What do you think?
Rate this book
It Happened on a Sunday
In a much-anticipated return to contemporary romance, Tracy Wolff weaves a rich love story of a complicated pop star and the professional football player, who’s America’s boy next door.
368 pages, Paperback
First published September 2, 2025
299 people are currently reading
9384 people want to read
About the author
Tracy Wolff
141 books12.1k followersNew York Times and USA Today bestselling author Tracy Wolff is a lover of vampires, dragons, and all things that go bump in the night. A onetime English professor, she now devotes all her time to writing dark and romantic stories with tortured heroes and kick-butt heroines. She has written all her sixty-plus novels from her home in Austin, Texas, which she shares with her family. tracywolffbooks.com
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 185 reviews
Want to read
August 13, 2025Ahhh! I love Tracy’s books, I didn’t know she had a contemporary coming out! I’m so excited! 😃
September 3, 2025
safe no ow/om drama no virgins no manwhore
a cute love story
a cute love story
Want to read
July 24, 2025Very Taylor Swift/Travis Kelce-coded.
I dig it.
I dig it.
August 12, 2025
Thank you, thank you, Tracy Wolff, Entanged Publishing, and NetGalley for granting me an advance eCopy of It Happened on a Sunday.
I will be dreaming about Sly and Sloan for many, many nights to come.
Their love story left me reeling. I was hooked from the first chapter. I couldn't read it fast enough. I had to find out what was going to happen next.
I was rooting for Sloan and Sly as they grew closer and closer as they opened up to each other, shared their pasts traumatic experiences, and trusted one another.
I want to comment on so many things but don't want to give anything away. I will say, I am a sucker for a happy ending, and the ending blew me away!
I highly, highly recommend, It Happened on a Sunday!
Five stars plus!
#ithappenedonasunday
#tracywolff
#entangledpublishing
#wolffpack
I will be dreaming about Sly and Sloan for many, many nights to come.
Their love story left me reeling. I was hooked from the first chapter. I couldn't read it fast enough. I had to find out what was going to happen next.
I was rooting for Sloan and Sly as they grew closer and closer as they opened up to each other, shared their pasts traumatic experiences, and trusted one another.
I want to comment on so many things but don't want to give anything away. I will say, I am a sucker for a happy ending, and the ending blew me away!
I highly, highly recommend, It Happened on a Sunday!
Five stars plus!
#ithappenedonasunday
#tracywolff
#entangledpublishing
#wolffpack
July 29, 2025
This is why I don’t read romances. They are too beautiful and too real and I love them too much.
I loved everything about this book. From the broken and battered characters to the slight mystery to the love. Everything was perfect.
I’ve never read a football/pop star romance before but I can confidently say I need more.
Please read this one. And make sure your tissues are near when you do.
Thank you so much Entangled Insiders for this ARC!
I loved everything about this book. From the broken and battered characters to the slight mystery to the love. Everything was perfect.
I’ve never read a football/pop star romance before but I can confidently say I need more.
Please read this one. And make sure your tissues are near when you do.
Thank you so much Entangled Insiders for this ARC!
August 11, 2025
Tracy Wolfe’s “It Happened on a Sunday” is a Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce–inspired romance between a celebrity pop star and an NFL quarterback.
Twenty-seven-year-old Matteo “Sly” Sylvester is the quarterback for the Austin Twisters. Raised by his grandmother, Abuela Ximena, alongside his three sisters, Sly is deeply devoted to family. When he scores tickets to a concert for his grandmother’s favorite artist, pop sensation Black Widow, he splurges on a meet-and-greet. That chance meeting changes the trajectory of his life.
Sloane Walker, better known as Black Widow, is no stranger to scandal. Both of her previous serious boyfriends died tragically, one in a drunk driving accident (Hayden Jeffries), and the other, singer-songwriter Jarrod Bowers, in a drowning. Fans, obsessed with the eerie coincidences, have left hate mail and conspiracy theories in their wake. Emotionally guarded and heavily traumatized, Sloane masks her pain behind a façade, pretending her flask of sweet tea is bourbon and keeping the world at arm’s length. That begins to change when she meets Sly and his warm, loving grandmother, Ximena.
Sly is instantly drawn to Sloane’s magnetic yet closed-off presence. Still haunted by the trauma of discovering a teammate assaulted his sister, he sees himself as a protector of the vulnerable. So, when Sloane begins receiving disturbing threats and stalker-like attention, complete with demented dolls and escalating danger, Sly becomes determined not to let history repeat itself.
With the media relentlessly tracking their every move and the stalker becoming bolder, Sly and Sloane must decide whether their budding relationship is worth the emotional cost and constant scrutiny.
Wolfe’s novel is anything but a slow burn. Sly proclaims he's in love with Sloane by their second encounter, a pacing that may feel rushed to some readers.
At times, Wolfe’s prose leans purple, occasionally using elevated vocabulary (“insouciance,” “vestiges”) that may feel out of step with the otherwise contemporary, commercial tone. The novel also falters in believability: Sly’s fine by his coach, which somehow becomes public knowledge nationwide, stretches realism to its limits. Some sex scenes are vague or strangely clinical: “head lolling back to bare my jugular” being one example, leaving readers either confused or unintentionally amused.
Additionally, the plot becomes increasingly overloaded with Law and Order–style drama, including FBI involvement, which detracts from the core romance. The novel’s strength lies in its pop culture winks, particularly the clever sprinkling of Taylor Swift song titles like “Getaway Car,” “Willow,” “August,” and “Wildest Dreams,” among others.
I received an ARC from Edelweiss and Amara/Macmillian in exchange for an honest review.
Twenty-seven-year-old Matteo “Sly” Sylvester is the quarterback for the Austin Twisters. Raised by his grandmother, Abuela Ximena, alongside his three sisters, Sly is deeply devoted to family. When he scores tickets to a concert for his grandmother’s favorite artist, pop sensation Black Widow, he splurges on a meet-and-greet. That chance meeting changes the trajectory of his life.
Sloane Walker, better known as Black Widow, is no stranger to scandal. Both of her previous serious boyfriends died tragically, one in a drunk driving accident (Hayden Jeffries), and the other, singer-songwriter Jarrod Bowers, in a drowning. Fans, obsessed with the eerie coincidences, have left hate mail and conspiracy theories in their wake. Emotionally guarded and heavily traumatized, Sloane masks her pain behind a façade, pretending her flask of sweet tea is bourbon and keeping the world at arm’s length. That begins to change when she meets Sly and his warm, loving grandmother, Ximena.
Sly is instantly drawn to Sloane’s magnetic yet closed-off presence. Still haunted by the trauma of discovering a teammate assaulted his sister, he sees himself as a protector of the vulnerable. So, when Sloane begins receiving disturbing threats and stalker-like attention, complete with demented dolls and escalating danger, Sly becomes determined not to let history repeat itself.
With the media relentlessly tracking their every move and the stalker becoming bolder, Sly and Sloane must decide whether their budding relationship is worth the emotional cost and constant scrutiny.
Wolfe’s novel is anything but a slow burn. Sly proclaims he's in love with Sloane by their second encounter, a pacing that may feel rushed to some readers.
At times, Wolfe’s prose leans purple, occasionally using elevated vocabulary (“insouciance,” “vestiges”) that may feel out of step with the otherwise contemporary, commercial tone. The novel also falters in believability: Sly’s fine by his coach, which somehow becomes public knowledge nationwide, stretches realism to its limits. Some sex scenes are vague or strangely clinical: “head lolling back to bare my jugular” being one example, leaving readers either confused or unintentionally amused.
Additionally, the plot becomes increasingly overloaded with Law and Order–style drama, including FBI involvement, which detracts from the core romance. The novel’s strength lies in its pop culture winks, particularly the clever sprinkling of Taylor Swift song titles like “Getaway Car,” “Willow,” “August,” and “Wildest Dreams,” among others.
I received an ARC from Edelweiss and Amara/Macmillian in exchange for an honest review.
September 2, 2025
Thank you to Entangled and Tracy for entrusting me with an early copy!
Standalone contemporary romance
Dual POV, two celebrities, pop star FMC, star quarterback MMC, cinnamon roll (MMC) x black cat persona (FMC), stalker/suspense/treats, mental health rep, he falls first and hard, banter
Sloane is a pop star who has embraced her bad girl Black Widow persona after a second boyfriend died tragically. Mateo is the beloved quarterback who is taking his grandmother to one of Sloane's concerts when he manages to arrange a meet and greet. An immediate media storm is caused when he gets caught in the edge of a photo Sloane takes with his grandmother. While a spark is there, Sloane is convinced a relationship between them would be disastrous. Can Mateo convince her that they are worth a try and to ignore the public's opinion?
This was both a cute and emotional read! It definitely was giving Taylor and Travis vibes, which I loved! I appreciated the development of Sloane's trust in Mateo and how they stood together in the face of everything that came at them. Mateo seeing past the front to the real Sloane was also wonderful. And Abuela Ximena was pure gold! I adore her! I had a great time with this and ended it on a Sunday with happy teary eyes.
August 31, 2025
I got to read this early as an ARC and wow—this book gave me total Taylor and Travis vibes (but trust me, it’s not their story!). I absolutely adore Mateo and Sloane. Their chemistry, their banter, the way they just fit—it completely pulled me in. I flew through it and the second I finished, I immediately ordered a finished copy because I need this one on my shelf.
August 7, 2025
3.5/5 rounding up
A massive thank you to Entangled/AMARA for a physical ARC of this book! (I always feel truly honored to get picked for any ARCs - y'all are the best<3)
I really enjoyed this popstar x football player romance! At first, I thought it would be another Taylor Swift x Travis Kelce inspired book, but it was very different!
We get Sloane (aka the Black Widow) who is the "bad girl" of pop music, and Sly (first name Mateo) who is our loveable golden retriever of a quarterback. The two MCs have to learn to navigate a budding relationship under the ever present eye of the media, all while Sloane is being harassed by a stalker at her shows. Sly wants nothing more than to keep her safe, but will she let him?
While I liked this book, I did feel that the major conflict of the story was resolved a bit too quickly after all of the build-up.
This was my first contemporary romance by Tracy Wolff, and I would absolutely read more!
A massive thank you to Entangled/AMARA for a physical ARC of this book! (I always feel truly honored to get picked for any ARCs - y'all are the best<3)
I really enjoyed this popstar x football player romance! At first, I thought it would be another Taylor Swift x Travis Kelce inspired book, but it was very different!
We get Sloane (aka the Black Widow) who is the "bad girl" of pop music, and Sly (first name Mateo) who is our loveable golden retriever of a quarterback. The two MCs have to learn to navigate a budding relationship under the ever present eye of the media, all while Sloane is being harassed by a stalker at her shows. Sly wants nothing more than to keep her safe, but will she let him?
While I liked this book, I did feel that the major conflict of the story was resolved a bit too quickly after all of the build-up.
This was my first contemporary romance by Tracy Wolff, and I would absolutely read more!
August 9, 2025
Slaaaaaaaay.
August 6, 2025
Thank you, Entangled Insiders, for this ARC.
I really enjoyed this book. The first few chapters were a little tough to get through, but the book flowed well together. Romance with a little mystery. I thought the character development portrayed was excellent.
It's one of the best romances I've read so far this year.
I really enjoyed this book. The first few chapters were a little tough to get through, but the book flowed well together. Romance with a little mystery. I thought the character development portrayed was excellent.
It's one of the best romances I've read so far this year.
September 2, 2025
You can find this review of It Happened on a Sunday on my blog, Heart’s Content!
A big big shout out and thank you to the publisher, Entangled, for providing me with a complimentary copy in exchange for an honest review!
The first genre—from what I remember—that paved the path of love for romance in my reader heart was contemporary romance. As much as I love, adore and gravitate towards fantasy, there’s something so grounding, touching and real about the genre of contemporary romance that always has me coming back to it. Sometimes not even the presence of magical beings or a protagonist’s ability to fly can rival the strength of a love story between two very real people struggling with very real, very relatable and heartbreaking pain.
To me, It Happened on a Sunday represents all that and more.
The blurb of IHoaS immediately hints at who may have been the spark of inspiration that lead the author down the path that created these characters in this particular world. It, both interested and worried me at first, wondering if I would be able to get lost in it or if I would find myself unable to shake the original couple from my mind.
It was the single most pleasant experience to note that one page in, the author’s writing ensures you see nothing but Sloane and Sly. Wolff adopts a really smart and interesting choice of writing; where the length of the book is not influenced by the number of events that take place in it, but rather, by the depth with which each event is delved into. There are perhaps… ten prominent situations that take place through the whole book, within which Wolff tells her whole story. Having gotten used to big books usually being peppered with several shorter filler scenes and only two or three longer important scenes, I enjoyed reading a book with a selective number of scenes, but whose content expands across emotional, situational, personal and social interactions and struggles. Kudos to the author and her writing for being able to drown me from nearly the first moment into a world of glamour, grit and love.
Unusual as it may seem, I would say there’s a certain level of world building this book requires. A layman has very little understanding of what each day could possibly look like for a celebrity. Sure, of course, they are ultimately people like us; except imagine if everything about your life were to be fodder for the press and public to consume. The weight of this, the effect it has on an individual, the internal (and external) strides someone has to take to constantly live with and overcome the consequences of being in the limelight and (my favourite part) the subtle mention of how there’s a gender related difference to this experience as well, were all a very large part of IHoaS. To say I was surprised (and pleased) with this book is to say the least.
The characters, are of course, the heart of any book; but with contemporary there’s a certain vulnerability the characters and the theme requires, that demands a complete baring of the soul to its readers. Sloan and Sly are much like braids, taking turns baring their hearts and pain to the reader in their own unique ways but in an eternally entwined pattern. Personally, I enjoyed that this book balanced the characters’ growth, even though it may not initially seem that way. The subtle mention of trauma being loud in some and quiet in some, but both being equally true, significant and debilitating, was so wonderful.
The plot of this book is closely associated to its characters. It is quite simply the coming together of two people who find peace in one another. Though, I will say, as simple as it sounds, it is perhaps one of the more complex plot lines to sew; since as readers we often want it to feel perfect and right, with not a single detail out of place—something we might not even demand of a fantastical theme. I did come across a few reviews that mentioned an “insta-love” aspect to this story and I would just like to make a small shift to the phrase. I would call it an insta-connection. A singular moment in time when you feel a kinship, a familiarity or a comfort with someone that intuitively makes you want to pursue a relationship with them, whether platonic or romantic or any other. To me, that’s what this story was about. A connection that’s explored with a lot of courage, communication, love, pain and healing.
The pace in this book is even for the most part, but somehow perhaps because of how the author has styled her book, you do feel like you’ve spent longer with the characters than is true and you’re sometimes impatient for the story to move forward.
Reading It Happened on a Sunday was a sweet experience that makes me smile every time I think about it. It’s a warm hand that is holding you gently but surely, while helping you navigate out of a crowd, quietening all the bluster and having you thinking only about moving forward with them. Are you smiling yet?
Four and a half stars! Happy reading! Please read the list of trigger warnings before venturing into this book, it features themes that some may find difficult.
A big big shout out and thank you to the publisher, Entangled, for providing me with a complimentary copy in exchange for an honest review!
The first genre—from what I remember—that paved the path of love for romance in my reader heart was contemporary romance. As much as I love, adore and gravitate towards fantasy, there’s something so grounding, touching and real about the genre of contemporary romance that always has me coming back to it. Sometimes not even the presence of magical beings or a protagonist’s ability to fly can rival the strength of a love story between two very real people struggling with very real, very relatable and heartbreaking pain.
To me, It Happened on a Sunday represents all that and more.
The blurb of IHoaS immediately hints at who may have been the spark of inspiration that lead the author down the path that created these characters in this particular world. It, both interested and worried me at first, wondering if I would be able to get lost in it or if I would find myself unable to shake the original couple from my mind.
It was the single most pleasant experience to note that one page in, the author’s writing ensures you see nothing but Sloane and Sly. Wolff adopts a really smart and interesting choice of writing; where the length of the book is not influenced by the number of events that take place in it, but rather, by the depth with which each event is delved into. There are perhaps… ten prominent situations that take place through the whole book, within which Wolff tells her whole story. Having gotten used to big books usually being peppered with several shorter filler scenes and only two or three longer important scenes, I enjoyed reading a book with a selective number of scenes, but whose content expands across emotional, situational, personal and social interactions and struggles. Kudos to the author and her writing for being able to drown me from nearly the first moment into a world of glamour, grit and love.
Unusual as it may seem, I would say there’s a certain level of world building this book requires. A layman has very little understanding of what each day could possibly look like for a celebrity. Sure, of course, they are ultimately people like us; except imagine if everything about your life were to be fodder for the press and public to consume. The weight of this, the effect it has on an individual, the internal (and external) strides someone has to take to constantly live with and overcome the consequences of being in the limelight and (my favourite part) the subtle mention of how there’s a gender related difference to this experience as well, were all a very large part of IHoaS. To say I was surprised (and pleased) with this book is to say the least.
The characters, are of course, the heart of any book; but with contemporary there’s a certain vulnerability the characters and the theme requires, that demands a complete baring of the soul to its readers. Sloan and Sly are much like braids, taking turns baring their hearts and pain to the reader in their own unique ways but in an eternally entwined pattern. Personally, I enjoyed that this book balanced the characters’ growth, even though it may not initially seem that way. The subtle mention of trauma being loud in some and quiet in some, but both being equally true, significant and debilitating, was so wonderful.
The plot of this book is closely associated to its characters. It is quite simply the coming together of two people who find peace in one another. Though, I will say, as simple as it sounds, it is perhaps one of the more complex plot lines to sew; since as readers we often want it to feel perfect and right, with not a single detail out of place—something we might not even demand of a fantastical theme. I did come across a few reviews that mentioned an “insta-love” aspect to this story and I would just like to make a small shift to the phrase. I would call it an insta-connection. A singular moment in time when you feel a kinship, a familiarity or a comfort with someone that intuitively makes you want to pursue a relationship with them, whether platonic or romantic or any other. To me, that’s what this story was about. A connection that’s explored with a lot of courage, communication, love, pain and healing.
The pace in this book is even for the most part, but somehow perhaps because of how the author has styled her book, you do feel like you’ve spent longer with the characters than is true and you’re sometimes impatient for the story to move forward.
Reading It Happened on a Sunday was a sweet experience that makes me smile every time I think about it. It’s a warm hand that is holding you gently but surely, while helping you navigate out of a crowd, quietening all the bluster and having you thinking only about moving forward with them. Are you smiling yet?
Four and a half stars! Happy reading! Please read the list of trigger warnings before venturing into this book, it features themes that some may find difficult.
August 21, 2025
It Happened on a Sunday is everything I love about Tracy Wolff’s writing—intense, emotional, and utterly swoony. From the very first page, I was hooked by Sloane, the so-called “Black Widow” who has been crushed under the weight of the media’s cruel spotlight, and Sly, the NFL’s golden boy who sees the real woman beneath the glitter and armor.
Their first meeting—thanks to his abuela being one of Sloane’s biggest fans—was one of my favorite moments in the book. That family connection only deepened my love for Sly. His bond with his abuela and sisters is so warm and genuine, and it made me even more invested in his story. Honestly, I’m intrigued by the entire Sylvester family and would happily read books about every single one of them.
The romance itself is everything I want in a rockstar/celebrity love story. The gifts Sly sends Sloane? Sweet, thoughtful, and impossible for her to ignore. The dates he plans? Pure magic. Their text conversations while juggling careers—her on tour, him in the middle of the season—felt real and believable, full of yearning and connection. And those grand gestures on both sides had me swooning more than once.
What really made this book sing for me was the way it balanced Sloane’s painful past and the glittering but lonely reality of her career. She’s been through so much, and my heart hurt for her, but I admired her strength and how she’s still standing. Watching her slowly lower her walls with Sly, who has his own scars and shadows, was deeply satisfying. They fit together in a way that makes you root for them with every page.
I also loved the little touches—like the Twisters playing the Lightning from Wolff’s other series and Hunter Browning’s off-page cameo at the end. And Marquis, Sly’s best friend, nearly stole the show with his humor and huge personality (I’d love to see him get a book of his own).
Yes, I had to suspend a little disbelief with some of the football details, but Wolff keeps the focus on Sloane, her music, and her emotional journey. Since I’ve been in my rockstar romance era all year, this was exactly the story I wanted to read.
By the end, I was swooning, kicking my feet, and big mad on Sloane and Sly’s behalf at certain twists. But above all, I was left with a smile on my face and a full heart. It Happened on a Sunday hit every single note for me—a moving, romantic, and beautifully written story about choosing love even when the whole world is watching.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for this ARC.
Release Date: Sept 2, 2025
Their first meeting—thanks to his abuela being one of Sloane’s biggest fans—was one of my favorite moments in the book. That family connection only deepened my love for Sly. His bond with his abuela and sisters is so warm and genuine, and it made me even more invested in his story. Honestly, I’m intrigued by the entire Sylvester family and would happily read books about every single one of them.
The romance itself is everything I want in a rockstar/celebrity love story. The gifts Sly sends Sloane? Sweet, thoughtful, and impossible for her to ignore. The dates he plans? Pure magic. Their text conversations while juggling careers—her on tour, him in the middle of the season—felt real and believable, full of yearning and connection. And those grand gestures on both sides had me swooning more than once.
What really made this book sing for me was the way it balanced Sloane’s painful past and the glittering but lonely reality of her career. She’s been through so much, and my heart hurt for her, but I admired her strength and how she’s still standing. Watching her slowly lower her walls with Sly, who has his own scars and shadows, was deeply satisfying. They fit together in a way that makes you root for them with every page.
I also loved the little touches—like the Twisters playing the Lightning from Wolff’s other series and Hunter Browning’s off-page cameo at the end. And Marquis, Sly’s best friend, nearly stole the show with his humor and huge personality (I’d love to see him get a book of his own).
Yes, I had to suspend a little disbelief with some of the football details, but Wolff keeps the focus on Sloane, her music, and her emotional journey. Since I’ve been in my rockstar romance era all year, this was exactly the story I wanted to read.
By the end, I was swooning, kicking my feet, and big mad on Sloane and Sly’s behalf at certain twists. But above all, I was left with a smile on my face and a full heart. It Happened on a Sunday hit every single note for me—a moving, romantic, and beautifully written story about choosing love even when the whole world is watching.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for this ARC.
Release Date: Sept 2, 2025
August 15, 2025
Thank you Entangled for the early copy. All opinions are my own.
‘Because when Sly leans into me, there is no before. And there is no after. There is only this single, wild moment and the tornado it unleashed between us.’
🎤 Pop Star x Professional football player
🏈 Stalking
🎤 Accidental overdose
🏈 Insta-attraction
When pop star Sloane Walker aka “Black Widow” and professional football player Mateo “Sly” Sylvester paths cross, they are instantly drawn to each other. But with the persistent press, obsessive fans, and a traumatizing past, the two consider if a relationship is worth pursuing
So I guess we are all just out here living the same life huh lol because after texting the person you like the only logical thing to do is freak out and throw your phone 😬
Mateo is such a cinnamon roll when it comes to Sloane yall, and you know what’s better than a cinnamon roll? One who has absolutely no problem letting people know not to disrespect his girl, and Mateo did just that. My boy said aht aht 👏🏾👏🏾 put some respect on Ms. Walker’s name
And speaking of the Black Widow, she really did try to protect both herself and Mateo by keeping her distance, but he was having none of that. Between his smile, his personality, and his determination she didn’t stand a chance. But let’s be honest it was those arms huh girl 😏 I get it 🤭
I will say since I lean more towards fantasy than contemporary it took a few chapters for me to “dig in” but once I was there I was there, so I think that was more of a me thing than the book
This story is about more than just romance. It’s about healing. It’s about getting back up after you’ve been knocked down. It’s about piecing yourself back together, and opening yourself back up. It’s about accepting the joy that you deserve
And because i couldn’t just pick one favorite quote…
“I don’t know how much of me there’s left to offer, Mateo. I’m just a bunch of jagged pieces held together by glitter and eyelash glue.”
If you’re searching for a book that will take you on an emotional journey then add this to your tbr
‘Because when Sly leans into me, there is no before. And there is no after. There is only this single, wild moment and the tornado it unleashed between us.’
🎤 Pop Star x Professional football player
🏈 Stalking
🎤 Accidental overdose
🏈 Insta-attraction
When pop star Sloane Walker aka “Black Widow” and professional football player Mateo “Sly” Sylvester paths cross, they are instantly drawn to each other. But with the persistent press, obsessive fans, and a traumatizing past, the two consider if a relationship is worth pursuing
So I guess we are all just out here living the same life huh lol because after texting the person you like the only logical thing to do is freak out and throw your phone 😬
Mateo is such a cinnamon roll when it comes to Sloane yall, and you know what’s better than a cinnamon roll? One who has absolutely no problem letting people know not to disrespect his girl, and Mateo did just that. My boy said aht aht 👏🏾👏🏾 put some respect on Ms. Walker’s name
And speaking of the Black Widow, she really did try to protect both herself and Mateo by keeping her distance, but he was having none of that. Between his smile, his personality, and his determination she didn’t stand a chance. But let’s be honest it was those arms huh girl 😏 I get it 🤭
I will say since I lean more towards fantasy than contemporary it took a few chapters for me to “dig in” but once I was there I was there, so I think that was more of a me thing than the book
This story is about more than just romance. It’s about healing. It’s about getting back up after you’ve been knocked down. It’s about piecing yourself back together, and opening yourself back up. It’s about accepting the joy that you deserve
And because i couldn’t just pick one favorite quote…
“I don’t know how much of me there’s left to offer, Mateo. I’m just a bunch of jagged pieces held together by glitter and eyelash glue.”
If you’re searching for a book that will take you on an emotional journey then add this to your tbr
August 22, 2025
This is one of the most beautiful love stories I have read in a long time.
This is also one of my first Tracy Wolff books, and it most definitely will not be my last.
If you're a fan of pop star romances where she's the bad girl and he's footballs golden boy, this one is for you. I absolutely ate this book up and haven't shut up about it when talking to my book friends.
Sloane Walker aka the Black Widow is known for being one of pop's "bad girls." Unfortunate events seem to follow wherever she goes, and she lives up to her stage name... So when a chance encounter with the NFL's golden boy and star QB, Mateo "Sly" Sylvester gets the medias attention, all Sloane can think to do is run the other way. She's closed herself off from any romantic involvements for the past 5 years and she's perfectly content being the Black Widow and letting the world see her as such. But for the first time in months, Sloane is able to hear and write music again when she thought she'd lost her spark for song writing. And the one thing on her mind that's seemed to awaken her once dormant musical brain is none other than Sly... Could it really hurt to go on a couple dates with the guy? Maybe give the fans and the media what they want? Or will the Black Widow strike again?
Y'ALL - this story was SO wonderfully written. The chemistry between Sloane and Mateo absolutely jumped off the page. Their patience and vulnerability with one another was so heartbreakingly beautiful that I was in tears. The way Sloane learned to trust again and how well Mateo took care of her had my heart bursting at the seams. These two were everything. From the banter, to the secrets shared, to the love they expressed, I ADORE them.
Their story is such a special one and it's something I'll be thinking of for a long time.
Highly HIGHLY recommend It Happened on a Sunday for lovers of:
- "bad girl" pop star x NFL "golden boy"
- he falls first
- romantic suspense
- found family
- hurt/comfort
Thank you so much to Tracy and Entangled for my ARC!
This is also one of my first Tracy Wolff books, and it most definitely will not be my last.
If you're a fan of pop star romances where she's the bad girl and he's footballs golden boy, this one is for you. I absolutely ate this book up and haven't shut up about it when talking to my book friends.
Sloane Walker aka the Black Widow is known for being one of pop's "bad girls." Unfortunate events seem to follow wherever she goes, and she lives up to her stage name... So when a chance encounter with the NFL's golden boy and star QB, Mateo "Sly" Sylvester gets the medias attention, all Sloane can think to do is run the other way. She's closed herself off from any romantic involvements for the past 5 years and she's perfectly content being the Black Widow and letting the world see her as such. But for the first time in months, Sloane is able to hear and write music again when she thought she'd lost her spark for song writing. And the one thing on her mind that's seemed to awaken her once dormant musical brain is none other than Sly... Could it really hurt to go on a couple dates with the guy? Maybe give the fans and the media what they want? Or will the Black Widow strike again?
Y'ALL - this story was SO wonderfully written. The chemistry between Sloane and Mateo absolutely jumped off the page. Their patience and vulnerability with one another was so heartbreakingly beautiful that I was in tears. The way Sloane learned to trust again and how well Mateo took care of her had my heart bursting at the seams. These two were everything. From the banter, to the secrets shared, to the love they expressed, I ADORE them.
Their story is such a special one and it's something I'll be thinking of for a long time.
Highly HIGHLY recommend It Happened on a Sunday for lovers of:
- "bad girl" pop star x NFL "golden boy"
- he falls first
- romantic suspense
- found family
- hurt/comfort
Thank you so much to Tracy and Entangled for my ARC!
August 18, 2025
This was a beautiful, lovely story about healing, finding yourself, and fighting for your happily ever after.
While some parts may be unbelievable (because how many of us are either pop stars or NFL players and/or can put ourselves in their shoes, among other things), I absolutely FELT for Sloan, and Sly is... everything ♡
Thank you to Amara, an imprint of Entangled Publishing, for the gifted copy!
Website | Bookstagram | BookTok
While some parts may be unbelievable (because how many of us are either pop stars or NFL players and/or can put ourselves in their shoes, among other things), I absolutely FELT for Sloan, and Sly is... everything ♡
Thank you to Amara, an imprint of Entangled Publishing, for the gifted copy!
Website | Bookstagram | BookTok
September 3, 2025
This is my first book by Tracy Wolff and I was very pleasantly surprised. I really enjoyed this Travis and Taylor inspired story with the darker aspects thrown in and a bit of mystery as well.
There is a lot of angst and longing, especially by our boy Mateo, whom I absolutely love. He shows up for Sloane in ways noone else has before and it's everything. It totally makes the story.
Very low spice (the word c0ck is not in the book at all to help some of y'all out lol) but the story is really sweet and flows so nicely.
SPICE: 🌶️
There is a lot of angst and longing, especially by our boy Mateo, whom I absolutely love. He shows up for Sloane in ways noone else has before and it's everything. It totally makes the story.
Very low spice (the word c0ck is not in the book at all to help some of y'all out lol) but the story is really sweet and flows so nicely.
SPICE: 🌶️
September 3, 2025
4.5 Stars
August 21, 2025
If you’re looking for a book that has black cat/golden retriever vibes this book is for you. I give it 3 stars bc It is more of a slow burn & it took me over halfway into the book to become super invested in the characters. With that being said I found the storyline & the relationship that developed between the Main Characters to be super sweet.
September 9, 2025
It Happened on a Sunday was a beautiful, well-paced love story about a pop star in her prime, Sloane, and a professional star quarterback, Mateo "Sly" Sylvester, who happen to meet due to his abuelita's fandom. Mateo is immediately crushing hard on Sloane. Her mysterious beauty motivates him enough to send her ice cream sundaes, before he even knows much about her past history as the "Black Widow" of pop.
Sloane is resistant to his attention, as she's scarred from several past relationships with high-profile people who burned bright, and burned out quickly. She expects to be hurt. She's built up walls around herself, literally and emotionally. She has a team of people around her, scheduling her every move and coaching her in order to shape the pop star she must be in order to maintain fame.
But through his gentle nature, love of his family, humor, grand gestures, and steady belief in himself and what he wants, Sloane learns to trust herself and her heart again. Their slow burn heat and chemistry is top notch. I love a celebrity romance, because it shows that even through all the outside noise, they still have the same desires and needs we all do. As Sly and Sloane heal each other, it's easy to see how love can be the perfect soil for growth. Their vulnerabilities allowed them to see the other's strengths, and their love really blossomed when it mattered; under pressure!
Sly's way of loving out loud heals the parts of Sloane that needed to be seen, even though she feels seen by everyone. The safety and reliability of a steady partner can give you the nurturing and sunlight to blossom in a world that provides a lot of difficult experiences and trauma. I would definitely recommend to Swifties, as the Taylor/Trav vibes are HEAVY! 🩷
Tracy Wolff's writing really shines in creating believable backstories for the big emotions her characters are feeling, and then pulling the tension out perfectly to let the payoff feel really emotional. I thought the way they fell apart, together, and helped each other put the pieces back together is a real testament to the power of love and believing in second, third, fourth chances. Theirs is a really beautiful and moving story!
Major Tropes and Themes:
- Celebrity Romance (Pop star x Quarterback)
- Golden Retriever MMC
- grumpy x sunshine
- healing together, mental health struggles/trauma
- found family
- Spanish language/Hispanic rep
- Public scrutiny, paparazzi, media scrutiny
- Grand gestures
Perfect for fans of:
- Taylor Swift
- Daisy Jones & The Six - Taylor Jenkins Reid
- The Bodyguard - Katherine Center
- Instant Star (TV)
- A Star is Born (film)
- The Score - Elle Kennedy
To end, I'd like to send a huge thank you to the Entangled Publishing team and Tracy Wolff for being blessed with the ability to read an advanced copy! I am truly grateful and very much appreciate the opportunity to read this one!🫶
Sloane is resistant to his attention, as she's scarred from several past relationships with high-profile people who burned bright, and burned out quickly. She expects to be hurt. She's built up walls around herself, literally and emotionally. She has a team of people around her, scheduling her every move and coaching her in order to shape the pop star she must be in order to maintain fame.
But through his gentle nature, love of his family, humor, grand gestures, and steady belief in himself and what he wants, Sloane learns to trust herself and her heart again. Their slow burn heat and chemistry is top notch. I love a celebrity romance, because it shows that even through all the outside noise, they still have the same desires and needs we all do. As Sly and Sloane heal each other, it's easy to see how love can be the perfect soil for growth. Their vulnerabilities allowed them to see the other's strengths, and their love really blossomed when it mattered; under pressure!
Sly's way of loving out loud heals the parts of Sloane that needed to be seen, even though she feels seen by everyone. The safety and reliability of a steady partner can give you the nurturing and sunlight to blossom in a world that provides a lot of difficult experiences and trauma. I would definitely recommend to Swifties, as the Taylor/Trav vibes are HEAVY! 🩷
Tracy Wolff's writing really shines in creating believable backstories for the big emotions her characters are feeling, and then pulling the tension out perfectly to let the payoff feel really emotional. I thought the way they fell apart, together, and helped each other put the pieces back together is a real testament to the power of love and believing in second, third, fourth chances. Theirs is a really beautiful and moving story!
Major Tropes and Themes:
- Celebrity Romance (Pop star x Quarterback)
- Golden Retriever MMC
- grumpy x sunshine
- healing together, mental health struggles/trauma
- found family
- Spanish language/Hispanic rep
- Public scrutiny, paparazzi, media scrutiny
- Grand gestures
Perfect for fans of:
- Taylor Swift
- Daisy Jones & The Six - Taylor Jenkins Reid
- The Bodyguard - Katherine Center
- Instant Star (TV)
- A Star is Born (film)
- The Score - Elle Kennedy
To end, I'd like to send a huge thank you to the Entangled Publishing team and Tracy Wolff for being blessed with the ability to read an advanced copy! I am truly grateful and very much appreciate the opportunity to read this one!🫶
September 7, 2025
Picture this: a famous pop star nicknamed the Black Widow because her last 2 boyfriends are dead. No, she didn't kill them but the media still blames her. Sloane Walker has embraced the black widow persona for the past 5 years and know what she has to do to protect herself. When a meet and greet with her biggest fan aka Sly's grandma and Sly, her plans come crashing down. If you're looking for a white knight in shining armor, then Mateo 'Sly' Sylvester is your man. All the green flags of football's golden boy who is never late, loves his grandma, takes care of his sisters, and the only one who has a chance to break down Sloane's walls. A broken pop star with a past collides with the only person who can help put her together again. He's protective, cautious, and always putting her first to make sure she is seen and safe. Everyone needs a Sly in their life.
I really enjoyed this book. The pacing could have been better because it took awhile for me to get invested to be on team Sloaney. However, still a solid read since this is the popstar × football player story we have been begging for since Taylor and Travis went public.
I really enjoyed this book. The pacing could have been better because it took awhile for me to get invested to be on team Sloaney. However, still a solid read since this is the popstar × football player story we have been begging for since Taylor and Travis went public.
August 7, 2025
The premise of this one sounded exactly up my alley, but unfortunately, it wasn't for me. It was both quick-paced and dragged on at the same time, and I had to force myself to pick it back up to keep going. While the characters bonded over trauma and had difficult pasts, I found it difficult to connect emotionally to either of them. The love story felt forced (it was insta love for sure), and I don't think there was really a ton of development. The plot twist/betrayal at the end was relatively obvious, and I thought there was too much time spent on that rather than the continuation of the main relationship. I didn't feel any chemistry either. Sloane was back and forth with an inner monologue most of the time, and Sly was dead set on professing his love and protecting her, which was nice, but there was no individuality. I liked the texts between the characters, and that actually gave more insight into their personalities, but overall, this one highly missed for me. Thank you to Entangled for the ARC to read and review!
August 17, 2025
Thank you Entangled Publishing for the ARC; I do not take ARC opportunities for granted, whether I enjoyed the book or not. This publishing company has been so generous with their community of fans and deserves all the shoutouts!
This book did not pull on my heartstrings. I won’t lie, I’m not a Swiftie, so the Swift/Kelce inspo didn’t work in the author’s favor when it came to me, but I still love a good sports romance and felt hopeful. I think this inspo will have others SWOONING, though.
I tend to enjoy insta-love and “unable to make up their mind” characters LESS THAN a slow and confident burn. There were inconsistencies throughout, repetitive language (*THIS COULD GET EDITED OUT AS I DID NOT HAVE A FINAL EDIT COPY), and the ending was not for me.
HOWEVER, there were some good/emotional moments and character arcs that had potential and that’s what kept my interest. I loved the Black Widow persona (gave dark Hannah Montana) and wish I could’ve learned more about the FMCs trauma to help develop her character more fully. She was definitely the (pop)star of the novel 🩷🖤
This book did not pull on my heartstrings. I won’t lie, I’m not a Swiftie, so the Swift/Kelce inspo didn’t work in the author’s favor when it came to me, but I still love a good sports romance and felt hopeful. I think this inspo will have others SWOONING, though.
I tend to enjoy insta-love and “unable to make up their mind” characters LESS THAN a slow and confident burn. There were inconsistencies throughout, repetitive language (*THIS COULD GET EDITED OUT AS I DID NOT HAVE A FINAL EDIT COPY), and the ending was not for me.
HOWEVER, there were some good/emotional moments and character arcs that had potential and that’s what kept my interest. I loved the Black Widow persona (gave dark Hannah Montana) and wish I could’ve learned more about the FMCs trauma to help develop her character more fully. She was definitely the (pop)star of the novel 🩷🖤
August 31, 2025
Thank you to Entangled for mailing me an ARC copy of this book 😀.
This book is for anyone that is a fan of Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce. As a casual Taylor Swift listener…I was a bit skeptical when this appeared in my mailbox and I started reading but pretty soon I was hooked (Lol and Taylor and Travis conveniently got engaged while I read this book … So that could’ve heightened the experience 😂). I feel like we’ll see a lot of musician/football player romances show up now…so it was nice to give this a try. I really liked the characters and the storyline was compelling. This was dual POV which I also enjoy in any novel. There were lots of cute parts you could tell were inspired by some of the things we’ve seen in the press about Taylor and Travis. The romance was a little insta love but I didn’t really mind it this time around. I did think some of this got a little repetitive especially when the characters were talking about their relationship/feelings. Overall I liked this more than I thought I would and would recommend to Taylor and Travis fans and sports romance readers.
This book is for anyone that is a fan of Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce. As a casual Taylor Swift listener…I was a bit skeptical when this appeared in my mailbox and I started reading but pretty soon I was hooked (Lol and Taylor and Travis conveniently got engaged while I read this book … So that could’ve heightened the experience 😂). I feel like we’ll see a lot of musician/football player romances show up now…so it was nice to give this a try. I really liked the characters and the storyline was compelling. This was dual POV which I also enjoy in any novel. There were lots of cute parts you could tell were inspired by some of the things we’ve seen in the press about Taylor and Travis. The romance was a little insta love but I didn’t really mind it this time around. I did think some of this got a little repetitive especially when the characters were talking about their relationship/feelings. Overall I liked this more than I thought I would and would recommend to Taylor and Travis fans and sports romance readers.
September 2, 2025
If you like your romance contemporary, swoony, and dramatic without a third act break up, then this book is for you.
Reminiscent of a real-life romance between a popstar and a football player, this is a story of self-love and romantic love. With a star quarterback known as the league's golden boy who will stop at nothing and will fight to keep his girl, who is known as THE bad girl, this story is so passionate. While I'd have liked to have seen the villain have more of a backstory, the cast of characters in this story all contributed so much.
The self-love journey that Sloane is on is truly the best part, but never once takes the reader away from the story. Wolff clearly put a lot of heart into this character, and it made me care for her like she was a real person.
PS. Marquis deserves his own story.
Thank you, Entangled Publishing, for the ARC opportunity. This honest review has been left voluntarily.
Reminiscent of a real-life romance between a popstar and a football player, this is a story of self-love and romantic love. With a star quarterback known as the league's golden boy who will stop at nothing and will fight to keep his girl, who is known as THE bad girl, this story is so passionate. While I'd have liked to have seen the villain have more of a backstory, the cast of characters in this story all contributed so much.
The self-love journey that Sloane is on is truly the best part, but never once takes the reader away from the story. Wolff clearly put a lot of heart into this character, and it made me care for her like she was a real person.
PS. Marquis deserves his own story.
Thank you, Entangled Publishing, for the ARC opportunity. This honest review has been left voluntarily.
September 2, 2025
This is definitely one of my favorite reads of the year! If I could give this more stars I would in a heartbeat! You absolutely had me speechless after finishing it! I could not put this book down. I was so drawn into the story line and the love story taking place. I was rooting for them and really got connected to Sloane and Sly. Our girl is a trooper who has been put through so much and decided she was going to play the part she is supposed to play and not take anyone's crap anymore. Until someone comes in and lets her be herself. And let me say our man Sly has the biggest heart and will do whatever he can for the people he cares about. After finishing this book I am definitely having a book hangover and might have to read it again! I highly recommend this book if you like contemporary romance books! Thank you so much @tracywolffbooks and @entangled_publishing for the opportunity to be a part of the ARC Team!❤️❤️❤️
August 4, 2025
I have loved everything Tracy Wolff has written and this book is no exception. It is a sweet and romantic story that will give you all the feels. I found myself kicking my feet in excitement at what was happening. You couldn’t help but root for Sly and Sloane!
I love them so much. Sly is so caring and will do anything to protect those he cares about. While he may take that “job” a little too seriously, he comes and realizes he can’t hold himself responsible for everyone’s actions. But the way he is there for Sloane and helps her come out of her “black widow” persona was perfection. He is the best person Sloane could be with.
My darling Sloane. My heart broke for her with what she had to go through in her life. She is so strong and once she opened herself up to Sly, she realized she doesn’t need to be the black widow. She is so much more than what the media deemed her as. I loved watching her growth and figuring out that she deserves love and that Sly is the person to give her that.
(And yes this will give you Taylor/Travis vibes)
I love them so much. Sly is so caring and will do anything to protect those he cares about. While he may take that “job” a little too seriously, he comes and realizes he can’t hold himself responsible for everyone’s actions. But the way he is there for Sloane and helps her come out of her “black widow” persona was perfection. He is the best person Sloane could be with.
My darling Sloane. My heart broke for her with what she had to go through in her life. She is so strong and once she opened herself up to Sly, she realized she doesn’t need to be the black widow. She is so much more than what the media deemed her as. I loved watching her growth and figuring out that she deserves love and that Sly is the person to give her that.
(And yes this will give you Taylor/Travis vibes)
August 25, 2025
Well that was the cutest, heart felt book I’ve read in a hot minute! Dare I say emotional rollercoaster? But I loved every minute!
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️✨ (4.5)
🌶️🔥 (1.5)
I will admit, I am not a swiftie but girl, did this book pull me in! Sloane is the queen of pop, called the Black Widow for her rough past and cold exterior. And Sly, the golden boy NFL quarterback, striving to protect his team and all those around him!
🎤Pop Star X Professional Athlete
🏈 Golden Boy X Bad Girl
🎤Insta-Love
🏈 He Falls First
🎤 Found Family
🏈 Romantic Suspense
🎤Painful Pasts
🏈 Stalkers
(Trigger warnings: domestic violence & drug abuse)
The banter between Sly & Sloane made me kick my feet with glee! It was so sweet seeing Sloane open herself up and learn to love and be loved again.
I wish we could share quotes for ARC reads, I flagged 50 pages at least!
Abuela Ximena is the secondary star of the show. Loves her character so much. She was so sweet and you could feel her love for Sly and his sisters.
The ending!? The villain twist?! I love a good surprise!
Thank you so so much to Entangled for the ARC!
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️✨ (4.5)
🌶️🔥 (1.5)
I will admit, I am not a swiftie but girl, did this book pull me in! Sloane is the queen of pop, called the Black Widow for her rough past and cold exterior. And Sly, the golden boy NFL quarterback, striving to protect his team and all those around him!
🎤Pop Star X Professional Athlete
🏈 Golden Boy X Bad Girl
🎤Insta-Love
🏈 He Falls First
🎤 Found Family
🏈 Romantic Suspense
🎤Painful Pasts
🏈 Stalkers
(Trigger warnings: domestic violence & drug abuse)
The banter between Sly & Sloane made me kick my feet with glee! It was so sweet seeing Sloane open herself up and learn to love and be loved again.
I wish we could share quotes for ARC reads, I flagged 50 pages at least!
Abuela Ximena is the secondary star of the show. Loves her character so much. She was so sweet and you could feel her love for Sly and his sisters.
The ending!? The villain twist?! I love a good surprise!
Thank you so so much to Entangled for the ARC!
August 26, 2025
NFL quarterback meets emotionally damaged popstar <3 If this sounds familiar, it’s because it is! But it was also wonderful and gave me ALL THE FEELS!
I really enjoyed settling into this beautifully written novel. I’ll admit, I was hesitant at first because, like many others, I’ve been a little burnt out on all the Travis Kelce/Taylor Swift relationship coverage in the media. Don’t get me wrong, I think they’re adorable together, but it gets old seeing it on every scroll of my feed. Anyway…
It Happened on a Sunday took that cuteness of the concept and dug deep into the real beauty of true love and relationships. The story went beyond the surface and really highlighted the layers of these main characters, making me root for them so hard.
Tracy Wolff wrote this in such a way that I felt fully immersed in the story, flipping pages long past when I should have stopped. And can we talk about this precious little grandmother? She was the epitome of how we all wish our grandma could be.
This one wasn’t just a fluffy romance; it was heartfelt, layered, and genuinely moving.
I really enjoyed settling into this beautifully written novel. I’ll admit, I was hesitant at first because, like many others, I’ve been a little burnt out on all the Travis Kelce/Taylor Swift relationship coverage in the media. Don’t get me wrong, I think they’re adorable together, but it gets old seeing it on every scroll of my feed. Anyway…
It Happened on a Sunday took that cuteness of the concept and dug deep into the real beauty of true love and relationships. The story went beyond the surface and really highlighted the layers of these main characters, making me root for them so hard.
Tracy Wolff wrote this in such a way that I felt fully immersed in the story, flipping pages long past when I should have stopped. And can we talk about this precious little grandmother? She was the epitome of how we all wish our grandma could be.
This one wasn’t just a fluffy romance; it was heartfelt, layered, and genuinely moving.
August 31, 2025
What a sweet romance! 4.5 stars
Sloane "Black Widow" a pop star with a bad rep (two of her ex's have ended up dead) does a meet and greet after one of her shows. There she meets America's golden boy and NFL star Sly and his abuela Ximena. Abuela Ximena runs one of the Black Widow fan accounts and absolutely loves her, it did seem that abuela had an underlying reason for the meet and greet.
I freaking loved Sloane with her fierce attitude but yet has a sweet side. Sly is completely captivated by her and can see past the mask she puts up for the public but he knows he has to prove to her that he isn't out to play her. The dates he takes her on, the gifts and their text messages were SO freaking adorable. Love how vulnerable they were able to get with one another eventually, it was such a captivating and great read.
Thank you Entangled Publishing for sending me a physical ARC
Sloane "Black Widow" a pop star with a bad rep (two of her ex's have ended up dead) does a meet and greet after one of her shows. There she meets America's golden boy and NFL star Sly and his abuela Ximena. Abuela Ximena runs one of the Black Widow fan accounts and absolutely loves her, it did seem that abuela had an underlying reason for the meet and greet.
I freaking loved Sloane with her fierce attitude but yet has a sweet side. Sly is completely captivated by her and can see past the mask she puts up for the public but he knows he has to prove to her that he isn't out to play her. The dates he takes her on, the gifts and their text messages were SO freaking adorable. Love how vulnerable they were able to get with one another eventually, it was such a captivating and great read.
Thank you Entangled Publishing for sending me a physical ARC
Displaying 1 - 30 of 185 reviews