What do you think?
Rate this book
A Sherlock Holmes Devotional: Uncovering the Mysteries of God
After a century, Sherlock Holmes mysteries still fascinate us—and this devotional will delight you with spiritual truths drawn from the pages of the classic detective stories. A Sherlock Holmes Devotional contains 60 entries drawn from the characters, stories, and events of the Holmes canon. From 221b Baker Street to Reichenbach Falls, from Irene Adler to the evil Dr. Moriarty, from the pipe to the violin, this book investigates the spiritual truths we can discern from this enigmatic fictional character—a brusque, stubborn, and arrogant man who also shows honor, trust, and self-sacrificing friendship. It’s a fascinating read for fans of the series—or those yet to meet the great detective!
320 pages, Paperback
First published July 1, 2015
11 people are currently reading
109 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 28 of 28 reviews
August 23, 2015
I adore this devotional based on lessons from the works of Sherlock Holmes! Each chapter focuses on a particular quote, or a quality of Holmes and Watson, or one of their adventures, and weaves a similarity between that concept and the Christian life. Although Conan Doyle was not a notable Christian and Holmes is somewhat ambiguous about his beliefs, there are still lessons to be learned from the stories!
My only problem was that sometimes the lesson to be taught from the Holmes story was really a stretch. The spiritual points reached were not at all similar to Doyle's writing, and it felt like the author was trying too hard to make a comparison that just isn't there. But that didn't happen too often. Most of the time the concept from Doyle's writing works with the devotion portion of the chapter.
I loved all the details from the stories, the background on Conan Doyle, and the history of the Victorian times. There are lots of quotes from the books, and references to the movies and generations of fans... it's just wonderful! The author really researched the whole world of Sherlock; they definitely know their stuff.
Each chapter begins with a quote from Holmes, and ends with a Scripture verse. What a delightful way to bookend the chapters! The devotional parts are very inspirational, and give sound truths in a concise and clear way. The Sherlockian in me is so happy right now!
Disclaimer: I received this book from the publisher in exchange for a free and honest review. The opinions stated here are my own true thoughts, and are not influenced by anyone.
My only problem was that sometimes the lesson to be taught from the Holmes story was really a stretch. The spiritual points reached were not at all similar to Doyle's writing, and it felt like the author was trying too hard to make a comparison that just isn't there. But that didn't happen too often. Most of the time the concept from Doyle's writing works with the devotion portion of the chapter.
I loved all the details from the stories, the background on Conan Doyle, and the history of the Victorian times. There are lots of quotes from the books, and references to the movies and generations of fans... it's just wonderful! The author really researched the whole world of Sherlock; they definitely know their stuff.
Each chapter begins with a quote from Holmes, and ends with a Scripture verse. What a delightful way to bookend the chapters! The devotional parts are very inspirational, and give sound truths in a concise and clear way. The Sherlockian in me is so happy right now!
Disclaimer: I received this book from the publisher in exchange for a free and honest review. The opinions stated here are my own true thoughts, and are not influenced by anyone.
November 8, 2015
RESEÑA COMPLETA EN ESPAÑOL
Discovering the mysteries of God in a very Sherlock Holmes style.
I'm a Sherlockian since long ago, and I like to read almost everything that mentions his name. However, sometimes I don’t like the adaptations or new novels that are written because I don’t think it's the same Holmes Sir Arthur Conan Doyle wrote.
Instead, this book was a delight to my eyes and my heart.
The author has sharp detective skills, because she takes the novels and stories of Holmes and turns them into daily lessons about God. This is not a book of finding God in Holmes stories, but learning from him to know God.
Each page was a refreshingly new way to discover the mysteries of God, besides it’s very enjoyable and an entertaining read. I also liked that included Bible verses to accompany each lesson, and thus lead to further reflection.
If you haven’t read about Holmes, you can still read this devotional because it can also function as an introduction to his books.
I wish everyone would read this book, because so far this year, is one of the best books I've read!
December 22, 2015
This book provides readers with how to look at the literary character of Sherlock Holmes from a Christian perspective, and furthermore, using the art of deduction to find God's everlasting mercies in your life. It's a unique, one-of-a-kind book, which combines two big things in my life: a fictional detective who has stood the test of time and God, who created time itself and everything in it.
The author grabs your attention immediately by beginning each devotional with an introduction on a topic either about Sherlock himself, a case he encountered, or the characters that frequent 221B Baker Street. She than switches the lens to focus in on the subject paired with scriptures that uncover the true motives behind popular features of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's stories. As the layers peel off, it is fascinating for me to see further into these snippets of literature than ever before. While reading Trisha White Priebe's book I began to perceive more things about Holmes and to renew my thoughts towards the Almighty.
"Truth: Sherlock Holmes found more of a friend in Dr. Watson than he ever did in his own brother, Mycroft. We, too, have a Friend who sticks closer than a brother." (Chapter 10, A Sherlock Holmes Devotional)
Fans of the Victorian-era detective, will delight in all of the interesting facts and "behind the scenes" information concerning their favorite fictional character and his author. While you're learning these thrilling things of historical import, the author is also revealing amazing truths about God and His unending love for His children.
"Even if our trials never make sense to us in this life, we can be certain they make sense to God. The tangles and knots we view from this vantage point will appear as a perfect work of art when studied from the perspective of heaven." (Chapter 5, A Sherlock Holmes Devotional)
Page after page, be prepared for awe and surprise. There are 60 devotionals in the book, and while I tried to pace myself to only read 1 a day (thinking that I could enjoy it for 2 whole months), I finished it quicker than I anticipated to, by "sheer accident".
I took many notes while reading it... of well-phrased words to remind me of His amazing grace, and also many intriguing things about a certain detective who never even took a breath. It's all just TOO GOOD. Wouldn't you like to know about Doyle's posthumous story just published in 2001? Or how U.S. presidents such as Franklin D. Roosevelt and Harry S. Truman took to Sherlock Holmes? Or even whom the evil Moriarty's character was based upon?
This was the perfect book for me --- so happy to have found it when I did! I'll probably have to read it again one day, after I finish reading the entire Holmes canon.
Keep "A Sherlock Holmes Devotional" in mind for your Holmesian friends who enjoy the art of deducing.
Thanks to the author and Netgalley for the free review copy.
The author grabs your attention immediately by beginning each devotional with an introduction on a topic either about Sherlock himself, a case he encountered, or the characters that frequent 221B Baker Street. She than switches the lens to focus in on the subject paired with scriptures that uncover the true motives behind popular features of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's stories. As the layers peel off, it is fascinating for me to see further into these snippets of literature than ever before. While reading Trisha White Priebe's book I began to perceive more things about Holmes and to renew my thoughts towards the Almighty.
"Truth: Sherlock Holmes found more of a friend in Dr. Watson than he ever did in his own brother, Mycroft. We, too, have a Friend who sticks closer than a brother." (Chapter 10, A Sherlock Holmes Devotional)
Fans of the Victorian-era detective, will delight in all of the interesting facts and "behind the scenes" information concerning their favorite fictional character and his author. While you're learning these thrilling things of historical import, the author is also revealing amazing truths about God and His unending love for His children.
"Even if our trials never make sense to us in this life, we can be certain they make sense to God. The tangles and knots we view from this vantage point will appear as a perfect work of art when studied from the perspective of heaven." (Chapter 5, A Sherlock Holmes Devotional)
Page after page, be prepared for awe and surprise. There are 60 devotionals in the book, and while I tried to pace myself to only read 1 a day (thinking that I could enjoy it for 2 whole months), I finished it quicker than I anticipated to, by "sheer accident".
I took many notes while reading it... of well-phrased words to remind me of His amazing grace, and also many intriguing things about a certain detective who never even took a breath. It's all just TOO GOOD. Wouldn't you like to know about Doyle's posthumous story just published in 2001? Or how U.S. presidents such as Franklin D. Roosevelt and Harry S. Truman took to Sherlock Holmes? Or even whom the evil Moriarty's character was based upon?
This was the perfect book for me --- so happy to have found it when I did! I'll probably have to read it again one day, after I finish reading the entire Holmes canon.
Keep "A Sherlock Holmes Devotional" in mind for your Holmesian friends who enjoy the art of deducing.
Thanks to the author and Netgalley for the free review copy.
April 8, 2015
An interesting, engaging and thoughtful pairing of spiritual truths with the irresistible methods of Sherlock Holmes. Delving deeply into the canon, wrought with fantastic research and anecdotes and excavating the humanity behind the automatonic detective, Priebe extols the virtues of the science of mystery against the fascination of religion. Indeed, is there any better parallel of faith than Watson believing so greatly in Holmes' methods despite his all-too-human limitations when it comes to understanding his friend's great mind?
December 31, 2017
This is effectively a bible study aid which can be used over a couple of months. Here are 60 illustrations from the writing of Arthur Conan Doyle about the most famous detective Sherlock Holmes. Using a quote from on of these stories the writer goes on to give the points far more significance through the Word of God. Rich in biblical reference and a point to think about this book would make an excellent tool for a christian’s quiet time.
Growing up I remember a minister in our church who always seemed to dwell upon the latest episodes of Doctor Who to bring his sermons alive. Unfortunately you lost any spiritual lessons as they were seldom linked back and referenced to the Bible or the life and teachings of Jesus.
No such accusation could be levelled here the balance is just about right and the clear message relates to a spiritual lesson.
The author therefore writes clearly and with little repetition uplifting thoughts based on biblical teaching. What makes it special is the departure point which remarkably lies in 60 quotes from Doyle’s stories about Holmes and Watson.
Perhaps a book for the Sherlock fan or detective mystery lover. It isn’t a magic trick to deceive the reader, rather a reflection on these works from 100 years ago to help one’s devotions. The reader will learn some Holmes information in passing but the purpose of the book is to bring the reader closer to God and have a deeper love for the Bible.
Growing up I remember a minister in our church who always seemed to dwell upon the latest episodes of Doctor Who to bring his sermons alive. Unfortunately you lost any spiritual lessons as they were seldom linked back and referenced to the Bible or the life and teachings of Jesus.
No such accusation could be levelled here the balance is just about right and the clear message relates to a spiritual lesson.
The author therefore writes clearly and with little repetition uplifting thoughts based on biblical teaching. What makes it special is the departure point which remarkably lies in 60 quotes from Doyle’s stories about Holmes and Watson.
Perhaps a book for the Sherlock fan or detective mystery lover. It isn’t a magic trick to deceive the reader, rather a reflection on these works from 100 years ago to help one’s devotions. The reader will learn some Holmes information in passing but the purpose of the book is to bring the reader closer to God and have a deeper love for the Bible.
October 14, 2015
I'm not usually a fan of devotionals that try to mesh secular things with the spiritual. Actually, I'm a little wary of devotionals in general because I find that a lot of people use them instead of actual Bible reading, and are more inclined to trust other authors' interpretations than what the Bible actually says. That's why, when I first saw this book several months ago, I passed it by without a second glance.
However, I've been thinking lately that you really can't divide the world into the "spiritual" and the "secular"- God is Lord of all, even entertainment. And while I still do not at all like when people try to "sanitize" truly ungodly things, I do think that if one has a Christian worldview, then that mindset while affect how you look at everything.
Even fictional detectives.
So, as I was browsing netgalley (newly encouraged to try more ebooks now that I have a smartphone) I rather impulsively-and still full if misgivings about it- selected this book.
I think what made this book work was that the author didn't try to sugarcoat or Christian-ize everything. The author was just as good in using Sherlock Holmes as an example of what not to do as much (or even more, to tell the truth) as what one should do. I liked how the lessons weren't just drawn from the stories themselves, but also from the life of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle or even the different Sherlockian societies today. The author never pretended that Sherlock Holmes was some sort of Christian literature, but proved there were lessons to be learned from the books nevertheless. I admit that there were a few times that there was a disconnect between the Holmes quote/example and the Biblical application where I felt the author might have been trying a little too hard to make it work, but overall I surprised by how much I got out of it. (I fully admit I was not expecting to be impressed)
One of my favorite bits was when the author used the quote, "You see but you do not observe" to illustrate how we often read the Bible: mindlessly, taking in the words without thinking about what it really means or how we can apply them to our own lives. Her words on foolishness and society's tendency to gloss over such behavior and make excuses for it was also good. Honestly, there was very little (if any) theological points that I found I disagreed with.
Another thing I liked was that several times she quoted theologians and pastors who lived around the same time that Conan Doyle was writing, such as Charles Spurgeon, Dietrich Bonhoeffer, and C.S. Lewis.
Of course, I don't need to tell you that like any devotional, this isn't something to replace personal Bible reading. And, while deeper than I thought it would be, it's still more on the "fluff" end of the theological spectrum. But that doesn't mean that it doesn't have good lessons to impart, and perhaps might be good companion material to use while reading the Sherlock Holmes stories themselves. Still, I would use it more as a literary resource than a Biblical one.
I received this ebook for free from netgalley.com in exchange for my honest review.
However, I've been thinking lately that you really can't divide the world into the "spiritual" and the "secular"- God is Lord of all, even entertainment. And while I still do not at all like when people try to "sanitize" truly ungodly things, I do think that if one has a Christian worldview, then that mindset while affect how you look at everything.
Even fictional detectives.
So, as I was browsing netgalley (newly encouraged to try more ebooks now that I have a smartphone) I rather impulsively-and still full if misgivings about it- selected this book.
I think what made this book work was that the author didn't try to sugarcoat or Christian-ize everything. The author was just as good in using Sherlock Holmes as an example of what not to do as much (or even more, to tell the truth) as what one should do. I liked how the lessons weren't just drawn from the stories themselves, but also from the life of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle or even the different Sherlockian societies today. The author never pretended that Sherlock Holmes was some sort of Christian literature, but proved there were lessons to be learned from the books nevertheless. I admit that there were a few times that there was a disconnect between the Holmes quote/example and the Biblical application where I felt the author might have been trying a little too hard to make it work, but overall I surprised by how much I got out of it. (I fully admit I was not expecting to be impressed)
One of my favorite bits was when the author used the quote, "You see but you do not observe" to illustrate how we often read the Bible: mindlessly, taking in the words without thinking about what it really means or how we can apply them to our own lives. Her words on foolishness and society's tendency to gloss over such behavior and make excuses for it was also good. Honestly, there was very little (if any) theological points that I found I disagreed with.
Another thing I liked was that several times she quoted theologians and pastors who lived around the same time that Conan Doyle was writing, such as Charles Spurgeon, Dietrich Bonhoeffer, and C.S. Lewis.
Of course, I don't need to tell you that like any devotional, this isn't something to replace personal Bible reading. And, while deeper than I thought it would be, it's still more on the "fluff" end of the theological spectrum. But that doesn't mean that it doesn't have good lessons to impart, and perhaps might be good companion material to use while reading the Sherlock Holmes stories themselves. Still, I would use it more as a literary resource than a Biblical one.
I received this ebook for free from netgalley.com in exchange for my honest review.
July 25, 2015
Every once in a while I read a book that is just trying way too hard to be cool. Sadly, this is one of those books.
Sherlock Holmes was an amazing detective. The Bible is an amazing book. So why not make a Sherlock Holmes devotional? The answer is because the two are about totally different things, and when you try to make a secular thing spiritual, you end up with poison.
I requested this book with suspicion (the same publisher had a bunch of other awesome-looking books, and this was the only one I was iffy about), but I hoped it would surprise and maybe impress me. Sadly, it’s actually worse than I imagined.
For example: The first devotional is about the Case of the Cardboard Box, where a woman has a package delivered to her with two severed ears. The devotional goes on to praise Sherlock for solving the crime, and then diverts to “We can hear the voice of God. Sherlock said the ear is amazing. See how these two are connected?” And yes obviously that’s a paraphrase. But it was the point of the devotional.
In staying in this same idea, let me tell you a story and give you a practical on how it made me feel.
Did you know in the Appalachian mountains, some people put Mountain Dew in their babies bottles? It’s cheaper than milk and the kids get addicted to it young. Obviously it causes major health issues like diabetes and sever obesity, the kids end up loosing their teeth before they even break skin, and (though I haven’t researched it, I’m sure) that some have died.
In the same way, the Bible tells us that newer Christians thrive on smaller amounts of doctrine, simple statements of truth. In the new testament, a Christian not moving past that stage is considered an adult still drinking baby milk. But the milk isn’t enough, and eventually, their faith will die if they don’t move forward. So Mountain Dew is like Baby Milk. See how the two are connected?
Sorry, but this book isn’t baby food. It’s poison. I love Sherlock and I love Jesus. But I find this book offensive
Sherlock Holmes was an amazing detective. The Bible is an amazing book. So why not make a Sherlock Holmes devotional? The answer is because the two are about totally different things, and when you try to make a secular thing spiritual, you end up with poison.
I requested this book with suspicion (the same publisher had a bunch of other awesome-looking books, and this was the only one I was iffy about), but I hoped it would surprise and maybe impress me. Sadly, it’s actually worse than I imagined.
For example: The first devotional is about the Case of the Cardboard Box, where a woman has a package delivered to her with two severed ears. The devotional goes on to praise Sherlock for solving the crime, and then diverts to “We can hear the voice of God. Sherlock said the ear is amazing. See how these two are connected?” And yes obviously that’s a paraphrase. But it was the point of the devotional.
In staying in this same idea, let me tell you a story and give you a practical on how it made me feel.
Did you know in the Appalachian mountains, some people put Mountain Dew in their babies bottles? It’s cheaper than milk and the kids get addicted to it young. Obviously it causes major health issues like diabetes and sever obesity, the kids end up loosing their teeth before they even break skin, and (though I haven’t researched it, I’m sure) that some have died.
In the same way, the Bible tells us that newer Christians thrive on smaller amounts of doctrine, simple statements of truth. In the new testament, a Christian not moving past that stage is considered an adult still drinking baby milk. But the milk isn’t enough, and eventually, their faith will die if they don’t move forward. So Mountain Dew is like Baby Milk. See how the two are connected?
Sorry, but this book isn’t baby food. It’s poison. I love Sherlock and I love Jesus. But I find this book offensive
June 17, 2015
BRAVO BRAVO!
At first, I didn't have too high hopes for this book. "Ho-Hum" I thought, when I saw the approach of the author. Sherlock Holmes and Christian theology? How will that work?
Oops--I was dead wrong.
The author takes selected passages from the Sherlock Holmes "Canon" and relates them to the Bible and Christian life. Each chapter is just a few pages long, and starts with an interesting theme from the stories. Usually, it involves an observation or quotation from Holmes. Then, Trisha relates that to some key aspect of the Christian life.
For example, the author explains what true humility is. It is not a focus on your own flaws--it is a focus AWAY from yourself. Nicely stated! I had never thought of it that way.
The author is obviously a well-read Christian, and thoroughly sound in her Christian doctrine. (How many authors know enough theology to quote Jonathan Edwards and Andrew Murray?)
Honestly, I am HUGELY IMPRESSED with this book. I seriously misjudged both the book and the author. Fun to read about Holmes, and inspiring (and sometimes sobering) practical theology.
Sample copy for impartial review.
At first, I didn't have too high hopes for this book. "Ho-Hum" I thought, when I saw the approach of the author. Sherlock Holmes and Christian theology? How will that work?
Oops--I was dead wrong.
The author takes selected passages from the Sherlock Holmes "Canon" and relates them to the Bible and Christian life. Each chapter is just a few pages long, and starts with an interesting theme from the stories. Usually, it involves an observation or quotation from Holmes. Then, Trisha relates that to some key aspect of the Christian life.
For example, the author explains what true humility is. It is not a focus on your own flaws--it is a focus AWAY from yourself. Nicely stated! I had never thought of it that way.
The author is obviously a well-read Christian, and thoroughly sound in her Christian doctrine. (How many authors know enough theology to quote Jonathan Edwards and Andrew Murray?)
Honestly, I am HUGELY IMPRESSED with this book. I seriously misjudged both the book and the author. Fun to read about Holmes, and inspiring (and sometimes sobering) practical theology.
Sample copy for impartial review.
September 11, 2015
An interesting concept and Ms. Priebe executed it nicely, flanking each study with a quote from the Sherlock Holmes stories at the beginning and ending with a Bible verse. Each devotional study has a theme that invites contemplation, but doesn't dive deep into scriptures to find meaning of it. Using the art of deduction in which Sherlock Holmes, as a character is known for, readers can seek the many mysteries of the Bible and in the end learn and know more about God. It was an easy read, most of the studies do make sense and does stimulate thought, but because of the concept, some areas, I find Ms. Priebe trying to hard to coordinate or corroborate between Sherlock Holmes and a need to make it a sound devotional. For any Sherlock fan, I think this is a great read because it ultimately allows others to see that God is in everything, even in secular works.
NOTE: I received a complimentary e-copy of this book from the publisher, Barbour Publishing through Net Galley for an honest review.
For more book reviews and giveaways, check out my blog at: http://justcommonly.blogspot.com
NOTE: I received a complimentary e-copy of this book from the publisher, Barbour Publishing through Net Galley for an honest review.
For more book reviews and giveaways, check out my blog at: http://justcommonly.blogspot.com
October 16, 2015
As a Sherlockian and a Christian, I was pleased that these two things were put together, and very pleased at it's outcome! It uses bits and pieces of Sherlock's skills and adventures. It then relates them to a Christian Devotional topic. Thank you, NetGalley, for this free review ebook!
April 23, 2015
My favorite devotional by far!!!
I love Sherlock, so this book was perfect for me. I loved how the author connect Holmes' cases with the Bible and God. It was a refreshing and a blessed reading.
I love Sherlock, so this book was perfect for me. I loved how the author connect Holmes' cases with the Bible and God. It was a refreshing and a blessed reading.
August 24, 2018
Title: A Sherlock Holmes Devotional
Author: Trisha White Priebe
Genre: Christian, Nonfiction, Devotional, Spiritual
Plot: In a world filled with devotionals for everyone in every walk of faith at every age and written for every schedule type, there are a few that stand out as unique and this is one of them. Using the classic mysteries which have entertained and fascinated us for over a century, Trisha Priebe delves into the mysteries of God with a detective's enthusiasm and comes up with some surprising insights into our favorite detective as well as some words of truth and encouragement which have stood the test of time.
And since this is such a unique devotional, it is perfect for the novice Sherlock reader and the die-hard fan alike as well as fitting in perfectly with a season of time with the Lord or a unit study on Sherlock Holmes and the Victorian era.
Likes/Dislikes: While I didn't finish this book (I had a baby which can really take away from book reading, sadly), I did enjoy the first half and fully intend to revisit it again. And when my kids are older, I'm going to go all homeschool mom on them and incorporate this into their Sherlock Holmes/Victorian era faze for maximum benefits. I liked how there were new insights into Sherlock which I missed or didn't remember when I read the mysteries. So cool.
Rating: PG-12 and up, mainly for reading level. Geared more toward teens and adults.
Date Review Written: August 24th, 2018
I received a copy of this book courtesy of Netgalley and wasn't required to write a positive review. The opinions expressed in the above review are my own.
Author: Trisha White Priebe
Genre: Christian, Nonfiction, Devotional, Spiritual
Plot: In a world filled with devotionals for everyone in every walk of faith at every age and written for every schedule type, there are a few that stand out as unique and this is one of them. Using the classic mysteries which have entertained and fascinated us for over a century, Trisha Priebe delves into the mysteries of God with a detective's enthusiasm and comes up with some surprising insights into our favorite detective as well as some words of truth and encouragement which have stood the test of time.
And since this is such a unique devotional, it is perfect for the novice Sherlock reader and the die-hard fan alike as well as fitting in perfectly with a season of time with the Lord or a unit study on Sherlock Holmes and the Victorian era.
Likes/Dislikes: While I didn't finish this book (I had a baby which can really take away from book reading, sadly), I did enjoy the first half and fully intend to revisit it again. And when my kids are older, I'm going to go all homeschool mom on them and incorporate this into their Sherlock Holmes/Victorian era faze for maximum benefits. I liked how there were new insights into Sherlock which I missed or didn't remember when I read the mysteries. So cool.
Rating: PG-12 and up, mainly for reading level. Geared more toward teens and adults.
Date Review Written: August 24th, 2018
I received a copy of this book courtesy of Netgalley and wasn't required to write a positive review. The opinions expressed in the above review are my own.
May 1, 2019
Some people may feel the connections the author made between elements in the Sherlock Holmes stories and the mysteries or character of God might be a bit of a stretch, but I really enjoyed it. I love bookish references and Sherlock Holmes is a favorite literary character of mine. I gathered some nuggets of wisdom and enjoyed learning more about Christian living and our relationship with God and others.
July 17, 2019
This actually inspired me to do a devotional of my own. It’ll be a while before it gets released, though. I love how this one ties in excerpts from the story to spiritual life lessons.
October 25, 2020
The juxtaposition of Sherlock Holmes and devotional in the title caught my interest. Priebe however found more God in the Holmes stories than I would have expected.
July 15, 2023
Greatly enjoyed this devotional! It added a new perspective and tied in the fictional story well with scripture.
March 17, 2017
My only complaint was that I felt like I was learning more about Sherlock Holmes than about God.
November 14, 2015
Since 1887, when Sherlock Holmes first stalked into the public arena through the creative writing of Arthur Conan Doyle, readers have been captivated by his elevated senses and deductive reasoning.
Trisha White Priebe notes that the internet abounds with information, references, books, fan clubs and societies all captivated by Sherlock Holmes. In fact, a Sherlockian is known to be an enthusiast who studies the stories and writing of Arthur Conan Doyle and the stories and utterances of Sherlock Holmes.
But while Doyle's popular works of fiction are impressive, they cannot compare with God's Word. Trisha reminds us that God has given us the Scriptures as a means of knowing and loving Him more. Do we study it as passionately as devotees of Sherlock Holmes? Do we share and discuss it's passages? Do we commit it to heart?
Through this series of devotions, she leads and encourages us to deepen our understanding of the Master and the mastermind. You'll find readings titled 'The Art of Listening,' 'The Power of Restraint,' 'Observation Skills,' and many more. Using the original stories featuring Sherlock as an introduction or object lesson, she goes on to lead us to explore spiritual truths. Trisha identifies Sherlock's characteristics and reminds us of details of particular stories to emphasize her points. But more importantly, we are led on to examine Biblical truths and encouraged to read more deeply of God's Word.
"Through Arthur Conan Doyle's stories, collectively called the canon, Holmes continues to leave endless clues that teach us truths about ourselves."
While Holmes intellect and deductive reasoning is efficacious, we are reminded that what we need most is God and His eternal wisdom.
If you know and love the adventures of Sherlock Holmes, you will enjoy this devotional. But more than that, this devotional is a refreshing approach to developing your Bible reading, and will encourage you to find the clues that will help you learn and grow.
A Sherlock Holmes Devotional; Uncovering the Mysteries of God
by Trisha White Priebe
Publisher: Shiloh Run Press (Barbour Pub Inc)
Format: Paperback, Kindle
Trisha White Priebe notes that the internet abounds with information, references, books, fan clubs and societies all captivated by Sherlock Holmes. In fact, a Sherlockian is known to be an enthusiast who studies the stories and writing of Arthur Conan Doyle and the stories and utterances of Sherlock Holmes.
But while Doyle's popular works of fiction are impressive, they cannot compare with God's Word. Trisha reminds us that God has given us the Scriptures as a means of knowing and loving Him more. Do we study it as passionately as devotees of Sherlock Holmes? Do we share and discuss it's passages? Do we commit it to heart?
Through this series of devotions, she leads and encourages us to deepen our understanding of the Master and the mastermind. You'll find readings titled 'The Art of Listening,' 'The Power of Restraint,' 'Observation Skills,' and many more. Using the original stories featuring Sherlock as an introduction or object lesson, she goes on to lead us to explore spiritual truths. Trisha identifies Sherlock's characteristics and reminds us of details of particular stories to emphasize her points. But more importantly, we are led on to examine Biblical truths and encouraged to read more deeply of God's Word.
"Through Arthur Conan Doyle's stories, collectively called the canon, Holmes continues to leave endless clues that teach us truths about ourselves."
While Holmes intellect and deductive reasoning is efficacious, we are reminded that what we need most is God and His eternal wisdom.
If you know and love the adventures of Sherlock Holmes, you will enjoy this devotional. But more than that, this devotional is a refreshing approach to developing your Bible reading, and will encourage you to find the clues that will help you learn and grow.
A Sherlock Holmes Devotional; Uncovering the Mysteries of God
by Trisha White Priebe
Publisher: Shiloh Run Press (Barbour Pub Inc)
Format: Paperback, Kindle
August 26, 2015
The first Sherlock Holmes story was published in 1887. Ever since, the brilliant detective has fascinated readers and viewers. Trisha Priebe’s devotional attempts to draw from the Holmes canon spiritual truths to inspire the Christian’s life. The publisher states that “this book investigates the spiritual truths we can discern from this enigmatic fictional character – a brusque, stubborn, and arrogant man who also shows honor, trust, and self-sacrificing friendship.”
Unfortunately, Priebe’s investigation does not reveal all that it could reveal.
I liked the concept, which is what drew me to read the book. I’m always interested in how others make connections between faith and pop culture – and yes even though Sherlock Holmes’ first appearance was in 1887, he is just as part of our pop culture as James Bond or Bruce Wayne. The best parts of this book are the first half of each of the devotionals where Priebe shares information about the different stories or events leading up to the writing of those stories. Here she reveals interesting facts about the character, his legacy, and his creator Arthur Conan Doyle.
Read more at http://jasoncstanley.com/book-review-...
Unfortunately, Priebe’s investigation does not reveal all that it could reveal.
I liked the concept, which is what drew me to read the book. I’m always interested in how others make connections between faith and pop culture – and yes even though Sherlock Holmes’ first appearance was in 1887, he is just as part of our pop culture as James Bond or Bruce Wayne. The best parts of this book are the first half of each of the devotionals where Priebe shares information about the different stories or events leading up to the writing of those stories. Here she reveals interesting facts about the character, his legacy, and his creator Arthur Conan Doyle.
Read more at http://jasoncstanley.com/book-review-...
January 8, 2017
A devotional inspired by THE Sherlock Holmes is definitely an interesting concept, the more so given the Sherlockian revival of the last years, The authoress is obviously an eager fan herself and shares a lot of trivia and less known facts here, but, most importantly, the multitude if devotionals based on the famous characters by A.C. Doyle and their environment.
So, what is the reason for 3 stars? The concept is definitely interesting, but the execution feels like a stretch too often for me. The Holmes books, however brilliant, were written as an entertainment read, not as a motivational read, and they are based on the intellect-driven aspects (mostly). And Holmes and friends are the characters of fiction, let's not forget that. So the search for moral messages in these stories might appear as artificial. While some devotions (mostly the ones based on more general aspects) are very good and I was able to take the morale from them, in some devotionals the connections between the Holmes aspect and the Christian message feel unnatural.
The book might be better if the amount of the devotionals was cut down with the preferences towards the selected messages.
So, what is the reason for 3 stars? The concept is definitely interesting, but the execution feels like a stretch too often for me. The Holmes books, however brilliant, were written as an entertainment read, not as a motivational read, and they are based on the intellect-driven aspects (mostly). And Holmes and friends are the characters of fiction, let's not forget that. So the search for moral messages in these stories might appear as artificial. While some devotions (mostly the ones based on more general aspects) are very good and I was able to take the morale from them, in some devotionals the connections between the Holmes aspect and the Christian message feel unnatural.
The book might be better if the amount of the devotionals was cut down with the preferences towards the selected messages.
December 31, 2015
I absolutely adore Sherlock Holmes and was incredibly excited to see a devotional utilizing this great literary character. I learned an incredible amount of information about the Sherlock Holmes novels and Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. While Priebe did her best to relate the Bible to the stories about Sherlock Holmes, at times I found the correlations to be a bit of a stretch. The devotional was interesting, and kept me engaged, though I do not think that I would utilize it to really draw me deeper into the Bible during my quiet time. It would perhaps read better as a book itself and not a devotional.
*I received a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review from NetGalley and the Publisher.*
*I received a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review from NetGalley and the Publisher.*
October 2, 2016
I am an avid fan of Sherlock Holmes, and so when I saw this devotional on the store shelf, I had to pick it up to read it. The only complaint, it only has 60 days of devotions. Would have loved reading it daily for a whole year. Utilizing quotes from the various stories, the author then ties in Scriptural truth and Scripture to draw the reader closer to God. I can't recommend this highly enough. Will read it again probably next year, and who knows - maybe even yearly. If you are a follower of the Sherlock Holmes accounts, find a copy and go to 221b Baker Street to be challenged in your walk with God.
May 24, 2015
I received a copy of this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
This is a difficult book for me to review for a number of reasons. It was also difficult to decide how to explain my distance from the text. In the end, I can only say that I took little to nothing from the supposed devotionals in the text. I didn't really learn anything or see anything which connected the Sherlock Holmes stories to the chosen verses without a detailed explanation. No where did it lead me to ask questions or think on the mystery of God.
This is a difficult book for me to review for a number of reasons. It was also difficult to decide how to explain my distance from the text. In the end, I can only say that I took little to nothing from the supposed devotionals in the text. I didn't really learn anything or see anything which connected the Sherlock Holmes stories to the chosen verses without a detailed explanation. No where did it lead me to ask questions or think on the mystery of God.
December 28, 2015
I was pleasantly surprised to love this devotional. The author clearly has an extensive knowledge of Sherlock Holmes, but the devotional shows so much more than that. Each devotional starts with an idea, concept or example from an episode of Sherlock Holmes, then applies it both to the bible (accurately) and makes it relevant to people's trials, trouble and lives today. New, very engaging, different, outside the box, relevant and biblically accurate not just feel good. An excellent and surprising devotional!
June 29, 2016
I am a fan of Sherlock Holmes. I admit it. So when I saw the title of this book I had to get the book.
I have been using this devotional this month. I really like how the author builds each daily devotional around a biblical principle. Using an illustration from Sherlock's life complete with an excerpt reinforcing the illustration, each principle is presented. The reader is asked to reflect upon their own lives and ponder how the lesson applies to them.
I highly recommend this book. You don't have to be a Sherlock Holmes fan, but it doesn't hurt.
I have been using this devotional this month. I really like how the author builds each daily devotional around a biblical principle. Using an illustration from Sherlock's life complete with an excerpt reinforcing the illustration, each principle is presented. The reader is asked to reflect upon their own lives and ponder how the lesson applies to them.
I highly recommend this book. You don't have to be a Sherlock Holmes fan, but it doesn't hurt.
November 16, 2015
The Sherlock Holmes Devotional promises to be a steller devotional with hints of suspense! This must read is for everyone who loves the Lord and would like to ameliorate their relationship with God the Father. This devotional belongs on everyone's shelf! As Sherlock Holmes has endured the test of time, so this devotioal promises to warm our hearts and bring us to a closer walk with God!
May 3, 2016
Sometimes the author was 'reaching' for her connections between Holmes and the Bible, but on occasion she was right on.
Most important lesson I learned: "Be more like Mrs. Hudson and serve everyone and be happy doing it."
Most important lesson I learned: "Be more like Mrs. Hudson and serve everyone and be happy doing it."
June 1, 2015
Full Review coming soon!
Displaying 1 - 28 of 28 reviews