Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

A Candy Shop Mystery #1

Candy Apple Dead

Rate this book
When she is stood up by fellow merchant Brandon Mills, Abby Shaw, the owner of the Divinity Candy Shop, is shocked when he is found murdered and discovers a whole new and disturbing side to this man whom she thought she knew when she launches her own investigation. Original.

222 pages, Mass Market Paperback

First published September 6, 2005

33 people are currently reading
3355 people want to read

About the author

Sammi Carter

8 books93 followers
Sammi Carter is the multi-published, award-winning author of the popular Candy Shop mystery series featuring amateur sleuth Abby Shaw. Sammi Carter is the pseudonym of Sherry Lewis.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
441 (25%)
4 stars
528 (31%)
3 stars
539 (31%)
2 stars
152 (8%)
1 star
37 (2%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 129 reviews
Profile Image for Ell.
523 reviews66 followers
October 25, 2017
Candy Apple Dead is the first book in Sammi Carter's "Candy Shop Mysteries" and I have bought all the rest in the series after reading this book. I just really loved how relaxed this cozy was. It was perfect reading for the beach or park. As other readers have mentioned, it is not a particularly suspenseful cozy, but I think the way the mystery unraveled was expertly written. The main character, Abby, is very likeable. If you are looking for a cozy series that is more relaxing than suspenseful, this is it!
Profile Image for Jenn.
1,647 reviews34 followers
April 4, 2008
I read quite a few of the themed cozy mysteries. For the life of me I can't remember why I didn't enjoy this one at all, but I do remember stating a few times during this book that I really hated it. I think it may have been the characters who drove me crazy.
6,067 reviews78 followers
May 10, 2018
Fairly decent cozy about a candy store owner/amateur sleuth.

When a man, who is perhaps a little too popular with the ladies, dies in a fire the sleuth's brother is the prime suspect. She has to get him off the spot, so she investigates, and finds the usual small town secrets.

Not bad. Some good recipes, too.
Profile Image for Diane Morasco.
Author 10 books16 followers
April 9, 2011
What could be more delish than a mystery series that takes place in a candy shop? Adding pizza, cheese & baked goods is the only thing that comes to mine. Oh, talk about sheer deliciousness.

Sammi Carter's Abby Shaw is the latest amateur sleuth to join the ranks in the cozy mystery genre.

Candy Apple Dead is a luscious read.

I enjoyed getting to know Abby in this tempting debut. I loved the small town feel of life in Paradise, Colorado.

Carter created a likable heroine who has chutzpah. Abby seems to have no fear & thrusts herself right into the thick of things.

While Abby does stick herself into the midst of some precarious situations & you often wonder,"what the heck is she doing?" it makes sense.

Granted, it is a bit frustrating but you can't help but root for her as she tries to get to the bottom of the murder. Which is what makes her a believable & endearing protagonist. You just want Abby to persevere.

The characters are interesting & not all syrupy sweet. Love that!

The family dynamics between Abby & her brother are intriguing. You want to know more about what lies beneath all of their tension. You want to know what makes Wyatt behave the way he does. Why two children growing up under the same roof veer off into two very different paths.

Carter pens Wyatt in a way where you want to know what makes him tick ~ you just want to know more about him, his wife & children.

As for Abby, you want her to have it all. She is charming, sassy & smart.

Candy Apple Dead is an entertaining mystery. The clues are drizzled about evenly & it is a fast, fun read.

Carter's Candy Apple Dead kicks off the Candy Shop Mystery series & this series shows bright promise.

My only gripe was the ending. It seemed to end a tad too abruptly. For me, the big reveal was more like, "Huh?" it just didn't click well enough for me.

Perhaps, a few more pages would of done the trick?!
Profile Image for Vickie.
2,266 reviews6 followers
March 31, 2008
Really only partly finished this. Skimmed mostly. Character pissed me off with her waffling.
Profile Image for Tabby Kat.
145 reviews
June 23, 2018
Abby Shaw is trying to readjust to life in Paradise, Colorado after years away. Part of that adjustment is running Divinity Candy Shop, which she just inherited from her aunt.

But adjusting to life in a small town also means adjusting to local politics. The Downtown Merchants Alliance is currently debating the merits of moving the local Arts Festival to the downtown area. The issue is hotly contested. Brandon Mills is spearheading the effort to move it, so when he doesn't show up at a meeting about the issue, Abby is concerned. That night, Brandon's shop burns down - an act of arson. Then Brandon's bones are found in the ruins and Abby's brother Wyatt becomes the chief suspect. With the detective assigned to the case infuriating Abby, she decides to step in and see what other motives she can dig up. What she uncovers sheds a whole new light on many people she knows. Yet more and more the evidence is pointing to Wyatt. Did he do it? If not, can Abby clear him
Profile Image for SweetCheeses And Coffee Dreams.
48 reviews
October 18, 2013
I thought this book was going to a cute and quirky mystery, based on the reviews I read. It was just meh. Story of a woman who comes back to her hometown after years of being away and a failed marriage(her husband cheated on her and she is pretty bitter about it) and inherits a candy shop from her aunt. There is a mystery, too, but it didn't hold my interest that much. Her character development was just OK, and it seemed she spent more time making up interesting names for them and for the shops in the town (odd choices, I thought). She spent all this time trying to clear her brother of a crime, but I didn't see much love between them...and I know you do for family, but it didn't have the chemistry or passion one usually has for their family. At least I didn't feel it. *sighs* That being said, I read another review that said the second one was much better. We'll see. It might be a while, but I might try one more in this series.
Profile Image for Versel Rush.
106 reviews4 followers
April 11, 2012
I finally gave in after seeing this pop up every time I opened my Amazon recommendations (and, lately, on my Goodread recommendations as well). I hope that this is the last I will see of this series on any recommendations list.

The book was boring--no other way to put it. Abby, the new owner of Divinity Candy Shop, was wishy washy and, frankly, not too bright. By the end of the book I was seriously tired of hearing about her cheating ex-husband and the dysfunctional relationship she has with her drunk, self-centered brother and her nasty, know-it-all cousin/employee.

The mystery was silly; the ending predictable (even without any real clues).

The recipes sounded really good and, yep, I liked the dog. Those two things are the only reason this book gets 2 stars instead of 1.

Profile Image for Kellene.
1,114 reviews17 followers
July 30, 2017
I'm not sure exactly how to review this one. I would say I have mixed feelings about it, but I don't really. The main character, Abby, was not really likable for me. She comes across as way too wishy-washy to have been a corporate lawyer, and I'm not sure how she is going to keep a candy store running when she can't stay in the store long enough to fill orders (did the lady ever get her candy bouquets or not?). The other characters went from ho-hum to down right horrid (Abby's brother is a major butthead regardless of how sympathetic the author tries to make him). The cop was okay, I guess, but the only character I really liked was Max, the dog. The setting was typical cozy small town, but I wouldn't want to spend any time there. And the mystery.... without including spoilers.... I felt totally ripped off by the solution. Seriously doubt this series is going anywhere else on my list.
Profile Image for Georgiann Hennelly.
1,960 reviews25 followers
July 12, 2011
Abby Shaw now owns Divinity candy shop when her aunt passed away she left it to Abby. Making sweets and selling them eases her heartache, but having Brandon MIlls sweett on her helps it even more. Brandon invites Abby to go to dinner with him after they attend the town meeting . But when he fails to show up for the meeting or the dinner date , and his store burns down. Abby fears something has happened to him and when she see,s her brothers truck near the scene before the fire and a body is found in the ruins of the store. Abbys brother becomes the prime suspect, and she sets out to prove he didn,t kill Brandon. But can she do it before the police catch her brother and lock him p for murder? Looking forward to reading more books by this author.
Profile Image for Amy.
867 reviews3 followers
October 14, 2012
My first cozy mystery and first mystery in a very long time with a short history. I loved the idea of combining candy with murder (I'm a bit of a sweet tooth), but this book was bad. The title had nothing to do with the plot. The main character is an idiot and is constantly doing things a former corporate lawyer or anyone who studies law should know not to do. So much of it was her sheer stupidity in ticking everyone off asking stupid questions and saying stupid things. I found her character not endearing in the least, and anything candy-related usually gives me warm fuzzies without trying. This book may have totally turned me off an entire genre. But it was a short read at least.
Profile Image for Mark Baker.
2,354 reviews195 followers
March 19, 2014
The idea of moving the Arts Festival downtown stirs up trouble, including arson and murder. Can Abby get her feet under her running a new business and solve the crime? I liked the characters and setting, but the plot was a little rough.

Read my full review at Carstairs Considers.
Profile Image for Jessica.
164 reviews19 followers
November 17, 2009
I was surprised by this book. The writing was more detailed and the story more interesting than I had expected. I am looking forward to seeing if the next book in the series will prove to be as entertaining.
Profile Image for Anjula.
389 reviews2 followers
did-not-finish
December 11, 2014
What's the point in "investigating" if you ignore everything that people tell you? Or assume that you know better?
Profile Image for Hailey Sawyer.
Author 1 book50 followers
October 11, 2023
I've had this novel on one of my bookshelves for a long time. I have no idea how I got it or when I got it, but now was a good time to check it out.

(When she is stood up by fellow merchant Brandon Mills, Abby Shaw, the owner of the Divinity Candy Shop, is shocked when he is found murdered and discovers a whole new and disturbing side to this man whom she thought she knew when she launches her own investigation. Original.) ~ Blurb from Goodreads

I liked Abby. She has a lot on her plate (like the death of her Aunt Grace, reacclimating to a town she moved away from, running her late aunt's candy shop, struggling to live up to her aunt's legacy, and so on) but she still puts in a genuine effort to keep a smile on her face and do the best she can to manage everything she has to deal with.

The setting was nice. So this story mainly takes place in a small town in Colorado. From the high altitude making it difficult for Abby to climb steep stairs to it affecting the candy making process to how vividly the town was described and the general attitude of its inhabitants, I was able to get a really good grasp on what it's like and really get immersed in it. Honestly, it feels like a town that could actually exist in real life.

The way the novel handled Brandon was smart. So in chapter one, the reader gets an entire scene where, just through Brandon's interactions with Abby alone, they learn that Brandon is a sweet, charming, upbeat guy who loves sweets and genuinely likes Abby. But, as the novel goes on, the reader gets to learn about a whole other side of Brandon that Abby was not aware of. In chapter This is great. I like how the post-fire scene at Brandon's store is set up in a way where the cause could plausibly be something else other than that.

The pacing is rather wonky. So the novel is trying to go for a slower, more relaxed pace, but it does so in a way that feels rather artificial. Normally I don't mind slower paced stories, but from the fire incident in chapter two to finding out that Brandon was the corpse found at the scene in chapter eight, it's just repeating the same points over and over again without really adding all that much to them. People talk about the fire, Brandon is not who you think he is, Brandon isn't what the rumors say he is, Is Brandon alive or dead?, you get the idea. Excluding the candy recipes, this novel is less than two hundred and twenty pages long, so this problem is especially noticeable.

Speaking of that, there's a lot of repetition. For example, in addition to the aforementioned repetition in chapter two through eight, various characters throughout the novel constantly repeat some kind of variation of "What if Brandon started that fire for insurance purposes?" Honestly, a good chunk of these moments could've been cut and have nothing important be lost.

There was one choice that just seemed weird. Besides the word "Hell", there are no other swear words actually present, despite the fact that there are numerous moments where the novel will just describe a character as swearing rather than letting the reader hear them swearing. I don't get it. I can understand using this method in something like a middle grade novel. But this novel is for adults. If you're gonna have the characters swear, just let them swear.

Overall, Candy Apple Dead isn't the worst mystery I've ever read, but it's one that I don't see myself returning to anytime soon.

Overall Grade: C-
363 reviews2 followers
July 3, 2017
I keep trying to sort out my feelings on this one, but I'm having a lot of trouble figuring it out. The mystery itself was decent, but for some reason I kept feeling an overwhelming sense of sadness.
Profile Image for Connie N..
2,746 reviews
March 29, 2014
This is a very good start to a cozy mystery series about a candy shop owner, Abby Shaw, who returns to her hometown in Colorado after her divorce and when Abby inherits the store after the death of her Aunt Grace. Abby has hopes that she and handsome Brandon might be a couple until his store burns down, with him in it. Abby's brother Wyatt becomes Suspect #1, so it's natural for Abby to start looking for answers. She does this in a very believable way, talking to friends and neighbors to follow leads and see what she can learn, hopefully one step ahead of the police who are focusing on Wyatt's "guilt." I really liked Wyatt, and especially the strong brother/sister relationship between him and Abby. Jawarski is the cop on the case and is amusing in a very understated way. We meet a lot of the townspeople (and Max the dog), so many that it is often confusing trying to keep them straight, although that's a general failing with the first of any series. Carter has a very smooth and easy-to-read writing style, with some subtle humor that made me smile. I was confused all the way to the end, having no idea of the identity of the murderer, which is good. But, on the bad side, the ending was way too abrupt, featuring people that hadn't been properly introduced within the bulk of the story. However, I liked the story and the writing for the most part and will certainly continue with the series.
Profile Image for Jessica.
98 reviews16 followers
January 29, 2011
Candy Apple Dead is the first book in Sammi Carter's "Candy Shop Mysteries" and I absolutely love it! I read the whole book in about 2 1/2 days! I probably could have read the whole thing from start to finish in one afternoon but... ya know... pesky priorities get in the way lol. Seriously though, I couldn't put it down. It was such a page turner and Sammi kept me guessing and in suspense with every character!... soon everyone became a suspect and I was just itching to find out who did it! I also love the main character "Abby Shaw" she is a woman after my own heart. Determined, head strong, feisty, sarcastic and hilarious! I am definitely glad that I own this book, because I will be coming back to it again sometime in the future... need to read a few more mysteries so I forget who the killer is ;)

I also love the fact that there are candy recipe's in the back of the book! And you better believe I will be trying these!
Profile Image for Natalie.
791 reviews2 followers
December 1, 2014
I have to say, this book wasn't entirely memorable. I finished it on Wednesday, and I've already forgotten most of it. It felt like this book was too full of stereotypes. Brandon the player, Abby the burned ex, Stella the PTA/town council busybody, Wyatt the misunderstood husband... etc. Abby stumbled through most of the book, making it entirely obvious that she was looking for Brandon's killer. The book dragged on and on, throwing red herrings in the mix, until, like Abby, we fell on top of the murderer. Not impressed. Loved the candy store idea, but that was about it.
Profile Image for Lunetaylina.
76 reviews20 followers
June 22, 2010
I first read this in fifth grade. I loved it! I was, and still somewhat, a mystery freak. I liked reading of suspense, still do, that makes my heart pound and this book did the treat. Although since I was in 5th grade the first time i read it, i didn't know why they were talking so much about monkeys... (but now I do... (^-^)-ew!) ReReading it for good times during the summer.
Re read it and i still love it!
Profile Image for Maria (Ri).
502 reviews48 followers
June 23, 2010
I wanted to like this book, but found it only just ok. It's the typical cozy scenario - a single woman in a cute job finds herself in the middle of a murder that she feels compelled to solve herself. It felt too predictable, too similar to many other small town women sleuth cozies. Plus, all the talk about candy made me so hungry!! I'm hoping this series develops a little more depth and personality. I'd like to see more of te small town characters fleshed out a bit more too.
Profile Image for Linda.
2,265 reviews57 followers
May 12, 2016
Overall I enjoyed this book and look forward to making another trip to Paradise. I wouldn't have minded a little more candy making but the mystery was good. I think this book suffered from a little first bookitis, not sure exactly what it was but I think there is some good material here. Also a plus that there were candy recipes at the end.
Profile Image for Julie .
4,228 reviews38.1k followers
April 1, 2013
A good cozy style mystery.
Abby' s brother is suspect number one in the death of the town's playboy, Brandon.
Abby is determined to prove her brother is innocent, so she starts asking a few questions.
There were a few loose ends that needed to be explained and some personal issues I would have liked to have seen a resolution to, but otherwise a fairly entertaining read. Overall a C+
179 reviews
January 18, 2012
I hate to put 2 negative reviews up in a row but this book was not good. The main character was super annoying and self-righteous. I am officially done with mysteries where the main character has NO reason to be investigating. All it does is make me angry.
Profile Image for Amy Martin.
98 reviews2 followers
January 22, 2014
I didn't like any of the characters. The concept was okay, but if you don't even like the murder victim through most of the book - why do you really care if the murder is solved. The writing was stilted and it didn't even seem like any of the characters liked each other!
Profile Image for Megan Burns.
229 reviews12 followers
November 21, 2023
From big-city lawyer to small-town candymaker, middle-aged divorcee Abby Shaw is on the case.

I found Abby to be a rather relatable — if not entirely realistic — heroine. She stubbornly forged ahead in her investigation of the death of local business owner Brandon Mills, refusing to back off the case both because Brandon was a friend/would-be suitor and because her brother Wyatt is named as the prime suspect. While everyone kept telling her to let the police handle it, she was bound and determined to prove her brother's innocence, self-preservation instincts be damned. I'm not sure I would've done the same in her shoes (especially being an only child myself), but like Abby, I too despise people telling me what to do.

Unfortunately, I wish some of the other characters had been as fleshed out. Take Officer Jawarski, for instance. While there is the trope of the small-town mystery heroine butting heads with the local law enforcement officer — who's usually hunky and just the heroine's type — Jawarski didn't make a ton of appearances and therefore I didn't feel like I (or Abby, for that matter) really got to know him. I also couldn't get a feel for Abby's cousin/coworker Karen, or for some of the red herring characters the story introduced. Meanwhile, Abby's brother Wyatt was a dumbass of the nth degree, partly because of his own paranoia fueled by the town's rumor mill but mostly because he refused to talk to police to clear up a few matters (like an alibi).

If I can give the author anything, though, the story kept me guessing until the last minute, and I did enjoy the fall atmosphere. Also, I like that this story didn't try to be so family-friendly with the language, though I could've done with a few milder words to differentiate it from all the 'clean' cozy mysteries out there. As a side note, though, I could've done without the (albeit brief) history lesson on marshmallows. While a neat tidbit, it added nothing to the story but padding. Anyway, just my two cents.

Overall Verdict: 8 candy apples out of 10
Profile Image for Theresa.
16 reviews1 follower
May 8, 2020
Abby has just moved back to her home town of Paradise after divorcing her cheating husband and leaving her law career behind. Her recently deceased aunt has left her Divinity, the candy shop in town which Abby is currently running. Abbys life seems to be turning around when Brandon Mills, a handsome flirt who owns the shop down the street asks her out to dinner. Unfortunately, her hope is dashed when Brandon is a no show. Later that night, Abby awakes to sirens and a fire burning Brandon’s shop to the ground. Now with Brandon missing, a body found under the rubble, and her brother Wyatt a top suspect, Abby finds herself directly in the middle of a mystery.

Candy Apple Dead is a fun and quick cozy read. I really liked the main character Abby. She is level headed, smart, and observant. I find it enjoyable when cozy characters do not put themselves in situations that make my eyes roll. The mystery kept me guessing and I was curious as to what secrets Brandon had tucked away. At first, I was unsure of the police character but Officer Jawarski certainly has a charm! This book did not follow exactly the typical cozy structure which I found refreshing. 🍭
... also I still love the cover even though it really does not match the story!
Profile Image for Nicole.
18 reviews
June 14, 2024
So just coming off a 29 book marathon from another sweet shop murder mystery series.

I have to say this is a breath of fresh air. People are not just giving out personal information that is not theirs to share and there are some people that don’t want to talk are answer Abby’s questions.

What I can’t understand is why if Abby is so wise in her years, was a lawyer. Why she acts so naive and pries so much into peoples’ personal affairs. She asks a bunch of questions that are just not her business like the divorce between her brother and sister in law. I get it that he is your brother but if he does not want to talk. He does not want to talk. Stop picking at a scab that’s not yours to pick.

Abby Just got into town a couple of months ago and is more trusting of womanizer over everyone else just because he was giving her some attention? So mad that people were talking down on him when YOU have not experienced his bad side, had your business threatened, had your relationship ruined?

With that being side I will not be reading the next 4 books.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Genevieve.
1,300 reviews10 followers
December 8, 2018
Abby Shaw has returned to her hometown of Paradise, Colorado to take over her aunt's candy shop, Divinity. A man that has been flirting with and who she considers a friend ends up dead in his burned down shop. Major suspect Abby's brother whose wife had been having an emotional affair with the man. Abby sets out to prove that her brother is innocent.
This is the first book of the series and is fantastic. I can't wait to read the rest. Abby is a little obsessed with cheating but who wouldn't be after having been cheated on that to me is what makes her character seem real. The side characters are fun and I love her relationship with her brother they argue and fight but still would defend each other. The mystery was great and made me keep guessing to almost the end.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 129 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.