feel that the writing was losing focus and sense of what it aimed to achieve. The sudden risks Calvin started to take seemed callous if not far-fetched. 'I’d come here not knowing what I wanted, but now I knew what I would do.' Some decisions were too unbelievable, and I did feel that the thriller part of the story did not reach a satisfying conclusion. 🙍🏻♀️ It was resolved in a too convenient, if not neat way that even left certain points unaddressed. The lighthearted and hopeful tone of the ending felt out of place in comparison to the darker events that had been cast. While I do get the need to emphasize change, I still would have liked a more closure to it, so that I could have felt just as settled, as well.
March 6, 2024
I received a gifted copy for an honest review.
I read this author’s other two novels. While I enjoyed them both, I didn’t think anything would top my love for This Is My America, yet here we are.
This story was thoughtfully written and heavily researched. Each and every character was written with care. I could feel each one’s emotions - confusion, helplessness, determination, rage, hatred, etc. As a Florida resident, this is a part of history that the department of education is meticulously trying to erase. Yet it shows how society continued to be complicit to the racism previous generations experienced (and carried out). The author beautifully illustrated what it means when we say “the children will lead them.”
I also found it interesting learning the story of passing from someone that did not have input in the decision. We often hear the stories of people passing but never learn about those directly and indirectly impacted. We know that they have to say goodbye forever but how do you explain to a child that their social circle is not only going to be changed but they have to deny everything they have to ever known? How do manage a forbidden love that could potentially threaten not only your life but the lives of everyone close to you?
There is so much more I want to say about this story but I want to be cognizant of spoilers. This is officially my new favorite book by Kim Johnson and I highly, highly recommend it.
My only hope is that the publishing company properly markets this and gives it the support it rightly deserves. Unfortunately, publishing companies do a disservice to not only their Black authors and readers, but to themselves by not utilizing the extensive Black reading company to spread the word about their books. I pray this time is different because this book deserves better.
I read this author’s other two novels. While I enjoyed them both, I didn’t think anything would top my love for This Is My America, yet here we are.
This story was thoughtfully written and heavily researched. Each and every character was written with care. I could feel each one’s emotions - confusion, helplessness, determination, rage, hatred, etc. As a Florida resident, this is a part of history that the department of education is meticulously trying to erase. Yet it shows how society continued to be complicit to the racism previous generations experienced (and carried out). The author beautifully illustrated what it means when we say “the children will lead them.”
I also found it interesting learning the story of passing from someone that did not have input in the decision. We often hear the stories of people passing but never learn about those directly and indirectly impacted. We know that they have to say goodbye forever but how do you explain to a child that their social circle is not only going to be changed but they have to deny everything they have to ever known? How do manage a forbidden love that could potentially threaten not only your life but the lives of everyone close to you?
There is so much more I want to say about this story but I want to be cognizant of spoilers. This is officially my new favorite book by Kim Johnson and I highly, highly recommend it.
My only hope is that the publishing company properly markets this and gives it the support it rightly deserves. Unfortunately, publishing companies do a disservice to not only their Black authors and readers, but to themselves by not utilizing the extensive Black reading company to spread the word about their books. I pray this time is different because this book deserves better.
February 22, 2024
As someone in my 40s, I recall the required readings from high school like "Of Mice and Men," "Fahrenheit 451," "The Great Gatsby," and "To Kill a Mockingbird." This book deserves to be added to that list. It tackles racism, passing, and the myriad of emotions that come with them in a way that's easy to grasp.
The story was both emotionally charged and fast-paced, ultimately leaving a heartwarming impression. The characters were compelling (except for the racist ones), and the book really evokes strong emotions.
I highly recommend this book. Many thanks to Kim Johnson and NetGalley for the opportunity to read it. It was both engaging and enlightening. I plan to purchase a physical copy upon release and suggest to my local library that they add it to their shelves.
The story was both emotionally charged and fast-paced, ultimately leaving a heartwarming impression. The characters were compelling (except for the racist ones), and the book really evokes strong emotions.
I highly recommend this book. Many thanks to Kim Johnson and NetGalley for the opportunity to read it. It was both engaging and enlightening. I plan to purchase a physical copy upon release and suggest to my local library that they add it to their shelves.
June 13, 2024
This book was so intense and absolutely brilliant. Literally a MUST read‼️ If you haven’t read any of Johnson’s books I’m gone need you to get into them expeditiously. The way she weaves historical facts into the narrative makes every book she writes worth the read. We’re given a wholesome story and a history lesson at the same time. The Color of a Lie spoke volumes and Calvin’s character was courageous, conscientious, and outspoken.
White passing wasn’t a new experience for Calvin Greene he’s done it before in the past. But when his father purchases a new home in Levittown which was an all white community Calvin struggles to adjust. It’s hard living a lie when all you want to do is be your true authentic self. When Lily Baker integrates into Calvin’s high school it leaves him torn between two worlds. As he begins to uncover racist secrets about his suburb Calvin’s actions will put his family at risk.
It’s so sad that many Black Americans during the Jim Crow era with lighter complexions had to white pass in order to experience the so called American Dream. Throughout the novel the author focused on many themes surrounding traveling while Black, sundown towns, white communities fighting against integration, mentions of Emmett Till, the story of Levittown, segregation, influencing access to quality education, and the use of the Green book that helped Black Americans find safe travel routes and dining.
Overall, I thoroughly enjoyed reading this book it will have you hooked after the first chapter. For readers interested in historical fiction, social justice, YA books, or the history of Black Americans this book is for you. Special thanks to @cocoachapters @kcjohnsonwrites @getunderlined for my gifted copy‼️
White passing wasn’t a new experience for Calvin Greene he’s done it before in the past. But when his father purchases a new home in Levittown which was an all white community Calvin struggles to adjust. It’s hard living a lie when all you want to do is be your true authentic self. When Lily Baker integrates into Calvin’s high school it leaves him torn between two worlds. As he begins to uncover racist secrets about his suburb Calvin’s actions will put his family at risk.
It’s so sad that many Black Americans during the Jim Crow era with lighter complexions had to white pass in order to experience the so called American Dream. Throughout the novel the author focused on many themes surrounding traveling while Black, sundown towns, white communities fighting against integration, mentions of Emmett Till, the story of Levittown, segregation, influencing access to quality education, and the use of the Green book that helped Black Americans find safe travel routes and dining.
Overall, I thoroughly enjoyed reading this book it will have you hooked after the first chapter. For readers interested in historical fiction, social justice, YA books, or the history of Black Americans this book is for you. Special thanks to @cocoachapters @kcjohnsonwrites @getunderlined for my gifted copy‼️
October 24, 2024
“Keeping me away from news back home won’t hide them at these things still happen to us! You can’t put me in a bubble of white walls and think that’s somehow going to protect me. I’m in disguise but it doesn’t erase who i am. You can’t erase me. I won’t let you.”
I love this book. Black historical fiction is like my top 3 favorite genres and this book is for sure a favorite of mines. The story takes you right in and you can feel the pain from the mmc Calvin. The whole plot you can feel how intense things are in that moment to point i was clutching my pearls. Damn near holding my breath. The emotions are right there on the edge. Fast paced yet so clear and thought out to bring the readers something brilliant.
Calvin’s character was amazing and i loved this being told from his pov. We see how his family has used white passing in order to help with the Green Book. Talking and dealing with sundown towns in this, as well as integration, death, racism, underground railroads and much more. However, Calvin having to white pass in such a while to live when all he wanted to do was be the black boy he loves and not pretend to be anything else. I’m glad his spirit in this shined through and i thank the author for that. The way he lit up when Lily joined the school and went in to protect her no matter what just shows the strength and courage of him at times like that. Very thankful to see how all this affected Calvin’s family and the communities around them. The secret and lies had me shaking my head.
I could go on but i think it’s best you read it yourself. There’s so much that goes on it’s heartbreaking yet amazing. I love my peoples history because black history in America is American history. No matter age, race, background or whatever there’s something here to be learned.
I love this book. Black historical fiction is like my top 3 favorite genres and this book is for sure a favorite of mines. The story takes you right in and you can feel the pain from the mmc Calvin. The whole plot you can feel how intense things are in that moment to point i was clutching my pearls. Damn near holding my breath. The emotions are right there on the edge. Fast paced yet so clear and thought out to bring the readers something brilliant.
Calvin’s character was amazing and i loved this being told from his pov. We see how his family has used white passing in order to help with the Green Book. Talking and dealing with sundown towns in this, as well as integration, death, racism, underground railroads and much more. However, Calvin having to white pass in such a while to live when all he wanted to do was be the black boy he loves and not pretend to be anything else. I’m glad his spirit in this shined through and i thank the author for that. The way he lit up when Lily joined the school and went in to protect her no matter what just shows the strength and courage of him at times like that. Very thankful to see how all this affected Calvin’s family and the communities around them. The secret and lies had me shaking my head.
I could go on but i think it’s best you read it yourself. There’s so much that goes on it’s heartbreaking yet amazing. I love my peoples history because black history in America is American history. No matter age, race, background or whatever there’s something here to be learned.
August 16, 2024
An amazing, unputdownable work of historical fiction.
Calvin is fed up. His family had to move from their home in Chicago to Pennsylvania for their own safety. His family is very light-skinned, so his father is insisting that in Levittown, they will pass for White. So Calvin basically has to “erase” his true self of 17 years, forget his old life and friendships, and be on constant guard about what he says, wears, even what kind of music he’s into. Because any slip would reveal to the citizens of Levittown that a Black family has moved into the “White” part of town, with disastrous results…
Such a powerful novel, written about a very unsettling time in our nation’s history. In 1955, WW2 had been over for ten years, a war in which soldiers of all races fought against the tyranny of madmen, only for many to return home to hate and prejudice in their own country. Because of the bravery of ordinary citizens, who refused to be oppressed because of their skin color and stood tall, differences in the laws of segregation and integration began to be changed, slowly but surely.
This book should be in every Y.A. classroom; it would an excellent teaching tool for learning about the Civil Rights Movement. The notes in the back are interesting and thorough.
I’ll be looking for more novels by this author!
Calvin is fed up. His family had to move from their home in Chicago to Pennsylvania for their own safety. His family is very light-skinned, so his father is insisting that in Levittown, they will pass for White. So Calvin basically has to “erase” his true self of 17 years, forget his old life and friendships, and be on constant guard about what he says, wears, even what kind of music he’s into. Because any slip would reveal to the citizens of Levittown that a Black family has moved into the “White” part of town, with disastrous results…
Such a powerful novel, written about a very unsettling time in our nation’s history. In 1955, WW2 had been over for ten years, a war in which soldiers of all races fought against the tyranny of madmen, only for many to return home to hate and prejudice in their own country. Because of the bravery of ordinary citizens, who refused to be oppressed because of their skin color and stood tall, differences in the laws of segregation and integration began to be changed, slowly but surely.
This book should be in every Y.A. classroom; it would an excellent teaching tool for learning about the Civil Rights Movement. The notes in the back are interesting and thorough.
I’ll be looking for more novels by this author!
February 9, 2025
The color of a lie
-this book was captivating I couldn’t put it down I needed to know more
-you feel the reality of fighting and hiding for your life
-the intertwined history and story telling is so well done
-I truly felt like I was in Calvin’s head learning about his reality and fears
-the fact they have to act “white” to survive and hide their true identity is heartbreaking
-can we please take a moment for the cover wow
-it hurts so much him having to hide his identity we should be able to be who we are why do they hate us so much 😔
-this should be a required reading in schools
-i love Lily she’s badass and straight up
-this book was eye opening, heart wrenching and thrilling
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️.5
-this book was captivating I couldn’t put it down I needed to know more
-you feel the reality of fighting and hiding for your life
-the intertwined history and story telling is so well done
-I truly felt like I was in Calvin’s head learning about his reality and fears
-the fact they have to act “white” to survive and hide their true identity is heartbreaking
-can we please take a moment for the cover wow
-it hurts so much him having to hide his identity we should be able to be who we are why do they hate us so much 😔
-this should be a required reading in schools
-i love Lily she’s badass and straight up
-this book was eye opening, heart wrenching and thrilling
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️.5
August 27, 2024
The Color of the Lie is a propulsive YA coming-of-age historical fiction/thriller that examines racial passing in the 1950s. Filled with fascinating history about the Levittown suburbs and racial segregation, this book delicately balances tough themes with the relatable struggles of a boy deciding who he wants to be in such a fraught time period. Part romance, part thriller, and wholly historical fiction, this book will resonate with all readers — teens and adults alike.
Full review with content warnings & grade recommendations: https://readingmiddlegrade.com/the-co...
Full review with content warnings & grade recommendations: https://readingmiddlegrade.com/the-co...
November 16, 2024
first read from this author, and it was quite enjoyable.
good for anyone looking for a read that isn’t heavy, but still keeps some suspense.
good for anyone looking for a read that isn’t heavy, but still keeps some suspense.
April 12, 2025
I loved everything about this book 🖤
June 8, 2024
OUTSTANDING! Unputdownable!
June 1, 2024
I love that Kim writes socially conscious books for the youth! As an adult reader, I find it timely and highly engaging for young people to read about how race, social inequality, and many other social issues plague our world. Not only does she make these issues the focal point of her writing, but it's nice to see the teenage characters navigating their world as they progress toward adulthood, everything from love relationships and family to knowing who they are and what they want. As a pediatric nurse, I've always been fond of the teenage population and am constantly fascinated by how they navigate such an exciting but tumultuous time in their lives. This is my third time reading a book by this author, and I enjoyed it. I loved the intersectionality of race, passing, and the desire for equality in education. The main character, Calvin, and his family are passing in a majority white community, and there is this tug at Calvin to go along with his parents' wishes but also do what is right and in his heart. The writing was thoughtful, and it felt like I was teleported to the 1950s. Throughout this book, I was on the edge of my seat, especially with the sundown rules. Reading this story reminded me of the sundown scenes in Lovecraft Country. This was a historical adventure of a read!
May 1, 2025
“I knew what it meant to pass - most often it meant that never the two worlds should meet. It was an unwritten rule to let them be.
Calvin is a teenager in the 1950s forced to “pass” in order to have a “better” life. But at what cost?
Kim Johnson does it again in Color of a Lie!! She has an incredible talent for bringing important truths and history into this story that will make youth and adults, alike, want to sit down, listen, digest, and discuss. I found myself wondering, if I would pass if I could pass… in order to not be shunned for my skin tone.
We often read stories of adult Blacks passing, but this is my first time reading from a young person’s perspective. He’s Black but has to hide his love of Blackness to stay safe and under the radar. Younger people tend to want to play by their own rules, so Calvin has a very hard conflict in doing what he wants to do vs what he is supposed to do.
Calvin did get on my nerves many times because his actions could’ve ended badly for many people, but he was so intent on his desires.
The audiobook was excellent! Here are some powerful quotes that stuck with me!
❥"We're caught in a scam that has the bottom half bamboozled, believing that the American dream is achievable by those who deserve it, work hard enough. Then they justify burning up our justice, our access, our dream. The very thing this country was created to uphold but this country only knows how to rule in terror and by blood. The physical and the methaphysical. The hate that has now fueled this country against us is as visible as skin color and as invisible as the soul."
❥"I realize that this whole big world...is so small for us. So many spaces that are confined and it's suffocating"
❥"Bland, delicate communities were worse than any nightmares."
Calvin is a teenager in the 1950s forced to “pass” in order to have a “better” life. But at what cost?
Kim Johnson does it again in Color of a Lie!! She has an incredible talent for bringing important truths and history into this story that will make youth and adults, alike, want to sit down, listen, digest, and discuss. I found myself wondering, if I would pass if I could pass… in order to not be shunned for my skin tone.
We often read stories of adult Blacks passing, but this is my first time reading from a young person’s perspective. He’s Black but has to hide his love of Blackness to stay safe and under the radar. Younger people tend to want to play by their own rules, so Calvin has a very hard conflict in doing what he wants to do vs what he is supposed to do.
Calvin did get on my nerves many times because his actions could’ve ended badly for many people, but he was so intent on his desires.
The audiobook was excellent! Here are some powerful quotes that stuck with me!
❥"We're caught in a scam that has the bottom half bamboozled, believing that the American dream is achievable by those who deserve it, work hard enough. Then they justify burning up our justice, our access, our dream. The very thing this country was created to uphold but this country only knows how to rule in terror and by blood. The physical and the methaphysical. The hate that has now fueled this country against us is as visible as skin color and as invisible as the soul."
❥"I realize that this whole big world...is so small for us. So many spaces that are confined and it's suffocating"
❥"Bland, delicate communities were worse than any nightmares."
May 10, 2024
4 Stars, maybe 4.5
I loved this book. It dives into an aspect of history that really is under-explored in fiction, and it raises some very salient questions about identity, safety, and activism that are relevant both in a historical context and in a contemporary one. My only qualm is that sometimes it feels like it veers a little too modern in language choices, but it is written for a YA audience, so this can be somewhat forgiven.
Anyway, I've got more to gush about here, and all of that will be available in my full review, going live on June 14, 2024 at Gateway Reviews. Stop by if you get the chance!
I was provided with an ARC by the publisher through Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. All opinions here are my own.
I loved this book. It dives into an aspect of history that really is under-explored in fiction, and it raises some very salient questions about identity, safety, and activism that are relevant both in a historical context and in a contemporary one. My only qualm is that sometimes it feels like it veers a little too modern in language choices, but it is written for a YA audience, so this can be somewhat forgiven.
Anyway, I've got more to gush about here, and all of that will be available in my full review, going live on June 14, 2024 at Gateway Reviews. Stop by if you get the chance!
I was provided with an ARC by the publisher through Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. All opinions here are my own.
February 16, 2025
Set in 1955 Pennsylvania. Historical places and people referenced. Author gives additional material to study.
Good character and world building. Sterile 1955 suburbs, brainwashing and conformity, what it means to pass and not be yourself. It was tense.
I can’t believe more people haven’t picked this up or talk about it.
Well written.
Good character and world building. Sterile 1955 suburbs, brainwashing and conformity, what it means to pass and not be yourself. It was tense.
I can’t believe more people haven’t picked this up or talk about it.
Well written.
November 22, 2024
Read for class. 3.5 rounded up
I think this was my favorite read - talks about colorism, white passing, sunset towns, and redlining. It makes it so easy to understand really rough topics and opens up multiple avenues to make more connections. I loved it!
I think this was my favorite read - talks about colorism, white passing, sunset towns, and redlining. It makes it so easy to understand really rough topics and opens up multiple avenues to make more connections. I loved it!
February 10, 2025
Man was this a beautiful book. There is so much I could say but I think this is one of those books that everyone should read and experience for themselves. My review wouldn't do it justice and this book is the epitome of why I love to read historical fiction.
August 17, 2025
I really enjoyed this book! Books that are fiction but heavily based on real life people, places and historical events are the best reads….I learned alot about Levittown PA’s history , how it got its name and the racist practices surrounding the selling of homes in that township in the 1950’s. Living two states over from PA, i’ve heard of Levittown all my life (cant recall ever visiting tho). Also, “passing” is a subject that I have always found fascinating….wondering how people could pull it off. I guess I understand WHY they would try to pass….for a better future and better opportunities that were afforded to whites and not blacks during those times…..this book shows how it’s not easy to just ditch your true roots and turn into something you’re not. It also had to be scary!
This book wrapped up pretty well also….with the family making the right decision in the end. I’m happy that Calvin reunited with some people that were pretty special to him. If you love historical fiction and choose to pick this book up, you wont be disappointed. Happy reading!🙂
This book wrapped up pretty well also….with the family making the right decision in the end. I’m happy that Calvin reunited with some people that were pretty special to him. If you love historical fiction and choose to pick this book up, you wont be disappointed. Happy reading!🙂
Read
April 7, 2024The Color of a Lie is soooo good! The plot, the writing, the characters all get a 10/10 from me.
This book takes us back to 1955 where our main character Calvin and his family are passing for white in a “Whites Only” town (Levittown community). After a tragedy forced the family to flee Chicago, Calvin’s dad urges his wife and son to embrace their new white lifestyle. Calvin is fully against it. He hates having to pretend and is always anxious about getting caught. At first, he tries to adapt, but ultimately, his desire to freely be himself wins out. Despite the risk, he goes across town (on the Black side) to make friends. Racist secrets about the white town start to reveal themselves which leads Calvin to realize the increased danger of passing.
Below is from the book description and it encompasses the story perfectly.
“Expertly weaving together real historical events with important reflections on being Black in America, acclaimed author Kim Johnson powerfully connects readers to the experience of being forced to live a life-threatening lie or embrace an equally deadly truth.”
I love how Kim tells this story while also shining a light on prominent issues Black people faced during this time such as:
-The greenbook aka traveling while black
-Passing
-The barriers to educational integration
-Sundown towns
-Homeownership discrimination
-Redlining
-Police brutality/harassment
Most of the above are still issues today. A reality that puts progress in the hot seat. How far have we really come being almost 80 years in the future, yet the adversity is the same?
In my experience, passing stories tend to sway towards the potential benefits, so I also really appreciate the pov of a Black person passing who didn’t want to. In addition, focusing on the turmoil that comes with passing. Kim gave us a story that shows pass wasn’t just an easy thing to do; nor was it without increased danger. It was a lie that could put you in an early grave.
Amazing job Kim! I highly recommend!!! I’d love to see this book brought to screen.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an advanced eARC.
This book takes us back to 1955 where our main character Calvin and his family are passing for white in a “Whites Only” town (Levittown community). After a tragedy forced the family to flee Chicago, Calvin’s dad urges his wife and son to embrace their new white lifestyle. Calvin is fully against it. He hates having to pretend and is always anxious about getting caught. At first, he tries to adapt, but ultimately, his desire to freely be himself wins out. Despite the risk, he goes across town (on the Black side) to make friends. Racist secrets about the white town start to reveal themselves which leads Calvin to realize the increased danger of passing.
Below is from the book description and it encompasses the story perfectly.
“Expertly weaving together real historical events with important reflections on being Black in America, acclaimed author Kim Johnson powerfully connects readers to the experience of being forced to live a life-threatening lie or embrace an equally deadly truth.”
I love how Kim tells this story while also shining a light on prominent issues Black people faced during this time such as:
-The greenbook aka traveling while black
-Passing
-The barriers to educational integration
-Sundown towns
-Homeownership discrimination
-Redlining
-Police brutality/harassment
Most of the above are still issues today. A reality that puts progress in the hot seat. How far have we really come being almost 80 years in the future, yet the adversity is the same?
In my experience, passing stories tend to sway towards the potential benefits, so I also really appreciate the pov of a Black person passing who didn’t want to. In addition, focusing on the turmoil that comes with passing. Kim gave us a story that shows pass wasn’t just an easy thing to do; nor was it without increased danger. It was a lie that could put you in an early grave.
Amazing job Kim! I highly recommend!!! I’d love to see this book brought to screen.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an advanced eARC.
May 18, 2024
I think I wanted a bit more out of this. It takes place during such an important part of US history but it felt too surface level? I think it’ll work better for younger high school kids
June 9, 2024
I received a free copy of this book as part of a book tour & for my honest opinion
This book comes out June 11th & when it comes out RUN & GET IT! Even pre-order it if you can wait
After reading 𝘗𝘢𝘴𝘴𝘪𝘯𝘨 by Nella Larson (which was NOT what I really expected but that's for a different review) I was intrigued to read this.
Calvin Greene & his family move from Chicago to Levittown, PA after a terrible tragedy. They move into an all-white community and Calvin attends an all-white school, all because the family is fair enough to pass. Calvin's father wants the family to assimilate so life will be easier, but Calvin finds it exhausting (knowing which sides to show; what to pretend to like, etc..) and this leads him to the Black part of town, where he can be himself.
While there he meets Lily, and begins to fall for her. But because he's passing as white and Lily is black, they cannot be seen in public together (oh yeah, it's 1955 if you didn't know!) But while visiting the black part of town he begins to learn about Levittown's shady dealings and passing becomes too much, and too dangerous, for Calvin.
I absolutely love how every time I read a historical fiction novel I learn something new. I knew about Chicago, what happened in 1955, sundown towns & of course, segregation but I did not know about Levitt & Sons. They were responsible for the Levittowns of PA & NY, and did not want their towns integrated. Fell down a rabbit hole and did even more research & American history is SHADY! I wish they taught more about redlining, SUNDOWN TOWNS (which I did not learn about until I was in my 20s! & to think that some sundown towns still exists smh) and the Civil Rights movement.
Overall, this is a book that I believe everyone should read. It's a YA novel so it's not graphic or anything but may be a bit triggering for some sensitive readers.
This book comes out June 11th & when it comes out RUN & GET IT! Even pre-order it if you can wait
After reading 𝘗𝘢𝘴𝘴𝘪𝘯𝘨 by Nella Larson (which was NOT what I really expected but that's for a different review) I was intrigued to read this.
Calvin Greene & his family move from Chicago to Levittown, PA after a terrible tragedy. They move into an all-white community and Calvin attends an all-white school, all because the family is fair enough to pass. Calvin's father wants the family to assimilate so life will be easier, but Calvin finds it exhausting (knowing which sides to show; what to pretend to like, etc..) and this leads him to the Black part of town, where he can be himself.
While there he meets Lily, and begins to fall for her. But because he's passing as white and Lily is black, they cannot be seen in public together (oh yeah, it's 1955 if you didn't know!) But while visiting the black part of town he begins to learn about Levittown's shady dealings and passing becomes too much, and too dangerous, for Calvin.
I absolutely love how every time I read a historical fiction novel I learn something new. I knew about Chicago, what happened in 1955, sundown towns & of course, segregation but I did not know about Levitt & Sons. They were responsible for the Levittowns of PA & NY, and did not want their towns integrated. Fell down a rabbit hole and did even more research & American history is SHADY! I wish they taught more about redlining, SUNDOWN TOWNS (which I did not learn about until I was in my 20s! & to think that some sundown towns still exists smh) and the Civil Rights movement.
Overall, this is a book that I believe everyone should read. It's a YA novel so it's not graphic or anything but may be a bit triggering for some sensitive readers.
February 8, 2025
This book delivers a powerful and thought-provoking story. A historical thriller set in 1955 that explores race, identity, and the cost of survival. The story follows Calvin Greene, a Black teen whose family moves to Levittown, Pennsylvania—a segregated suburb where they are forced to pass as white. Calvin never asked for this deception, yet he finds himself trapped in a lie that denies him his true identity. The internal conflict he faces is heartbreaking, as he struggles between the safety that passing provides and the deep shame of erasing his Blackness.
What makes this story so compelling is how Johnson explores the psychological and emotional toll of passing. Calvin isn’t just hiding from a racist society—he’s also suppressing parts of himself, distancing himself from the Black community, and questioning where he truly belongs. His relationships, particularly with Lily, a Black girl integrating into his all-white school, push him to confront uncomfortable truths about privilege, identity, and the dangers of standing out in a world that punishes difference.
The tension in this book is constant, both from the racial injustices of the time and the ever-present fear of being discovered. The historical setting feels vivid and immersive, making the stakes feel even more real. Johnson does an incredible job weaving history, suspense, and raw emotion into a story that is both gripping and deeply meaningful.
This isn’t just a story about passing—it’s about the cost of survival, the weight of secrets, and the fight for self-acceptance. If you love historical fiction that challenges you to think while keeping you on edge, The Color of a Lie is a must-read. Easily a 5-star book that will stay with me for a long time. I want every young person in my life to read this!
What makes this story so compelling is how Johnson explores the psychological and emotional toll of passing. Calvin isn’t just hiding from a racist society—he’s also suppressing parts of himself, distancing himself from the Black community, and questioning where he truly belongs. His relationships, particularly with Lily, a Black girl integrating into his all-white school, push him to confront uncomfortable truths about privilege, identity, and the dangers of standing out in a world that punishes difference.
The tension in this book is constant, both from the racial injustices of the time and the ever-present fear of being discovered. The historical setting feels vivid and immersive, making the stakes feel even more real. Johnson does an incredible job weaving history, suspense, and raw emotion into a story that is both gripping and deeply meaningful.
This isn’t just a story about passing—it’s about the cost of survival, the weight of secrets, and the fight for self-acceptance. If you love historical fiction that challenges you to think while keeping you on edge, The Color of a Lie is a must-read. Easily a 5-star book that will stay with me for a long time. I want every young person in my life to read this!
June 14, 2024
Thank you @getunderlined for my book.
My 💭:
Growing up Black I’m familiar with the term “passing” but never read a book about it until now. Reading this book gave me a different perspective as to why some Black people would prefer to pass as White. From a personal standpoint I couldn’t do it because that’s another way they would win and I’m petty. 🙃
Calvin was so stressed because he didn’t want to live a lie and why should he have to because of racists folks? This story touched on crucial Black History moments that made me smile as I read along and part of me wishes I was alive during that time. The story also mentioned The Greenbook manual by Victor H. Green that Black people used to stay safe while traveling in certain states aka Sundown Towns. I actually had a copy before the house fire and reading that book had me so angry that we even needed that book in the first place. Imagine being told you can’t drive at night because of your skin color and if you got caught you would be dealt with accordingly…….but they call us animals.🙃 This is the third book that I have read by Kim Johnson and she doesn’t not miss at all. I also loved the questions at the end which made me think. This book should be required reading in all the schools!
My 💭:
Growing up Black I’m familiar with the term “passing” but never read a book about it until now. Reading this book gave me a different perspective as to why some Black people would prefer to pass as White. From a personal standpoint I couldn’t do it because that’s another way they would win and I’m petty. 🙃
Calvin was so stressed because he didn’t want to live a lie and why should he have to because of racists folks? This story touched on crucial Black History moments that made me smile as I read along and part of me wishes I was alive during that time. The story also mentioned The Greenbook manual by Victor H. Green that Black people used to stay safe while traveling in certain states aka Sundown Towns. I actually had a copy before the house fire and reading that book had me so angry that we even needed that book in the first place. Imagine being told you can’t drive at night because of your skin color and if you got caught you would be dealt with accordingly…….but they call us animals.🙃 This is the third book that I have read by Kim Johnson and she doesn’t not miss at all. I also loved the questions at the end which made me think. This book should be required reading in all the schools!
April 20, 2024
Kim Johnson is quickly becoming an auto-buy author for me.
The Color of a Lie, Johnson’s first historical thriller, is a fast paced story of a high school junior caught in the middle of a living lie. After a tragic experience in their home town, Calvin and his parents move to a segregated town under the required guise of a family passing as white. But Calvin realizes almost instantly just how hard it is to live a lie. Stifling himself and his preferences at almost every turn was one thing, but denying himself true love? Impossible.
In this well researched historical tale, Calvin finds himself constantly choosing between the lies he’s been assigned and the truth he so desperately craves.
What I loved most about this book:
1) THE RESEARCH WAS EVIDENT and makes the history accessible to young adults who may be reading about the civil rights movement for the first time.
2) The characters are so reflective of society’s attitude during this time! Also characters were complex.
3) Lily. I would read it again for her.
Thank you to #netgalley for this ARC!
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
The Color of a Lie, Johnson’s first historical thriller, is a fast paced story of a high school junior caught in the middle of a living lie. After a tragic experience in their home town, Calvin and his parents move to a segregated town under the required guise of a family passing as white. But Calvin realizes almost instantly just how hard it is to live a lie. Stifling himself and his preferences at almost every turn was one thing, but denying himself true love? Impossible.
In this well researched historical tale, Calvin finds himself constantly choosing between the lies he’s been assigned and the truth he so desperately craves.
What I loved most about this book:
1) THE RESEARCH WAS EVIDENT and makes the history accessible to young adults who may be reading about the civil rights movement for the first time.
2) The characters are so reflective of society’s attitude during this time! Also characters were complex.
3) Lily. I would read it again for her.
Thank you to #netgalley for this ARC!
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
June 9, 2024
This book had me in a chokehold! I couldn’t put it down!
The Color of a Lie by Kim Johnson touched on several important themes that stood out to me:
1. Referencing Emmett Till's Death: The novel refers to the tragic and brutal murder of Emmett Till. This connection to actual historical events adds gravity and authenticity to the story and reminds readers of the genuine dangers faced by black Americans during this time.
2. Highlighting the Unfair Treatment of Black Veterans: The book sheds light on the injustices faced by black veterans who, despite their service and sacrifices, were mistreated upon their return home.
3. Showing People Can Evolve and Change: Various characters within the family and the broader community demonstrate that people can change their views and actions, offering a message of hope and progress.
4. Provoking Personal Reflection on Sacrifice and Safety: The novel's depiction of the family's desperate measures to ensure their safety—such as passing as white and undertaking dangerous missions— made me to reflect deeply on what I would be willing to do or sacrifice to protect myself and my loved ones. This powerful introspection highlights individuals' moral and ethical dilemmas under extreme oppression.
The Color of a Lie by Kim Johnson touched on several important themes that stood out to me:
1. Referencing Emmett Till's Death: The novel refers to the tragic and brutal murder of Emmett Till. This connection to actual historical events adds gravity and authenticity to the story and reminds readers of the genuine dangers faced by black Americans during this time.
2. Highlighting the Unfair Treatment of Black Veterans: The book sheds light on the injustices faced by black veterans who, despite their service and sacrifices, were mistreated upon their return home.
3. Showing People Can Evolve and Change: Various characters within the family and the broader community demonstrate that people can change their views and actions, offering a message of hope and progress.
4. Provoking Personal Reflection on Sacrifice and Safety: The novel's depiction of the family's desperate measures to ensure their safety—such as passing as white and undertaking dangerous missions— made me to reflect deeply on what I would be willing to do or sacrifice to protect myself and my loved ones. This powerful introspection highlights individuals' moral and ethical dilemmas under extreme oppression.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
February 11, 2025
This book delves deep into themes of identity and race.
Set in 1955 Pennsylvania, it follows Calvin Greene, a black teenager whose family chooses to pass as white in a segregated society and this decision forces Calvin to batte with truth, belonging, self acceptance, courage.
The writing in this book was very gripping and immersive, and it brought the racial tensions of the era to life with raw honesty. The book explores the insidious nature of racism, both overt and subtle. The author illustrates how systematic racism permeates everyday life, affecting the characters' choices, relationships, and sense of self.
The relationships within the story were painted very vividly, how friendships and familial bonds are strained by racial tensions.
The book brought so many reactions out of me, mostly rage at how black people were treated. I love how Calvin's character grew in strength and courage, how he and all the other oppressed people were able to stand up for what they believed in and take a stand to the injustice that was happening.
A must read.
Set in 1955 Pennsylvania, it follows Calvin Greene, a black teenager whose family chooses to pass as white in a segregated society and this decision forces Calvin to batte with truth, belonging, self acceptance, courage.
The writing in this book was very gripping and immersive, and it brought the racial tensions of the era to life with raw honesty. The book explores the insidious nature of racism, both overt and subtle. The author illustrates how systematic racism permeates everyday life, affecting the characters' choices, relationships, and sense of self.
The relationships within the story were painted very vividly, how friendships and familial bonds are strained by racial tensions.
The book brought so many reactions out of me, mostly rage at how black people were treated. I love how Calvin's character grew in strength and courage, how he and all the other oppressed people were able to stand up for what they believed in and take a stand to the injustice that was happening.
A must read.
June 15, 2024
As Calvin navigates the complexities of his dual identity, he also grapples with the guilt of hiding his true self from his family and friends. He struggles with the pressure to conform to societal expectations while also yearning for the freedom to be his authentic self.
The more involved in the black community, Calvin is the more he sees the injustices and discrimination that exist in Levittown. He witnesses the struggles of his new friends and neighbors, and he is forced to confront his own privilege and complicity in perpetuating a system that oppresses others.
Kim Johnson is quickly becoming one of my favorite YA authors. I adored not only this book but Invisible Son and This is My America. She has a way of writing that keeps you turning pages and racing to see what happens next. She has a way of making you connect with her characters that is uncanny. Definitely one of my top books for the year.
The more involved in the black community, Calvin is the more he sees the injustices and discrimination that exist in Levittown. He witnesses the struggles of his new friends and neighbors, and he is forced to confront his own privilege and complicity in perpetuating a system that oppresses others.
Kim Johnson is quickly becoming one of my favorite YA authors. I adored not only this book but Invisible Son and This is My America. She has a way of writing that keeps you turning pages and racing to see what happens next. She has a way of making you connect with her characters that is uncanny. Definitely one of my top books for the year.
September 9, 2024
This book deserves all its stars! 6 🌟 for me. I loved how the story depicts what could really happen or might have happened during the time of segregation. Including the importance of strong Black leaders: Thurgood Marshall protecting the rights of all citizens , Rosa Parks stance for equality, Martin Luther King to all the local folks who stood for equal schooling- integration and helping others in the community activate change. Loved how Calvin's family (dad) had a hidden agenda to help others. Loved that the author included reference to the famous, The Green Book. THIS WAS SO GOOD!
Loved the quote by Lille, Calvin's love interest. It speaks to life beyond romantic love:
"Just because we can't find a place to be public with each other doesn't mean I want to hide the whole time. I am worth being seen with."
❤️ Read this book then share it with your kids.
Loved the quote by Lille, Calvin's love interest. It speaks to life beyond romantic love:
"Just because we can't find a place to be public with each other doesn't mean I want to hide the whole time. I am worth being seen with."
❤️ Read this book then share it with your kids.
June 13, 2024
Thanks to Netgalley and Random House for the advance Kindle copy of this book. It actually came out already, so check it out! All opinions are my own.
•
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5. Set in 1955, this follows a family devastated after a fire in their Chicago home killed their daughter. Now, light-skinned Calvin and his parents are starting over in a Pennsylvania suburb - and passing as white. Calvin’s father claims that it is for their safety, but Calvin is miserable. As he learns more about what is going on in Leavittown, he is determined to change it at a cost. Powerful and thought-provoking. Recommended for readers in grades 7+.
•
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5. Set in 1955, this follows a family devastated after a fire in their Chicago home killed their daughter. Now, light-skinned Calvin and his parents are starting over in a Pennsylvania suburb - and passing as white. Calvin’s father claims that it is for their safety, but Calvin is miserable. As he learns more about what is going on in Leavittown, he is determined to change it at a cost. Powerful and thought-provoking. Recommended for readers in grades 7+.
March 1, 2025
I have been aware of housing discrimination and the concept of passing, but this is the first book I've read where these issues were center stage and brought to life. (I believe fiction can be the most powerful since it brings empathy and reality to the historical truth.)
I'm so glad I picked this thriller-esque book up. The constant fear the MC faced of being found out, the hints and whispers of a dark backstory to their town, and Lily were the most powerful parts. I especially liked the empathy that was shown to his parents, and the idea of different ways of fighting back.
It got me thinking... if the MC could do that much with his perceived white privilege, how much more could I do, and why am I not doing it?
I'll definitely try more by this author.
CW: racism, racially motivated violence, deaths (one off page), language, bullying. Emmett Till's death hits the MC hard. A side character is gay.
I'm so glad I picked this thriller-esque book up. The constant fear the MC faced of being found out, the hints and whispers of a dark backstory to their town, and Lily were the most powerful parts. I especially liked the empathy that was shown to his parents, and the idea of different ways of fighting back.
It got me thinking... if the MC could do that much with his perceived white privilege, how much more could I do, and why am I not doing it?
I'll definitely try more by this author.
CW: racism, racially motivated violence, deaths (one off page), language, bullying. Emmett Till's death hits the MC hard. A side character is gay.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 217 reviews