What do you think?
Rate this book
Chicago World's Fair Mystery #2
Deception on Sable Hill
The World’s Fair is nearing its end, but the danger in Chicago lingers.
It's mid-September of 1893 and Eloisa Carstairs is the reigning beauty of Gilded Age Chicago society. To outsiders she appears to have it all. But Eloisa is living with a dark secret. Several months ago, she endured a horrible assault at the hands of Douglass Sloane, heir to one of Chicago's wealthiest families. Fearing the loss of her reputation, Eloisa confided in only one friend. That is, until she meets Detective Sean Ryan at a high-society ball.
Sean is on the outskirts of the wealthy Chicago lifestyle. Born into a poor Irish family, becoming a policeman was his best opportunity to ensure his future security. Despite society's restrictions, he is enamored with Eloisa Carstairs. Sean seethes inside at what he knows happened to her, and he will do anything to keep her safe-even if he can never earn her affections.
It's mid-September of 1893 and Eloisa Carstairs is the reigning beauty of Gilded Age Chicago society. To outsiders she appears to have it all. But Eloisa is living with a dark secret. Several months ago, she endured a horrible assault at the hands of Douglass Sloane, heir to one of Chicago's wealthiest families. Fearing the loss of her reputation, Eloisa confided in only one friend. That is, until she meets Detective Sean Ryan at a high-society ball.
Sean is on the outskirts of the wealthy Chicago lifestyle. Born into a poor Irish family, becoming a policeman was his best opportunity to ensure his future security. Despite society's restrictions, he is enamored with Eloisa Carstairs. Sean seethes inside at what he knows happened to her, and he will do anything to keep her safe-even if he can never earn her affections.
325 pages, Paperback
First published April 7, 2015
48 people are currently reading
1268 people want to read
About the author
Shelley Gray
13 books279 followersalso publishes under the name Shelley Shepard Gray (Amish fiction, Christian fiction).
I live in southern Ohio with my husband, two teenagers, and two dogs. My days are filled with busy activities like most any other mom and housewife. But I also love to write books.
Each morning, after my kids go off to school, I sit at my desk, look out my window, and dream of other places. The hours fly by as I make up people and places and drink way too much coffee.
Writing for Avon Inspire has truly been a dream come true. Being able to spend my days in my make-believe world of the Brenneman Bed and Breakfast is a true blessing. I have enjoyed getting to know more about the Amish culture and tapping into my faith as I show each character’s progression toward a personal relationship with our Lord.
Before becoming a full time writer, I taught elementary school in Texas, Arizona, and Colorado. A job transfer to Ohio led my husband to encourage me to finally give writing a try. After all, I had notebooks full of made up stories.
I’ll never forget that first book I typed in our unfinished basement. It was exciting to make up a story, but also very scary. I was also so embarrassed, sure someone would come out of the woodwork and point out that I wasn’t a ‘real’ writer. But I persevered, and sold my third manuscript.
Things have changed a bit. Now I have a real office of my own. (think old guest bedroom!) My walls are painted pink, and more than a couple of book covers decorate my walls. But my days are still the same. I wake up, dream about other people, and do my best to type out stories.
I live in southern Ohio with my husband, two teenagers, and two dogs. My days are filled with busy activities like most any other mom and housewife. But I also love to write books.
Each morning, after my kids go off to school, I sit at my desk, look out my window, and dream of other places. The hours fly by as I make up people and places and drink way too much coffee.
Writing for Avon Inspire has truly been a dream come true. Being able to spend my days in my make-believe world of the Brenneman Bed and Breakfast is a true blessing. I have enjoyed getting to know more about the Amish culture and tapping into my faith as I show each character’s progression toward a personal relationship with our Lord.
Before becoming a full time writer, I taught elementary school in Texas, Arizona, and Colorado. A job transfer to Ohio led my husband to encourage me to finally give writing a try. After all, I had notebooks full of made up stories.
I’ll never forget that first book I typed in our unfinished basement. It was exciting to make up a story, but also very scary. I was also so embarrassed, sure someone would come out of the woodwork and point out that I wasn’t a ‘real’ writer. But I persevered, and sold my third manuscript.
Things have changed a bit. Now I have a real office of my own. (think old guest bedroom!) My walls are painted pink, and more than a couple of book covers decorate my walls. But my days are still the same. I wake up, dream about other people, and do my best to type out stories.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 184 reviews
August 12, 2015
It took me a bit to get my mind wrapped around this story... Give me a break, though, it's been a year and over 100 books since I read Secrets of Sloane House! And I also did not read the book blurb before diving in. I'm sure that would have helped. Lol! ;)
Anyway, once I did get into the story (which didn't really take that long), I loved it! I loved the characters and the setting and the mystery... I was drawn into the story and could barely make myself put the book down. And I didn't figure out who the culprit was until right before it was revealed to all. Boy, do I like that kind of story!! The suspense... Wow. Very well done, I thought. And there was a very satisfying ending too, I might add.
I cannot wait for book three!
Note: There are some sexual topics so I would recommend this book for more mature readers.
Anyway, once I did get into the story (which didn't really take that long), I loved it! I loved the characters and the setting and the mystery... I was drawn into the story and could barely make myself put the book down. And I didn't figure out who the culprit was until right before it was revealed to all. Boy, do I like that kind of story!! The suspense... Wow. Very well done, I thought. And there was a very satisfying ending too, I might add.
I cannot wait for book three!
Note: There are some sexual topics so I would recommend this book for more mature readers.
January 25, 2016
Deception on Sable Hill is the second book of the Chicago World's Fair Mystery Series.
I enjoyed this one even more than the first of the series (Secrets of Sloane House). Deception on Sable Hill is mainly about Eloisa, Chicago's darling that was hurt in the first book of the series. While her love story with Sean bloomed beautifully, I would have enjoyed reading a bit more about her growth in her spiritual journey. A secondary story in the novel was regarding Katie, Sean's sister and Owen, Sean's police officer partner.
As for the mystery piece, I didn't realize who the villain was until the very end.
I look forward to reading the conclusion of this series.
I enjoyed this one even more than the first of the series (Secrets of Sloane House). Deception on Sable Hill is mainly about Eloisa, Chicago's darling that was hurt in the first book of the series. While her love story with Sean bloomed beautifully, I would have enjoyed reading a bit more about her growth in her spiritual journey. A secondary story in the novel was regarding Katie, Sean's sister and Owen, Sean's police officer partner.
As for the mystery piece, I didn't realize who the villain was until the very end.
I look forward to reading the conclusion of this series.
January 13, 2015
Find this and other reviews at: http://flashlightcommentary.blogspot....
My experience with Shelley Gray's Deception on Sable Hill can be summed up in the single word: snoozefest. I know that is blunt and I'm dreadfully sorry, but I'm not known for beating round the bush and I don't intend to start now. I call it like I see it and the second installment of the Chicago World's Fair Mystery series had me sawing logs.
First things first, if you haven't read book one, stop reading this instant and direct your attention to Secrets of Sloane House. I haven't read it, but having jumped into the series at book two I can honestly say that a) I was well aware I'd missed something and b) I was disappointed with how many details of that something were spelled out in the early chapters of the follow-up. If you take nothing else from my comments, please do yourself a favor and tackle these novels as written.
Now I know you're getting a little red in the face thinking I'm unreasonable for giving a two star rating over such a minor frustration and I don't blame you. I'd be thinking the same thing if I were in your shoes, but let me quash your argument here and now because I'm just getting started. My next point of note, Gray's pacing. Deception on Sable Hill is slow. Glacially so. The tension depends on class conflict over societal rules and expectations which might have been nice if I hadn't seen it in a million other novels. This is trite, clichéd, and prosaic situational drama.
Hold on minute, what about the star-crossed romance between Sean Ryan and Eloisa Carstairs? Forget it, instalove from the beginning. The Society Slasher? Largely absent, and when all is revealed, highly predictable both in motive and identity. The World's Fair? Historically Gray incorporates some interesting details into Deception on Sable Hill, but the setting isn't a central part of the telling. I felt characters flat and marked a distinct lack of cohesion between the various elements of the story. Nothing clashed, but the various story lines didn't complement each other as much as I'd hoped.
At the end of the day Deception on Sable Hill wasn't my cup of tea. I anticipated most of the plot twists and didn't care for the cast. Stylistically, the novel was too light for my particular tastes and I was overwhelmingly dissatisfied with the lack of creativity I noted in the underlying themes of Sean and Eloisa's story.
My experience with Shelley Gray's Deception on Sable Hill can be summed up in the single word: snoozefest. I know that is blunt and I'm dreadfully sorry, but I'm not known for beating round the bush and I don't intend to start now. I call it like I see it and the second installment of the Chicago World's Fair Mystery series had me sawing logs.
First things first, if you haven't read book one, stop reading this instant and direct your attention to Secrets of Sloane House. I haven't read it, but having jumped into the series at book two I can honestly say that a) I was well aware I'd missed something and b) I was disappointed with how many details of that something were spelled out in the early chapters of the follow-up. If you take nothing else from my comments, please do yourself a favor and tackle these novels as written.
Now I know you're getting a little red in the face thinking I'm unreasonable for giving a two star rating over such a minor frustration and I don't blame you. I'd be thinking the same thing if I were in your shoes, but let me quash your argument here and now because I'm just getting started. My next point of note, Gray's pacing. Deception on Sable Hill is slow. Glacially so. The tension depends on class conflict over societal rules and expectations which might have been nice if I hadn't seen it in a million other novels. This is trite, clichéd, and prosaic situational drama.
Hold on minute, what about the star-crossed romance between Sean Ryan and Eloisa Carstairs? Forget it, instalove from the beginning. The Society Slasher? Largely absent, and when all is revealed, highly predictable both in motive and identity. The World's Fair? Historically Gray incorporates some interesting details into Deception on Sable Hill, but the setting isn't a central part of the telling. I felt characters flat and marked a distinct lack of cohesion between the various elements of the story. Nothing clashed, but the various story lines didn't complement each other as much as I'd hoped.
At the end of the day Deception on Sable Hill wasn't my cup of tea. I anticipated most of the plot twists and didn't care for the cast. Stylistically, the novel was too light for my particular tastes and I was overwhelmingly dissatisfied with the lack of creativity I noted in the underlying themes of Sean and Eloisa's story.
May 11, 2020
For a novel with “mystery” in the series title, I was expecting a bit more mystery than appears on the back cover copy. Basically that’s it—women getting slashed, by a guy who seems to know society people intimately but who hates them. No clues to put together. No explanation of motive, no mention of how the culprit would know these women so intimately. The number of victims even seemed to change depending on who was mentioning it. No detail as to how a stranger could enter, slash/kill, and vanish so skillfully without a soul seeing them. Zero explanation about how a policeman could be close enough once to get stabbed but not see or hear anything.
All the page space was mostly about two romances.
Hope House was brought up as a potential plot point and dropped without explanation when a mishap occurs on the way there (like a side note on how to get a character in a particular place, perhaps?)
A doctor views a victim and talks about the extreme loss of blood but then says “oh, she’ll live” very confidently and sends her on a carriage ride before bothering to stitch up her wounds. If she was that critical, she wouldn’t survive without being stitched up before being bounced in a conveyance; and he seems to have forgotten infection when speaking so confidently. Infection killed at least twice as many folks back then as injuries did.
It’s published by Zondervan, a famous Christian house, but speaks a generic “faith in God or lack thereof” in just a couple of spots; no mention of Jesus as the reason for faith. Two outright profanities and one mention of a certain neighborhood being “Godforsaken.” Patent lie, but the supposed-believer seems to think it true because of the crime and poverty rate. Overall disappointing.
All the page space was mostly about two romances.
Hope House was brought up as a potential plot point and dropped without explanation when a mishap occurs on the way there (like a side note on how to get a character in a particular place, perhaps?)
A doctor views a victim and talks about the extreme loss of blood but then says “oh, she’ll live” very confidently and sends her on a carriage ride before bothering to stitch up her wounds. If she was that critical, she wouldn’t survive without being stitched up before being bounced in a conveyance; and he seems to have forgotten infection when speaking so confidently. Infection killed at least twice as many folks back then as injuries did.
It’s published by Zondervan, a famous Christian house, but speaks a generic “faith in God or lack thereof” in just a couple of spots; no mention of Jesus as the reason for faith. Two outright profanities and one mention of a certain neighborhood being “Godforsaken.” Patent lie, but the supposed-believer seems to think it true because of the crime and poverty rate. Overall disappointing.
April 15, 2015
This is a lighter mystery with undercurrents of a much darker subject. While the "Slasher" of Chicago, during the time around the World's Fair, preys on society ladies, so recently abused heiress Eloisa fights with a life meted out for her--- of lavish parties and eligible gentlemen--even as she believes that she has been soiled for it by the sinister deed of Douglass Sloane. Her interactions with Sean Ryan of the police department and his investigations into the identity of the Slasher introduce her to a world heretofore barred from her. Their developing relationship--including Eloisa's visits to his sister's work for women fallen on hard times--- is the heart and soul of the story.
This is a mystery, yes, but a light one. Instead it is a carefully wrought music on class construction and the layers of society. We have all read enough cross-the-tracks love stories to keep us going for years; but this one particularly stood out because its development is so intricately woven and so beautifully realized.
This is a mystery, yes, but a light one. Instead it is a carefully wrought music on class construction and the layers of society. We have all read enough cross-the-tracks love stories to keep us going for years; but this one particularly stood out because its development is so intricately woven and so beautifully realized.
March 13, 2016
I only THOUGHT I was riveted by Secrets of Sloane House. And then I read Deception on Sable Hill. Could not put it down! I was delighted to spend more time with Eloisa - I frankly needed to know she was okay after what happened to her in book 1. Well, I am happy to report that Sean and his family (especially Katie!) and even Owen Howard were the perfect addition to Eloisa's world - even if society begged to disagree. In fact, the portrait painted here of the vast division of the classes is even more vivid than in Secrets. Sean and Eloisa have a lot to overcome if they are to continue being friends - not the least of which is the Society Slasher who is wreaking terror in the hearts of debutantes throughout the Windy City. What we have in common, though, should draw us together more tightly than whatever divides us, and one kiss in particular preached this sermon quite well!
(I received a copy of this book in exchange for only my honest review.)
(I received a copy of this book in exchange for only my honest review.)
April 6, 2015
The much anticipated second book in a Chicago World's Fair Mystery.
Mystery, intrigue and romance, this book has it all and is just one more example of why I'm a huge fan of Shelley Gray.
The relationship between Eloisa Carstairs and Detective Sean Ryan is multifaceted. There's the attraction, the forbidden aspect of their attraction due to their stations in society and the genuine love between them. This story has subplots that are equally as interesting and very well written.
Ms. Gray has an amazing talent for creating characters that you genuinely care about.
In this book, she's at her finest with the dialog between the characters, the vivid descriptions of their surroundings and as always she keeps the reader interested from beginning to end and leaves you wanting more.
Mystery, intrigue and romance, this book has it all and is just one more example of why I'm a huge fan of Shelley Gray.
The relationship between Eloisa Carstairs and Detective Sean Ryan is multifaceted. There's the attraction, the forbidden aspect of their attraction due to their stations in society and the genuine love between them. This story has subplots that are equally as interesting and very well written.
Ms. Gray has an amazing talent for creating characters that you genuinely care about.
In this book, she's at her finest with the dialog between the characters, the vivid descriptions of their surroundings and as always she keeps the reader interested from beginning to end and leaves you wanting more.
November 5, 2015
Riveting! This book was a breathtaking ride through Gilded Age America, as the world turned its eye on Chicago and its World's Fair. The author did a splendid job at keeping me guessing the entire way, so that each time I felt I had figured things out something happened to make me second guess! Absolutely stunning!
May 15, 2016
SUMMARY: The World’s Fair has introduced many new ideas to Chicago society—but can two individuals from very different backgrounds find love together?
It’s mid-September 1893 and Eloisa Carstairs is the reigning debutant of Gilded Age Chicago society. To outsiders she appears to have it all. But Eloisa is living with a dark secret. Several months ago, she endured a horrible assault at the hands of Douglass Sloane, heir to one of Chicago’s wealthiest families. Fearing the loss of her reputation, Eloisa confided in only one friend. That is, until she meets Detective Sean Ryan at a high-society ball.
Sean is on the fringes of the Chicago elite. Born into a poor Irish family, becoming a policeman was his best chance to ensure security. Despite social boundaries, he is enamored with Eloisa Carstairs. Sean will do anything to keep her safe—even if he can never earn her affections.
Eloisa longs to feel normal again, but a killer is on the loose. In the last month, three debutants have been accosted by an assailant wielding a knife, and Eloisa fears for her safety at every event she attends. As the danger in the city increases, and as the romance between Eloisa and Sean blossoms, they both realize they want to be seen as more than how the world views them. But will they catch the killer before all their hopes come crashing down?
REVIEW: I really enjoyed the first book in Gray's Chicago World's Fair Mystery series, but this one was even better. I loved the focus on Eloisa after what had happened to her in the first book. The story was filled with romance, suspense and great characters. Several times I thought I had figured out who the Society Slasher was, but it was only at the last moment that I began to realize who it was.
Eloisa's change from her withdrawn, defeated self into a bold, courageous woman was slowly developed throughout the storyline. The relationships the grew and helped her heal between her and Juliet, her maid, Sean's sisters, Maeve and Katie, with Sean's police partner, and with Sean were all complex and sweet. It was nice to see her confidence develop and to move beyond the tragic things that had effected her.
Sean was a favorite character of mine. I loved his ability to move beyond his circumstances and his striving to better himself educationally and career wise. His caring and compassion for Eloisa and her understanding of her feelings made him so lovable. Yet at the same time, he displayed his insecurity in regards to their differences in social status. His care and concern for his siblings and mother even though they disagreed about his attitude towards life.
Gray dealt with several issues that would have been front and center during this time period. First the disparity and non-mixing of classes both due to social status and ethnic background. Second the strong focus by upper class parents to insist on an advantageous marriage connection for their daughter whether love and compatibility between the couple existed or not. Third, the difficulties for two people in love when they came from different social classes. Finally, the varying attitudes of those in the lower classes: those who were willing to settle for what they were and what they had always been versus those who wanted to work and better themselves.
Overall, a great read. I would recommend this book to anyone who likes historical, romantic suspense.
FAVORITE QUOTES: "My father likes to say she's never met an ailment she hasn't wished to adopt."
"Everyone no matter their background or circumstances, like and hoped to deserve nice things."
"But someone told me that it is better to experience life than to merely to live on its sidelines."
"Deception can be so very dark. So much so, it's often a struggle to enjoy the light of bare truth. So I've been hiding in the dark."
It’s mid-September 1893 and Eloisa Carstairs is the reigning debutant of Gilded Age Chicago society. To outsiders she appears to have it all. But Eloisa is living with a dark secret. Several months ago, she endured a horrible assault at the hands of Douglass Sloane, heir to one of Chicago’s wealthiest families. Fearing the loss of her reputation, Eloisa confided in only one friend. That is, until she meets Detective Sean Ryan at a high-society ball.
Sean is on the fringes of the Chicago elite. Born into a poor Irish family, becoming a policeman was his best chance to ensure security. Despite social boundaries, he is enamored with Eloisa Carstairs. Sean will do anything to keep her safe—even if he can never earn her affections.
Eloisa longs to feel normal again, but a killer is on the loose. In the last month, three debutants have been accosted by an assailant wielding a knife, and Eloisa fears for her safety at every event she attends. As the danger in the city increases, and as the romance between Eloisa and Sean blossoms, they both realize they want to be seen as more than how the world views them. But will they catch the killer before all their hopes come crashing down?
REVIEW: I really enjoyed the first book in Gray's Chicago World's Fair Mystery series, but this one was even better. I loved the focus on Eloisa after what had happened to her in the first book. The story was filled with romance, suspense and great characters. Several times I thought I had figured out who the Society Slasher was, but it was only at the last moment that I began to realize who it was.
Eloisa's change from her withdrawn, defeated self into a bold, courageous woman was slowly developed throughout the storyline. The relationships the grew and helped her heal between her and Juliet, her maid, Sean's sisters, Maeve and Katie, with Sean's police partner, and with Sean were all complex and sweet. It was nice to see her confidence develop and to move beyond the tragic things that had effected her.
Sean was a favorite character of mine. I loved his ability to move beyond his circumstances and his striving to better himself educationally and career wise. His caring and compassion for Eloisa and her understanding of her feelings made him so lovable. Yet at the same time, he displayed his insecurity in regards to their differences in social status. His care and concern for his siblings and mother even though they disagreed about his attitude towards life.
Gray dealt with several issues that would have been front and center during this time period. First the disparity and non-mixing of classes both due to social status and ethnic background. Second the strong focus by upper class parents to insist on an advantageous marriage connection for their daughter whether love and compatibility between the couple existed or not. Third, the difficulties for two people in love when they came from different social classes. Finally, the varying attitudes of those in the lower classes: those who were willing to settle for what they were and what they had always been versus those who wanted to work and better themselves.
Overall, a great read. I would recommend this book to anyone who likes historical, romantic suspense.
FAVORITE QUOTES: "My father likes to say she's never met an ailment she hasn't wished to adopt."
"Everyone no matter their background or circumstances, like and hoped to deserve nice things."
"But someone told me that it is better to experience life than to merely to live on its sidelines."
"Deception can be so very dark. So much so, it's often a struggle to enjoy the light of bare truth. So I've been hiding in the dark."
November 11, 2015
Deception On Sable Hill by Shelley Gray is the second book in the Chicago World's Fair Mystery series. It was completely gripping from start to finish. Although part of a series, it can be read as a stand-alone. However for full enjoyment, read book one first.
Eloisa was first introduced in the previous novel, The Secrets of Sloane House, but she is the focus of this novel. Eloisa belongs to one of the richest families in Chicago. She is a popular debutante, but over the past few months has become more reclusive. A previous event is haunting her waking and sleeping moments. Shelley Gray depicts Eloisa as hiding from her past. She has no one to confide in. She needs a friend, and she needs God, in order to move forwards.
Sean Ryan is from a poor Irish family, and he has worked his way up through the ranks of the police. He and fellow officer Owen Howard are searching for the Society Slasher, a villain who slashes society ladies faces. Shelley Gray keeps the reader guessing as the number of victims begins to pile up. The Chicago streets become increasingly dangerous. Eloisa and Sean's paths cross, and inspite of their class differences, they feel a connection.
Shelley Gray explores the themes of class and equality. There are those who wish to keep the upper class to themselves. There are those in the lower class who believe the boundaries' cannot be crossed. However there are characters who look beyond the outward appearance and see the person within. Eloisa is one such character. With her, conventional boundaries are blurred, and consequently she has a lovely relationship with her maid.
The injustices of the time are highlighted in the novel, as the reader is introduced to Hope House. This is a refuge for women and children. Even officer Sean is not allowed inside its doors. There is a beautiful and touching scene described with six year old orphan Greta.
Within the novel romances begin to bubble. Attractions are fought. Will love win through?
The family theme is shown in Deception On Sable Hill. There are many different types of families. Eloisa's are rich, they love her but their goal is to see her marry well. Sean's is a large, welcoming, hospitable Irish family. There is also the Hope House family, bonded together by circumstance. As well as the wider family of God.
The theme of forgiveness crops up in the novel. Forgiveness needs to be dispensed because without it, one will live a life trapped in bitterness and with one foot firmly planted in the past.
I love all Shelley Gray's novels and Deception On Sable Hill is no exception. There is something for everyone within its pages - history, romance, social comment and thrilling action. I kept trying to guess who the Society Slasher was, and I must admit, I got it wrong (again!) Deception On Sable Hill is a fabulous novel. It is part of a great series, and I cannot wait to read the third and final book Whispers In The Reading Room.
Eloisa was first introduced in the previous novel, The Secrets of Sloane House, but she is the focus of this novel. Eloisa belongs to one of the richest families in Chicago. She is a popular debutante, but over the past few months has become more reclusive. A previous event is haunting her waking and sleeping moments. Shelley Gray depicts Eloisa as hiding from her past. She has no one to confide in. She needs a friend, and she needs God, in order to move forwards.
Sean Ryan is from a poor Irish family, and he has worked his way up through the ranks of the police. He and fellow officer Owen Howard are searching for the Society Slasher, a villain who slashes society ladies faces. Shelley Gray keeps the reader guessing as the number of victims begins to pile up. The Chicago streets become increasingly dangerous. Eloisa and Sean's paths cross, and inspite of their class differences, they feel a connection.
Shelley Gray explores the themes of class and equality. There are those who wish to keep the upper class to themselves. There are those in the lower class who believe the boundaries' cannot be crossed. However there are characters who look beyond the outward appearance and see the person within. Eloisa is one such character. With her, conventional boundaries are blurred, and consequently she has a lovely relationship with her maid.
The injustices of the time are highlighted in the novel, as the reader is introduced to Hope House. This is a refuge for women and children. Even officer Sean is not allowed inside its doors. There is a beautiful and touching scene described with six year old orphan Greta.
Within the novel romances begin to bubble. Attractions are fought. Will love win through?
The family theme is shown in Deception On Sable Hill. There are many different types of families. Eloisa's are rich, they love her but their goal is to see her marry well. Sean's is a large, welcoming, hospitable Irish family. There is also the Hope House family, bonded together by circumstance. As well as the wider family of God.
The theme of forgiveness crops up in the novel. Forgiveness needs to be dispensed because without it, one will live a life trapped in bitterness and with one foot firmly planted in the past.
I love all Shelley Gray's novels and Deception On Sable Hill is no exception. There is something for everyone within its pages - history, romance, social comment and thrilling action. I kept trying to guess who the Society Slasher was, and I must admit, I got it wrong (again!) Deception On Sable Hill is a fabulous novel. It is part of a great series, and I cannot wait to read the third and final book Whispers In The Reading Room.
July 15, 2015
Riveting second book in the A Chicago World's Fair Mystery series. And while this one does start where the first left off (including some carry-over characters and plot) you don't need to have read the first one in order to embrace Deception on Sable Hill. And it's definitely the kind of book you want to hug! :-)
The clash of class distinction in the late 19th century is at the heart of this story. Gray portrays the challenges of change for both the wealthy and the poor in vivid emotional detail. I especially found the contrast of opinion between a lower class man courting an upper class lady in comparison to an upper class gentleman wooing a lower class woman totally fascinating -- and annoying! Definitely adds an extra edge to the overall plot. Not to mention the romance.
I have to 'fess up and admit to adoring a self-made Irish hero and Sean Ryan fits the bill to a T. He's got that confident swagger, a wee bit of blarney dripping off the tip of his tongue and, saints preserve us -- that grin! Mind you, he needs the luck o' the Irish and no small amount of divine intervention to achieve his happily ever after! Of course, Eloisa is smitten. How could she not? But Gray has not been kind to this heroine -- not in the first book of the series and not in this one -- so be prepared to run a gamut of emotions during this read.
There's the bonus of a secondary romance as well. And a dark mystery to solve. All in all an enthralling read. Can't wait for the third in the series to release in November -- Whispers in the Reading Room -- about a librarian!!!! Be still my book-loving heart.
March 28, 2015
Chicago, wealth, prestige, mystery, murder, intrigue, love, friendship, family and good characters sets the stage for this second in a trilogy written and crafted by the talented Shelley Gray.
Eloisa Carstairs is mentioned briefly in the first book called Secrets of Sloane House. In Deception on Sable Hill she is one of the major figures, along with Detective Sean Ryan. Through a chance meeting at a formal party their lives become intertwined as Detective Ryan tries to solve the mystery of the "Society Slasher."
Eloisa has a lot going for her as a member of Chicago's elite society, but she also carries a terrible secret (from the first book). Sean comes from a strong Irish family, and not all of his family appreciate his choice of profession. Even though they come from different financial backgrounds, a friendship develops and a bond of trust is formed.
Do you know when you watch a movie and a sequel is made? Down deep you think how are they going to top the first one? Well, I knew that Deception was going to be good, but this was a wonderful sequel, and well worth the wait!! Even I fell in love with Detective Ryan...or at least the qualities that he has. He is a true gentleman. A man of integrity, a sense of family, loves justice, and yet he is bold enough to step up to the plate and serve the city he loves so much. Despite the fact that in the eyes of society, Eloisa and Sean, have nothing in common they go to prove that love goes deeper than money. They show that love never fails and can overcome any obstactle.
I am going to be disappointed when this series ends, but I love the fact that I will be able to cherish these stories and relive them over and over again. Another home run...thank you Shelley!!
Eloisa Carstairs is mentioned briefly in the first book called Secrets of Sloane House. In Deception on Sable Hill she is one of the major figures, along with Detective Sean Ryan. Through a chance meeting at a formal party their lives become intertwined as Detective Ryan tries to solve the mystery of the "Society Slasher."
Eloisa has a lot going for her as a member of Chicago's elite society, but she also carries a terrible secret (from the first book). Sean comes from a strong Irish family, and not all of his family appreciate his choice of profession. Even though they come from different financial backgrounds, a friendship develops and a bond of trust is formed.
Do you know when you watch a movie and a sequel is made? Down deep you think how are they going to top the first one? Well, I knew that Deception was going to be good, but this was a wonderful sequel, and well worth the wait!! Even I fell in love with Detective Ryan...or at least the qualities that he has. He is a true gentleman. A man of integrity, a sense of family, loves justice, and yet he is bold enough to step up to the plate and serve the city he loves so much. Despite the fact that in the eyes of society, Eloisa and Sean, have nothing in common they go to prove that love goes deeper than money. They show that love never fails and can overcome any obstactle.
I am going to be disappointed when this series ends, but I love the fact that I will be able to cherish these stories and relive them over and over again. Another home run...thank you Shelley!!
July 29, 2016
This is the second book in the Chicago's World Fair series by Shelley Gray. I haven't read the first one and I was glad that I didn't feel like I was missing out on any significant back story. One of the main page genres was Christian Fiction and I didn't understand why other than it was really clean (ie: no bodice ripping from the 2 romances.)
I liked the Chicago setting. That was well done. There was such a nice depiction of place and I always love that when reading historical fiction. But the story was the classic uptown girl meets downtown boy. It was like Billy Joel meets Christie Brinkley. And then the other romance was the uptown boy meets the downtown girl. The romances and the different classes were the main stage of this book. The fact that there was a serial murderer around slaying the young elite women of Chicago was a side story. But overall, I liked it. It was 3 stars.
I liked the Chicago setting. That was well done. There was such a nice depiction of place and I always love that when reading historical fiction. But the story was the classic uptown girl meets downtown boy. It was like Billy Joel meets Christie Brinkley. And then the other romance was the uptown boy meets the downtown girl. The romances and the different classes were the main stage of this book. The fact that there was a serial murderer around slaying the young elite women of Chicago was a side story. But overall, I liked it. It was 3 stars.
April 6, 2015
3.5 out of 5 stars
Received a copy from HarperCollins/BookLooks: This did not influence my opinion/review in any way.
Eloisa Carstairs is one of the reigning beauties of the high Chicago society, but she has a secret. A couple months ago, she was assaulted by Douglass Sloane, heir to one of Chicago's most influential families. He might have died in an accident, but she has not shaken her fear of being in an enclosed space with a single man. Detective Sean Ryan has been hired to keep a watch out for the Society Slasher who has been murdering high debutants. He befriends Eloisa, unable to resist her ethereal beauty despite the fact that they are of two complete different social ladders and their relationship can be nothing more than a friendship. When the Slasher starts to hit closer to Eloisa, Sean has to make sure that he protects the woman who's captured his heart, even if he can't even capture hers.
I don't know if you could tell from the summary above, but this book is pretty focused on romance. If you go into this novel thinking you're going to get a chill-creeping murder thriller, you'll be disappointed because the murders, while important, take a back seat when compared to the romance aspect of the story. I found this out from another review on Goodreads and it made all the difference to me when I was reading this book. With that being said, the romance of this novel specifically addresses the issue of overcoming the social barriers and not being confined to society's expectations. Detective Ryan is from a poor Irish family, but with his position in the police force, he's already moved up the ladder a bit, but not enough to enter the elite. The relationship between him and Eloisa is so adorable with him trying to figure out how to treat a lady and she is trying to convince him that he doesn't need to be someone he's not.
That brings me to the topic of Eloisa Carstairs. I can't say much about her other than she's kind of your typical elite girl. She's suffered rape from someone of the same circle which has made her extremely distrustful of others. To be honest, she's kind of flat, but she does have a good heart when she volunteers to help the children and women at the Hope House. Her feelings toward Sean are kind of "insta" but not in the love way. It's more in the fact that he makes her feel safe and protected while the gentlemen she usually hangs with don't.
Sean is definitely more dimensional than Eloisa. As he's from the lower class, he struggles with fitting in with the elites as well as with his childhood neighborhood, some who believe that he joined the police force to leave behind his lowly past. He's really dedicated to his job and it's really cute to see how fluttery he gets when he's around Eloisa sometimes. His sisters were also really interesting characters, particularly his younger sister Katie. She's definitely a fireball but has her fears about breaching society. However, that doesn't stop her from dreaming about some possible relationship with a certain person who is technically a couple classes higher than her.
The final reveal of the who the Society Slasher was kind of disappointing. I didn't do the research to see if the Slasher was a real person, but as a character, he wasn't as twisted and messed up as I had kind of hoped he would be. Over the summer I read Devil in the White City which focused on the serial killer HH Holmes. Now that man is messed up. The Slasher attacked his victims because they didn't give him enough attention. To me that's just bratty bordering on creepy.
Overall, it was an enjoyable read and I'm definitely curious to check out the first book. I believe the third book comes out sometime in the fall of this year which is exciting. Oh, one last thing: the covers! I love the designs of the covers with the subtle silhouette of the woman, lace detailing on the top, and the overlay of photographs from the World Far. Just thought I'd point that out. :)
Read my reviews at:
https://extreemeobsessed.blogspot.com
Received a copy from HarperCollins/BookLooks: This did not influence my opinion/review in any way.
Eloisa Carstairs is one of the reigning beauties of the high Chicago society, but she has a secret. A couple months ago, she was assaulted by Douglass Sloane, heir to one of Chicago's most influential families. He might have died in an accident, but she has not shaken her fear of being in an enclosed space with a single man. Detective Sean Ryan has been hired to keep a watch out for the Society Slasher who has been murdering high debutants. He befriends Eloisa, unable to resist her ethereal beauty despite the fact that they are of two complete different social ladders and their relationship can be nothing more than a friendship. When the Slasher starts to hit closer to Eloisa, Sean has to make sure that he protects the woman who's captured his heart, even if he can't even capture hers.
I don't know if you could tell from the summary above, but this book is pretty focused on romance. If you go into this novel thinking you're going to get a chill-creeping murder thriller, you'll be disappointed because the murders, while important, take a back seat when compared to the romance aspect of the story. I found this out from another review on Goodreads and it made all the difference to me when I was reading this book. With that being said, the romance of this novel specifically addresses the issue of overcoming the social barriers and not being confined to society's expectations. Detective Ryan is from a poor Irish family, but with his position in the police force, he's already moved up the ladder a bit, but not enough to enter the elite. The relationship between him and Eloisa is so adorable with him trying to figure out how to treat a lady and she is trying to convince him that he doesn't need to be someone he's not.
That brings me to the topic of Eloisa Carstairs. I can't say much about her other than she's kind of your typical elite girl. She's suffered rape from someone of the same circle which has made her extremely distrustful of others. To be honest, she's kind of flat, but she does have a good heart when she volunteers to help the children and women at the Hope House. Her feelings toward Sean are kind of "insta" but not in the love way. It's more in the fact that he makes her feel safe and protected while the gentlemen she usually hangs with don't.
Sean is definitely more dimensional than Eloisa. As he's from the lower class, he struggles with fitting in with the elites as well as with his childhood neighborhood, some who believe that he joined the police force to leave behind his lowly past. He's really dedicated to his job and it's really cute to see how fluttery he gets when he's around Eloisa sometimes. His sisters were also really interesting characters, particularly his younger sister Katie. She's definitely a fireball but has her fears about breaching society. However, that doesn't stop her from dreaming about some possible relationship with a certain person who is technically a couple classes higher than her.
The final reveal of the who the Society Slasher was kind of disappointing. I didn't do the research to see if the Slasher was a real person, but as a character, he wasn't as twisted and messed up as I had kind of hoped he would be. Over the summer I read Devil in the White City which focused on the serial killer HH Holmes. Now that man is messed up. The Slasher attacked his victims because they didn't give him enough attention. To me that's just bratty bordering on creepy.
Overall, it was an enjoyable read and I'm definitely curious to check out the first book. I believe the third book comes out sometime in the fall of this year which is exciting. Oh, one last thing: the covers! I love the designs of the covers with the subtle silhouette of the woman, lace detailing on the top, and the overlay of photographs from the World Far. Just thought I'd point that out. :)
Read my reviews at:
https://extreemeobsessed.blogspot.com
July 1, 2015
I really enjoyed this mysterious and suspenseful story! The author did a great job of crafting a tale that kept me guessing till the very end. Deception on Sable Hill is book two in the Chicago World’s Fair Mystery series. It can definitely stand alone, however, Eloisa Carstairs is the heroine in this novel and is first introduced in book one, Secrets of Sloane House. I would recommend book one because it makes Eloisa’s tale in book two even more meaningful.
The cover is very eye catching and adds to the mystery of the story. My husband even commented on what an interesting cover this book has. I definitely agree with him. The story inside is even more interesting. A distinct class system existed back in 1893 Chicago. The way upper crust society viewed the lower classes and vice versa was an integral part of this book. I enjoyed seeing the hero, Detective Sean Ryan, as he had to navigate through that society. It was also interesting to watch as Detective Owen Howard, a man born into society, lived his life as a police officer.
There is a central romance and a side romance to follow throughout the book. I really enjoyed watching the development of both of these relationships. Both of them added so much to the story. The mystery and constant threat of danger in The Deception on Sable Hill kept me intrigued from cover to cover. I definitely recommend this to fans of mystery and suspense.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from BookLook Bloggers in exchange for an honest review.
You can read this review on my blog at:
https://brittreadsfiction.wordpress.c...
The cover is very eye catching and adds to the mystery of the story. My husband even commented on what an interesting cover this book has. I definitely agree with him. The story inside is even more interesting. A distinct class system existed back in 1893 Chicago. The way upper crust society viewed the lower classes and vice versa was an integral part of this book. I enjoyed seeing the hero, Detective Sean Ryan, as he had to navigate through that society. It was also interesting to watch as Detective Owen Howard, a man born into society, lived his life as a police officer.
There is a central romance and a side romance to follow throughout the book. I really enjoyed watching the development of both of these relationships. Both of them added so much to the story. The mystery and constant threat of danger in The Deception on Sable Hill kept me intrigued from cover to cover. I definitely recommend this to fans of mystery and suspense.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from BookLook Bloggers in exchange for an honest review.
You can read this review on my blog at:
https://brittreadsfiction.wordpress.c...
April 17, 2015
This review is also posted on Book by Book.
The follow-up to Secrets of Sloane House in Shelley Gray’s Chicago World’s Fair Mystery, Deception on Sable Hill offers another intriguing historical mystery and romance. Once again, I loved the exquisite backdrop of the 1897 World’s Fair in Chicago Gray utilizes, as well as the characters she places within it. Eloisa Carstairs and Sean Ryan take the focus of this novel, as they seem to continually cross one another’s path, despite their class differences, in the pursuit of the fearsome Society Slasher. The closer they draw to the surprising culprit, the deeper their relationship naturally becomes and the more vulnerable each must be with their fears and past. An overall entertaining and satisfying read, this well-rounded story has a little bit of everything to give its readers, alternating easily between sweet and suspenseful moments. I really enjoyed reading Deception of Sable Hill and I would certainly recommend it to fans of historical fiction.
Thanks to BookLook Bloggers, I received a copy of Deception on Sable Hill and the opportunity to honestly review it. I was not required to write a positive review, and all the opinions I have expressed are my own. (I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255: “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”)
The follow-up to Secrets of Sloane House in Shelley Gray’s Chicago World’s Fair Mystery, Deception on Sable Hill offers another intriguing historical mystery and romance. Once again, I loved the exquisite backdrop of the 1897 World’s Fair in Chicago Gray utilizes, as well as the characters she places within it. Eloisa Carstairs and Sean Ryan take the focus of this novel, as they seem to continually cross one another’s path, despite their class differences, in the pursuit of the fearsome Society Slasher. The closer they draw to the surprising culprit, the deeper their relationship naturally becomes and the more vulnerable each must be with their fears and past. An overall entertaining and satisfying read, this well-rounded story has a little bit of everything to give its readers, alternating easily between sweet and suspenseful moments. I really enjoyed reading Deception of Sable Hill and I would certainly recommend it to fans of historical fiction.
Thanks to BookLook Bloggers, I received a copy of Deception on Sable Hill and the opportunity to honestly review it. I was not required to write a positive review, and all the opinions I have expressed are my own. (I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255: “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”)
January 5, 2015
I have so enjoyed experiencing the Chicago’s World Fair, back in 1893, and getting to know the layout and the buildings. With this story the Fair is getting ready to close, and we attend a fabulous gala with quite a send off.
We have a clash of social status here, and this book does carry on from where we left off in The Secrets of Slone House, which I recommend you read, but is not necessary to know what is happening here. This book is Eloisa Carstairs story, and there is a refresher as to what horrible thing happened to her in the previous book. She has confided in one person and that is Police Detective Sean Ryan, and this is where we go from upper to lower classes.
Where Eloisa has had her every whim taken care of her whole life, born with a silver spoon, and richer than most of her friends, a privileged life. On the other hand Detective Ryan, was born in a very poor Irish family and lived in the other side of town.
Will it be possible to break down barriers and social status for these two to have a relationship? Also there is danger surrounding both of these people, one because she is a debutant and the other because of his job. You will think you know who is the culprit, but I changed my mind a few times.
Come along and enjoy the mystery and intrigue that happen during the fleeting moments of this historical event, and walk in the shoes of these characters, I for one hate these stories to end.
I received this book through Net Galley and the Publisher Zondervan, and was not required to give a positive review.
We have a clash of social status here, and this book does carry on from where we left off in The Secrets of Slone House, which I recommend you read, but is not necessary to know what is happening here. This book is Eloisa Carstairs story, and there is a refresher as to what horrible thing happened to her in the previous book. She has confided in one person and that is Police Detective Sean Ryan, and this is where we go from upper to lower classes.
Where Eloisa has had her every whim taken care of her whole life, born with a silver spoon, and richer than most of her friends, a privileged life. On the other hand Detective Ryan, was born in a very poor Irish family and lived in the other side of town.
Will it be possible to break down barriers and social status for these two to have a relationship? Also there is danger surrounding both of these people, one because she is a debutant and the other because of his job. You will think you know who is the culprit, but I changed my mind a few times.
Come along and enjoy the mystery and intrigue that happen during the fleeting moments of this historical event, and walk in the shoes of these characters, I for one hate these stories to end.
I received this book through Net Galley and the Publisher Zondervan, and was not required to give a positive review.
March 22, 2015
"Deception on Sable Hill" is the second of the Chicago World's Fair mysteries. Taking place in 1893, it highlights some of the changes brought about in Chicago by the influx of people who arrived in droves to view the spectacle that was the World's Fair.
The time period is also significant as it seemed to whisper that the highly regimented social classes may have been coming unraveled. Children who had been brought up in the stricter times of their parents were questioning some of the restrictive rules of the upper classes. And people who had been from solidly middle to lower working class were yearning for more opportunities for themselves and their children.
Shelley Gray does such a wonderful job weaving her story around the time period. Her characters are believable. I appreciated the friendship she created between Sean Ryan, a lower middle-class Irish cop and an upper class Owen Howard. It's interesting right from the beginning, as Ryan is Howard's superior. The men share another bond in that neither of their families is exactly pleased that being a policeman is their desired profession.
I enjoyed the story. It's a "clean read" with reality, romance, and suspense woven in. I look forward to the next installment of this series.
March 19, 2017
I received this book for free from GoodReads FirstReads in exchange for my honest review.
I am honestly mystified at how this book got so many sterling reviews. The writing was amateurish, the dialog was stiff and unnatural, the scene transitions were awkward, and the characters were as flat and lifeless as paper dolls. Every single plot point was spelled out for the reader in primary-colored block letters. I kept waiting for Elmo to pop up and explain the 'mystery' to me.
In the give-and-take spirit of the FirstReads program, and because the plot had so much potential, I read much more of this book than I normally would a book I'm not enjoying. But I had to give up. Life is too short for boring books.
I am honestly mystified at how this book got so many sterling reviews. The writing was amateurish, the dialog was stiff and unnatural, the scene transitions were awkward, and the characters were as flat and lifeless as paper dolls. Every single plot point was spelled out for the reader in primary-colored block letters. I kept waiting for Elmo to pop up and explain the 'mystery' to me.
In the give-and-take spirit of the FirstReads program, and because the plot had so much potential, I read much more of this book than I normally would a book I'm not enjoying. But I had to give up. Life is too short for boring books.
September 21, 2015
This book begged me to open its pages.
And once I did open its pages, I found myself determined to devour every last word.
I should also mention this book also caused me to hold tightly to my reading chair. But hey, that's what happens when you read a good mystery, right?
For lack of a better description, let me just say this novel is simply amazing! I was caught so off guard by the many, many surprises and shockers that happened throughout the story...
Really, I'm speechless!
I can't wait to forget everything about Deception On Sable Hill so I can read and enjoy it again as if for the first time!
And once I did open its pages, I found myself determined to devour every last word.
I should also mention this book also caused me to hold tightly to my reading chair. But hey, that's what happens when you read a good mystery, right?
For lack of a better description, let me just say this novel is simply amazing! I was caught so off guard by the many, many surprises and shockers that happened throughout the story...
Really, I'm speechless!
I can't wait to forget everything about Deception On Sable Hill so I can read and enjoy it again as if for the first time!
April 15, 2015
)Deception on Sable Hill, By: Shelley Gray, (The Chicago World’s Fair Mystery Series Book 2)
This book drew me in like a moth drawn to a flame! Wow, I couldn’t get enough of it. So be prepared to take an exciting trip through time to Chicago. I felt like I was part of this story, it was so well written! This is a book that will leave you craving more and more all the way through it. I had such a hard time putting this book down! Lots of twists, turns, suspense and mystery that will leave you guessing right up until the very end. Be sure to get your copy of the outstanding book today!
5 stars!
This book drew me in like a moth drawn to a flame! Wow, I couldn’t get enough of it. So be prepared to take an exciting trip through time to Chicago. I felt like I was part of this story, it was so well written! This is a book that will leave you craving more and more all the way through it. I had such a hard time putting this book down! Lots of twists, turns, suspense and mystery that will leave you guessing right up until the very end. Be sure to get your copy of the outstanding book today!
5 stars!
July 25, 2019
I enjoyed the mystery. Ms. Gray kept me guessing all the way to the end. I loved the MCs and enjoyed the plot. Happy reading/listening!
August 21, 2025
Good book, listened to most of it, read it following "Mystery of Sloan House" and it was the same type of story with different characters.
September 9, 2024
In 1893 during the Chicago Worlds Fair, women are being attacked and some murdered by the so called Slasher.
May 8, 2015
I enjoy reading mysteries centered in the late Victorian Era. Even though most of the books I have read and heard of come from Victorian England, not in America. Sherlock Holmes. Jack the Ripper. But when I saw the notice for a mystery series surrounding around the World’s Fair in Chicago during the same time period, my interest was piqued. What was going on American during this time frame? I did not know, but I couldn’t wait to find out by reading this new mystery series by Shelley Gray.
The idea of a Society Slasher going around slashing woman to scar them and then up the dealings to murder later in the book reminded me a lot of Jack the Ripper who killed prostitutes. Deception on Sable Hill occurs five years after Jack the Ripper made his mark on the London community. While the identity of Jack the Ripper was never truly found, the identity of the Society Slasher does come to light at the end of the book. Gray did a good job at keeping the identity of the Slasher hidden. I kept believing the murder was someone. I followed all the clues, but even, I was proven wrong. That is the markings of a good story teller.
The characters make or break the book. Sean Ryan is an enjoyable hero because he wants to improve himself and rise above his humble beginnings. He worked his way up the chain of command in the police force and is respected by many. Eloisa Carstairs, our heroine, feels safe with Sean Ryan around, even so far enough to tell him the dark incident in her past. I enjoyed following Sean through the story, and Eloisa is an admirable heroine because she sees past the social status and views Sean for who he really is. A loving, caring man who will do anything to protect her.
Overall, Shelley Gray, in her second book of the Chicago World’s Fair Mystery Series Deception on Sable Hill does a great job at recreating a Victorian mystery that will keep readers, either historical or mystery lovers, up all night, flipping through the pages hoping to find out who the Society Slasher is.
I received a complimentary copy from Zondervan through Netgalley and the opinions stated are all my own.
The idea of a Society Slasher going around slashing woman to scar them and then up the dealings to murder later in the book reminded me a lot of Jack the Ripper who killed prostitutes. Deception on Sable Hill occurs five years after Jack the Ripper made his mark on the London community. While the identity of Jack the Ripper was never truly found, the identity of the Society Slasher does come to light at the end of the book. Gray did a good job at keeping the identity of the Slasher hidden. I kept believing the murder was someone. I followed all the clues, but even, I was proven wrong. That is the markings of a good story teller.
The characters make or break the book. Sean Ryan is an enjoyable hero because he wants to improve himself and rise above his humble beginnings. He worked his way up the chain of command in the police force and is respected by many. Eloisa Carstairs, our heroine, feels safe with Sean Ryan around, even so far enough to tell him the dark incident in her past. I enjoyed following Sean through the story, and Eloisa is an admirable heroine because she sees past the social status and views Sean for who he really is. A loving, caring man who will do anything to protect her.
Overall, Shelley Gray, in her second book of the Chicago World’s Fair Mystery Series Deception on Sable Hill does a great job at recreating a Victorian mystery that will keep readers, either historical or mystery lovers, up all night, flipping through the pages hoping to find out who the Society Slasher is.
I received a complimentary copy from Zondervan through Netgalley and the opinions stated are all my own.
May 4, 2015
Deception can manifest itself in many ways; the tilt of a chin to hide one's true feelings, pretending to be a protector when in reality there is an intent to destroy, believing in the whisper of inferiority, and reticence to face one's deepest longings to demonstrate love.
Chicago heiress Eloisa Carstairs struggles to feel safe after a societal acquaintance brutally assaulted her; her nightmares continue and she has spoken to no one of her experience; that is, until she meets a handsome Irish police detective on protective detail at a society ball. Sean Ryan and his partner Owen Howard are on the front lines of a frantic search through-out the city of Chicago to locate and apprehend a serial "slasher"; a nefarious criminal who attacks women of society; "marking" them forever with the cruel slash of his knife across their face and neck. When Ryan begins to accompany "Miss Carstairs" on philanthropic trips to Hope House; a residence for young women and children who need refuge, they both discover that love can cross bold societal lines without hesitation. Will Ryan, an unpolished immigrant from a large, basically uneducated, but honorable family, be able to capture the heart of the beautiful Eloisa? Will Eloisa allow her self-image to remain imprisoned within the expectations of her family? Or will it take an horrific event for the truth to set them free?
This second book in Shelley Gray's "The Chicago World's Fair Mystery Series" has a nice cadence, endearing characters and a most satisfying conclusion. Thanks goodness there is one more!
Chicago heiress Eloisa Carstairs struggles to feel safe after a societal acquaintance brutally assaulted her; her nightmares continue and she has spoken to no one of her experience; that is, until she meets a handsome Irish police detective on protective detail at a society ball. Sean Ryan and his partner Owen Howard are on the front lines of a frantic search through-out the city of Chicago to locate and apprehend a serial "slasher"; a nefarious criminal who attacks women of society; "marking" them forever with the cruel slash of his knife across their face and neck. When Ryan begins to accompany "Miss Carstairs" on philanthropic trips to Hope House; a residence for young women and children who need refuge, they both discover that love can cross bold societal lines without hesitation. Will Ryan, an unpolished immigrant from a large, basically uneducated, but honorable family, be able to capture the heart of the beautiful Eloisa? Will Eloisa allow her self-image to remain imprisoned within the expectations of her family? Or will it take an horrific event for the truth to set them free?
This second book in Shelley Gray's "The Chicago World's Fair Mystery Series" has a nice cadence, endearing characters and a most satisfying conclusion. Thanks goodness there is one more!
April 15, 2015
Eloise Carstairs life is ruined because of an assault she suffered at the hands of Douglass Sloane, a high and mighty from a wealthy family in the Chicago area. But Eloise is afraid to mention the assault, because she doesn't want people to know, her parents would never accept and understand it, especially her mom, who is more interested in what it seen on the outside, not her feelings. When Detective Sean Ryan, comes into her life, she sees another side of life, because Sean is from the rugged side of Chicago, a place Eloise has never ever known. Eloise realizes that life is more important that dinners, parties, fancy dresses, servants, and the wealthy way of living, and decides to do what she can to help those who don't have much in life. But she has to be careful because a killer is on the loose, and this killer seems to be after the wealthy young ladies in this Chicago area. Sean will do everything he can to protect Eloise, but will his protection be enough?
You will enjoy this clean and fun mystery from Shelley Shepard Gray, along with the twists and turns that make this story one that you just cannot put down. I received this book from BookLook Bloggers to read and review. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 55.
You will enjoy this clean and fun mystery from Shelley Shepard Gray, along with the twists and turns that make this story one that you just cannot put down. I received this book from BookLook Bloggers to read and review. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 55.
March 23, 2015
In this second book of the Chicago World’s Fair Mystery series, we travel back to September 1893. The fair is coming to a close and many celebrations are taking place. Through it all, the police are kept busy looking for the person known as the “Society Slasher” who is going around cutting the faces of “ladies”…..those of the upper class...those fortunate enough to have been born to money.
Eloise Carstairs is a very beautiful young lady with a dark secret that keeps her hidden at home on Sable Hill. When she finally does go to a social event, she meets Lieutenant Detective Sean Ryan. Sean is an Irish policeman…both identify him as lower class. Also there to protect the ladies is Detective Owen Howard. Owen is from the upper class but, having joined the police force, he fits in in both “worlds”.
Eloise and Sean develop a friendship much to the dismay of some. As do Owen and Sean’s youngest sister Katie. What will come from these friendships? Can they break the social barriers? Will the Society Slasher ever be apprehended? Will he be one of the many visitors that came to Chicago to visit the fair? Will he be one of Chicago’s own?
Once you start reading this book, you won’t want to put it down! Thank you Shelley Gray for another great read!
Eloise Carstairs is a very beautiful young lady with a dark secret that keeps her hidden at home on Sable Hill. When she finally does go to a social event, she meets Lieutenant Detective Sean Ryan. Sean is an Irish policeman…both identify him as lower class. Also there to protect the ladies is Detective Owen Howard. Owen is from the upper class but, having joined the police force, he fits in in both “worlds”.
Eloise and Sean develop a friendship much to the dismay of some. As do Owen and Sean’s youngest sister Katie. What will come from these friendships? Can they break the social barriers? Will the Society Slasher ever be apprehended? Will he be one of the many visitors that came to Chicago to visit the fair? Will he be one of Chicago’s own?
Once you start reading this book, you won’t want to put it down! Thank you Shelley Gray for another great read!
March 24, 2015
Fantastic reads come to those who wait. I know because I have been waiting for this book since July 2014. After reading it I can say the wait was SO worth it. Deception on Sable Hill, the second book in the Chicago World's Fair Mystery series, is just as great as the first.
Shelley Gray whisks us away to 1893 Chicago in the first line of the book as we are waltzing across parquet ballroom floors with the high society people of Chicago. Set against the backdrop of the Chicago World's Fair, this book has just the right amount of mystery, suspense and romance. All three elements are perfectly woven together with great descriptions to keep the reader intrigued and engaged from beginning to end.
I really liked the two main characters in this book. They were authentic and honest and the complex nature of their relationship made them seem real. I enjoyed reading about Chicago and the World's Fair. Once again the descriptions Shelley wrote brought the city alive and it was so easy to imagine being there instead of just reading about it.
This is a must read book for anyone who likes historical fiction, suspense, mystery, or romance. A wonderful way to spend the day reading!
Shelley Gray whisks us away to 1893 Chicago in the first line of the book as we are waltzing across parquet ballroom floors with the high society people of Chicago. Set against the backdrop of the Chicago World's Fair, this book has just the right amount of mystery, suspense and romance. All three elements are perfectly woven together with great descriptions to keep the reader intrigued and engaged from beginning to end.
I really liked the two main characters in this book. They were authentic and honest and the complex nature of their relationship made them seem real. I enjoyed reading about Chicago and the World's Fair. Once again the descriptions Shelley wrote brought the city alive and it was so easy to imagine being there instead of just reading about it.
This is a must read book for anyone who likes historical fiction, suspense, mystery, or romance. A wonderful way to spend the day reading!
July 8, 2015
Shelley Gray's Deception on Sable Hill continues her Chicago World's Fair Mystery series in grand style. It picks up very shortly after the conclusion of Secrets of Sloane House with Eloisa Carstairs as one of the main characters.
The extravagance of the Gilded Age is once again important in this story, set against the backdrop of the closing days of Chicago's World's Fair. Although there is evidence of some changes happening in society, Eloisa and Sean find themselves caught in the struggle of the times as well as right in the middle of a dangerous crime spree.
Some of the characters from the first book play roles in this story, but Shelley also brings in several new ones as well. Watching Eloisa search for who she wants to become as she tries to overcome major hurts makes for a very intriguing story. A variety of other characters who find themselves at various points along society's changing class continuum keep the story and its mystery moving at a very enjoyable pace.
I highly recommend both books in this series as great reads. I don't know whether there are more books to come in this series, but I would certainly enjoy reading them if there are.
Thanks to BookLook Bloggers for providing a copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.
The extravagance of the Gilded Age is once again important in this story, set against the backdrop of the closing days of Chicago's World's Fair. Although there is evidence of some changes happening in society, Eloisa and Sean find themselves caught in the struggle of the times as well as right in the middle of a dangerous crime spree.
Some of the characters from the first book play roles in this story, but Shelley also brings in several new ones as well. Watching Eloisa search for who she wants to become as she tries to overcome major hurts makes for a very intriguing story. A variety of other characters who find themselves at various points along society's changing class continuum keep the story and its mystery moving at a very enjoyable pace.
I highly recommend both books in this series as great reads. I don't know whether there are more books to come in this series, but I would certainly enjoy reading them if there are.
Thanks to BookLook Bloggers for providing a copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 184 reviews