What do you think?
Rate this book
Maple Falls #1
The Cinnamon Spice Inn
🎃 🍂 🎃 🍂
Love is the sweetest spice of all.
A fiery, coffee-loving city girl. A laid-back handyman with irresistible hazel eyes. Is this a recipe for disaster? Find out in this totally cozy and unputdownable enemies-to-lovers romance in the small town of your dreams! Gilmore Girls + spice + everything autumn = 🔥
Self-confessed coffee addict and food writer Madison has convinced herself she belongs in NYC. But then she’s called back to the small town of Maple Falls to save her childhood home, The Cinnamon Spice Inn. She’s NOT looking forward to seeing her ex, Zach—now a sexy bearded handyman who knows exactly how to push her buttons. But she won’t let anything distract her from the inn’s relaunch… right?
Zach is frustrated in more ways than one when his latest job brings him face-to-face with the girl who got away. He’s already agreed to renovate her family’s inn and he’s nothing if not a man of his word. But the last thing he wants is to work side-by-side with that stubborn, infuriating—fine, totally gorgeous—red-head.
Sparks fly as they prepare for the big Halloween opening. Will Madison save The Cinnamon Spice Inn and have a second chance at love, or will it all go up in flames?
Grab your favourite spiced latte and settle in with this steamy romance, packed with small-town charm, scorching chemistry, and the perfect HEA. If you love Laurie Gilmore, Emily Henry, cozy autumn vibes and plenty of spice, this is perfect for you!
🎃 🍂 🎃 🍂
Enemies to lovers
Forced proximity
Small-town vs. city life
Opposites attract
Second chance romance
Childhood sweethearts
Work romance
Spicy
Love is the sweetest spice of all.
A fiery, coffee-loving city girl. A laid-back handyman with irresistible hazel eyes. Is this a recipe for disaster? Find out in this totally cozy and unputdownable enemies-to-lovers romance in the small town of your dreams! Gilmore Girls + spice + everything autumn = 🔥
Self-confessed coffee addict and food writer Madison has convinced herself she belongs in NYC. But then she’s called back to the small town of Maple Falls to save her childhood home, The Cinnamon Spice Inn. She’s NOT looking forward to seeing her ex, Zach—now a sexy bearded handyman who knows exactly how to push her buttons. But she won’t let anything distract her from the inn’s relaunch… right?
Zach is frustrated in more ways than one when his latest job brings him face-to-face with the girl who got away. He’s already agreed to renovate her family’s inn and he’s nothing if not a man of his word. But the last thing he wants is to work side-by-side with that stubborn, infuriating—fine, totally gorgeous—red-head.
Sparks fly as they prepare for the big Halloween opening. Will Madison save The Cinnamon Spice Inn and have a second chance at love, or will it all go up in flames?
Grab your favourite spiced latte and settle in with this steamy romance, packed with small-town charm, scorching chemistry, and the perfect HEA. If you love Laurie Gilmore, Emily Henry, cozy autumn vibes and plenty of spice, this is perfect for you!
🎃 🍂 🎃 🍂
Enemies to lovers
Forced proximity
Small-town vs. city life
Opposites attract
Second chance romance
Childhood sweethearts
Work romance
Spicy
351 pages, Kindle Edition
First published August 28, 2025
735 people are currently reading
2667 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 758 reviews
August 27, 2025
2.5 ⭐
The autumn vibes were the best part, I loved the writing and the descriptions. Autumn is my favourite season and this small town, with all its activities and decorations, was so cozy and inviting.
But the couple and the relationship were a huge letdown..
Madison receives a anonymous letter that her family inn is in trouble and that her family needs her, so she goes back to her hometown. It's something she's been avoiding for years, because she didn't want to run into her ex Zach, but now they're forced to spend time together. He's living in a cabin next to the inn, while he's helping to renovate it. Madison is there temporarily, but their connection never died, sparks are flying every time they're together.. But are they willing to give themselves a second chance, she's leaving again after all.. Would it be any different this time?
I genuinely liked the secondary characters and I'm looking forward to Liam's book.. I'm definitely reading it, because the vibes and writing style weren't the problem here, the direction of the romance story was, so I'm hoping his book is going to be a lot better! Don't let my rating dissuade you from reading it, you might love it, it just wasn't for me..
This being tagged as enemies to lovers should be a crime, she was fantasizing about him in chapter three and she just didn't stop. The number of times she thought about him and his hands was far too much.. In general, the amount of time they spent fantasizing about each other was overwhelming, it started to get on my nerves.. In what universe is this considered enemies to lovers? I couldn't fully enjoy all the autumn vibes, because I was so annoyed..
The miscommunication was so stupid, you're telling me they broke up and haven't seen each other for years because of something that took them literally a minute to clear up. Seriously, what are we doing?? And you would think this would make them realize that they need to communicate better, right? Yeah, you would think wrong.. It happened again and again.. The last time it happened, she came to talk to him and left WITHOUT SAYING ANYTHING.. Communication is clearly a foreign word to them.. And then it got resolved, just like that.. Like nothing happened.. Frustrated isn't a big enough word to describe how I was feeling..
I didn't like Madison at all, I'm sorry, I tried, but I hated the way she was behaving. I was far too much annoyed at her to ever truly like her. I liked Zach, he was sweet and he deserved better, even do he clearly didn't know how to communicate either. I was honestly rooting for them to break up for good.. Seems healthier for me than them staying together, but that's just my opinion..
Overall, while this wasn't for me, I would still recommend it if you looking for something cozy and autumnal and you don't mind the miscommunication..
*Thank you to Netgalley and to Bookouture for providing me with an ARC.*
.·:*¨ ¨*:·.
I can't with summer anymore, I need some autumn vibes!!
Let's hope this delivers 🍁🎃🍂
The autumn vibes were the best part, I loved the writing and the descriptions. Autumn is my favourite season and this small town, with all its activities and decorations, was so cozy and inviting.
But the couple and the relationship were a huge letdown..
Madison receives a anonymous letter that her family inn is in trouble and that her family needs her, so she goes back to her hometown. It's something she's been avoiding for years, because she didn't want to run into her ex Zach, but now they're forced to spend time together. He's living in a cabin next to the inn, while he's helping to renovate it. Madison is there temporarily, but their connection never died, sparks are flying every time they're together.. But are they willing to give themselves a second chance, she's leaving again after all.. Would it be any different this time?
I genuinely liked the secondary characters and I'm looking forward to Liam's book.. I'm definitely reading it, because the vibes and writing style weren't the problem here, the direction of the romance story was, so I'm hoping his book is going to be a lot better! Don't let my rating dissuade you from reading it, you might love it, it just wasn't for me..
This being tagged as enemies to lovers should be a crime, she was fantasizing about him in chapter three and she just didn't stop. The number of times she thought about him and his hands was far too much.. In general, the amount of time they spent fantasizing about each other was overwhelming, it started to get on my nerves.. In what universe is this considered enemies to lovers? I couldn't fully enjoy all the autumn vibes, because I was so annoyed..
The miscommunication was so stupid, you're telling me they broke up and haven't seen each other for years because of something that took them literally a minute to clear up. Seriously, what are we doing?? And you would think this would make them realize that they need to communicate better, right? Yeah, you would think wrong.. It happened again and again.. The last time it happened, she came to talk to him and left WITHOUT SAYING ANYTHING.. Communication is clearly a foreign word to them.. And then it got resolved, just like that.. Like nothing happened.. Frustrated isn't a big enough word to describe how I was feeling..
I didn't like Madison at all, I'm sorry, I tried, but I hated the way she was behaving. I was far too much annoyed at her to ever truly like her. I liked Zach, he was sweet and he deserved better, even do he clearly didn't know how to communicate either. I was honestly rooting for them to break up for good.. Seems healthier for me than them staying together, but that's just my opinion..
Overall, while this wasn't for me, I would still recommend it if you looking for something cozy and autumnal and you don't mind the miscommunication..
*Thank you to Netgalley and to Bookouture for providing me with an ARC.*
.·:*¨ ¨*:·.
I can't with summer anymore, I need some autumn vibes!!
Let's hope this delivers 🍁🎃🍂
September 10, 2025
➳
4.25/5 stars
This book honestly felt like having a warm cup of coffee on a rainy day, the kind that just settles into your soul and makes you feel safe, cozy, and content.
There was such a sense of comfort within the story that I found myself sinking into it so naturally, like it was written to be read slowly and savored. I’ve always believed that second chance stories only truly leave an impact when they’re done right, when the emotions aren’t rushed but built with care and depth. And this book, to me, was the perfect example of how to do it well.
The characters were such a joy to follow, and each of them brought something unique to the story. That said, I do think the male main character could have been explored a little more. There were moments where it felt as if his presence was overshadowed, almost like the focus leaned more on the female lead’s journey rather than balancing the two perspectives. But at the same time, I can’t really complain too much, because the female protagonist’s arc was so beautifully done. The way she slowly came into herself, finding her strength and realizing she had always belonged in Maple Falls it was moving to watch.
What I loved most was how natural her growth felt, like it wasn’t forced or exaggerated but written with a quiet truthfulness that made it relatable. Her journey of self-discovery didn’t just make me root for her, it made me reflect a little on belonging, love, and the places that shape us. And even if the male character didn’t get as much time in the spotlight, it almost felt intentional as if the story wanted to remind us that sometimes the greatest love story is the one you have with yourself, and with the place you call home.
All in all, I can easily say this book was everything I hoped it would be. It was heartfelt, comforting, and filled with the kind of warmth that lingers even after you’ve turned the last page. And while there may have been little things here and there that could’ve been done differently, they feel so small in comparison to the beauty of the whole.
➳ "Overall, if you’re on the hunt for the perfect fall read, this book is truly it. Cozy, heartfelt, and full of warmth, it’s the kind of story that makes you want to curl up and savor every page." 💌
— Thank you to NetGalley, the publisher and the author for providing me with an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
This book honestly felt like having a warm cup of coffee on a rainy day, the kind that just settles into your soul and makes you feel safe, cozy, and content.
There was such a sense of comfort within the story that I found myself sinking into it so naturally, like it was written to be read slowly and savored. I’ve always believed that second chance stories only truly leave an impact when they’re done right, when the emotions aren’t rushed but built with care and depth. And this book, to me, was the perfect example of how to do it well.
The characters were such a joy to follow, and each of them brought something unique to the story. That said, I do think the male main character could have been explored a little more. There were moments where it felt as if his presence was overshadowed, almost like the focus leaned more on the female lead’s journey rather than balancing the two perspectives. But at the same time, I can’t really complain too much, because the female protagonist’s arc was so beautifully done. The way she slowly came into herself, finding her strength and realizing she had always belonged in Maple Falls it was moving to watch.
What I loved most was how natural her growth felt, like it wasn’t forced or exaggerated but written with a quiet truthfulness that made it relatable. Her journey of self-discovery didn’t just make me root for her, it made me reflect a little on belonging, love, and the places that shape us. And even if the male character didn’t get as much time in the spotlight, it almost felt intentional as if the story wanted to remind us that sometimes the greatest love story is the one you have with yourself, and with the place you call home.
All in all, I can easily say this book was everything I hoped it would be. It was heartfelt, comforting, and filled with the kind of warmth that lingers even after you’ve turned the last page. And while there may have been little things here and there that could’ve been done differently, they feel so small in comparison to the beauty of the whole.
➳ "Overall, if you’re on the hunt for the perfect fall read, this book is truly it. Cozy, heartfelt, and full of warmth, it’s the kind of story that makes you want to curl up and savor every page." 💌
— Thank you to NetGalley, the publisher and the author for providing me with an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
August 27, 2025
The Cinnamon Spice Inn is the first book in the Maple Falls series written by Harper Graham. I don't really know where to start with this book because it wasn't necessarily horrible by any means, in fact it was a strong four star rating for me until the miscommunication trope came in after an argument that happened to our main characters when they were in their early twenties and they still can't have a proper conversation about it until the end of the story? Meanwhile they are both horn dogs and can rip each other's clothes off and have sex, but they can't have a civil conversation like adults? That's just an ick for me. It definitely took me sometime to fully get invested in this story and the characters lives, but despite the issues I had, I will most definitely read the second book because I just can't leave myself hanging with what happens next. I was so excited to pick up this fall themed book because this summer heat is kicking my ass and I mean that cover is stunning, but unfortunately this one missed the mark for me. 🍁☕🔥The Cinnamon Spice Inn is for every reader that believes fall is the most perfect season for romance, second chances, and a dash of spice🍁☕🔥. If you don't mind the miscommunication trope, then mark your calendars for August 28th, 2025 for the release of The Cinnamon Spice Inn written by Harper Graham.
THANK YOU TO NETGALLEY AND BOOKOUTURE FOR AN ARC OF THIS BOOK IN EXCHANGE FOR AN HONEST REVIEW!!!!!!!
🎵MUSICAL PLAYLIST🎵
☕'Tis The Damn Season- Taylor Swift☕
☕Invisible String- Taylor Swift☕
☕After The Storm- Mumford and Sons☕
☕Home- Edward Sharpe ft. The Magnetic Zeros☕
☕Where You Lead I Will Follow- Carole King☕
☕Love You For A Long Time- Maggie Rogers☕
☕Hate To Be Lame- Lizzy McAlpine ft. Finneas☕
☕Risk- Gracie Abrams☕
☕Fade Into You- Mazzy Star☕
☕Cinnamon Girl- Lana Del Rey☕
☕Autumn Leaves- Ed Sheeran☕
☕All My Love- Noah Kahan☕
☕Second Chances- Gregory Alan Isakov☕
☕Apple Pie- Lizzy McAlpine☕
☕Willow- Taylor Swift☕
"💓🍺To soulmates, wherever the hell they are💓🍺".
"💯🔪Midwesterners didn't normally kill people in sheds in the middle of the night💯🔪".
"😍🏡Sometimes you have to get away from everything just to enjoy what is right in your backyard😍🏡".
"💗😭Maybe that was what love was- wanting someone to be happy, even if it meant letting them go💗😭".
☕🍁🏫The Cinnamon Spice Inn is a twelve room inn, it's like a big warm hug and the most perfect place to curl up with a book and a coffee by the window. On a stormy night in early October, the town's oldest maple tree which was the Hallmark of the inn's charm- crashed right through the heart of the inn which was the dining room, where there was delicious food available and a place where guests could mingle and talk to other people. The Inn has no money coming in because there's no guests arriving, and it's falling apart because it was left to it's own advantage after our female main character's mom passed away. The Cinnamon Spice Inn also has an array of animals such as a dog named Cocoa and two Highland cows named Pumpkin and Spice☕🍁🏫.
Madison Kelly is a passionate, determined, and a head strong coffee addict and a secret mystery junkie. The Cinnamon Spice Inn was Madison's childhood home where she learned how to make her mom's famous cinnamon rolls and read a book on the ledge by the window with the fireplace crackling next to her. Madison left Maple Falls when she was twenty-two years old and she planned to never call Maple Falls home ever again after a falling out with her boyfriend and after her mom's passing. Madison left Maple Falls six years ago to become a popular food writer in New York City because she loved the big city and immersing herself in the culinary world. Madison came back to Maple Falls three years ago for her mom's funeral and The Cinnamon Spice Inn was thriving, but now someone sent Madison a typed letter saying the inn was in trouble and asked her to come back home to Maple Falls, but there was no signature and no return address on this mysterious letter. If you could win a medal for running away from your problems, Madison Kelly would come in first place. Zach Whitaker is Madison's ex-boyfriend, her first love, and her former best friend. Zach inherited his grandparents apple orchard and their farmhouse after they passed away, but Zach is now making major renovations on the farmhouse in hopes to bring Madison back into his life. Zach is an annoyingly attractive contractor in the small town of Maple Falls. Madison would forever be the love of Zach's life- but goodness gracious these two never communicated well. Zach comes across as grumpy, but he is always there for anyone who ever needs him. Zach is the type of person who has always been good at masking his emotions.
Madison and Zach are now rediscovering everything they thought they had lost, but how is that possible with ignored text messages and minimal conversations? I truly liked these two characters, but damn, their communication skills were so horrible, instead of actually communication about their falling out, they decided to get down and do the dirty. Let's get to this falling out real quick, Madison was going to surprise Zach on their dating anniversary on her first visit home from New York City, but Madison saw Zach at a bar with another woman, keep in mind Zach wasn't doing anything wrong, he was literally miserable that this other woman was trying to flirt with him, but instead of speaking up Zach let it go while Madison ran away. After the maple tree came falling through the inn, Zach is staying at the honeymoon cabin while he fixes up the inn for Madison, her father, and her grandmother, but his moto is fix the inn and keep away from Madison. But they just can't stay away from each other-"let's not pretend we are who we used to be". Madison and Zach are still wildly and stupidly attracted to one another despite trying to keep their distance. The one thing they had in common was their love of solving things, but again how could they solve their past mishaps without communicating? It didn't matter how many years had passed: Madison was still the same spark to Zach's dry timber and Zach was still the fool ready to burn for Madison. Madison and Zach were both amazing human beings as individuals, but when they were together, I just wanted to scream at both of them to actually communicate with one another because I mean they are both adults, it's not hard to have a civil conversation about something that happened in their early twenties.
THANK YOU TO NETGALLEY AND BOOKOUTURE FOR AN ARC OF THIS BOOK IN EXCHANGE FOR AN HONEST REVIEW!!!!!!!
🎵MUSICAL PLAYLIST🎵
☕'Tis The Damn Season- Taylor Swift☕
☕Invisible String- Taylor Swift☕
☕After The Storm- Mumford and Sons☕
☕Home- Edward Sharpe ft. The Magnetic Zeros☕
☕Where You Lead I Will Follow- Carole King☕
☕Love You For A Long Time- Maggie Rogers☕
☕Hate To Be Lame- Lizzy McAlpine ft. Finneas☕
☕Risk- Gracie Abrams☕
☕Fade Into You- Mazzy Star☕
☕Cinnamon Girl- Lana Del Rey☕
☕Autumn Leaves- Ed Sheeran☕
☕All My Love- Noah Kahan☕
☕Second Chances- Gregory Alan Isakov☕
☕Apple Pie- Lizzy McAlpine☕
☕Willow- Taylor Swift☕
"💓🍺To soulmates, wherever the hell they are💓🍺".
"💯🔪Midwesterners didn't normally kill people in sheds in the middle of the night💯🔪".
"😍🏡Sometimes you have to get away from everything just to enjoy what is right in your backyard😍🏡".
"💗😭Maybe that was what love was- wanting someone to be happy, even if it meant letting them go💗😭".
☕🍁🏫The Cinnamon Spice Inn is a twelve room inn, it's like a big warm hug and the most perfect place to curl up with a book and a coffee by the window. On a stormy night in early October, the town's oldest maple tree which was the Hallmark of the inn's charm- crashed right through the heart of the inn which was the dining room, where there was delicious food available and a place where guests could mingle and talk to other people. The Inn has no money coming in because there's no guests arriving, and it's falling apart because it was left to it's own advantage after our female main character's mom passed away. The Cinnamon Spice Inn also has an array of animals such as a dog named Cocoa and two Highland cows named Pumpkin and Spice☕🍁🏫.
Madison Kelly is a passionate, determined, and a head strong coffee addict and a secret mystery junkie. The Cinnamon Spice Inn was Madison's childhood home where she learned how to make her mom's famous cinnamon rolls and read a book on the ledge by the window with the fireplace crackling next to her. Madison left Maple Falls when she was twenty-two years old and she planned to never call Maple Falls home ever again after a falling out with her boyfriend and after her mom's passing. Madison left Maple Falls six years ago to become a popular food writer in New York City because she loved the big city and immersing herself in the culinary world. Madison came back to Maple Falls three years ago for her mom's funeral and The Cinnamon Spice Inn was thriving, but now someone sent Madison a typed letter saying the inn was in trouble and asked her to come back home to Maple Falls, but there was no signature and no return address on this mysterious letter. If you could win a medal for running away from your problems, Madison Kelly would come in first place. Zach Whitaker is Madison's ex-boyfriend, her first love, and her former best friend. Zach inherited his grandparents apple orchard and their farmhouse after they passed away, but Zach is now making major renovations on the farmhouse in hopes to bring Madison back into his life. Zach is an annoyingly attractive contractor in the small town of Maple Falls. Madison would forever be the love of Zach's life- but goodness gracious these two never communicated well. Zach comes across as grumpy, but he is always there for anyone who ever needs him. Zach is the type of person who has always been good at masking his emotions.
Madison and Zach are now rediscovering everything they thought they had lost, but how is that possible with ignored text messages and minimal conversations? I truly liked these two characters, but damn, their communication skills were so horrible, instead of actually communication about their falling out, they decided to get down and do the dirty. Let's get to this falling out real quick, Madison was going to surprise Zach on their dating anniversary on her first visit home from New York City, but Madison saw Zach at a bar with another woman, keep in mind Zach wasn't doing anything wrong, he was literally miserable that this other woman was trying to flirt with him, but instead of speaking up Zach let it go while Madison ran away. After the maple tree came falling through the inn, Zach is staying at the honeymoon cabin while he fixes up the inn for Madison, her father, and her grandmother, but his moto is fix the inn and keep away from Madison. But they just can't stay away from each other-"let's not pretend we are who we used to be". Madison and Zach are still wildly and stupidly attracted to one another despite trying to keep their distance. The one thing they had in common was their love of solving things, but again how could they solve their past mishaps without communicating? It didn't matter how many years had passed: Madison was still the same spark to Zach's dry timber and Zach was still the fool ready to burn for Madison. Madison and Zach were both amazing human beings as individuals, but when they were together, I just wanted to scream at both of them to actually communicate with one another because I mean they are both adults, it's not hard to have a civil conversation about something that happened in their early twenties.
September 8, 2025
2.5 stars rounded up! ⭐️🍂
One thing about me is I will absolutely eat up any book that has hallmark small town vibes (at my ripe age of 21 👵🏼). This was nothing super amazing or special, but it was enjoyable!
The romance was cute but very bland. There was so much miscommunication that it just made me tired LOL. I didn’t really care about the main characters being together but I did enjoy the side characters and everything else.
It was cute overall and I would definitely recommend if you’re looking for an easy cute fall read!
One thing about me is I will absolutely eat up any book that has hallmark small town vibes (at my ripe age of 21 👵🏼). This was nothing super amazing or special, but it was enjoyable!
The romance was cute but very bland. There was so much miscommunication that it just made me tired LOL. I didn’t really care about the main characters being together but I did enjoy the side characters and everything else.
It was cute overall and I would definitely recommend if you’re looking for an easy cute fall read!
August 22, 2025
☆☆☆
Thanks to Netgalley and Bookouture Audio for this audio ARC.
The Cinnamon Spice Inn by Harper Graham is a perfect book for anyone craving a cozy, autumnal escape. The vibes? Immaculate. From the picturesque town of Maple Falls to the scent of cinnamon wafting through the pages, the atmosphere was spot-on. This book absolutely nails the cozy, autumn aesthetic, and I could practically feel the crisp air and see the golden leaves falling. The author has a real talent for creating a setting that feels like home, and that’s where this book shines the most.
Kit was by far my favorite character, and honestly, I hope she gets her own book because I’d love to see more of her story. There’s something so likable and relatable about her. Also, let’s not forget about the cover it's so adorable! It perfectly matches the tone of the book, and I’m a sucker for a cover that aligns with the vibe inside.
However, the main plot device (miscommunication trope) didn’t quite work for me. I just couldn’t wrap my head around how the characters couldn’t talk to each other! For me, it felt a bit toxic and frustrating. I’m left wondering whether their relationship will have a future, because the way they just kept avoiding communication was a major hurdle for me.
Additionally, Madison was described as a “straight shooter” by her grandma, but I found her to be the direct opposite. I kept waiting for her to be more open and direct, but she ended up being more closed off than expected. This disconnect made it harder for me to connect with her character.
Overall, while I really enjoyed the fall vibes and the setting, the miscommunication aspect and some character inconsistencies held this book back from being a true favorite for me. If you love autumnal settings and small-town charm, it’s definitely worth checking out, but be prepared for some frustrating moments with the characters.
Thanks to Netgalley and Bookouture Audio for this audio ARC.
The Cinnamon Spice Inn by Harper Graham is a perfect book for anyone craving a cozy, autumnal escape. The vibes? Immaculate. From the picturesque town of Maple Falls to the scent of cinnamon wafting through the pages, the atmosphere was spot-on. This book absolutely nails the cozy, autumn aesthetic, and I could practically feel the crisp air and see the golden leaves falling. The author has a real talent for creating a setting that feels like home, and that’s where this book shines the most.
Kit was by far my favorite character, and honestly, I hope she gets her own book because I’d love to see more of her story. There’s something so likable and relatable about her. Also, let’s not forget about the cover it's so adorable! It perfectly matches the tone of the book, and I’m a sucker for a cover that aligns with the vibe inside.
However, the main plot device (miscommunication trope) didn’t quite work for me. I just couldn’t wrap my head around how the characters couldn’t talk to each other! For me, it felt a bit toxic and frustrating. I’m left wondering whether their relationship will have a future, because the way they just kept avoiding communication was a major hurdle for me.
Additionally, Madison was described as a “straight shooter” by her grandma, but I found her to be the direct opposite. I kept waiting for her to be more open and direct, but she ended up being more closed off than expected. This disconnect made it harder for me to connect with her character.
Overall, while I really enjoyed the fall vibes and the setting, the miscommunication aspect and some character inconsistencies held this book back from being a true favorite for me. If you love autumnal settings and small-town charm, it’s definitely worth checking out, but be prepared for some frustrating moments with the characters.
September 4, 2025
I looovveee a good fall small town romance, but unfortunately this one was just a huge miss. It seemed like the author knew the tropes and vibes they wanted, but could not execute the plot at all. The fall vibes? Great. The second chance romance in a small town? Horrible. The hero and heroine apparently date for like 7 years, but it felt like they barely knew each other. The hero would mention something he would always do growing up, AND THE HEROINE HAD NO IDEA!? You literally dated for over 5 years growing up!? Then they broke up because of miscommunication and then just continued to miscommunicate the entire time. I didn't buy their past connection or relationship at all and felt zero yearning and pining beyond just the physical. This just did not feel liked a polished, plotted book but instead was put out to get the "vibes" in time for the holiday season. It was a huge miss and I would say skip this one.
September 7, 2025
Cozy, small town romance, second chances, forced proximity, small-town vs. city life.
﹒⟡﹒﹒⟡﹒﹒⟡﹒﹒⟡﹒﹒⟡﹒﹒⟡﹒
Recently divorced woman who inherits The Cinnamon Spice Inn to start over. Warm, cautious, and secretly doubts she deserves happiness.
Local carpenter/contractor hired to help restore the inn. Rugged, dependable, carrying his own quiet grief.
The Inn Itself - Almost a character on its own, creaky floors, cozy fireplaces, cinnamon-scented halls and a guestbook full of stories from people passing through.
﹒⟡﹒﹒⟡﹒﹒⟡﹒﹒⟡﹒﹒⟡﹒﹒⟡﹒
The Cinnamon Spice Inn was a cozy, heartwarming read with all the right ingredients for a small town romance. A charming inn, a sprinkle of drama, and plenty of cinnamon scented atmosphere. The descriptions of the inn and the town felt warm and inviting, like stepping into a Hallmark movie!
The thing with that trope “enemies to lovers” is it only really works if there’s genuine conflict or opposition between the main characters at the start. The Cinnamon Spice Inn leans more toward cozy small-town, second chance, or forced proximity vibes rather than full on enemies to lovers.
Overall, it’s a sweet, feel-good book perfect for when you want something light, cozy, and charming!
﹒⟡﹒﹒⟡﹒﹒⟡﹒﹒⟡﹒﹒⟡﹒﹒⟡﹒
I would like to give a huge thank you to NetGalley, Harper Graham, & Bookoutour for providing me with an eARC of The Cinnamon Spice Inn in exchange for my honest review. You guys are the best!
﹒⟡﹒﹒⟡﹒﹒⟡﹒﹒⟡﹒﹒⟡﹒﹒⟡﹒
Follow me on my socials ↓
Instagram
Medium
﹒⟡﹒﹒⟡﹒﹒⟡﹒﹒⟡﹒﹒⟡﹒﹒⟡﹒
Recently divorced woman who inherits The Cinnamon Spice Inn to start over. Warm, cautious, and secretly doubts she deserves happiness.
Local carpenter/contractor hired to help restore the inn. Rugged, dependable, carrying his own quiet grief.
The Inn Itself - Almost a character on its own, creaky floors, cozy fireplaces, cinnamon-scented halls and a guestbook full of stories from people passing through.
﹒⟡﹒﹒⟡﹒﹒⟡﹒﹒⟡﹒﹒⟡﹒﹒⟡﹒
The Cinnamon Spice Inn was a cozy, heartwarming read with all the right ingredients for a small town romance. A charming inn, a sprinkle of drama, and plenty of cinnamon scented atmosphere. The descriptions of the inn and the town felt warm and inviting, like stepping into a Hallmark movie!
The thing with that trope “enemies to lovers” is it only really works if there’s genuine conflict or opposition between the main characters at the start. The Cinnamon Spice Inn leans more toward cozy small-town, second chance, or forced proximity vibes rather than full on enemies to lovers.
Overall, it’s a sweet, feel-good book perfect for when you want something light, cozy, and charming!
﹒⟡﹒﹒⟡﹒﹒⟡﹒﹒⟡﹒﹒⟡﹒﹒⟡﹒
I would like to give a huge thank you to NetGalley, Harper Graham, & Bookoutour for providing me with an eARC of The Cinnamon Spice Inn in exchange for my honest review. You guys are the best!
﹒⟡﹒﹒⟡﹒﹒⟡﹒﹒⟡﹒﹒⟡﹒﹒⟡﹒
Follow me on my socials ↓
Medium
August 14, 2025
Check out this review and many more at windymornings.com
DING DING DING! Finally! A cute, cozy, and adorable romance book that wasn’t corny and tried to include too many tropes, which makes my head spin. I would like to start by saying that this book was given to me by Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
The Cinnamon Spice Inn is your perfect blend of the warm fuzzies mixed with the frustration of two lovers who can’t ever seem to be on the same page. Now, don’t run off! The miscommunication trope has been overdone for a few years now, and I totally get not enjoying it. However, I can confidently say that Harper did a very good job of keeping it entertaining and having me subtly yelling at the book every now and then. I will say that I loved the characters and was rooting for both of them the whole time. I think that’s why I didn’t mind the miscommunication trope throughout the book, because of how likable the characters were. I also want to applaud Harper for making the male main character not an anger-fueled beast that hates women, definitely a change from most “cozy” romance books out there.
Ok! Let’s turn our fireplaces on (I know it’s still summer, just do it, ok.) Get your pumpkin spice lattes, apple crisp pastries, and your favorite blanket, and let’s book a room at the Cinnamon Spice Inn. We follow the main character, Maddison. Small town born and raised, with a loving family, knew grief at a young age. She lost her mother while she was in college and relied heavily on the nostalgia of the Inn to keep her company. After the funeral of her mother, Maddison left for New York and didn’t look back. She built a name for herself in the culinary world by becoming a very well-known food critic and editor. She loved her life in New York and the friends that she made along the way. Especially her best friend Jo, who has kept her company and been a shoulder to cry on when her mother died. One busy New York-filled day, Maddison left work with plans to begin her weekend. When she arrived at her apartment, there was a letter waiting for her at the doorstep. Stating that the family-owned “Cinnamon Spice Inn” needs help and asking Maddison to consider coming back home to aid her grandmother and father. It didn’t take much for Maddie to pack a bag and head north. The night that she got there, she expected to see the front porch decorated in the iconic festive decor, only to find an empty porch with molded leaves sticking to the flaking paint. She opened the front door to the Inn, waiting for the cinnamon spice and pumpkin scents to flood her nose, but all she got was the scent of damp, wet, musty carpet. She was confused as to why her grandmother or father didn’t keep up with her late mother’s decoration schedule, as it was a leading cause of tourist booking rooms. Every year, tourists come searching for the fall coziness and bright orange and red colors. She could tell there was something seriously wrong.
Maddie stepped foot into the kitchen and was quickly wrapped in a warm hug by her father and grandmother. After catching up for a while, she finally got settled in, unpacked her bags, and started reading her latest novel. As the night went on, the storm outside grew bigger and bigger until she heard a loud crash coming from the den. She quickly got up and peeked outside her room to see a massive tree in her living room. Her father met her outside, making sure Maddison was ok. She asked her dad who could fix this roof that won’t put us in even more debt? Her father called the one and only contractor in the city, Zack. The same Zack that Maddison left to pursue a career in New York, the same Zack she saw flirting at a bar on their anniversary day, the same Zack that she always loved and never forgot about. She quickly realized that she’s going to have to figure out how to be in the same room with Zack, without falling for him… again. The Inn needs a large remodel and fixings, and it’s all going to be done by Zack. Can she hold on to her feelings, or will she go back into Zack’s arms? Will Zack even open himself up to her again?
Well, needless to say, this book was a five-star read, after two, three-star books. I can confidently say this pulled me out of a very dark road towards a very long reading slump. I felt like I was in Maddison’s hometown, sipping apple crisp lattes, and reading a book in the local coffee shop, while snacking on apple butter-filled pastries. I would definitely recommend this book to my friends… not so much family, as it does have a 3/5 spice rating. But, if you’re into that, then by all means. I’m not generally one for romance novels; however, this book was the perfect exception. I am extremely excited to see what Harper has in store for Liam and Cassidy!
DING DING DING! Finally! A cute, cozy, and adorable romance book that wasn’t corny and tried to include too many tropes, which makes my head spin. I would like to start by saying that this book was given to me by Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
The Cinnamon Spice Inn is your perfect blend of the warm fuzzies mixed with the frustration of two lovers who can’t ever seem to be on the same page. Now, don’t run off! The miscommunication trope has been overdone for a few years now, and I totally get not enjoying it. However, I can confidently say that Harper did a very good job of keeping it entertaining and having me subtly yelling at the book every now and then. I will say that I loved the characters and was rooting for both of them the whole time. I think that’s why I didn’t mind the miscommunication trope throughout the book, because of how likable the characters were. I also want to applaud Harper for making the male main character not an anger-fueled beast that hates women, definitely a change from most “cozy” romance books out there.
Ok! Let’s turn our fireplaces on (I know it’s still summer, just do it, ok.) Get your pumpkin spice lattes, apple crisp pastries, and your favorite blanket, and let’s book a room at the Cinnamon Spice Inn. We follow the main character, Maddison. Small town born and raised, with a loving family, knew grief at a young age. She lost her mother while she was in college and relied heavily on the nostalgia of the Inn to keep her company. After the funeral of her mother, Maddison left for New York and didn’t look back. She built a name for herself in the culinary world by becoming a very well-known food critic and editor. She loved her life in New York and the friends that she made along the way. Especially her best friend Jo, who has kept her company and been a shoulder to cry on when her mother died. One busy New York-filled day, Maddison left work with plans to begin her weekend. When she arrived at her apartment, there was a letter waiting for her at the doorstep. Stating that the family-owned “Cinnamon Spice Inn” needs help and asking Maddison to consider coming back home to aid her grandmother and father. It didn’t take much for Maddie to pack a bag and head north. The night that she got there, she expected to see the front porch decorated in the iconic festive decor, only to find an empty porch with molded leaves sticking to the flaking paint. She opened the front door to the Inn, waiting for the cinnamon spice and pumpkin scents to flood her nose, but all she got was the scent of damp, wet, musty carpet. She was confused as to why her grandmother or father didn’t keep up with her late mother’s decoration schedule, as it was a leading cause of tourist booking rooms. Every year, tourists come searching for the fall coziness and bright orange and red colors. She could tell there was something seriously wrong.
Maddie stepped foot into the kitchen and was quickly wrapped in a warm hug by her father and grandmother. After catching up for a while, she finally got settled in, unpacked her bags, and started reading her latest novel. As the night went on, the storm outside grew bigger and bigger until she heard a loud crash coming from the den. She quickly got up and peeked outside her room to see a massive tree in her living room. Her father met her outside, making sure Maddison was ok. She asked her dad who could fix this roof that won’t put us in even more debt? Her father called the one and only contractor in the city, Zack. The same Zack that Maddison left to pursue a career in New York, the same Zack she saw flirting at a bar on their anniversary day, the same Zack that she always loved and never forgot about. She quickly realized that she’s going to have to figure out how to be in the same room with Zack, without falling for him… again. The Inn needs a large remodel and fixings, and it’s all going to be done by Zack. Can she hold on to her feelings, or will she go back into Zack’s arms? Will Zack even open himself up to her again?
Well, needless to say, this book was a five-star read, after two, three-star books. I can confidently say this pulled me out of a very dark road towards a very long reading slump. I felt like I was in Maddison’s hometown, sipping apple crisp lattes, and reading a book in the local coffee shop, while snacking on apple butter-filled pastries. I would definitely recommend this book to my friends… not so much family, as it does have a 3/5 spice rating. But, if you’re into that, then by all means. I’m not generally one for romance novels; however, this book was the perfect exception. I am extremely excited to see what Harper has in store for Liam and Cassidy!
August 5, 2025
I would like to thank Netgalley & Bookouture for an advanced copy of this!!
This book was able to accomplish in a day what me & my therapist haven't been able to accomplish in a year. The dopamine shot this book gives should be studied!
If you've been reading my reviews, you should already know, this is absolutely NOTHINGGGG like what I usually read. I am not a romance/ contemporary romance (basically anything that brings straight joy) girlie. But maybe this is my sign to change that.
I was first drawn to this when Gilmore Girls was mentioned in the synopsis. Gilmore Girls has always had my little black heart in a chokehold. This delivered on that promise in the most absolutely perfect ways!
I was feeling all the feels with this one, feelings I didn't even know were possible to obtain from a book. Happy tears, frustrated tears, goosebumps, nausea, & I swear I thought I was going to dry heaving once or twice.. The pining 🤌🏻🤌🏻 the yearning 🤌🏻🤌🏻 the lack of flippin communication that leaves you raging 🤌🏻🤌🏻🤌🏻
Also, like many, I've been ready for spooky season since yesterday & have finally started to gaslight myself into thinking it's here. Which was another reason I was drawn to this.
This book delivers smoother than an obstetrician. The mood is SUPERB! Everything I needed to catapult every fiber of my being to cozy season. This book kicks all five of your senses into overdrive! Apple vanilla lattes!? Baked goods that will make you swoon almost as fast as the cinnamon roll of a man we have here!? & Again GILMORE GIRLS!? I feel as if that should be "nuff said" right there!
This book was able to accomplish in a day what me & my therapist haven't been able to accomplish in a year. The dopamine shot this book gives should be studied!
If you've been reading my reviews, you should already know, this is absolutely NOTHINGGGG like what I usually read. I am not a romance/ contemporary romance (basically anything that brings straight joy) girlie. But maybe this is my sign to change that.
I was first drawn to this when Gilmore Girls was mentioned in the synopsis. Gilmore Girls has always had my little black heart in a chokehold. This delivered on that promise in the most absolutely perfect ways!
I was feeling all the feels with this one, feelings I didn't even know were possible to obtain from a book. Happy tears, frustrated tears, goosebumps, nausea, & I swear I thought I was going to dry heaving once or twice.. The pining 🤌🏻🤌🏻 the yearning 🤌🏻🤌🏻 the lack of flippin communication that leaves you raging 🤌🏻🤌🏻🤌🏻
Also, like many, I've been ready for spooky season since yesterday & have finally started to gaslight myself into thinking it's here. Which was another reason I was drawn to this.
This book delivers smoother than an obstetrician. The mood is SUPERB! Everything I needed to catapult every fiber of my being to cozy season. This book kicks all five of your senses into overdrive! Apple vanilla lattes!? Baked goods that will make you swoon almost as fast as the cinnamon roll of a man we have here!? & Again GILMORE GIRLS!? I feel as if that should be "nuff said" right there!
September 4, 2025
Thank you to NetGalley and Bookouture for this ARC!
Ok! The first third of this book was amazing! I love the name Madison (FMC). I love autumnal vibes and small towns. All a great set up for me. I loved the bar scene with the flirting back and forth between the two leads. It all seemed to be going in the right direction!
THEN ... it just all fell apart . The miscommunication thing did not work, I’m sorry. Like what on earth are we doing here?? The FMC and MMC constantly did not communicate with each other and the early disclosure about how stupid their original breakup was completely destroyed the vibes for me.
It even says at one point from Zack's perspective: '...even if he wouldn't fight for their relationship." Ummmmm, what the hell???? He’s not planning to fight for the relationship … what am I reading???
Liam (MMC best friend): 'I mean, it's gotta be hard seeing her again after all these years. But you could've just, I don't know, told her how you felt instead of trying to electrocute yourself into an early grave." Liam = MVP. My favourite character, the only one with an actual braincell!
ALSO, the amount of blaspheming going on in this book made me want to throw it across the room. This was a put off for me completely and does not seem very in keeping with the small town vibes, it was just not necessary in my opinion.
This second chance trope ... I think is not for me at all. It didn't work out the first time for them ... and everyone can see why! ... and it is not going to work out the second time either.
They were also jumping into bed together before anything had even been worked out. There was no longing, there was no yearning, it was just awful. Their messing around and insta-lusting was meh. There was just no tension because of all of this silliness.
ALSO, this from the FMC grandmother: 'Now, dear, there's nothing wrong with a little hanky-panky.' Hmmmmmmmmm, I have never heard a grandmother say that to their granddaughter EVER. This gave me the major ick!
The last third of the book, they were again not talking ad nauseam.
Even Liam (the champ that he is💕) knew Madison and Zach were rubbish together: '...Madison has a way of screwing with your head.' Damn right she does, great point Liam!
And then her grandmother at the end calling her a 'straight shooter' had me screaming!!!
I have never been so passionately annoyed by a book in recent years.
Learning moments:
1. I HATE second chance romances!
2. I loathe the last two thirds of this book.
3. Liam is the best!
3. This grandmother! I have no words.
4. These two are going to be miserable together and I don’t care a bit.
1 star for Liam and 1 star for the first third of the book.
Thank you all for reading!
Ok! The first third of this book was amazing! I love the name Madison (FMC). I love autumnal vibes and small towns. All a great set up for me. I loved the bar scene with the flirting back and forth between the two leads. It all seemed to be going in the right direction!
THEN ... it just all fell apart . The miscommunication thing did not work, I’m sorry. Like what on earth are we doing here?? The FMC and MMC constantly did not communicate with each other and the early disclosure about how stupid their original breakup was completely destroyed the vibes for me.
It even says at one point from Zack's perspective: '...even if he wouldn't fight for their relationship." Ummmmm, what the hell???? He’s not planning to fight for the relationship … what am I reading???
Liam (MMC best friend): 'I mean, it's gotta be hard seeing her again after all these years. But you could've just, I don't know, told her how you felt instead of trying to electrocute yourself into an early grave." Liam = MVP. My favourite character, the only one with an actual braincell!
ALSO, the amount of blaspheming going on in this book made me want to throw it across the room. This was a put off for me completely and does not seem very in keeping with the small town vibes, it was just not necessary in my opinion.
This second chance trope ... I think is not for me at all. It didn't work out the first time for them ... and everyone can see why! ... and it is not going to work out the second time either.
They were also jumping into bed together before anything had even been worked out. There was no longing, there was no yearning, it was just awful. Their messing around and insta-lusting was meh. There was just no tension because of all of this silliness.
ALSO, this from the FMC grandmother: 'Now, dear, there's nothing wrong with a little hanky-panky.' Hmmmmmmmmm, I have never heard a grandmother say that to their granddaughter EVER. This gave me the major ick!
The last third of the book, they were again not talking ad nauseam.
Even Liam (the champ that he is💕) knew Madison and Zach were rubbish together: '...Madison has a way of screwing with your head.' Damn right she does, great point Liam!
And then her grandmother at the end calling her a 'straight shooter' had me screaming!!!
I have never been so passionately annoyed by a book in recent years.
Learning moments:
1. I HATE second chance romances!
2. I loathe the last two thirds of this book.
3. Liam is the best!
3. This grandmother! I have no words.
4. These two are going to be miserable together and I don’t care a bit.
1 star for Liam and 1 star for the first third of the book.
Thank you all for reading!
August 1, 2025
This was gorgeous. Cosy, spicy, autumnal, small town, forced proximity, friends to enemies to lovers - I don't think there's much else you need to know!
She's a small town girl who moved to the big city, but receives a mysterious letter urging her to return to her family's inn which is floundering and needs her help. He's a flannel-clad handyman who agrees to help renovate the inn after a disaster. They dated years ago and were childhood sweethearts, but it all fell apart when she moved to New York. Now Madison's returned home and Zach is around to help again, will they get the second chance they're both hoping for?
I've read a handful of small town, autumn themed romances recently, and honestly, this one blew the others out of the water. The fall descriptions were just *chef's kiss*. I'm truly craving all those gorgeous autumn foods and fall experiences - give me all the apple butter cinnamon rolls and pumpkinfests and cosy nights around the fire on a lakeside wrapped in blankets in Adirondack chairs. The crafting circle of women was a particular highlight too - women of all ages coming together to create something beautiful for the town's benefit. Sigh.
The only thing that bothered me about it was the miscommunication trope, which isn't top of my favourites. There was a lot of "just speak to each other!!" going on in my head while reading this, but the story pans out well in the end, and you get the happy ending you're looking for, so it doesn't concern me that much!
This is the first in a series entitled Maple Falls with more books to come - I can't wait to dive back into this world again with our next duo. The cast of characters was lovely so I'm excited to see which ones crop up again in the next book. I genuinely feel homesick reading this book - despite never living in small town America!
Thank you to Netgalley, the author and the publishers for a review copy of this book.
She's a small town girl who moved to the big city, but receives a mysterious letter urging her to return to her family's inn which is floundering and needs her help. He's a flannel-clad handyman who agrees to help renovate the inn after a disaster. They dated years ago and were childhood sweethearts, but it all fell apart when she moved to New York. Now Madison's returned home and Zach is around to help again, will they get the second chance they're both hoping for?
I've read a handful of small town, autumn themed romances recently, and honestly, this one blew the others out of the water. The fall descriptions were just *chef's kiss*. I'm truly craving all those gorgeous autumn foods and fall experiences - give me all the apple butter cinnamon rolls and pumpkinfests and cosy nights around the fire on a lakeside wrapped in blankets in Adirondack chairs. The crafting circle of women was a particular highlight too - women of all ages coming together to create something beautiful for the town's benefit. Sigh.
The only thing that bothered me about it was the miscommunication trope, which isn't top of my favourites. There was a lot of "just speak to each other!!" going on in my head while reading this, but the story pans out well in the end, and you get the happy ending you're looking for, so it doesn't concern me that much!
This is the first in a series entitled Maple Falls with more books to come - I can't wait to dive back into this world again with our next duo. The cast of characters was lovely so I'm excited to see which ones crop up again in the next book. I genuinely feel homesick reading this book - despite never living in small town America!
Thank you to Netgalley, the author and the publishers for a review copy of this book.
August 30, 2025
The Cinnamon Spice Inn offers an absolutely charming autumn atmosphere, perfect for anyone who loves the season. The setting of a small town with cozy decorations, fall activities, and an inviting family inn creates the perfect backdrop for the story.
The writing does an excellent job capturing the warmth and nostalgia of autumn, making it easy to immerse yourself in the seasonal vibes. However, the romance element did not quite meet my expectations.
The plot centers around Madison, who returns to her family inn after receiving an anonymous letter about its struggles. She’s reluctant to return because it means facing her ex, Zach, who is still living nearby and helping to renovate the inn. The two are forced to spend time together, and while the chemistry between them is undeniable, the development of their relationship felt a bit underwhelming.
One of my biggest frustrations was the miscommunication between Madison and Zach. The misunderstanding that led to their breakup years ago could have been resolved quickly, yet it was dragged out unnecessarily.
Unfortunately, this pattern of poor communication continued throughout the story, which made it difficult to fully invest in their relationship. Madison’s actions, in particular, were hard to understand and left me feeling disconnected from her character. While Zach seemed like a genuinely kind person, his inability to communicate effectively also created tension in the narrative.
That being said, the secondary characters were a highlight, especially Liam, whose story I am genuinely looking forward to reading. The writing style and the overall vibe of the book were enjoyable, and while the romance didn’t resonate with me personally, I believe others might appreciate it more.
Overall, while this book didn’t fully meet my expectations in terms of romance, it still offers a warm, autumnal setting that will appeal to readers looking for a light, seasonal read.
If you’re a fan of cozy, autumnal settings and don’t mind a bit of miscommunication in a second-chance romance, this could be a great pick for you. However, the "enemies to lovers" trope doesn’t quite apply here, as there’s more of a lingering attraction than actual animosity between the characters.
The writing does an excellent job capturing the warmth and nostalgia of autumn, making it easy to immerse yourself in the seasonal vibes. However, the romance element did not quite meet my expectations.
The plot centers around Madison, who returns to her family inn after receiving an anonymous letter about its struggles. She’s reluctant to return because it means facing her ex, Zach, who is still living nearby and helping to renovate the inn. The two are forced to spend time together, and while the chemistry between them is undeniable, the development of their relationship felt a bit underwhelming.
One of my biggest frustrations was the miscommunication between Madison and Zach. The misunderstanding that led to their breakup years ago could have been resolved quickly, yet it was dragged out unnecessarily.
Unfortunately, this pattern of poor communication continued throughout the story, which made it difficult to fully invest in their relationship. Madison’s actions, in particular, were hard to understand and left me feeling disconnected from her character. While Zach seemed like a genuinely kind person, his inability to communicate effectively also created tension in the narrative.
That being said, the secondary characters were a highlight, especially Liam, whose story I am genuinely looking forward to reading. The writing style and the overall vibe of the book were enjoyable, and while the romance didn’t resonate with me personally, I believe others might appreciate it more.
Overall, while this book didn’t fully meet my expectations in terms of romance, it still offers a warm, autumnal setting that will appeal to readers looking for a light, seasonal read.
If you’re a fan of cozy, autumnal settings and don’t mind a bit of miscommunication in a second-chance romance, this could be a great pick for you. However, the "enemies to lovers" trope doesn’t quite apply here, as there’s more of a lingering attraction than actual animosity between the characters.
August 4, 2025
Thank you to NetGalley and Bookouture for the ARC in exchange for an honest review of this book.
The Cinnamon Spice Inn follows Madison, back in her hometown from the big city here to rescue her family’s inn. Back for the first time in years, it’s also the first time she’s seen Zach since their breakup, and their second-chance romance unfolds across the pages.
Unfortunately, this book did not live up to my expectations. The concept of this town and many of the side characters have potential. I loved that the cows were named Pumpkin and Spice. I love an everyone-knows-everyone town. I think Kit in particular would have a compelling story. I love the craft circle. But despite some of the charms present, this book fell completely flat for me on almost all fronts.
While it promises to be cozy, I felt the writing to be a lot of telling, rather than showing. Something is not cozy just because you tell the reader it is, the feeling needs to be present, and it just was not here. I also found the banter between characters a bit stilted, when it could have had more voice and character, especially through the different characters. Liam’s was especially painful in his conversations with Zach, which only served to move the plot forward for his relationship with Madison.
The worst offender in this book is the miscommunication. I found it impossible to root for our leads, who have spent years of no contact, over a misunderstanding that took almost no time to resolve. Miscommunication is the source of all of their problems in this book - how can I ever expect these two to have a relationship if they can never have an honest conversation? If the author had spent more time exploring their relationship beforehand, maybe I would have been more invested. For a couple that was together since elementary school, I didn’t feel any kind of spark between them besides physical, which made their story uninteresting and uninspiring.
I love a romance, but this didn’t do it for me. The characters were underdeveloped and the conflict lacked depth, this story would have benefitted from beginning a bit earlier to really feel their back story and having us be invested.
The Cinnamon Spice Inn follows Madison, back in her hometown from the big city here to rescue her family’s inn. Back for the first time in years, it’s also the first time she’s seen Zach since their breakup, and their second-chance romance unfolds across the pages.
Unfortunately, this book did not live up to my expectations. The concept of this town and many of the side characters have potential. I loved that the cows were named Pumpkin and Spice. I love an everyone-knows-everyone town. I think Kit in particular would have a compelling story. I love the craft circle. But despite some of the charms present, this book fell completely flat for me on almost all fronts.
While it promises to be cozy, I felt the writing to be a lot of telling, rather than showing. Something is not cozy just because you tell the reader it is, the feeling needs to be present, and it just was not here. I also found the banter between characters a bit stilted, when it could have had more voice and character, especially through the different characters. Liam’s was especially painful in his conversations with Zach, which only served to move the plot forward for his relationship with Madison.
The worst offender in this book is the miscommunication. I found it impossible to root for our leads, who have spent years of no contact, over a misunderstanding that took almost no time to resolve. Miscommunication is the source of all of their problems in this book - how can I ever expect these two to have a relationship if they can never have an honest conversation? If the author had spent more time exploring their relationship beforehand, maybe I would have been more invested. For a couple that was together since elementary school, I didn’t feel any kind of spark between them besides physical, which made their story uninteresting and uninspiring.
I love a romance, but this didn’t do it for me. The characters were underdeveloped and the conflict lacked depth, this story would have benefitted from beginning a bit earlier to really feel their back story and having us be invested.
August 28, 2025
3.25. City girl back in her home town vs grumpy handyman with all the fall scents, flavors, and colors! This second chance romance is perfect for a cozy fall read with some spice.
I really enjoyed the theme of fall, when I read a book that’s set in a fall or holiday setting, I want it to throw it at my face and this definitely did the job! The setting was cute and I love a corny hallmark type story for these seasonal reads. My issue was with the characters. This man was being a big man baby about her passions and career-EWW. They weren’t my favorite but this book did its job still!
Andi Eloise and Brandon Francis did a great job with these characters, the audio was really engaging and fun!
Thank you so much Harper Graham and Bookouture Audio for providing this free ALC. This is my honest review!
I really enjoyed the theme of fall, when I read a book that’s set in a fall or holiday setting, I want it to throw it at my face and this definitely did the job! The setting was cute and I love a corny hallmark type story for these seasonal reads. My issue was with the characters. This man was being a big man baby about her passions and career-EWW. They weren’t my favorite but this book did its job still!
Andi Eloise and Brandon Francis did a great job with these characters, the audio was really engaging and fun!
Thank you so much Harper Graham and Bookouture Audio for providing this free ALC. This is my honest review!
August 27, 2025
"𝐟𝐨𝐫 𝐞𝐯𝐞𝐫𝐲 𝐫𝐞𝐚𝐝𝐞𝐫𝐬 𝐰𝐡𝐨 𝐛𝐞𝐥𝐢𝐞𝐯𝐞𝐬 𝐟𝐚𝐥𝐥 𝐢𝐬 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐩𝐞𝐫𝐟𝐞𝐜𝐭 𝐬𝐞𝐚𝐬𝐨𝐧 𝐟𝐨𝐫 𝐫𝐨𝐦𝐚𝐧𝐜𝐞, 𝐬𝐞𝐜𝐨𝐧𝐝 𝐜𝐡𝐚𝐧𝐜𝐞𝐬, 𝐚𝐧𝐝 𝐚 𝐝𝐚𝐬𝐡 𝐨𝐟 𝐬𝐩𝐢𝐜𝐞"
4 ⭐️
I want to start by saying that the fall vibes were totally there and did not dissapoint. I loved the small town setting so much. It's a very easy and quick read and I was hooked. i got the fall mood even though I read it in middle but it's never too early
The only reason that it wasn't a 5 star is because of the miscommunication ughh. But everything else was incredible.
My favorite characters are probably Liam and Kit and I'm really excited for his book and I hope we get one of her later on. He was really funny and I'm excited to read more about him. And Kit, that girl is amazing.
Our main characters Zach and Madison were also incredible. I really liked them together. And I will let you discover them on your own terms.
i also really liked the storyline with the letters helping the Inn and i think it was my favorite part of the book even though i guessed who it was (tbf I accused everyone than found the right one lol)
If you love a cozy falll romance this is for you !
🍁🍂🥮🎃
🌶️ rating : There is explicits scenes that you can skip but there is tension through out the book
Content warning : Panic attacks, explicit sexual content and grief
"𝐢𝐭 𝐬𝐨𝐮𝐧𝐝𝐞𝐝 𝐥𝐢𝐤𝐞 𝐬𝐨𝐦𝐞𝐭𝐡𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐨𝐮𝐭 𝐨𝐟 𝐚 𝐫𝐨𝐦𝐚𝐧𝐜𝐞 𝐧𝐨𝐯𝐞𝐥-𝐬𝐦𝐚𝐥𝐥 𝐭𝐨𝐰𝐧 𝐛𝐨𝐲 𝐡𝐨𝐥𝐝𝐬 𝐚 𝐭𝐨𝐫𝐜𝐡 𝐟𝐨𝐫 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐠𝐢𝐫𝐥 𝐰𝐡𝐨 𝐥𝐞𝐟𝐭. 𝐁𝐮𝐭 𝐥𝐢𝐟𝐞 𝐰𝐚𝐬𝐧'𝐭 𝐚 𝐦𝐨𝐯𝐢𝐞. 𝐚𝐧𝐝 𝐬𝐡𝐞 𝐢𝐬 𝐧𝐨𝐭 𝐭𝐡𝐚𝐭 𝐠𝐢𝐫𝐥 𝐚𝐧𝐲𝐦𝐨𝐫𝐞"
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher Bookouture for giving me an early reader digital copy in exchange of an honest review.
4 ⭐️
I want to start by saying that the fall vibes were totally there and did not dissapoint. I loved the small town setting so much. It's a very easy and quick read and I was hooked. i got the fall mood even though I read it in middle but it's never too early
The only reason that it wasn't a 5 star is because of the miscommunication ughh. But everything else was incredible.
My favorite characters are probably Liam and Kit and I'm really excited for his book and I hope we get one of her later on. He was really funny and I'm excited to read more about him. And Kit, that girl is amazing.
Our main characters Zach and Madison were also incredible. I really liked them together. And I will let you discover them on your own terms.
i also really liked the storyline with the letters helping the Inn and i think it was my favorite part of the book even though i guessed who it was (tbf I accused everyone than found the right one lol)
If you love a cozy falll romance this is for you !
🍁🍂🥮🎃
🌶️ rating : There is explicits scenes that you can skip but there is tension through out the book
Content warning : Panic attacks, explicit sexual content and grief
"𝐢𝐭 𝐬𝐨𝐮𝐧𝐝𝐞𝐝 𝐥𝐢𝐤𝐞 𝐬𝐨𝐦𝐞𝐭𝐡𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐨𝐮𝐭 𝐨𝐟 𝐚 𝐫𝐨𝐦𝐚𝐧𝐜𝐞 𝐧𝐨𝐯𝐞𝐥-𝐬𝐦𝐚𝐥𝐥 𝐭𝐨𝐰𝐧 𝐛𝐨𝐲 𝐡𝐨𝐥𝐝𝐬 𝐚 𝐭𝐨𝐫𝐜𝐡 𝐟𝐨𝐫 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐠𝐢𝐫𝐥 𝐰𝐡𝐨 𝐥𝐞𝐟𝐭. 𝐁𝐮𝐭 𝐥𝐢𝐟𝐞 𝐰𝐚𝐬𝐧'𝐭 𝐚 𝐦𝐨𝐯𝐢𝐞. 𝐚𝐧𝐝 𝐬𝐡𝐞 𝐢𝐬 𝐧𝐨𝐭 𝐭𝐡𝐚𝐭 𝐠𝐢𝐫𝐥 𝐚𝐧𝐲𝐦𝐨𝐫𝐞"
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher Bookouture for giving me an early reader digital copy in exchange of an honest review.
July 29, 2025
I received a free copy of, The Cinnamon Spice Inn, by Harper Graham, from the publisher and Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. This is book one, in the Maple Falls, series. Madison Kelly is leaving New York City, to go back home to Maple Falls. I thought this was a nice read, I just prefer romance books that are less, instead of more. The Cinnamon Spice Inn, seems like it would be a lovely place at the holidays.
August 25, 2025
3.75 stars rounded up
The Cinnamon Spice Inn by Harper Graham is a second chance romance that follows Madison and Zach. Madison recently came to visit to help her family's Inn after a mysterious note showed up in her apartment in New York City. During her visit she sees her ex-boyfriend Zach again, who is still the handsome small town boy she left after seeing him with another woman. Madison and Zach must work together to revamp the Inn so the town can get back on track.
What did I think? I loved the cute fall vibes, I give it top marks for that. I also read this book in what I consider to be technically one sitting. I enjoyed myself but sometimes it was like reading a horny teenager's journal which is hilarious and entertaining but I don't know if it was what the book intended. The two main characters were incapable of having a conversation without wanting to jump each other's bones. To be honest, it was a little distracting. I wish there was more substance between them other than they think the other person is hot. But I want to reiterate, I had a great time reading this book.
I would recommend this book to people who enjoy fall vibes as it gives that so much. I do want to point out that the book was also just one big misunderstanding plot so if you don't like misunderstandings this is not for you but if you like them... boy will you love this book! I would also not recommend this book to anyone looking for high stakes, this is a cozy book.
I want to take a second to praise the narrators. I enjoyed them a lot but I did wish it was a duet rather than the male narrator doing the voice of the woman and the woman doing the voice of the male narrator in their chapters. I still want to say that they were both great, I just wished they were great together.
Tropes: misunderstanding, small town, second chance, rivals to lovers, forced proximity, childhood sweethearts
Triggers: death of a parent (mentioned)
Thank you to NetGalley, Bookouture, Bookouture Audio, and Harper Graham for giving me the opportunity to review this ARC. All opinions are my own.
The Cinnamon Spice Inn by Harper Graham is a second chance romance that follows Madison and Zach. Madison recently came to visit to help her family's Inn after a mysterious note showed up in her apartment in New York City. During her visit she sees her ex-boyfriend Zach again, who is still the handsome small town boy she left after seeing him with another woman. Madison and Zach must work together to revamp the Inn so the town can get back on track.
What did I think? I loved the cute fall vibes, I give it top marks for that. I also read this book in what I consider to be technically one sitting. I enjoyed myself but sometimes it was like reading a horny teenager's journal which is hilarious and entertaining but I don't know if it was what the book intended. The two main characters were incapable of having a conversation without wanting to jump each other's bones. To be honest, it was a little distracting. I wish there was more substance between them other than they think the other person is hot. But I want to reiterate, I had a great time reading this book.
I would recommend this book to people who enjoy fall vibes as it gives that so much. I do want to point out that the book was also just one big misunderstanding plot so if you don't like misunderstandings this is not for you but if you like them... boy will you love this book! I would also not recommend this book to anyone looking for high stakes, this is a cozy book.
I want to take a second to praise the narrators. I enjoyed them a lot but I did wish it was a duet rather than the male narrator doing the voice of the woman and the woman doing the voice of the male narrator in their chapters. I still want to say that they were both great, I just wished they were great together.
Tropes: misunderstanding, small town, second chance, rivals to lovers, forced proximity, childhood sweethearts
Triggers: death of a parent (mentioned)
Thank you to NetGalley, Bookouture, Bookouture Audio, and Harper Graham for giving me the opportunity to review this ARC. All opinions are my own.
September 4, 2025
⭐4.5 stars⭐
Just finished reading an advanced copy of a book that was just released on August 28th called, The Cinnamon Spice Inn. This is about Madison, she's a food writer living in New York when she gets an anonymous note telling her to come home that her family's inn needs her. She comes home to find her family's inn is barely getting by and in desperate need of a handyman. And the town handyman just so happens to be her ex, Zach. Madison is the one that got away in Zach's life, and although he agreed to help fix up her family's inn, the last place he wants to be is this close to Madison all the time. Madison decides to relaunch the inn and have a reopening on Halloween, as she is getting the inn ready she can't seem to keep her mind or her eyes off Zach as he's fixing the place up. Zach knows the last time he let himself get close to Madison she left, and he knows her being back is only temporary, yet he can't keep himself away from her. This was such a fun story and a fantastic read to get into the fall mood! The banter, the connection, and the slow burn between the characters of this story were all done so well! I loved the setting of the story with the small town and the inn, it was so easy to picture and it gave Gilmore Girls vibes in all the best ways. Also the continuous mentioning of Apple Butter Cinnamon Rolls throughout the story inspired me to bake some myself! So that's why my review is a little late, because I had to get the ingredients and make my own Apple Butter Cinnamon Rolls for my social media photo to go with my book review! 🧡📚
Thank you to the author, the publisher, and Netgalley for this ARC of The Cinnamon Spice Inn, in exchange for an honest review.
Just finished reading an advanced copy of a book that was just released on August 28th called, The Cinnamon Spice Inn. This is about Madison, she's a food writer living in New York when she gets an anonymous note telling her to come home that her family's inn needs her. She comes home to find her family's inn is barely getting by and in desperate need of a handyman. And the town handyman just so happens to be her ex, Zach. Madison is the one that got away in Zach's life, and although he agreed to help fix up her family's inn, the last place he wants to be is this close to Madison all the time. Madison decides to relaunch the inn and have a reopening on Halloween, as she is getting the inn ready she can't seem to keep her mind or her eyes off Zach as he's fixing the place up. Zach knows the last time he let himself get close to Madison she left, and he knows her being back is only temporary, yet he can't keep himself away from her. This was such a fun story and a fantastic read to get into the fall mood! The banter, the connection, and the slow burn between the characters of this story were all done so well! I loved the setting of the story with the small town and the inn, it was so easy to picture and it gave Gilmore Girls vibes in all the best ways. Also the continuous mentioning of Apple Butter Cinnamon Rolls throughout the story inspired me to bake some myself! So that's why my review is a little late, because I had to get the ingredients and make my own Apple Butter Cinnamon Rolls for my social media photo to go with my book review! 🧡📚
Thank you to the author, the publisher, and Netgalley for this ARC of The Cinnamon Spice Inn, in exchange for an honest review.
August 9, 2025
I am incredibly grateful to Harper Graham, Bookouture, and NetGalley for providing me with an advanced reader copy of "The Cinnamon Spice Inn."
This book is a quintessential autumn romance, a true equivalent of a cozy Hallmark movie with an extra dash of spice! From the very first page, Harper Graham’s writing transports you to the charming small town of Maple Falls in October. She masterfully paints vivid pictures and cozy scenes - think beautiful autumn leaves, light reflecting on the lake, the nostalgic magic of a family's inn, and small yet subtle details which really bring the small town vibe to life.
This story is the romance book equivalent of a delicious sweet treat. Warning, it just might make you have an insane craving for an apple cinnamon vanilla latte. The author has filled this book to the brim with mouthwatering descriptions of all things fall, from cinnamon rolls to decadent desserts. It’s a slow (emphasis on slow) burn romance that lets you savor every moment of the story—perfect for those who love to take their time and marinate in a good read.
You'll find yourself rooting for Madison and Zach, even through all their highs and lows. Their journey is a sweet and heartwarming fall romance about rediscovering first love and taking a chance on a new chapter. Plus, all the animals in the story are adorable, especially the cute puppy named Cocoa, who was a total scene-stealer.
"The Cinnamon Spice Inn" is a perfect book to curl up with a blanket and a cup of cider, light a candle, and celebrate sweater weather. It's an absolute must-read for anyone who is obsessed with fall, summerween, and a reminder to embrace the magic of the season.
A perfect read for fans of:
🍂 Fall romances
❤️ Slow-burn love stories
🎃 Small-town, cozy settings
🍁 Hallmark movies with a little bit of extra spice
This book is a quintessential autumn romance, a true equivalent of a cozy Hallmark movie with an extra dash of spice! From the very first page, Harper Graham’s writing transports you to the charming small town of Maple Falls in October. She masterfully paints vivid pictures and cozy scenes - think beautiful autumn leaves, light reflecting on the lake, the nostalgic magic of a family's inn, and small yet subtle details which really bring the small town vibe to life.
This story is the romance book equivalent of a delicious sweet treat. Warning, it just might make you have an insane craving for an apple cinnamon vanilla latte. The author has filled this book to the brim with mouthwatering descriptions of all things fall, from cinnamon rolls to decadent desserts. It’s a slow (emphasis on slow) burn romance that lets you savor every moment of the story—perfect for those who love to take their time and marinate in a good read.
You'll find yourself rooting for Madison and Zach, even through all their highs and lows. Their journey is a sweet and heartwarming fall romance about rediscovering first love and taking a chance on a new chapter. Plus, all the animals in the story are adorable, especially the cute puppy named Cocoa, who was a total scene-stealer.
"The Cinnamon Spice Inn" is a perfect book to curl up with a blanket and a cup of cider, light a candle, and celebrate sweater weather. It's an absolute must-read for anyone who is obsessed with fall, summerween, and a reminder to embrace the magic of the season.
A perfect read for fans of:
🍂 Fall romances
❤️ Slow-burn love stories
🎃 Small-town, cozy settings
🍁 Hallmark movies with a little bit of extra spice
September 6, 2025
This book felt like a cozy warm hug...
☕🍂
I felt like reading The Cinnamon Spice Inn, owing to its cozy cover. It was giving major fall vibes and I wanted a cozy small town romance. And that is exactly what the book offered!
The story is about Madison who arrives at her family legacy, The Cinnamon Spice Inn, after receiving a mysterious letter. She isn't happy to be back from New York to this little town, especially because of a certain someone named Zach. Zach was her bestfriend and boyfriend that she bid goodbye when she left. Now sparks fly again as the famous couple of the town returns!
This was a second chance romance trope book and I was excited to read how the story would progress. Since it had dual perspectives, both the thoughts of Madison and Zach were shared, which portrayed the feelings they had hidden for each other.
Since Zach resides in the inn, the forced proximity faced by the characters was also explored.
The best thing about this story was how the small town was portrayed. There were times I wished I could stay there. With its cozy inn, apple orchards, nosy but helpful neighbours, and the cafes; the setting had everything one could wish for!
The story also explored the emotional dilemma faced by the characters. While Madison struggled with choosing life at NewYork or at the inn, Zach struggled with the idea of accepting Madison back. This made it seem like the characters struggling with their inner thoughts even while they were in love.
I did enjoy this book and the way it felt. This is perfect for fall season 🍁
☕🍂
I felt like reading The Cinnamon Spice Inn, owing to its cozy cover. It was giving major fall vibes and I wanted a cozy small town romance. And that is exactly what the book offered!
The story is about Madison who arrives at her family legacy, The Cinnamon Spice Inn, after receiving a mysterious letter. She isn't happy to be back from New York to this little town, especially because of a certain someone named Zach. Zach was her bestfriend and boyfriend that she bid goodbye when she left. Now sparks fly again as the famous couple of the town returns!
This was a second chance romance trope book and I was excited to read how the story would progress. Since it had dual perspectives, both the thoughts of Madison and Zach were shared, which portrayed the feelings they had hidden for each other.
Since Zach resides in the inn, the forced proximity faced by the characters was also explored.
The best thing about this story was how the small town was portrayed. There were times I wished I could stay there. With its cozy inn, apple orchards, nosy but helpful neighbours, and the cafes; the setting had everything one could wish for!
The story also explored the emotional dilemma faced by the characters. While Madison struggled with choosing life at NewYork or at the inn, Zach struggled with the idea of accepting Madison back. This made it seem like the characters struggling with their inner thoughts even while they were in love.
I did enjoy this book and the way it felt. This is perfect for fall season 🍁
September 8, 2025
Thanks NetGalley and Bookouture for this ARC read. I thought it was a perfect way to kick off the September month. It was super autumnal and has really got me ready for the fall months 🍂🧡☕️🍁
This book was a super cute small town romance - my favourite trope.
Madison the wmc returned to her hometown after moving to New York the help bring the family business back to life, obviously she bumped into her past lover Zach. Her and Zach were clearly meant to be together but there were a few obstacles in the way! One of them being their communication skills? That annoyed me lol but hey ho it still ended up being a happily ever after with lots of cinnamon rolls and spiced lattes🤎
This book was a super cute small town romance - my favourite trope.
Madison the wmc returned to her hometown after moving to New York the help bring the family business back to life, obviously she bumped into her past lover Zach. Her and Zach were clearly meant to be together but there were a few obstacles in the way! One of them being their communication skills? That annoyed me lol but hey ho it still ended up being a happily ever after with lots of cinnamon rolls and spiced lattes🤎
August 17, 2025
The Cinnamon Spice Inn is a super cozy fall romance.
FMC Madison receives a mysterious note saying that her family's Cinnamon Spice Inn is in dire need of her help. So she packs her bags immediately and heads down to Maple Falls from NYC. When she arrives, she finds the inn to be in worse shape than she had expected, with very few guests on the books. Add to that a storm that causes a roof collapse, and the inn is in trouble of going under. Madison's first night back, she also happens to run into her ex, Zach, whom she walked out on a number of years ago. But, the second she sees Zach again, she is immediately drawn right back in.
MMC Zach has lived in Maple Falls his entire life, and works as a handyman and contractor. So of course, Madison's father calls Zach right over when the roof collapses. Zach does not expect to run into Madison, his ex, whom he sort of never got over. The worst part, he finds himself immediately attracted to her. Zach refuses to allow his feelings through because he cannot handle losing Madison a second time...but will he be able to keep his hands to himself?
This story is super cozy, everything about the town of Maple Falls just screams small town autumn coziness. The Pumpkin Pie Bakery when Madison walks in and describes "The air was warm and filled with scents of cinnamon, vanilla, and freshly brewed coffee." It is a town I would like to live in, "The inn was set along the spring-fed lake, with a walking trail that wrapped around its entire perimeter" what a dream! I love the names of the other stores, ones I hope will potentially be in subsequent books (the next one is referenced at the end of the story!)
I found both Madison and Zach to be equally irritating as they both were bad at communicating. Honestly if they could have just been honest with each other, and NOT make assumptions, they would have avoided a lot of heartbreak! But, their second chance romance is super sweet and a perfect read for fall, or to get you in the mood for cool fall days and warm drinks. I also enjoyed the other characters in the story, Gram, always secretly meddling, and Madison's friends, old and new, were all wonderful. I loved Madison's father, and all his rescued animals.
There is a little spice in this cozy romance as well, but it is relatively mild.
This book is extremely charming and gets you in the mood for cozy blankets, warm fires, yummy treats and pumpkin spice lattes.
Some Fav Quotes:
"The warm dining room with its vaulted ceiling and crackling fire. Nobody could come here and not feel like they were being enclosed in a big, warm hug."
"And yet, there was that magnetic pull deep in her chest. A burning sensation. Like she was a moth being drawn into the flames, ready to be set alight."
"First the sex dream, now this. As if she needed a real-life encore to last night's thoroughly inappropriate fantasy."
"All the while, Zach remained cornered at the bar, sleeves rolled up, forearms flexed, hand wrapped around his tumbler like he owned the room. He looked a hell of a lot sexier than was fair."
"Heaven would've been the coffee Zach had offered her this morning. Fresh, hot, and handed over with those rough hands that used to know every inch of her body."
"God, he was something. Brutal, stubborn, beautiful."
"But that spark between them, the one he'd tried to ignore for years, was still there. Still crackling. Light a match, and they'd go up in flames."
"Focus, she reminded herself fiercely. Smile. Act normal. Do not, under any circumstances, climb him like a tree."
"Bravery isn't always loud. Sometimes it's just showing up when you're unsure. Sometimes it's staying when it would be easier to leave."
"Madison Kelly wasn't just any girl. She was the only one who had ever wrecked him-and the only one he hadn't been able to forget."
Thank you so much to Netgalley, Bookouture, and the author for a copy of this book!
FMC Madison receives a mysterious note saying that her family's Cinnamon Spice Inn is in dire need of her help. So she packs her bags immediately and heads down to Maple Falls from NYC. When she arrives, she finds the inn to be in worse shape than she had expected, with very few guests on the books. Add to that a storm that causes a roof collapse, and the inn is in trouble of going under. Madison's first night back, she also happens to run into her ex, Zach, whom she walked out on a number of years ago. But, the second she sees Zach again, she is immediately drawn right back in.
MMC Zach has lived in Maple Falls his entire life, and works as a handyman and contractor. So of course, Madison's father calls Zach right over when the roof collapses. Zach does not expect to run into Madison, his ex, whom he sort of never got over. The worst part, he finds himself immediately attracted to her. Zach refuses to allow his feelings through because he cannot handle losing Madison a second time...but will he be able to keep his hands to himself?
This story is super cozy, everything about the town of Maple Falls just screams small town autumn coziness. The Pumpkin Pie Bakery when Madison walks in and describes "The air was warm and filled with scents of cinnamon, vanilla, and freshly brewed coffee." It is a town I would like to live in, "The inn was set along the spring-fed lake, with a walking trail that wrapped around its entire perimeter" what a dream! I love the names of the other stores, ones I hope will potentially be in subsequent books (the next one is referenced at the end of the story!)
I found both Madison and Zach to be equally irritating as they both were bad at communicating. Honestly if they could have just been honest with each other, and NOT make assumptions, they would have avoided a lot of heartbreak! But, their second chance romance is super sweet and a perfect read for fall, or to get you in the mood for cool fall days and warm drinks. I also enjoyed the other characters in the story, Gram, always secretly meddling, and Madison's friends, old and new, were all wonderful. I loved Madison's father, and all his rescued animals.
There is a little spice in this cozy romance as well, but it is relatively mild.
This book is extremely charming and gets you in the mood for cozy blankets, warm fires, yummy treats and pumpkin spice lattes.
Some Fav Quotes:
"The warm dining room with its vaulted ceiling and crackling fire. Nobody could come here and not feel like they were being enclosed in a big, warm hug."
"And yet, there was that magnetic pull deep in her chest. A burning sensation. Like she was a moth being drawn into the flames, ready to be set alight."
"First the sex dream, now this. As if she needed a real-life encore to last night's thoroughly inappropriate fantasy."
"All the while, Zach remained cornered at the bar, sleeves rolled up, forearms flexed, hand wrapped around his tumbler like he owned the room. He looked a hell of a lot sexier than was fair."
"Heaven would've been the coffee Zach had offered her this morning. Fresh, hot, and handed over with those rough hands that used to know every inch of her body."
"God, he was something. Brutal, stubborn, beautiful."
"But that spark between them, the one he'd tried to ignore for years, was still there. Still crackling. Light a match, and they'd go up in flames."
"Focus, she reminded herself fiercely. Smile. Act normal. Do not, under any circumstances, climb him like a tree."
"Bravery isn't always loud. Sometimes it's just showing up when you're unsure. Sometimes it's staying when it would be easier to leave."
"Madison Kelly wasn't just any girl. She was the only one who had ever wrecked him-and the only one he hadn't been able to forget."
Thank you so much to Netgalley, Bookouture, and the author for a copy of this book!
August 23, 2025
Thank you Netgalley and Bookouture for the ARC!
I must say that I debated giving the book 3 stars to not bring down the rating too much, but honestly I don’t want to lie 😭
I had so much beef with the plot that I started to think it must be AI generated since some plot points just do not make sense!! Honestly the writing really wasn’t bad, good even for a debut novel. But oh the plot just didn’t make sense to me.
(Spoilers from here on!!)
My icks:
- no seeming concern about a broken roof, it’s also fixed by 1 guy in no time
- seeminly no real concern about the financial aspects of the inn, no budgeting whatsoever even though theyre near financial ruin
- its so weird that in Madison’s pov she calls her relatives by name, switches back and forth (George instead of dad, Edith instead of grandma,…)
- some plot points that are brought up for no reason?? There is drama to make out of these (the woman flirting with him at the start, woman he was set up with on a date, the auction thing,… why bring it up if it serves no purpose? Were parts edited out afterwards?)
- she calls a flat white a ‘strong’ coffee multiple times?? Okay its got some espressos in there but it’s mostly milk though?
- why was Zach okay with Madison hypothetically cheating with him on her ‘bf Jo’ ? Also that misunderstanding was resolved so quickly, there was such a comedic possibility there for plot
- the DONT TALK TO EACH OTHER AT ALL!! After 12 days they’re supposedly in love, they barely talked, this is just lust based on nostalgic love. They could be such different people after not seeing each other for several years, they barely talked so they had no time to get to know each other again. Several years in New York is bound to change a person
- the big smut scene made no sense to me physically. He’s on top of her, also using both his hands on her and somehow thrusting, this man is a miracle.
- Zach was renovating his home ‘for her’. He definitely bought the home before he knew she was coming back. Either he’s that pathetic over his first love that was ‘the one that got away’ or he’s lying.
- they grew up close together and dated for several years before. Madison somehow doesn’t know that he made the butter with his grandma tf.
- the job offer contains a maple falls cook book OF COURSE IT’S SEMI REMOTE SO SHE CAN WRITE IT IN MAPLE FALLS HOLY FUCK. Also the job offer should mention this?
So sorry to the editorial team. But this one should’ve been edited further… the writing itself is really not a problem, but it definitely has some issues regarding the plot and just idk basic train of thought.
Also I found it wild that the acknowledgements didn’t even mention the Dream Harbour series, since it’s very clearly based on the same tropes.
So in general, fall vibes were definitely there. The writing wasn’t bad enough for 1 star, I got through it pretty quickly! But yeah I think it should’ve gone through a few more rounds of editing before being released. This is a Wattpad level book in my opinion. I see a clear intention, but honestly could’ve been written by a 14 year old with a dream.
I really don’t like giving ARC’s ratings this low, but honestly, I think the publishing team needs to know rip.
I don’t have high standards for fun romance novels, but it needs to be said.
I must say that I debated giving the book 3 stars to not bring down the rating too much, but honestly I don’t want to lie 😭
I had so much beef with the plot that I started to think it must be AI generated since some plot points just do not make sense!! Honestly the writing really wasn’t bad, good even for a debut novel. But oh the plot just didn’t make sense to me.
(Spoilers from here on!!)
My icks:
- no seeming concern about a broken roof, it’s also fixed by 1 guy in no time
- seeminly no real concern about the financial aspects of the inn, no budgeting whatsoever even though theyre near financial ruin
- its so weird that in Madison’s pov she calls her relatives by name, switches back and forth (George instead of dad, Edith instead of grandma,…)
- some plot points that are brought up for no reason?? There is drama to make out of these (the woman flirting with him at the start, woman he was set up with on a date, the auction thing,… why bring it up if it serves no purpose? Were parts edited out afterwards?)
- she calls a flat white a ‘strong’ coffee multiple times?? Okay its got some espressos in there but it’s mostly milk though?
- why was Zach okay with Madison hypothetically cheating with him on her ‘bf Jo’ ? Also that misunderstanding was resolved so quickly, there was such a comedic possibility there for plot
- the DONT TALK TO EACH OTHER AT ALL!! After 12 days they’re supposedly in love, they barely talked, this is just lust based on nostalgic love. They could be such different people after not seeing each other for several years, they barely talked so they had no time to get to know each other again. Several years in New York is bound to change a person
- the big smut scene made no sense to me physically. He’s on top of her, also using both his hands on her and somehow thrusting, this man is a miracle.
- Zach was renovating his home ‘for her’. He definitely bought the home before he knew she was coming back. Either he’s that pathetic over his first love that was ‘the one that got away’ or he’s lying.
- they grew up close together and dated for several years before. Madison somehow doesn’t know that he made the butter with his grandma tf.
- the job offer contains a maple falls cook book OF COURSE IT’S SEMI REMOTE SO SHE CAN WRITE IT IN MAPLE FALLS HOLY FUCK. Also the job offer should mention this?
So sorry to the editorial team. But this one should’ve been edited further… the writing itself is really not a problem, but it definitely has some issues regarding the plot and just idk basic train of thought.
Also I found it wild that the acknowledgements didn’t even mention the Dream Harbour series, since it’s very clearly based on the same tropes.
So in general, fall vibes were definitely there. The writing wasn’t bad enough for 1 star, I got through it pretty quickly! But yeah I think it should’ve gone through a few more rounds of editing before being released. This is a Wattpad level book in my opinion. I see a clear intention, but honestly could’ve been written by a 14 year old with a dream.
I really don’t like giving ARC’s ratings this low, but honestly, I think the publishing team needs to know rip.
I don’t have high standards for fun romance novels, but it needs to be said.
July 31, 2025
The Cinnamon Spice Inn gave me all the fall feels. It’s a small-town romance with just the right amount of heartache, hope, and healing. Madison returns home to help her dad save the family inn, only to find that not much has changed…especially her lingering feelings for her ex, Zach. Cue the angst, the banter, and the town that low-key ships them like it’s their full-time job.
There’s so much to love here: a cozy autumn setting, cows named Pumpkin and Spice (SO cute), a dog named Coco, and an old flame doing handyman repairs while trying not to fall back in love. I also really enjoyed the food-centered scenes and how Madison and her friend worked to reinvent the inn’s menu. It added charm and warmth.
But man…the miscommunication trope was everywhere. Every. Where. It made me want to shake the characters more than once. Still, despite the eye rolls, I stayed hooked. The emotional depth, the mystery around the letters, and the reveal about Madison’s dad selling the inn? All of it came together in a way that felt satisfying.
If you like slow burns, second-chance romance, and small towns that feel like home, this one’s worth the read.
Would I recommend this book to you? Yes
Expected Release Date: 08/28/2025
Thank you to NetGalley, the publisher, and the author for the arc. All thoughts in this review are my own.
There’s so much to love here: a cozy autumn setting, cows named Pumpkin and Spice (SO cute), a dog named Coco, and an old flame doing handyman repairs while trying not to fall back in love. I also really enjoyed the food-centered scenes and how Madison and her friend worked to reinvent the inn’s menu. It added charm and warmth.
But man…the miscommunication trope was everywhere. Every. Where. It made me want to shake the characters more than once. Still, despite the eye rolls, I stayed hooked. The emotional depth, the mystery around the letters, and the reveal about Madison’s dad selling the inn? All of it came together in a way that felt satisfying.
If you like slow burns, second-chance romance, and small towns that feel like home, this one’s worth the read.
Would I recommend this book to you? Yes
Expected Release Date: 08/28/2025
Thank you to NetGalley, the publisher, and the author for the arc. All thoughts in this review are my own.
September 2, 2025
ARC review
The Cinnamon Spice inn by Harper Graham
Awww, I absolutely love this story! The chemistry of the main characters is amazing, and the whole book gives me such a cozy fall romance vibes. 🍂✨️
I really enjoyed it - It hooked me right from the start. It has a bit of everything: romance, funnny moments ( the two old ladyes Mrs Bishop and C 😂), and so many heartwarming scenes.
I'm falling in love with all the characters, each one has something special that keeps me turning the pages and totally entertained 😍.
It was such a cute small-town story, and I adored every minute of it.
Favorite quote: "your dream will change and grow. That's okay. Just don't forget to check in with your heart. Don't chase a path just because it looks shiny. And don't stay out of guilt or fear. Stay because it fills you up, even when it's hard. Because you feel more like yourself than you ever have."
This one really hit hard.
Tropes:
Small town
Childhood friends
Second chance
Fall and cozy romance
✨️If you love these tropes, this book is totally for you! 🤗
Thank you Netgalley and Bookouture for a copy of this book. 💗✨️
The Cinnamon Spice inn by Harper Graham
Awww, I absolutely love this story! The chemistry of the main characters is amazing, and the whole book gives me such a cozy fall romance vibes. 🍂✨️
I really enjoyed it - It hooked me right from the start. It has a bit of everything: romance, funnny moments ( the two old ladyes Mrs Bishop and C 😂), and so many heartwarming scenes.
I'm falling in love with all the characters, each one has something special that keeps me turning the pages and totally entertained 😍.
It was such a cute small-town story, and I adored every minute of it.
Favorite quote: "your dream will change and grow. That's okay. Just don't forget to check in with your heart. Don't chase a path just because it looks shiny. And don't stay out of guilt or fear. Stay because it fills you up, even when it's hard. Because you feel more like yourself than you ever have."
This one really hit hard.
Tropes:
Small town
Childhood friends
Second chance
Fall and cozy romance
✨️If you love these tropes, this book is totally for you! 🤗
Thank you Netgalley and Bookouture for a copy of this book. 💗✨️
August 21, 2025
3.5 Stars
The Cinnamon Spice Inn is a solid and genuinely enjoyable entry in the small-town romance genre. It delivers exactly what it promises: a cozy, low-stakes escape with a satisfying second chance arc.
What worked for me was the strong sense of place. Harper Graham does an excellent job making Maple Falls feel lived-in and autumnal without veering into cliché. The renovation of the inn provided a great backdrop, and the descriptions of the food and the town's Halloween festivities were a highlight, adding texture without slowing the pace.
The central relationship between Madison and Zach is well-executed. Their conflict felt believable, and their chemistry was convincing. I appreciated that their bickering had a foundation in past history rather than just petty misunderstandings. The supporting cast, including a very cute puppy, added warmth without overshadowing the main plot.
Overall, this is a highly readable and charming novel perfect for readers seeking a comforting, seasonal romance with heart and a tangible sense of atmosphere.
Thank you Netgalley and Bookouture for the ARC. I will certainly look for the next in the series.
The Cinnamon Spice Inn is a solid and genuinely enjoyable entry in the small-town romance genre. It delivers exactly what it promises: a cozy, low-stakes escape with a satisfying second chance arc.
What worked for me was the strong sense of place. Harper Graham does an excellent job making Maple Falls feel lived-in and autumnal without veering into cliché. The renovation of the inn provided a great backdrop, and the descriptions of the food and the town's Halloween festivities were a highlight, adding texture without slowing the pace.
The central relationship between Madison and Zach is well-executed. Their conflict felt believable, and their chemistry was convincing. I appreciated that their bickering had a foundation in past history rather than just petty misunderstandings. The supporting cast, including a very cute puppy, added warmth without overshadowing the main plot.
Overall, this is a highly readable and charming novel perfect for readers seeking a comforting, seasonal romance with heart and a tangible sense of atmosphere.
Thank you Netgalley and Bookouture for the ARC. I will certainly look for the next in the series.
August 25, 2025
In case your fall spirit is nowhere to be found...
You know the drill—it’s time to switch your coffee order and your books to 𓇢𓆱 autumn 𓇢𓆱 .
The Cinnamon Spice Inn was exactly what The Pumpkin Spice Café was for me last year—the perfect transition into fall.
I’m such a weakling when it comes to second-chance romance… but if they’re high school sweethearts? Hold me, five people.
The town, the inn setting, Madison and Zach gave me the exact same feeling I get watching my ultimate fall show… you guessed it: Gilmore Girls.
The story is a little messy, nostalgic, with a sprinkle of mystery.
But beware—miscommunication is out there slaying souls...
This book also felt like a set-up for a future series. These new, wonderful women just kept popping up...
This is a lighthearted, quick read that captures the fall spirit beautifully. Just don’t expect it to dig too deep—it’s more about the cozy vibes than anything groundbreaking.
Thank you to NetGalley and Bookouture Audio for early access to the audiobook!
˙⋆.˚୨ৎ tropes ୨ৎ˙⋆.˚
💌 Second chance
🛤️ Small town
☕️ Fall setting
˙⋆.˚୨ৎ ria’s romance rating scale ୨ৎ˙⋆.˚
• plot 68/100
• writing 69/100
• characters 63/100
• giggle & feet-kick-ability 69/100
• general enjoyment 67/100
• cringe -0/-100
2/5 🌶️
total: 336
*500-451 - 6 stars
450-401 - 5 stars
400-341 - 4 stars
340-201 - 3 stars
200-101 - 2 stars
100-0 - 1 star
You know the drill—it’s time to switch your coffee order and your books to 𓇢𓆱 autumn 𓇢𓆱 .
The Cinnamon Spice Inn was exactly what The Pumpkin Spice Café was for me last year—the perfect transition into fall.
I’m such a weakling when it comes to second-chance romance… but if they’re high school sweethearts? Hold me, five people.
The town, the inn setting, Madison and Zach gave me the exact same feeling I get watching my ultimate fall show… you guessed it: Gilmore Girls.
The story is a little messy, nostalgic, with a sprinkle of mystery.
But beware—miscommunication is out there slaying souls...
This book also felt like a set-up for a future series. These new, wonderful women just kept popping up...
This is a lighthearted, quick read that captures the fall spirit beautifully. Just don’t expect it to dig too deep—it’s more about the cozy vibes than anything groundbreaking.
Thank you to NetGalley and Bookouture Audio for early access to the audiobook!
˙⋆.˚୨ৎ tropes ୨ৎ˙⋆.˚
💌 Second chance
🛤️ Small town
☕️ Fall setting
˙⋆.˚୨ৎ ria’s romance rating scale ୨ৎ˙⋆.˚
• plot 68/100
• writing 69/100
• characters 63/100
• giggle & feet-kick-ability 69/100
• general enjoyment 67/100
• cringe -0/-100
2/5 🌶️
total: 336
*500-451 - 6 stars
450-401 - 5 stars
400-341 - 4 stars
340-201 - 3 stars
200-101 - 2 stars
100-0 - 1 star
August 18, 2025
The Cinnamon Spice Inn by Harper Graham
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing me with a copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.
The Cinnamon Spice Inn was everything I could have hoped for in a cozy, small-town, second chance romance. From the very first chapter, I was swept into the charm of the town and the warmth of the story. It’s the kind of book that feels like wrapping yourself in a blanket with a cup of tea—comforting, heartfelt, and completely engrossing.
The romance was so sweet and genuine, perfectly balancing tender moments with the nostalgia of two people finding their way back to each other. I absolutely adored the characters—they felt real, relatable, and loveable, which made it impossible not to root for their happily ever after. The small-town setting was brought to life beautifully, adding an extra layer of coziness that made this the perfect seasonal read.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing me with a copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.
The Cinnamon Spice Inn was everything I could have hoped for in a cozy, small-town, second chance romance. From the very first chapter, I was swept into the charm of the town and the warmth of the story. It’s the kind of book that feels like wrapping yourself in a blanket with a cup of tea—comforting, heartfelt, and completely engrossing.
The romance was so sweet and genuine, perfectly balancing tender moments with the nostalgia of two people finding their way back to each other. I absolutely adored the characters—they felt real, relatable, and loveable, which made it impossible not to root for their happily ever after. The small-town setting was brought to life beautifully, adding an extra layer of coziness that made this the perfect seasonal read.
August 30, 2025
I wish wish wish wish I enjoyed this book more. And honestly I wish this book was better than it is.
Vibes (or the idea of) were there, seasonal cosiness sort of as well, I loved the small town and the secondary characters, but nothing was keeping me connected to the story nor to the FMC and MMC and their romance.
Things were not engaging, I was not rooting for them, and I am not interested in finding out what happens (especially not after reading some reviews).
I knew it would be an uphill battle for me as I do not like second chance romances, but there was nothing for me in the romance to enjoy.
The story / writing style was not for me– it felt rushed, there was a lack of atmosphere and ambiance, and when I noticed I kept thinking about other things than the story, I thought it was time to stop reading and go with another book.
I had high hopes for this book and was ready to make this into my new personality (as I have done with the Dream Harbor series by Laurie Gilmore). Too bad!!
Half a star for the amazing cover.
2.5 stars rounded down.
DNF @ 32%.
(I will probably buy this book if I see it for 3 pounds at the Works, because that cover!!!! Lovely. Here is to hoping!)
Vibes (or the idea of) were there, seasonal cosiness sort of as well, I loved the small town and the secondary characters, but nothing was keeping me connected to the story nor to the FMC and MMC and their romance.
Things were not engaging, I was not rooting for them, and I am not interested in finding out what happens (especially not after reading some reviews).
I knew it would be an uphill battle for me as I do not like second chance romances, but there was nothing for me in the romance to enjoy.
The story / writing style was not for me– it felt rushed, there was a lack of atmosphere and ambiance, and when I noticed I kept thinking about other things than the story, I thought it was time to stop reading and go with another book.
I had high hopes for this book and was ready to make this into my new personality (as I have done with the Dream Harbor series by Laurie Gilmore). Too bad!!
Half a star for the amazing cover.
2.5 stars rounded down.
DNF @ 32%.
(I will probably buy this book if I see it for 3 pounds at the Works, because that cover!!!! Lovely. Here is to hoping!)
August 22, 2025
Thank you so much to Bookouture for sending me an advanced copy of The Cinnamon Spice in by Harper Graham in exchange for an honest review!
Overall, this was such a cute & cosy book! It made me excited for autumn and all the cinnamon buns, gorgeous sunsets & cosy jumpers! The mystery letters were a nice wee touch & came to an emotional climax.
I feel like the enemies-to-lovers trope isn't 100% accurate for this. They disliked each other, but there's a lot of history there & the pining started pretty early on in the book from both Madison & Zach.
The mis-communication trope is one of THE most frustrating tropes on the go because something that happened 6 years ago could have been resolved by a 5 minute conversation!
Gram was a wee meddler 😂
I'd recommend it if you're looking for something to get you in the mood for autumn 🥰🍁
Overall, this was such a cute & cosy book! It made me excited for autumn and all the cinnamon buns, gorgeous sunsets & cosy jumpers! The mystery letters were a nice wee touch & came to an emotional climax.
I feel like the enemies-to-lovers trope isn't 100% accurate for this. They disliked each other, but there's a lot of history there & the pining started pretty early on in the book from both Madison & Zach.
The mis-communication trope is one of THE most frustrating tropes on the go because something that happened 6 years ago could have been resolved by a 5 minute conversation!
Gram was a wee meddler 😂
I'd recommend it if you're looking for something to get you in the mood for autumn 🥰🍁
Displaying 1 - 30 of 758 reviews