What do you think?
Rate this book
The Secrets of the Isles #1
The Nature of a Lady
1906Lady Elizabeth "Libby" Sinclair, with her love of microscopes and nature, isn't favored in society. She flees to the beautiful Isles of Scilly for the summer and stumbles into the dangerous secrets left behind by her holiday cottage's former occupant, also named Elizabeth, who mysteriously vanished. Oliver Tremayne--gentleman and clergyman--is determined to discover what happened to his sister, and he's happy to accept the help of the girl now living in what should have been Beth's summer cottage . . . especially when he realizes it's the curious young lady he met briefly two years ago, who shares his love of botany and biology. But the hunt for his sister involves far more than nature walks, and he can't quite believe all the secrets Beth had been keeping from him.As Libby and Oliver work together, they find ancient legends, pirate wrecks, betrayal, and the most mysterious phenomenon of love.
375 pages, Kindle Edition
First published May 4, 2021
170 people are currently reading
3428 people want to read
About the author
Roseanna M. White
56 books3,693 followersRoseanna M. White is a bestselling, Christy Award nominated author who has long claimed that words are the air she breathes. When not writing fiction, she’s homeschooling her two kids, editing, designing book covers, and pretending her house will clean itself. Roseanna is the author of a slew of historical novels that span several continents and thousands of years. Spies and war and mayhem always seem to find their way into her books…to offset her real life, which is blessedly ordinary. She and her family make their home in the beautiful mountains of West Virginia. You can learn more about her and her stories at www.RoseannaMWhite.com.
see also Roseanna White
see also Roseanna White
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 502 reviews
June 26, 2021
Oh, Roseanna White ... why do you do this to me?
Foreword here: I was the hugest fan of White's. I absolutely loved her books, especially A Name Unknown and A Song Unheard (more on those later.) I still love her writing. But this book was not what I wanted to see from her.
I'm going to start with the positives, because there were many of those. First off, the writing. White has a wonderful writing style - easy to read, but also poetic and beautiful when it's needed. (Though for some reason, this book didn't seem as ... poetic, I guess, as the other ones. Maybe it was just my mood when I read it, I don't know.) Anyway. Her writing is amazing. I wish I could write as well as she does.
Second, the characters. I appreciated that Libby was not the Christian fiction woman who has to be sassy and strong and all of that. She was kind of shy, terrified of conflict, and just wanted to be outside doing her thing with plants. Cool. And Oliver ... I was expecting him to melt my heart and make me love him. But he didn't measure up to the ultimate Roseanna White nice-guy character, Peter Holstein. Oliver just fell a little bit ... flat, I suppose? I can't put my finger on what it was. But I did enjoy the fact that he had some flaws (did Peter have a single flaw, that angel?) Oliver's rivalry with Casek was nice. And speaking of Casek, and Mabena, too ... side characters for the win! The rest of the characters were interesting - Mamm-wynn was sweet once I got past the weirdness of her name. Libby's brother was ok, basic older brother. (Now I'm getting Barclay vibes...) And that Sheridan dude? I don't know what to think. He was a funny side character, but I don't know if I can read an entire book with his speech patterns. What will his thought patterns be like??
Finally, I have to mention the setting. The Scillies sound like somewhere I want to go on vacation. They're beautiful, and I don't think I've ever read a book set there. The whole thing with the pirate treasure was a little strange - the plot was a little far-fetched. It just seemed a little shallow, I suppose, but then again, I'm comparing everything to her earlier books where there was a war going on and the stakes were much higher overall.
Ok, now to the rant. Much of the moral was this question of "science" and God. Libby thought "science" disagreed with the Bible, and she was caught in the middle. Her two main issues were that people understand science much more now than they did back when the Bible was written, and she also believed in evolution. First off, I was a little confused about this whole "people know so much about science." She basically said people could understand everything about the natural world. And, true, new things are discovered all of the time, and we certainly know more about science than they did two thousand years ago. However, we are faaaar from understanding everything about the world the Lord has made. Scientists know a lot, but their knowledge is like a grain of sand on the shore. There are so many, many mysteries out there in science that scientists have not solved. (Also, Libby made this comment about how Jesus said we can't know how a seed grows or something like that, and she found this as a contradiction. I'm assuming she was referring to Mark 4:26-27: "And he said, So is the kingdom of God, as if a man should cast seed into the ground; And should sleep, and rise night and day, and the seed should spring and grow up, he knoweth not how." Jesus didn't say no one can ever know how a seed grows. He was simply speaking in a parable about a dude who planted seeds and didn't know how they grew. He wasn't saying no one could ever understand.)
Then there's the whole part about evolution. *sigh* Ok, can we please stop calling evolution "science"? Evolution - the whole 18 million years, everything slowly evolving from literally nothing to the ordered, magnificent world we see today - is not science. Science is observable, repeatable, testable. I'm sorry, but not one scientist was there watching slime turn into more slime and get married and having slime babies. That's not observable, repeatable, or testable. And no, I'm not talking about microevolution. I'm talking about slime turning into a human over supposed millions of years. That's speculation. That's a theory. If you want to believe that, go ahead. I'm not the thought police. But don't call that science. There are zero instances of non-life turning to life - and that's the whole premise of evolution, plus a bunch of time to make it so mind-boggling no one can understand it. So please, don't call that science.
Ok. Back to the book. Libby believed in evolution. And did she read the Bible and see how God said He created the world? Nope. She just accepted that evolution must have happened - because science - and she could also believe in God. No actual looking at what He said He did in His Word. Not realizing evolution presents many problems for a Biblical worldview. (Were Adam and Eve apes? What about death before sin? etc.) Libby just decided to metaphorically have her cake and eat it too.
Now, is that what should be in Christian fiction? I don't think so. Nothing should come above the authority of the Word of God. Evolution is man's attempt to get God out of the picture. If we can subtract the Creator, we have no need for Him. If White had wanted to include this struggle between evolutionary theory and what the Bible said, she at least should have presented what the Bible said about Creation. She should have talked about the fact that evolution is a theory - not proven fact. The way she wrote it acted as if evolution was proven to be true, no questions asked. That's definitely not true. Sticking evolution into Genesis simply undermines the authority of the Bible in a person's mind. It questions God's Word. And that is a very dangerous thing.
So, to sum this up ... this book could have been very enjoyable. And I did enjoy parts of it. White is a talented author. But I would prefer her keeping out strange, un-Christian teachings from her books. (Also, why does she jump on every social bandwagon that rolls down the street? A Portrait of Loyalty literally had face masks, and as far as I know, this written before corona happened. Maybe she added the whole mask thing in during the corona days; please correct me if someone knows what's going on there. But that was the last thing I wanted to read about in a book. Then she writes Dreams of Savannah just in time for all of the racial tensions. And now this whole science thing - pitting supposed "science" against anything and everything, and if you don't accept what scientists say, you're wrong.) Can I please read a book that's encouraging, that's edifying, that's God-honoring, that's not pushing a bunch of social issues I have to deal with every day in real life? Thank you. It would be much appreciated.
Foreword here: I was the hugest fan of White's. I absolutely loved her books, especially A Name Unknown and A Song Unheard (more on those later.) I still love her writing. But this book was not what I wanted to see from her.
I'm going to start with the positives, because there were many of those. First off, the writing. White has a wonderful writing style - easy to read, but also poetic and beautiful when it's needed. (Though for some reason, this book didn't seem as ... poetic, I guess, as the other ones. Maybe it was just my mood when I read it, I don't know.) Anyway. Her writing is amazing. I wish I could write as well as she does.
Second, the characters. I appreciated that Libby was not the Christian fiction woman who has to be sassy and strong and all of that. She was kind of shy, terrified of conflict, and just wanted to be outside doing her thing with plants. Cool. And Oliver ... I was expecting him to melt my heart and make me love him. But he didn't measure up to the ultimate Roseanna White nice-guy character, Peter Holstein. Oliver just fell a little bit ... flat, I suppose? I can't put my finger on what it was. But I did enjoy the fact that he had some flaws (did Peter have a single flaw, that angel?) Oliver's rivalry with Casek was nice. And speaking of Casek, and Mabena, too ... side characters for the win! The rest of the characters were interesting - Mamm-wynn was sweet once I got past the weirdness of her name. Libby's brother was ok, basic older brother. (Now I'm getting Barclay vibes...) And that Sheridan dude? I don't know what to think. He was a funny side character, but I don't know if I can read an entire book with his speech patterns. What will his thought patterns be like??
Finally, I have to mention the setting. The Scillies sound like somewhere I want to go on vacation. They're beautiful, and I don't think I've ever read a book set there. The whole thing with the pirate treasure was a little strange - the plot was a little far-fetched. It just seemed a little shallow, I suppose, but then again, I'm comparing everything to her earlier books where there was a war going on and the stakes were much higher overall.
Ok, now to the rant. Much of the moral was this question of "science" and God. Libby thought "science" disagreed with the Bible, and she was caught in the middle. Her two main issues were that people understand science much more now than they did back when the Bible was written, and she also believed in evolution. First off, I was a little confused about this whole "people know so much about science." She basically said people could understand everything about the natural world. And, true, new things are discovered all of the time, and we certainly know more about science than they did two thousand years ago. However, we are faaaar from understanding everything about the world the Lord has made. Scientists know a lot, but their knowledge is like a grain of sand on the shore. There are so many, many mysteries out there in science that scientists have not solved. (Also, Libby made this comment about how Jesus said we can't know how a seed grows or something like that, and she found this as a contradiction. I'm assuming she was referring to Mark 4:26-27: "And he said, So is the kingdom of God, as if a man should cast seed into the ground; And should sleep, and rise night and day, and the seed should spring and grow up, he knoweth not how." Jesus didn't say no one can ever know how a seed grows. He was simply speaking in a parable about a dude who planted seeds and didn't know how they grew. He wasn't saying no one could ever understand.)
Then there's the whole part about evolution. *sigh* Ok, can we please stop calling evolution "science"? Evolution - the whole 18 million years, everything slowly evolving from literally nothing to the ordered, magnificent world we see today - is not science. Science is observable, repeatable, testable. I'm sorry, but not one scientist was there watching slime turn into more slime and get married and having slime babies. That's not observable, repeatable, or testable. And no, I'm not talking about microevolution. I'm talking about slime turning into a human over supposed millions of years. That's speculation. That's a theory. If you want to believe that, go ahead. I'm not the thought police. But don't call that science. There are zero instances of non-life turning to life - and that's the whole premise of evolution, plus a bunch of time to make it so mind-boggling no one can understand it. So please, don't call that science.
Ok. Back to the book. Libby believed in evolution. And did she read the Bible and see how God said He created the world? Nope. She just accepted that evolution must have happened - because science - and she could also believe in God. No actual looking at what He said He did in His Word. Not realizing evolution presents many problems for a Biblical worldview. (Were Adam and Eve apes? What about death before sin? etc.) Libby just decided to metaphorically have her cake and eat it too.
Now, is that what should be in Christian fiction? I don't think so. Nothing should come above the authority of the Word of God. Evolution is man's attempt to get God out of the picture. If we can subtract the Creator, we have no need for Him. If White had wanted to include this struggle between evolutionary theory and what the Bible said, she at least should have presented what the Bible said about Creation. She should have talked about the fact that evolution is a theory - not proven fact. The way she wrote it acted as if evolution was proven to be true, no questions asked. That's definitely not true. Sticking evolution into Genesis simply undermines the authority of the Bible in a person's mind. It questions God's Word. And that is a very dangerous thing.
So, to sum this up ... this book could have been very enjoyable. And I did enjoy parts of it. White is a talented author. But I would prefer her keeping out strange, un-Christian teachings from her books. (Also, why does she jump on every social bandwagon that rolls down the street? A Portrait of Loyalty literally had face masks, and as far as I know, this written before corona happened. Maybe she added the whole mask thing in during the corona days; please correct me if someone knows what's going on there. But that was the last thing I wanted to read about in a book. Then she writes Dreams of Savannah just in time for all of the racial tensions. And now this whole science thing - pitting supposed "science" against anything and everything, and if you don't accept what scientists say, you're wrong.) Can I please read a book that's encouraging, that's edifying, that's God-honoring, that's not pushing a bunch of social issues I have to deal with every day in real life? Thank you. It would be much appreciated.
April 23, 2021
The Nature of a Lady is the first book in The Secrets of the Isles series by Roseanna M. White, published by Bethany House Publishers. The setting is the Isles of Scilly, Cornwall 1906. Escaping her family’s marriage schemes, main character Lady Elizabeth, Libby, Sinclair puts together a plan to spend the summer on the Islands of Scilly enjoying all the flora and fauna she loves so much. She meets hansom local vicar Oliver Tremayne who searches for his missing sister Elisabeth, Beth. Mysterious clues come to light and danger increases. As Libby and Oliver work together to find what’s going on with Beth, they become very close friends. Libby’s family wants her to marry a titled gentleman, so if she wants to be with Oliver, she will have to give up her family’s financial and emotional support.
Main character is earl’s sister and passionate naturalist Lady Elizabeth, Libby, Sinclair. She seems close to her family and doesn’t seem to have much of a rebel in her. As the story progressed, I enjoyed that she became a little more assertive.
Supporting character is vicar Oliver Tremayne who does what locally is considered “elbow-magic” which inspires people to open up to him. This part adds a funny element to his character and the story, which I love, and he is my favorite.
This reads like a historical romance with a mystery element. The story stands out from others I have read set in Cornwall. The setting on the islands off the coast added an interesting new twist to the plot. I particularly loved the expertly written dramatic scenes. I felt a bit of a Poldark vibe with the seaside setting and the local way of life at the time. Libby’s brother’s character I felt started out as a bit of an ass, to be perfectly honest, but he was probably the character who developed the most. My favorite part of the story was descriptions of the rowing competition and party on the beach, which added a feeling of Cornish culture. I appreciate all the thorough research that must have gone into writing this.
Libby wants to believe in God, but struggles with what she has learned from her local vicar. I really enjoyed reading about how she arrives at a greater trust in God through her discussions with Oliver.
As this is the exiting first start to the Secrets of the Isles series, I eagerly await book 2. Anyone who enjoys a great historical romance with a mystery twist will love this one. As will fans of Roseanna M. White’s other works. Similar authors to explore might be #Kristi Ann Hunter or #Erica Vetsch.
Thank you to #Bethany House Publishers, #Roseanna M. White and #NetGalley for this opportunity to share my honest review. All opinions are completely my own.
Conclusion: The Nature of a Lady is the captivating story about gentlewoman Libby who escapes her family’s marriage schemes to spend the summer on the Isles of Scilly. She meets hansom local vicar Oliver, who searches for his missing sister. They both get mixed up in her secret and dangerous activity.
Main character is earl’s sister and passionate naturalist Lady Elizabeth, Libby, Sinclair. She seems close to her family and doesn’t seem to have much of a rebel in her. As the story progressed, I enjoyed that she became a little more assertive.
Supporting character is vicar Oliver Tremayne who does what locally is considered “elbow-magic” which inspires people to open up to him. This part adds a funny element to his character and the story, which I love, and he is my favorite.
This reads like a historical romance with a mystery element. The story stands out from others I have read set in Cornwall. The setting on the islands off the coast added an interesting new twist to the plot. I particularly loved the expertly written dramatic scenes. I felt a bit of a Poldark vibe with the seaside setting and the local way of life at the time. Libby’s brother’s character I felt started out as a bit of an ass, to be perfectly honest, but he was probably the character who developed the most. My favorite part of the story was descriptions of the rowing competition and party on the beach, which added a feeling of Cornish culture. I appreciate all the thorough research that must have gone into writing this.
Libby wants to believe in God, but struggles with what she has learned from her local vicar. I really enjoyed reading about how she arrives at a greater trust in God through her discussions with Oliver.
As this is the exiting first start to the Secrets of the Isles series, I eagerly await book 2. Anyone who enjoys a great historical romance with a mystery twist will love this one. As will fans of Roseanna M. White’s other works. Similar authors to explore might be #Kristi Ann Hunter or #Erica Vetsch.
Thank you to #Bethany House Publishers, #Roseanna M. White and #NetGalley for this opportunity to share my honest review. All opinions are completely my own.
Conclusion: The Nature of a Lady is the captivating story about gentlewoman Libby who escapes her family’s marriage schemes to spend the summer on the Isles of Scilly. She meets hansom local vicar Oliver, who searches for his missing sister. They both get mixed up in her secret and dangerous activity.
April 20, 2021
*Warnings*
#1 This is a long review, so pull up a chair and grab a bowl of popcorn. You’ll be here awhile.
#2 When I read a review, I want substantial information. So I will not skimp on the details. Which may mean some spoilers, so watch out.
#3—additional warning reserved only for this review—I ended up writing 2,000 words of gushiness, so if you would rather read that instead of the shortened version below, please click here!
#4—disclaimer—a complimentary copy of this book was provided by the publisher, publicist, or author, including NetGalley. All opinions expressed are my own.
Stars: 5+
Synopsis: Lady Elizabeth Sinclair had planned on running from a marriage arranged by her older brother—only, upon her arrival to the Scillies, she realizes that she may have run straight into the arms of danger...and maybe even the arms of love.
Favorite Quote: All of them!!! But if I have to pick just one…
“He knows your name. Not Libby, not Elizabeth Sinclair. Your true name, the one at the heart of you that has never been spoken. He knows you, and He calls you by it. You, in all your uniqueness. You, in all that makes you different from others. You, in all that you have in common with them. He knows you, and He calls you by name. He knows how you fit into this world.”
I have read all but one of Roseanna M. White’s books. I’ve read her biblical fiction, Love Finds You in Annapolis, Maryland (as in, before it became A Heart's Revolution), both the Culper Rings and Ladies of the Manor series twice, her two short stories, and for the last four years, I have been quite literally devouring every single new book she writes the moment I can get my hands on it.
I know the streets of London like the back of my hand, the ins and outs of high society, the best way to remain hidden in shadows whilst spying on Redcoats. I keep Camden and Lukas and Samuel on my bed because they are hands-down three of the best ever heroes. I’ve done the whole off-again/on-again relationship with White’s novels for so long—loving some, disliking others, being wholly engrossed in everything she writes anyway.
After On Wings of Devotion, I thought it couldn’t get any better. And for a while, it didn’t. A Portrait of Loyalty was good, but certainly not my favorite. Dreams of Savannah was amazing, and I loved the portrayal of the Civil War (and, more importantly, Southerners), but it was missing some little something that would have hoisted it to the #1 spot.
Then The Nature of a Lady showed up, and boy howdy, it got better!
I mean, Oliver isn’t Camden or Cayton. Libby isn’t Ara or Zip. It wasn’t as intriguing as the Culper Rings, as mysterious as The Codebreakers, as exciting as Shadows Over England. It wasn’t as romantic as On Wings of Devotion or A Lady Unrivaled. It wasn’t as raw as A Stray Drop of Blood or as powerful as A Soft Breath of Wind. It wasn’t as political or cultural as Dreams of Savannah.
But, y’all. Y’all. Y’all. Y’ALL. y a l l . . .
(I will devise a million different ways to write y’all.)
this book was perfect
there i said it
(Now you may dis me for not using periods or proper capitalization.)
IT WAS EVERYTHING. All of it, all at once.
Raw emotion, Holy Ghost power, mystery and intrigue, PIRATES, sugary sweet, tender romance—times two! I mean, I honestly don’t know what to say.
Want to finish this review? Click here!
#1 This is a long review, so pull up a chair and grab a bowl of popcorn. You’ll be here awhile.
#2 When I read a review, I want substantial information. So I will not skimp on the details. Which may mean some spoilers, so watch out.
#3—additional warning reserved only for this review—I ended up writing 2,000 words of gushiness, so if you would rather read that instead of the shortened version below, please click here!
#4—disclaimer—a complimentary copy of this book was provided by the publisher, publicist, or author, including NetGalley. All opinions expressed are my own.
Stars: 5+
Synopsis: Lady Elizabeth Sinclair had planned on running from a marriage arranged by her older brother—only, upon her arrival to the Scillies, she realizes that she may have run straight into the arms of danger...and maybe even the arms of love.
Favorite Quote: All of them!!! But if I have to pick just one…
“He knows your name. Not Libby, not Elizabeth Sinclair. Your true name, the one at the heart of you that has never been spoken. He knows you, and He calls you by it. You, in all your uniqueness. You, in all that makes you different from others. You, in all that you have in common with them. He knows you, and He calls you by name. He knows how you fit into this world.”
I have read all but one of Roseanna M. White’s books. I’ve read her biblical fiction, Love Finds You in Annapolis, Maryland (as in, before it became A Heart's Revolution), both the Culper Rings and Ladies of the Manor series twice, her two short stories, and for the last four years, I have been quite literally devouring every single new book she writes the moment I can get my hands on it.
I know the streets of London like the back of my hand, the ins and outs of high society, the best way to remain hidden in shadows whilst spying on Redcoats. I keep Camden and Lukas and Samuel on my bed because they are hands-down three of the best ever heroes. I’ve done the whole off-again/on-again relationship with White’s novels for so long—loving some, disliking others, being wholly engrossed in everything she writes anyway.
After On Wings of Devotion, I thought it couldn’t get any better. And for a while, it didn’t. A Portrait of Loyalty was good, but certainly not my favorite. Dreams of Savannah was amazing, and I loved the portrayal of the Civil War (and, more importantly, Southerners), but it was missing some little something that would have hoisted it to the #1 spot.
Then The Nature of a Lady showed up, and boy howdy, it got better!
I mean, Oliver isn’t Camden or Cayton. Libby isn’t Ara or Zip. It wasn’t as intriguing as the Culper Rings, as mysterious as The Codebreakers, as exciting as Shadows Over England. It wasn’t as romantic as On Wings of Devotion or A Lady Unrivaled. It wasn’t as raw as A Stray Drop of Blood or as powerful as A Soft Breath of Wind. It wasn’t as political or cultural as Dreams of Savannah.
But, y’all. Y’all. Y’all. Y’ALL. y a l l . . .
(I will devise a million different ways to write y’all.)
this book was perfect
there i said it
(Now you may dis me for not using periods or proper capitalization.)
IT WAS EVERYTHING. All of it, all at once.
Raw emotion, Holy Ghost power, mystery and intrigue, PIRATES, sugary sweet, tender romance—times two! I mean, I honestly don’t know what to say.
Want to finish this review? Click here!
June 1, 2021
The Nature Of A Lady is the first in the new Secrets of The Isles Book.
Libby doesn't exactly fit the expected rules of society that are set in 1906. She is more than happy to escape to Isles of Scilly as her lady's maid Mabena suggests. There she can avoid her brother's attempts to marry her off and she can finally relax and be herself studying the flora and fauna with her microscopes. Full of mystery,intrigue,romance and danger.
I am captivated by the descriptions of the island , the scents,the sounds,the textures. The mystery comes alive at this author's hands.
I am very much looking forward to the next story in this series!
Pub Date 04 May 2021
I was given a complimentary copy of this book. Thank you.
All opinions expressed are my own.
Libby doesn't exactly fit the expected rules of society that are set in 1906. She is more than happy to escape to Isles of Scilly as her lady's maid Mabena suggests. There she can avoid her brother's attempts to marry her off and she can finally relax and be herself studying the flora and fauna with her microscopes. Full of mystery,intrigue,romance and danger.
I am captivated by the descriptions of the island , the scents,the sounds,the textures. The mystery comes alive at this author's hands.
I am very much looking forward to the next story in this series!
Pub Date 04 May 2021
I was given a complimentary copy of this book. Thank you.
All opinions expressed are my own.
May 5, 2021
"He knows your name. Your true name, the one at the heart of you that has never been spoken. He knows you, and He calls you by it. You, in all your uniqueness...He knows how you fit into this world."
What a delightful start to the Secrets of the Isles series! Roseanna White is a master storyteller who weaves a fascinating tale with intriguing plot infused with mystery and suspense, witty dialogue among the 1900 English nobility and commonfolk, lovable characters who are diverse in background and interests, and deeply profound spiritual truths. The central theme of 'to know and be known' is beautifully laid out in the plot and in the characters' lives. This book has more mystery and shroud of intrigue surrounding the plot than her previous books and the plot has some nicely placed twists. If you enjoy historical fiction with a side of pirates and treasure-hunting, you will absolutely adore this book.
Libby is an unusual earl's sister - a naturalist with a keen scientific mind and a refreshing innocence, sweetness, and tenderness. She feels lost in her world until she comes to the Isles of Scilly. Oliver is a vicar on the islands who is truly lovely - so compassionate, caring, and loving. They're brought together when Oliver's sister goes missing and Libby becomes embroiled in the mystery and danger surrounding her disappearance. Mabena, Libby's maid, and Casek, Oliver's life-long nemesis, are fun and their relationship adds a different dimension to the plot. I can't wait for the next books in the series to get to know the other characters better.
I received a copy of the book from Bethany House Publishers and was under no obligation to post a positive comment. All opinions are solely my own.
What a delightful start to the Secrets of the Isles series! Roseanna White is a master storyteller who weaves a fascinating tale with intriguing plot infused with mystery and suspense, witty dialogue among the 1900 English nobility and commonfolk, lovable characters who are diverse in background and interests, and deeply profound spiritual truths. The central theme of 'to know and be known' is beautifully laid out in the plot and in the characters' lives. This book has more mystery and shroud of intrigue surrounding the plot than her previous books and the plot has some nicely placed twists. If you enjoy historical fiction with a side of pirates and treasure-hunting, you will absolutely adore this book.
Libby is an unusual earl's sister - a naturalist with a keen scientific mind and a refreshing innocence, sweetness, and tenderness. She feels lost in her world until she comes to the Isles of Scilly. Oliver is a vicar on the islands who is truly lovely - so compassionate, caring, and loving. They're brought together when Oliver's sister goes missing and Libby becomes embroiled in the mystery and danger surrounding her disappearance. Mabena, Libby's maid, and Casek, Oliver's life-long nemesis, are fun and their relationship adds a different dimension to the plot. I can't wait for the next books in the series to get to know the other characters better.
I received a copy of the book from Bethany House Publishers and was under no obligation to post a positive comment. All opinions are solely my own.
May 14, 2021
This book was as historically rich and wonderfully complex as every Roseanna M. White novel. (The funny thing is, almost every single time she releases a new book, I finish it and immediately want to go back and reread her other books...which I did once again this time.) She has this fantastic way of creating out-of-the-box heroes and heroines who aren't only unique, but also layered and relatable and flawed in the best of ways. I enjoyed the mystery in this one, the abundance of side characters with journeys of their own, and, of course (as always!) the romance. Another five-star read from one of my faves!
April 14, 2021
This book is a pleasant and enjoyable read. It is a sweet, Christian HR, which is not something I typically choose to read. I was lured by the promise of a Sicilian setting, which turned out was an Isles of Scilly (off the coast of Cornwall) setting, during the early 1900’s. Though it wasn’t Sicily, as I anticipated, it was a fun and interesting setting.
There was a bit of mystery and intrigue to this story, and the romance was smoothly integrated. I liked both the leads, Elizabeth and Oliver. I thought they were fairly well drawn, with human flaws rather than too-good-to-be-true, boring leads. Elizabeth is a lady with an interest in Botany. Her brother is pressuring her to marry, so she convinces her family to let her take a holiday on the Isles of Scillies, where her maid is from, before deciding. Oliver is the Vicar on one of the bigger islands and cousin to Elizabeth’s maid. There was a good cast of secondary characters.
The mystery involved a case of mistaken identity, missing persons, possibility of a ghost and the possibility of buried pirate treasure. It was an engaging story, and the narrative was strong. I would read more in this series or by this author. I recommend if looking for a kisses-only HR with some intrigue in the plot.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for a chance to read and review this book. Views are my own.
There was a bit of mystery and intrigue to this story, and the romance was smoothly integrated. I liked both the leads, Elizabeth and Oliver. I thought they were fairly well drawn, with human flaws rather than too-good-to-be-true, boring leads. Elizabeth is a lady with an interest in Botany. Her brother is pressuring her to marry, so she convinces her family to let her take a holiday on the Isles of Scillies, where her maid is from, before deciding. Oliver is the Vicar on one of the bigger islands and cousin to Elizabeth’s maid. There was a good cast of secondary characters.
The mystery involved a case of mistaken identity, missing persons, possibility of a ghost and the possibility of buried pirate treasure. It was an engaging story, and the narrative was strong. I would read more in this series or by this author. I recommend if looking for a kisses-only HR with some intrigue in the plot.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for a chance to read and review this book. Views are my own.
September 8, 2022
This is a wonderful historical story set in the British Isles of Scilly just at the beginning of the twentieth century. Lady Elizabeth Sinclair wants to disappear from home for the summer to escape her brother's plan for her engagement to his best friend and she has no desire for that. She loves botany and other sciences, not the London Season or parlor visits. Her maid is from the Isles and suggests a visit there for the summer is just the thing. Mabena has her own reasons to go home for the summer. Her best friend, Beth, is missing, and she wants to find her. Libby is happy to see Beth's brother, Oliver, who shares her love of botany. The two met two years ago in the garden of her home. Theirs is a sweet and special relationship. This is an interesting story with a mystery to solve, suspense, folklore and pirates. Filled with history and interesting facts, we meet wonderful characters with romance and faith interspersed. I recommend for those who love historical romances with faith and an interesting twist. I am looking forward to the rest of the series.
Read
April 25, 2021Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read an advance copy for a review. I loved The Lost Heiress, 5 stars, so I was quite excited to read another by the author.
I actually finished this a few days ago but had to let the story percolate through my mind before writing a review. This wasn't as much of a slam dunk for me as the first I read by Roseanna M. White, so I have decided not to leave a rating.
Both the main characters - Lady Elizabeth "Libby" and Oliver, a local vicar, were very likable characters with bright minds and good character. There were fun secondary characters, episodes of mistaken identity, searches for lost pirate treasure, plenty of mystery, and a unique setting on the Isles of Scilly. What's not to love?
I read both secular and Christian fiction, but I unfairly do not judge them the same. This contained a positive message to be yourself. God created you to be unique. I loved that, and I enjoyed the creativity of the story. The writing is beautiful. If I had not been asked not to copy any of the text, I would share some quotes. Not only was it beautifully written, it was relatable; and I cared. I even cried at a couple moments.
My only complaint is what I felt was the second message. Darwin's evolution became widely accepted in the 1870s. This took place in 1906, and Libby seems to have rejected God because of her love for science. Oliver helped her to understand that she could have faith in God while studying nature and embracing science. While I agree that a person may love and learn about God's creation, I have a difficult time encouraging closely embracing and working with natural scientists who have to explain everything without a God in the equation. I am one of those old-fashioned people who take the first 6 chapters of Genesis literally even though I was taught otherwise at college. I guess I just expect the Christian authors I read to do the same even though I have no such requirement for the many secular authors I support.
The story is clean and positive. Although the rhythm was slow, it was engaging and entertaining. If advocating agnostic science would not bother you, you will likely enjoy this book.
I actually finished this a few days ago but had to let the story percolate through my mind before writing a review. This wasn't as much of a slam dunk for me as the first I read by Roseanna M. White, so I have decided not to leave a rating.
Both the main characters - Lady Elizabeth "Libby" and Oliver, a local vicar, were very likable characters with bright minds and good character. There were fun secondary characters, episodes of mistaken identity, searches for lost pirate treasure, plenty of mystery, and a unique setting on the Isles of Scilly. What's not to love?
I read both secular and Christian fiction, but I unfairly do not judge them the same. This contained a positive message to be yourself. God created you to be unique. I loved that, and I enjoyed the creativity of the story. The writing is beautiful. If I had not been asked not to copy any of the text, I would share some quotes. Not only was it beautifully written, it was relatable; and I cared. I even cried at a couple moments.
My only complaint is what I felt was the second message. Darwin's evolution became widely accepted in the 1870s. This took place in 1906, and Libby seems to have rejected God because of her love for science. Oliver helped her to understand that she could have faith in God while studying nature and embracing science. While I agree that a person may love and learn about God's creation, I have a difficult time encouraging closely embracing and working with natural scientists who have to explain everything without a God in the equation. I am one of those old-fashioned people who take the first 6 chapters of Genesis literally even though I was taught otherwise at college. I guess I just expect the Christian authors I read to do the same even though I have no such requirement for the many secular authors I support.
The story is clean and positive. Although the rhythm was slow, it was engaging and entertaining. If advocating agnostic science would not bother you, you will likely enjoy this book.
April 15, 2024
Storyline: In 1906, we follow Lady Elizabeth (Libby) Sinclair who loves all things microscopes and nature, but isn't favored by society. She travels to the beautiful Isles of Scilly for the summer and stumbles right into the secrets left behind by the cottages former occupant, also named Elizabeth, my has mysteriously vanished! Oliver Tremayne - a clergyman - is determined to figure out what happened to his sister Beth as he starts to get to know the girl who is staying at her summer cottage, Libby. They end up working together to solve this mystery.
I really liked this book, it kept me engaged and I really liked the romance that blossomed between Oliver and Libby. I also enjoyed seeing Libby's faith journey. Libby had many faith questions and Oliver really helped her see she is fully known by the Lord.
One of my favorite quotes: “He knows your name. Not Libby, not Elizabeth Sinclair. Your true name, the one at the heart of you that has never been spoken. He knows you, and He calls you by it. You, in all your uniqueness. You, in everything that differentiates you from others. You, in all you have in common with them. He knows you, and He calls you by name. He knows how you fit into this world.” - LOVED that. As the story progressed, we really saw how Libby came to see that science and faith don't have to be at odds. There were some beautiful prayer moments as well.
Libby was such a complex and unique character. I love how even though she wasn't the "typical female" of society for the time, we really see her embrace who she was and her interests and how Oliver cares for her no matter what.
What's even more interesting is Libby is someone he met randomly 2 years ago and they each share a love of botany and biology.
I know some have mentioned having issues with the "theology" in this book but I felt like everything was fine for me personally. Nothing overstepped any beliefs for me and it was general enough talking about the Lord knows us by name and the prayers mentioned were very nice for me personally.
I also love how this had some fun pirate details and treasure hunting aspects!
Overall, I really enjoyed my time with this and am looking forward to the next book in the series.
I really liked this book, it kept me engaged and I really liked the romance that blossomed between Oliver and Libby. I also enjoyed seeing Libby's faith journey. Libby had many faith questions and Oliver really helped her see she is fully known by the Lord.
One of my favorite quotes: “He knows your name. Not Libby, not Elizabeth Sinclair. Your true name, the one at the heart of you that has never been spoken. He knows you, and He calls you by it. You, in all your uniqueness. You, in everything that differentiates you from others. You, in all you have in common with them. He knows you, and He calls you by name. He knows how you fit into this world.” - LOVED that. As the story progressed, we really saw how Libby came to see that science and faith don't have to be at odds. There were some beautiful prayer moments as well.
Libby was such a complex and unique character. I love how even though she wasn't the "typical female" of society for the time, we really see her embrace who she was and her interests and how Oliver cares for her no matter what.
What's even more interesting is Libby is someone he met randomly 2 years ago and they each share a love of botany and biology.
I know some have mentioned having issues with the "theology" in this book but I felt like everything was fine for me personally. Nothing overstepped any beliefs for me and it was general enough talking about the Lord knows us by name and the prayers mentioned were very nice for me personally.
I also love how this had some fun pirate details and treasure hunting aspects!
Overall, I really enjoyed my time with this and am looking forward to the next book in the series.
May 14, 2021
Lady Elizabeth Sinclair and her maid, Mabena Moon, are off to the Isles of Scilly near the coast of England to escape Elizabeth's brother, Bram, who is determined to marry her off to "stick-in-the-mud," Lord Sinclair. Elizabeth has never fit the mold of the cultured society of which her family is a part. "Libby" as she is called loves all things of nature, how they grow and function, and especially drawing them. But little does she know that her trip will lead her into mystery, suspense, and an interesting gentleman.
This book first caught my attention because of the absolutely incredible cover. It is definitely an eyecatcher. And, of course, any historical fiction by Roseanna White is a must read for me; and White definitely does not disappoint with the first book in her new series. The three main characters, Libby, Mabena, and Oliver were so well done with their varying personalities and problems; yet they worked together as a wonderful team to unearth the mystery taking place on the Isles of Scilly. I especially enjoyed that the romances took place as part of the background.
Highly recommend and can't wait for the next book in the series.
**I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley. Opinions are mine alone. I was not compensated for this review.
This book first caught my attention because of the absolutely incredible cover. It is definitely an eyecatcher. And, of course, any historical fiction by Roseanna White is a must read for me; and White definitely does not disappoint with the first book in her new series. The three main characters, Libby, Mabena, and Oliver were so well done with their varying personalities and problems; yet they worked together as a wonderful team to unearth the mystery taking place on the Isles of Scilly. I especially enjoyed that the romances took place as part of the background.
Highly recommend and can't wait for the next book in the series.
**I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley. Opinions are mine alone. I was not compensated for this review.
July 19, 2022
4.5 stars
" I always say that there are some born here. Some who visit. Some who leave. Others who stay. . . . . When we stay, it's because the islands know our names . . . "
Did these islands possibly know her name? Lady Elizabeth Sinclair wondered if anyone in her life had truly known her name, the hopes and dreams it represented . . . certainly not her brother, or he would have never insisted that she marry a man whom she hardly knew, much less loved. Surely sneaking away on a summer holiday would only postpone the inevitable, nevertheless, the Isles of Scilly would provide her with hours of uninterrupted enjoyment, for she was a lady who loved exploring nature far more that tittering away her time mingling with polite society. But never in her wildest imagination could Elizabeth have anticipated getting mixed up with the perplexing, albeit dangerous secrets of Isles. Or its handsome vicar.
"I'm just not a man of science, my lady. I'm also a man of faith. The sort who says God created an orderly universe, set rules in motion, . . . but who also believes that a God who made such rules can also break them on rare, very special occasions. . .. . . He can raise the dead."
Oliver Tremayne was a puzzle, to be sure. So knowledgeable about creation, and yet willing to have faith in a God whom he couldn't see. So kind, so genuine, so manly . . . . Elizabeth had never entertained the thought that she might take delight in studying a specimen of the male species. Birds, bugs, and flowering plants usually held her attention; but this man . . . and his friends, and his family (one of whom was missing, the other being missed already), and his faith. And they would need ever bit of all three to find the kind of treasure that others had been willing to kill for.
Enticing, entertaining, and enchanting all describe this considerable volume of pure reading pleasure, with its myriad of interesting characters who serve to evoke a lush, imaginative mirage of an island paradise where everyone knows your name.
"Libby . . . . listened to the night insects as they made their debut. And could swear that when the wind blew again, she could hear the islands whisper, 'Elizabeth'. "
I received a copy of this book from the author and publisher. The opinions stated above are entirely my own.
" I always say that there are some born here. Some who visit. Some who leave. Others who stay. . . . . When we stay, it's because the islands know our names . . . "
Did these islands possibly know her name? Lady Elizabeth Sinclair wondered if anyone in her life had truly known her name, the hopes and dreams it represented . . . certainly not her brother, or he would have never insisted that she marry a man whom she hardly knew, much less loved. Surely sneaking away on a summer holiday would only postpone the inevitable, nevertheless, the Isles of Scilly would provide her with hours of uninterrupted enjoyment, for she was a lady who loved exploring nature far more that tittering away her time mingling with polite society. But never in her wildest imagination could Elizabeth have anticipated getting mixed up with the perplexing, albeit dangerous secrets of Isles. Or its handsome vicar.
"I'm just not a man of science, my lady. I'm also a man of faith. The sort who says God created an orderly universe, set rules in motion, . . . but who also believes that a God who made such rules can also break them on rare, very special occasions. . .. . . He can raise the dead."
Oliver Tremayne was a puzzle, to be sure. So knowledgeable about creation, and yet willing to have faith in a God whom he couldn't see. So kind, so genuine, so manly . . . . Elizabeth had never entertained the thought that she might take delight in studying a specimen of the male species. Birds, bugs, and flowering plants usually held her attention; but this man . . . and his friends, and his family (one of whom was missing, the other being missed already), and his faith. And they would need ever bit of all three to find the kind of treasure that others had been willing to kill for.
Enticing, entertaining, and enchanting all describe this considerable volume of pure reading pleasure, with its myriad of interesting characters who serve to evoke a lush, imaginative mirage of an island paradise where everyone knows your name.
"Libby . . . . listened to the night insects as they made their debut. And could swear that when the wind blew again, she could hear the islands whisper, 'Elizabeth'. "
I received a copy of this book from the author and publisher. The opinions stated above are entirely my own.
May 15, 2021
This book had such a nice balance of mystery, faith, romance, folklore, nature, gentry, and intrigue. As far as books by Roseanne White goes, I found this one to be a little lighter than her last few books, which suited this particular story and setting well. The ending wasn’t as suspenseful as some of hers, but again, I think it would have put the book out of balance. All that to say, I appreciated it for what it is and thoroughly enjoyed the full story. It was exactly what I needed for recovering from a year of school. ;)
There was a slow and steady, sweet romance as well as an enemies-to-lovers romance. Both seemed natural to me. There were a few kisses but no untoward conversation that I recall. It is probably more suitable for older teens.
The faith element flowed in and out of the story. Evolution was mentioned but was not debated in depth. It was more accepted that God created the world with all its mysteries, though one character did question such. I appreciated the differentiation between the God of the Bible and the God often taught in “polite society.”
The only rather strange thing was the grandmother’s ability to know things (from a distance) before they happened. It was explained, but still a little weird.
*I received this book from the publisher and happily provided my honest thoughts*
There was a slow and steady, sweet romance as well as an enemies-to-lovers romance. Both seemed natural to me. There were a few kisses but no untoward conversation that I recall. It is probably more suitable for older teens.
The faith element flowed in and out of the story. Evolution was mentioned but was not debated in depth. It was more accepted that God created the world with all its mysteries, though one character did question such. I appreciated the differentiation between the God of the Bible and the God often taught in “polite society.”
The only rather strange thing was the grandmother’s ability to know things (from a distance) before they happened. It was explained, but still a little weird.
*I received this book from the publisher and happily provided my honest thoughts*
July 8, 2021
FTC Disclosure: I received a complimentary copy of this book. These are my honest thoughts.
I have loved the majority of Mrs. White’s books. I fully expected to love this one.
Sadly, I did not.
The premise was wonderful. I was in the mood for a good mystery, and I thought this one sounded like it would fit the bill.
The mystery started with a bang, so I thought I was going to be in for a jam-packed novel, filled to the brim with clues and red herrings and all sorts of mischief for me to sort through in order to find out what truly happened to the missing character. I was ready for the adventure.
However, it promptly fizzled out for me when the brother set aside his concern for his missing sister and instead focused on his everyday business of continuing his long-held rivalry with the town headmaster, racing said headmaster in a weekly rowing competition, and romancing the leading lady, who he just met. What happened to his urgent concern for his sister’s well-being???
The tension leading up to Mabena’s return to her home island was superb. I thought for sure I was in for a good showdown once she finally made it back home, because the tension was a palpable promise of such a thing. However, there was no follow-through on that understood promise. In Mabena’s big return home, there was not an on-page reunion with her parents, so there was no showdown or blowup or anything else worthy of all the built-up angst.
The mystical, fantasy-type vibes I got in the first forty percent of this book were creepy. There was some “magic elbow” thing that I didn’t really understand, and I wasn’t sure if Mamm-wynn was supposed to be a prophetess, a mystic, or just some senile old lady who imagined relationships and weddings and honeymoons where there were none. These and a couple of other little threads give me the willies.
The pro-evolution, pro-Charles Darwin leanings in the leading lady were so disturbing to me. I was completely shocked to see this content strung throughout a Christian novel. It was even worse when the “sage” Mamm-wynn “confirmed” Libby’s connection between evolution and God’s name choices for a few people in the Bible. This was a huge disappointment to me, as I have long been a big fan of Mrs. White’s work, and it seemed to come from left field, because there had been nothing of the sort in any of Mrs. White’s other books (of the ones I have read to this point; I have not read them all, but I have read many of them).
Later on, the story took an awkward turn when Libby suddenly discovered the “sport of man watching” and spent a while ogling men’s physiques as they prepared for a boat race. This was completely out of character for her and gave me the willies all over again, but for a different reason.
Soon after that, the story took another turn, this time introducing the very modern ideal of a person’s not being “less.” This ideal only became popular and trendy in the twenty-first century, so I’m not sure why it’s featured in a historical novel set just a few years into the twentieth century.
The modernity slipping into a historical book was the last straw, and I stopped reading the book at 40%, which was around page 154. I was really bummed out today when I decided to stop reading it, because what was supposed to be a fun, enjoyable mystery had not lived up to my expectations.
I really adored the little kitten, but it hardly had enough page time. I wanted much, much more of it. The early beach-combing scene was pretty enjoyable, and I greatly enjoyed the setting of the Scilly Islands. I hope I can find another series of books set on those beautiful isles.
I have loved the majority of Mrs. White’s books. I fully expected to love this one.
Sadly, I did not.
The premise was wonderful. I was in the mood for a good mystery, and I thought this one sounded like it would fit the bill.
The mystery started with a bang, so I thought I was going to be in for a jam-packed novel, filled to the brim with clues and red herrings and all sorts of mischief for me to sort through in order to find out what truly happened to the missing character. I was ready for the adventure.
However, it promptly fizzled out for me when the brother set aside his concern for his missing sister and instead focused on his everyday business of continuing his long-held rivalry with the town headmaster, racing said headmaster in a weekly rowing competition, and romancing the leading lady, who he just met. What happened to his urgent concern for his sister’s well-being???
The tension leading up to Mabena’s return to her home island was superb. I thought for sure I was in for a good showdown once she finally made it back home, because the tension was a palpable promise of such a thing. However, there was no follow-through on that understood promise. In Mabena’s big return home, there was not an on-page reunion with her parents, so there was no showdown or blowup or anything else worthy of all the built-up angst.
The mystical, fantasy-type vibes I got in the first forty percent of this book were creepy. There was some “magic elbow” thing that I didn’t really understand, and I wasn’t sure if Mamm-wynn was supposed to be a prophetess, a mystic, or just some senile old lady who imagined relationships and weddings and honeymoons where there were none. These and a couple of other little threads give me the willies.
The pro-evolution, pro-Charles Darwin leanings in the leading lady were so disturbing to me. I was completely shocked to see this content strung throughout a Christian novel. It was even worse when the “sage” Mamm-wynn “confirmed” Libby’s connection between evolution and God’s name choices for a few people in the Bible. This was a huge disappointment to me, as I have long been a big fan of Mrs. White’s work, and it seemed to come from left field, because there had been nothing of the sort in any of Mrs. White’s other books (of the ones I have read to this point; I have not read them all, but I have read many of them).
Later on, the story took an awkward turn when Libby suddenly discovered the “sport of man watching” and spent a while ogling men’s physiques as they prepared for a boat race. This was completely out of character for her and gave me the willies all over again, but for a different reason.
Soon after that, the story took another turn, this time introducing the very modern ideal of a person’s not being “less.” This ideal only became popular and trendy in the twenty-first century, so I’m not sure why it’s featured in a historical novel set just a few years into the twentieth century.
The modernity slipping into a historical book was the last straw, and I stopped reading the book at 40%, which was around page 154. I was really bummed out today when I decided to stop reading it, because what was supposed to be a fun, enjoyable mystery had not lived up to my expectations.
I really adored the little kitten, but it hardly had enough page time. I wanted much, much more of it. The early beach-combing scene was pretty enjoyable, and I greatly enjoyed the setting of the Scilly Islands. I hope I can find another series of books set on those beautiful isles.
May 8, 2021
I have to admit that I'm, like, slightly a tad mad at myself for finishing this book too fast instead of soaking it in over a few days. But with the author's alluring writing and plotline and the beautiful setting?? I couldn't resist reading one more chapter. And one more chapter. Aaaand another chapter. XD
Libby is THE most gentle lady I've ever read from - I just can't remember anyone else that gave me the impression she gave me because of how unforcefully unique she is! And gosh, did I really like her! She's not super sarcastic or witty like most ladies are in the field of fictional romance (or so the many ones I've read); she's just her - so natural and unfiltered and different. Everything about her exhibits calmness and gentleness! In fact, calmness and gentleness were the vibes this book gave me, especially with such a soothing color as purple as the cover! It was lovely and delightful to read, and I had a hard time not reading a little faster because I just needed to know what would happen next!
I did have a hard time with the first few chapters though. They felt slower and I wasn't too convinced whether I should continue (also because I didn't really like Libby or Mabena at that time). But alas, I gave the characters a chance, and very specifically at chapter 9 for no reason, I loved Libby a whole lot better (Benna was still a little "err, hmm. okay" for me then) and I was already hooked and couldn't stop reading!
The novel never exhausted me like how sometimes a novel can when you read too long at one go. Instead, it was so refreshing and absolutely so lovely to read with that touch of mystery that kept me going!
And to end this, I need to make a quick mention to Casek, cus DUH, he's THE MAN. He's, like, the most romantic of the most romantics. My heart melted in a puddle every single time he said something to Benna (specifically those flirting "nonsense" and among other more super toe-curling-romantic things). I need more characters like him! 😭
Oh! And how could I forget?! It's quote time!!😌😋
“You’re right. That’s not big enough. A dinner. A fancy one, with you in a pretty dress.” She snorted. “In your dreams, Casek Wearne.” “Every night, my ’ansum.”
“I see.” Libby squinted her eyes at her. “I don’t, actually. But I’ll pretend I do, if it makes you feel better.”
“I am not!” This time she actually shouted. Her—shouted. And the whole room fell silent. Bram stared at her as if she’d grown a second head and named it Alice.
“Our Lord is the opposite of that. He has created a universe of order and rules—but He himself is so much bigger. So full of mystery. Your sister is coming to understand that, I think. And when she does, I have a feeling she’ll realize she not only has a use for God, but the greatest need of Him.”
“Don’t you see, then? It’s like that with God, but more. He knows your name. Not Libby, not Elizabeth Sinclair. Your true name, the one at the heart of you that has never been spoken. He knows you, and He calls you by it. You, in all your uniqueness. You, in everything that differentiates you from others. You, in all you have in common with them. He knows you, and He calls you by name. He knows how you fit into this world.”
This is only a FRACTION of the funniest and inspirational lines in the book! ;)
Libby is THE most gentle lady I've ever read from - I just can't remember anyone else that gave me the impression she gave me because of how unforcefully unique she is! And gosh, did I really like her! She's not super sarcastic or witty like most ladies are in the field of fictional romance (or so the many ones I've read); she's just her - so natural and unfiltered and different. Everything about her exhibits calmness and gentleness! In fact, calmness and gentleness were the vibes this book gave me, especially with such a soothing color as purple as the cover! It was lovely and delightful to read, and I had a hard time not reading a little faster because I just needed to know what would happen next!
I did have a hard time with the first few chapters though. They felt slower and I wasn't too convinced whether I should continue (also because I didn't really like Libby or Mabena at that time). But alas, I gave the characters a chance, and very specifically at chapter 9 for no reason, I loved Libby a whole lot better (Benna was still a little "err, hmm. okay" for me then) and I was already hooked and couldn't stop reading!
The novel never exhausted me like how sometimes a novel can when you read too long at one go. Instead, it was so refreshing and absolutely so lovely to read with that touch of mystery that kept me going!
And to end this, I need to make a quick mention to Casek, cus DUH, he's THE MAN. He's, like, the most romantic of the most romantics. My heart melted in a puddle every single time he said something to Benna (specifically those flirting "nonsense" and among other more super toe-curling-romantic things). I need more characters like him! 😭
Oh! And how could I forget?! It's quote time!!😌😋
“You’re right. That’s not big enough. A dinner. A fancy one, with you in a pretty dress.” She snorted. “In your dreams, Casek Wearne.” “Every night, my ’ansum.”
“I see.” Libby squinted her eyes at her. “I don’t, actually. But I’ll pretend I do, if it makes you feel better.”
“I am not!” This time she actually shouted. Her—shouted. And the whole room fell silent. Bram stared at her as if she’d grown a second head and named it Alice.
“Our Lord is the opposite of that. He has created a universe of order and rules—but He himself is so much bigger. So full of mystery. Your sister is coming to understand that, I think. And when she does, I have a feeling she’ll realize she not only has a use for God, but the greatest need of Him.”
“Don’t you see, then? It’s like that with God, but more. He knows your name. Not Libby, not Elizabeth Sinclair. Your true name, the one at the heart of you that has never been spoken. He knows you, and He calls you by it. You, in all your uniqueness. You, in everything that differentiates you from others. You, in all you have in common with them. He knows you, and He calls you by name. He knows how you fit into this world.”
This is only a FRACTION of the funniest and inspirational lines in the book! ;)
April 30, 2021
This is another excellent story written by one of my favourite authors. The Nature of a Lady is full of good history and romance which we’ve come to expect from this talented story teller. Roseanna M White expands her creativity in this first edition of the Secrets of the Isles series. What begins as a simple summer vacation intended to be an escape from proper English society, ends up full of secrets, old legends, pirates, and buried treasure. The plot builds well. The characters are likeable and relatable. However, the inclusion of certain scientific theories, such as Darwinism, I thought unnecessary. While the science theme was a good one, and one that I support, I would have liked to see a stronger biblical perspective come through by the end. Beyond this one aspect, I recommend this novel to my fellow historical fiction and romance fans. I can’t wait to read book 2!
I received a complementary copy of this book. All opinions expressed are entirely my own.
I received a complementary copy of this book. All opinions expressed are entirely my own.
September 13, 2021
Okay, this would easily be a 5-star book for me if not for one major thing. I'll just say now that this will be a long review, my issue is with the theology, and I'm going to start off with what I loved.
I loved basically everything in the story - the characters (Bram excluded, of course), the setting, the storytelling. Roseanna has always be a favourite author of mine and this book is no exception. Although, I may have loved Mabena and Casek's side story a bit more than Libby and Oliver... there's just something about that hate-to-love-you trope that gets me every time. And the atmosphere - I could almost taste the salty sea air and feel the wind blowing through my hair. It was perfection.
There were many layers to this story and I loved it. The pirate lore, slightly suspenseful but also mystical tone, and complicated but close-knit island families made this story absolutely enchanting.
Now, on to what I found problematic. Namely, the theology. From the back cover and reviews, I was expecting a story that shows us how the beauty and variety of nature showcases God's glory. I was disappointed. This is all based on my personal convictions though, so please take it with a grain of salt.
One other thing, there were minor inconsistencies amongst the characters - Bram in particular. He can't be surly and overly hardheaded throughout the entire novel, and then in the last chapter make a joke and laugh and 'sling his arm' around Libby like they're best buds. He needed a redemptive arc, even if it was little.
Okay, rant over. I feel like I'm reading too much into it, but for a novel marked Christian, published by a Christian publishing house, the suggestion of evolution as science felt very wrong. This book is really hard to rate. If theology was set aside, this would be a 5-star read for me. If theology was the only criteria I considered, it would be 1. Yet, if you took the theology out of Christian fiction, then it wouldn't be Christian anymore. I'd still recommend this novel to my friends, but with the clear warning/disclaimer of the theological content. One star off for theology, half a star off for inconsistencies, so we're left with 3.5 stars.
I loved basically everything in the story - the characters (Bram excluded, of course), the setting, the storytelling. Roseanna has always be a favourite author of mine and this book is no exception. Although, I may have loved Mabena and Casek's side story a bit more than Libby and Oliver... there's just something about that hate-to-love-you trope that gets me every time. And the atmosphere - I could almost taste the salty sea air and feel the wind blowing through my hair. It was perfection.
There were many layers to this story and I loved it. The pirate lore, slightly suspenseful but also mystical tone, and complicated but close-knit island families made this story absolutely enchanting.
Now, on to what I found problematic. Namely, the theology. From the back cover and reviews, I was expecting a story that shows us how the beauty and variety of nature showcases God's glory. I was disappointed. This is all based on my personal convictions though, so please take it with a grain of salt.
One other thing, there were minor inconsistencies amongst the characters - Bram in particular. He can't be surly and overly hardheaded throughout the entire novel, and then in the last chapter make a joke and laugh and 'sling his arm' around Libby like they're best buds. He needed a redemptive arc, even if it was little.
Okay, rant over. I feel like I'm reading too much into it, but for a novel marked Christian, published by a Christian publishing house, the suggestion of evolution as science felt very wrong. This book is really hard to rate. If theology was set aside, this would be a 5-star read for me. If theology was the only criteria I considered, it would be 1. Yet, if you took the theology out of Christian fiction, then it wouldn't be Christian anymore. I'd still recommend this novel to my friends, but with the clear warning/disclaimer of the theological content. One star off for theology, half a star off for inconsistencies, so we're left with 3.5 stars.
March 28, 2021
I was hooked by the setting of this book, having never even heard of the Scilly islands before, and I love that this appears to be the first in a series so we can return. Roseanna has certainly set up a cast of secondary characters whose stories we need - are Beth and Sheridan going to get an enemies to lovers tale of their own? I certainly hope so.
Oliver, the sweet island vicar from the most precious family, made a wonderful hero. Libby didn't charm me as much. I didn't dislike her, but I fail to understand the need for SO many stories from Disney, Christian fiction, etc. to be about females who don't fit in whatever their lot is in life and go searching for "more." Thankfully, Libby found it in God, and Roseanna wrote a very clear gospel message, which is rare. I suppose I've never felt this way so I don't understand the sheer number of fictional females who do. She felt "done before" to me, I suppose. I wonder why a dark haired model was used on the cover of this book, when the heroine was fair-haired. It was confusing the whole book and something that seems easy to get right.
I love when a romance shows us why THIS particular man and woman are perfect for each other, and that seemed to be missing here; they fell in love because they appreciated things about each other, but I wasn't convinced about their strengths and weaknesses complementing each other as much as I Iike to see.
One thing that stood out to me as I read was that there was a lot of explaining. Every thought and conversation had a paragraph of explanation behind it, telling us about the culture or why the character felt that way. It made the story not feel smooth. It was odd and was in some places, redundant (we know everyone on the islands knows each other!).
The plot was okay and it was a nice read, but there wasn't anything magical, nothing to make me laugh or cry or remember it forever. Overall, I enjoyed the characters, the setting, and the faith message, and I'll read the rest of the series if it happens. I do wonder if Roseanna will ever write anything on the level of the Shadows over England series again.
I read a review copy of this book from Netgalley and the publisher but I was not compensated in any way and all opinions are my own.
Oliver, the sweet island vicar from the most precious family, made a wonderful hero. Libby didn't charm me as much. I didn't dislike her, but I fail to understand the need for SO many stories from Disney, Christian fiction, etc. to be about females who don't fit in whatever their lot is in life and go searching for "more." Thankfully, Libby found it in God, and Roseanna wrote a very clear gospel message, which is rare. I suppose I've never felt this way so I don't understand the sheer number of fictional females who do. She felt "done before" to me, I suppose. I wonder why a dark haired model was used on the cover of this book, when the heroine was fair-haired. It was confusing the whole book and something that seems easy to get right.
I love when a romance shows us why THIS particular man and woman are perfect for each other, and that seemed to be missing here; they fell in love because they appreciated things about each other, but I wasn't convinced about their strengths and weaknesses complementing each other as much as I Iike to see.
One thing that stood out to me as I read was that there was a lot of explaining. Every thought and conversation had a paragraph of explanation behind it, telling us about the culture or why the character felt that way. It made the story not feel smooth. It was odd and was in some places, redundant (we know everyone on the islands knows each other!).
The plot was okay and it was a nice read, but there wasn't anything magical, nothing to make me laugh or cry or remember it forever. Overall, I enjoyed the characters, the setting, and the faith message, and I'll read the rest of the series if it happens. I do wonder if Roseanna will ever write anything on the level of the Shadows over England series again.
I read a review copy of this book from Netgalley and the publisher but I was not compensated in any way and all opinions are my own.
May 25, 2021
Whenever I see a new historical novel from Roseanna M. White, it pretty much automatically goes on my "want to read" list, and this was no exception. I expected to love it and was not disappointed.
I felt like the story started a bit slow; but, as I continued reading, it picked up and towards the end I didn't want to put it down. I loved the characters and the treasure aspect. It was such an intriguing story and one that sticks with you.
All in all, I loved this story and definitely recommend it. I cannot wait to read the next book in this series when it releases. Side note: the cover is absolutely gorgeous - especially in person. <3
*Disclosure of Material Connection: I received one or more of the products or services mentioned above for free in the hope that I would mention/review it on my blog. I was not required to give a positive review, only my honest opinion - which I've done. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own and I only recommend products or services I use personally and believe will be good for my readers. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CFR, Part 255: "Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.*
I felt like the story started a bit slow; but, as I continued reading, it picked up and towards the end I didn't want to put it down. I loved the characters and the treasure aspect. It was such an intriguing story and one that sticks with you.
All in all, I loved this story and definitely recommend it. I cannot wait to read the next book in this series when it releases. Side note: the cover is absolutely gorgeous - especially in person. <3
*Disclosure of Material Connection: I received one or more of the products or services mentioned above for free in the hope that I would mention/review it on my blog. I was not required to give a positive review, only my honest opinion - which I've done. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own and I only recommend products or services I use personally and believe will be good for my readers. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CFR, Part 255: "Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.*
July 11, 2021
This author is normally a favorite of mine, and i did enjoy the story, the setting, the characters, etc. However, seeing as it is a Christian novel, i took some issues with it on those grounds.
1. God is Who He is and He doesn't adapt or morph to fit into a box where a person might find Him more likable and/or easier to "know". And yes, if your preconceptions of science set you at odds with what God says about Himself, then yes, you do have to choose.
2. Macro evolution cannot be shoehorned into creation without cracking the very foundations of the gospel. If God created one single tiny organism that then spent billions of years working through a cycle of life and death to eventually arrive at the world we know today, then why did God breathe life into Adam? Wouldn't he have already been alive like the billions of beings who came before him? And, even more crucially, why was death a punishment for Adam's sin, and why the need for a Savior to redeem us from said death? If evolution is true, then death pre-existed sin and we don't need a savior.
These truths are foundational to Christianity and anything contrary is a false theology.
1. God is Who He is and He doesn't adapt or morph to fit into a box where a person might find Him more likable and/or easier to "know". And yes, if your preconceptions of science set you at odds with what God says about Himself, then yes, you do have to choose.
2. Macro evolution cannot be shoehorned into creation without cracking the very foundations of the gospel. If God created one single tiny organism that then spent billions of years working through a cycle of life and death to eventually arrive at the world we know today, then why did God breathe life into Adam? Wouldn't he have already been alive like the billions of beings who came before him? And, even more crucially, why was death a punishment for Adam's sin, and why the need for a Savior to redeem us from said death? If evolution is true, then death pre-existed sin and we don't need a savior.
These truths are foundational to Christianity and anything contrary is a false theology.
June 2, 2021
The Nature of A Lady was one that admittedly took its sweet time snagging my attention, but once it did I was hooked. I enjoyed our hero and heroine, Oliver and Libby overall, and appreciated specifically Oliver's dedication to his brother, Morgan and his Maam-wynn (what a kind man!), but it was Mabena "Moon" and Casek that stole the show for me. I loved the slow unfurling of who Mabena was and her history there with Casek. Well, them and Maam-wynn - such an endearing soul! Oh and Libby's love for Darling was just adorable - cats rule!
Overall, a well crafted tale in a setting I can't wait to return to.
Overall, a well crafted tale in a setting I can't wait to return to.
Read
February 21, 20221906 Isles of Scilly (Britain near Cornwall)
Lovely start to a series with a spectacular cast of characters. Interesting to read about a part of England I'd never heard of and a place that behaves a bit differently than the mainland. It's more relaxed with a strong sense of community.
Lovely start to a series with a spectacular cast of characters. Interesting to read about a part of England I'd never heard of and a place that behaves a bit differently than the mainland. It's more relaxed with a strong sense of community.
May 29, 2021
Set in the Isles of Scilly off the coast of Cornwall, this book was a gorgeous treat to read!
The 1906 setting was interesting, and the islands themselves were drop-dead stunning and made me want to visit them! They sprang to life so well, considering I'd never read about this particular setting before, and were probably my favorite thing about the book! So unique and delightful, and I do love a good "island story." I loved how it also felt somewhat Cornish but with its own twist, and the villagers, cottages, boats, flowers, sea, rocks, etc. were all wonderful!
I loved the writing! The story itself was super engaging and kept me intrigued throughout, and I loved seeing the intertwining threads of characters' lives and secrets unfold, along with an exciting mystery/treasure hunt with lots of clues, and some super-cute romances thrown in there. Some of the twists surprised me in a good way (particularly a certain rivalry).
The characters all came to life and many of them were fabulous. I particularly loved mysterious lady's-maid-turned-untameable-island-girl Mabenna Moon--she was marvelous!-- and of course Oliver Tremayne, vicar and overall amazing fellow. And Mamm-wynn! Delightful mysterious, pixie-ish grandmother.
There were a couple things that weren't my favorite: I sometimes felt the heroine had a sort of scientific arrogance; a few things rubbed me the wrong way; and I wished for more time for a certain side romance, so it would seem less sudden. But these are personal preferences!
On the whole, I very much enjoyed reading it and being swept off to these enchanting islands on an adventure. There are a couple of unresolved threads and I hope to return to the Isles of Scilly with these lovely characters for more tales in future books! Do check this one out!
I received a free ARC of this book from the publisher. This is my honest review and all opinions are my own.
Review originally posted on my blog: https://thepagedreamer.wordpress.com/...
The 1906 setting was interesting, and the islands themselves were drop-dead stunning and made me want to visit them! They sprang to life so well, considering I'd never read about this particular setting before, and were probably my favorite thing about the book! So unique and delightful, and I do love a good "island story." I loved how it also felt somewhat Cornish but with its own twist, and the villagers, cottages, boats, flowers, sea, rocks, etc. were all wonderful!
I loved the writing! The story itself was super engaging and kept me intrigued throughout, and I loved seeing the intertwining threads of characters' lives and secrets unfold, along with an exciting mystery/treasure hunt with lots of clues, and some super-cute romances thrown in there. Some of the twists surprised me in a good way (particularly a certain rivalry).
The characters all came to life and many of them were fabulous. I particularly loved mysterious lady's-maid-turned-untameable-island-girl Mabenna Moon--she was marvelous!-- and of course Oliver Tremayne, vicar and overall amazing fellow. And Mamm-wynn! Delightful mysterious, pixie-ish grandmother.
There were a couple things that weren't my favorite: I sometimes felt the heroine had a sort of scientific arrogance; a few things rubbed me the wrong way; and I wished for more time for a certain side romance, so it would seem less sudden. But these are personal preferences!
On the whole, I very much enjoyed reading it and being swept off to these enchanting islands on an adventure. There are a couple of unresolved threads and I hope to return to the Isles of Scilly with these lovely characters for more tales in future books! Do check this one out!
I received a free ARC of this book from the publisher. This is my honest review and all opinions are my own.
Review originally posted on my blog: https://thepagedreamer.wordpress.com/...
April 12, 2021
An enchanting story from Roseanna M. White! The Nature of a Lady is inspirational, soul-stirring, and wonderfully romantic. I absolutely loved the charming, intriguing setting, and I can’t wait to continue reading about these characters!
I’ll admit, it took a little while for the story to grab me, but once it did I was completely hooked. There were times I didn’t feel like I knew Libby and Oliver as well as I could have, but I grew to love their inspiring personalities and eccentricities. White has an incredible knack for creating intensely relatable characters; I adored the side stories and am so eager to learn more about these people I feel like I know in real life.
The Nature of a Lady is not to be missed. Readers will be captured by White’s exquisite prose and impeccable talent for crafting a riveting tale. This is a wonderful beginning to a series I cannot wait to continue. 4.5/5 stars
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
I’ll admit, it took a little while for the story to grab me, but once it did I was completely hooked. There were times I didn’t feel like I knew Libby and Oliver as well as I could have, but I grew to love their inspiring personalities and eccentricities. White has an incredible knack for creating intensely relatable characters; I adored the side stories and am so eager to learn more about these people I feel like I know in real life.
The Nature of a Lady is not to be missed. Readers will be captured by White’s exquisite prose and impeccable talent for crafting a riveting tale. This is a wonderful beginning to a series I cannot wait to continue. 4.5/5 stars
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
May 4, 2021
This was everything I've come to expect from Roseanna M White. A cast full of lovable characters with intriguing personalities and interests, a mystery plot which kept me reading to find out what is going on, danger and fear for lovable characters, and not just one, but two sweet love stories for characters I was rooting for.
He has created a universe of order and rules - but He himself is so much bigger. So full of mystery.
There was so many characters to love, Libby with her love of science and journey to see how this and God's love for us/her would both fit into her life. Moon with her past hurts and love of the Scillies calling her back, and Oliver with his steadfast faith in God and support for others, but I think Mamm-wynn with her craziness and vision was my favourite.
"Mamm-wynn! What are you doing out of bed? And here, of all places?" Their grandmother laughed. "Saving the day, of course. I had to. All my favorites were here."
The mystery plot in this story was concluded, however, the danger and threats about this mystery has not fully come to an end and I'm expecting a lot more adventures in the future books in this series, as well as a lot of characters introduced which I'm hoping for a HEA for each of them as well.
Love really was like a bird. You didn't know where it might settle, or when. You couldn't tame it, couldn't force it. Couldn't predict it.
Wishing the next book's release was around the corner, because the Islands and its people has found a place in my heart.
Fans of Roseanna M White will not be disappointed with this one.
*I received a complimentary copy from the publisher. All opinions expressed are my own.*
He has created a universe of order and rules - but He himself is so much bigger. So full of mystery.
There was so many characters to love, Libby with her love of science and journey to see how this and God's love for us/her would both fit into her life. Moon with her past hurts and love of the Scillies calling her back, and Oliver with his steadfast faith in God and support for others, but I think Mamm-wynn with her craziness and vision was my favourite.
"Mamm-wynn! What are you doing out of bed? And here, of all places?" Their grandmother laughed. "Saving the day, of course. I had to. All my favorites were here."
The mystery plot in this story was concluded, however, the danger and threats about this mystery has not fully come to an end and I'm expecting a lot more adventures in the future books in this series, as well as a lot of characters introduced which I'm hoping for a HEA for each of them as well.
Love really was like a bird. You didn't know where it might settle, or when. You couldn't tame it, couldn't force it. Couldn't predict it.
Wishing the next book's release was around the corner, because the Islands and its people has found a place in my heart.
Fans of Roseanna M White will not be disappointed with this one.
*I received a complimentary copy from the publisher. All opinions expressed are my own.*
September 13, 2021
Roseanna M. White has a lovely, descriptive way of writing that is very satisfying to read. Libby was a very unique protagonist, and I think I liked that. Oddly enough, her more timid personality reminded me of myself in a way that I don't think any other protagonist I've read has ever done.
The characters were well-written, fleshed out, and real; the setting was lush and whimsical. My problem was with the romance. What I loved about Dreams of Savannah was how realistically the romance was portrayed, with the struggles and the growth. That was what I expected to find in The Nature of a Lady... but I didn't. It was a normal (if I may use that term) romance, unique in some ways certainly, but - and I mean no offense - sappy. And I am not a sappy camper.
I like romance that's built on deep faith, and/or that grows through trials and comes out ever stronger. And what struck me as most uncharacteristic about the romance in this novel was how Oliver falls for Libby, even kisses her out of his passion, but while he's a vicar - a pastor - she still questions the existence of God. Somehow, it frustrated me, coming from a godly man who is "assured" only by a feeling that Libby will one day come to God. I think that assurance - which seemed to brush aside the importance of being careful with one's attraction toward someone who doesn't believe - was what turned me off to the romance. Yes, followers of Christ can be and often are attracted to people who don't follow Christ. But the real issue is how they respond to that attraction and in that situation... and that conflict, that growth, was what I felt was missing in The Nature of a Lady.
The characters were well-written, fleshed out, and real; the setting was lush and whimsical. My problem was with the romance. What I loved about Dreams of Savannah was how realistically the romance was portrayed, with the struggles and the growth. That was what I expected to find in The Nature of a Lady... but I didn't. It was a normal (if I may use that term) romance, unique in some ways certainly, but - and I mean no offense - sappy. And I am not a sappy camper.
I like romance that's built on deep faith, and/or that grows through trials and comes out ever stronger. And what struck me as most uncharacteristic about the romance in this novel was how Oliver falls for Libby, even kisses her out of his passion, but while he's a vicar - a pastor - she still questions the existence of God. Somehow, it frustrated me, coming from a godly man who is "assured" only by a feeling that Libby will one day come to God. I think that assurance - which seemed to brush aside the importance of being careful with one's attraction toward someone who doesn't believe - was what turned me off to the romance. Yes, followers of Christ can be and often are attracted to people who don't follow Christ. But the real issue is how they respond to that attraction and in that situation... and that conflict, that growth, was what I felt was missing in The Nature of a Lady.
June 14, 2021
I have been waiting for this book since 2019 when I was one of the many Elizabeths who pre-ordered "The Number of Love" and ended up inspiring this story. I was the teensiest bit nervous after waiting that long that maybe The Nature of a Lady would be a total disappointment, but I haven't hated anything by Mrs. White yet, so I held on to hope, and I got it, and read it, and loved it! I'm so glad this released when it did because it is a perfect book for summer. I looooved the island setting, and PIRATE TREASURE! I did not know there would be pirate treasure, but there was, and I was a happy reader on a treasure hunt with the characters. Not a treasure hunt without danger, of course, because White is so good at adding conflict, but it was so much fun to wonder what was going on and learn how everything worked out.
Speaking of characters, they were so well done, but that's no surprise coming from Roseanna White. Most of her books that I've read tend to have a perspective from the heroine, the hero, and sometimes the villain. This one had the heroine, the hero... and the maid... which I wasn't expecting at all, LOL, but I liked getting to know Mabena, Libby's maid, from inside her head because she was a really interesting character who had so much more to her than you first realize! There was a lot to all of the characters, really. I'm so glad there's another book coming because I'd like to get to know several of them better than this book had room for! But for the ones I was able to get to know well, like Libby, Oliver, Mabena, and even Casek, I liked them a lot! I say "even Casek" because I didn't think I liked him at first since we initially meet him while learning about his and Oliver's issues with each other, but he turned out not to be such a bad guy, just competitive. I really like it when an author plays with first impressions like that by making you think a character is unlikable and then changing your mind. White did that with Sheridan as well. It's easy to think he's a villain at first because he's the one Libby's brother wants to force her to marry. White could have taken the easy road and made him a jerk so the reader would be totally on Libby's side, but he wasn't a jerk, he just wasn't very good at standing up to his friend. And he made some unwise decisions that spiraled out of his control, but it was nice to see him try to make up for it. I actually liked his personality, but even then I could see how he and Libby wouldn't be a good match. It seems I was right when I whiffed some chemistry between him an another character, though, given the synopsis for the second book. :D
As for the two Elizabeths, Libby and Beth, I enjoyed how White played with their similarities and differences. They looked enough alike that people who didn't know Beth well mistook Libby for her, but their personalities were totally different. It was exciting to watch Libby try to figure out where Beth had disappeared to, and I'm excited to get to know Beth better in the second book.
Another thing I liked was that Oliver, despite being a vicar and generally nice person, wasn't perfect. His rivalry with Casek was unexpected, but I think it helped him feel more real and I liked seeing them both grow and start to understand each other better.
And Mamm-Wynn was such a sweet lady, but feisty! I loved her dynamic with the other characters.
So, basically, I really enjoyed this! I'm honestly trying to think of anything I didn't like, but anything I wasn't sure about got satisfactorily resolved by the end, so I don't feel a particular need to bring them up. 5 stars!
Content Advisory:
Sexual:
Various characters are attracted to each other, but the attraction isn't obsessed upon. The mystery of the story is just as important as the romance.
Four kisses throughout the entire story. One is barely described at all. The other three are described a little bit longer, but more in emotional terms than physical.
Spiritual:
At the start, Libby believes in God but sees Him as a distant creator rather than someone who loves her and wants a personal relationship with her. But of course, she learns differently.
Mamm-wynn, though a little bit senile at times, sometimes knows things she couldn't possibly know via natural means. Like how she knew where certain people were without being told, or sometimes seems to have a little knowledge of future events. It befuddles Oliver, Libby, and Beth how this is possible. Mamm-wynn says something vague about "the veil slipping" but this is never explained in detail. I got the impression that she was implying that as she nears death, the veil between this world and heaven might be slipping for her a bit and perhaps God is allowing her to know some things others can't.
Violence:
A teenage boy is said to have been found dead in a cave and there are suspicions that it wasn't an accident. However, the body is not described. Two people get knocked over the head, and one almost drowns. Pain described. Multiple people are threatened by a gun and threatened in general. Someone is almost shot but is only grazed by the bullet. Brief mentions of pain and blood.
Speaking of characters, they were so well done, but that's no surprise coming from Roseanna White. Most of her books that I've read tend to have a perspective from the heroine, the hero, and sometimes the villain. This one had the heroine, the hero... and the maid... which I wasn't expecting at all, LOL, but I liked getting to know Mabena, Libby's maid, from inside her head because she was a really interesting character who had so much more to her than you first realize! There was a lot to all of the characters, really. I'm so glad there's another book coming because I'd like to get to know several of them better than this book had room for! But for the ones I was able to get to know well, like Libby, Oliver, Mabena, and even Casek, I liked them a lot! I say "even Casek" because I didn't think I liked him at first since we initially meet him while learning about his and Oliver's issues with each other, but he turned out not to be such a bad guy, just competitive. I really like it when an author plays with first impressions like that by making you think a character is unlikable and then changing your mind. White did that with Sheridan as well. It's easy to think he's a villain at first because he's the one Libby's brother wants to force her to marry. White could have taken the easy road and made him a jerk so the reader would be totally on Libby's side, but he wasn't a jerk, he just wasn't very good at standing up to his friend. And he made some unwise decisions that spiraled out of his control, but it was nice to see him try to make up for it. I actually liked his personality, but even then I could see how he and Libby wouldn't be a good match. It seems I was right when I whiffed some chemistry between him an another character, though, given the synopsis for the second book. :D
As for the two Elizabeths, Libby and Beth, I enjoyed how White played with their similarities and differences. They looked enough alike that people who didn't know Beth well mistook Libby for her, but their personalities were totally different. It was exciting to watch Libby try to figure out where Beth had disappeared to, and I'm excited to get to know Beth better in the second book.
Another thing I liked was that Oliver, despite being a vicar and generally nice person, wasn't perfect. His rivalry with Casek was unexpected, but I think it helped him feel more real and I liked seeing them both grow and start to understand each other better.
And Mamm-Wynn was such a sweet lady, but feisty! I loved her dynamic with the other characters.
So, basically, I really enjoyed this! I'm honestly trying to think of anything I didn't like, but anything I wasn't sure about got satisfactorily resolved by the end, so I don't feel a particular need to bring them up. 5 stars!
Content Advisory:
Sexual:
Various characters are attracted to each other, but the attraction isn't obsessed upon. The mystery of the story is just as important as the romance.
Four kisses throughout the entire story. One is barely described at all. The other three are described a little bit longer, but more in emotional terms than physical.
Spiritual:
At the start, Libby believes in God but sees Him as a distant creator rather than someone who loves her and wants a personal relationship with her. But of course, she learns differently.
Mamm-wynn, though a little bit senile at times, sometimes knows things she couldn't possibly know via natural means. Like how she knew where certain people were without being told, or sometimes seems to have a little knowledge of future events. It befuddles Oliver, Libby, and Beth how this is possible. Mamm-wynn says something vague about "the veil slipping" but this is never explained in detail. I got the impression that she was implying that as she nears death, the veil between this world and heaven might be slipping for her a bit and perhaps God is allowing her to know some things others can't.
Violence:
A teenage boy is said to have been found dead in a cave and there are suspicions that it wasn't an accident. However, the body is not described. Two people get knocked over the head, and one almost drowns. Pain described. Multiple people are threatened by a gun and threatened in general. Someone is almost shot but is only grazed by the bullet. Brief mentions of pain and blood.
April 30, 2021
"The Nature of a Lady" is a Christian romance set in 1906 in England. Oliver's sister has gone missing. People keep delivering messages and objects to Lady Elizabeth because she's living in the same vacation cottage and both women have a similar look. However, Oliver's sister promised an archaeological find to some men who now think that Lady Elizabeth is their contact and is withholding their prize. They've already killed one boy to get their treasure. Libby and Oliver must find Beth before more people get hurt.
Libby and Oliver shared an interest in science and studying nature. Oliver encouraged Libby to learn more, sharing his knowledge with her. He also respected her intelligence and her courage during their efforts to protect and find his sister. She encouraged him to live up to his faith and forgive a longtime rival. All of the characters were complex, realistic people, and I cared about what happened to the main characters.
Libby felt that science explained the world without a need for God. Oliver, a vicar, explained that learning more about God's creation didn't negate the need for God. He helped her to a sense of wonder at Christ's act offering salvation. Based on one sentence, it seemed like Libby still felt that the things she discovered using science should be used to reinterpret the Bible. I'd assert instead that the Bible helps us to properly interpret what we discover through science. After all, God knows how He created everything! (Go to the Answers in Genesis website for more information.) There was no sex or bad language. Overall, I'd recommend this enjoyable historical romance with a mystery.
I received an ebook review copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley.
Libby and Oliver shared an interest in science and studying nature. Oliver encouraged Libby to learn more, sharing his knowledge with her. He also respected her intelligence and her courage during their efforts to protect and find his sister. She encouraged him to live up to his faith and forgive a longtime rival. All of the characters were complex, realistic people, and I cared about what happened to the main characters.
Libby felt that science explained the world without a need for God. Oliver, a vicar, explained that learning more about God's creation didn't negate the need for God. He helped her to a sense of wonder at Christ's act offering salvation. Based on one sentence, it seemed like Libby still felt that the things she discovered using science should be used to reinterpret the Bible. I'd assert instead that the Bible helps us to properly interpret what we discover through science. After all, God knows how He created everything! (Go to the Answers in Genesis website for more information.) There was no sex or bad language. Overall, I'd recommend this enjoyable historical romance with a mystery.
I received an ebook review copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley.
May 18, 2021
Everyone probably knows that I am obsessed with pretty much everything that Roseanna writes at this point. She is one of my all time favorite authors. This one is a new series completely and a bit different than her usual, London spy situation, (which I have to say might still be my favorite) but it was a delightful burst of fresh air.
The characters were absolutely charming and I adored every single one of them. The mystery was intense, the drama real, and the protagonist’s dreams so real.
Libby’s struggle to understand a God who knows her name, her innermost thoughts and cares deeply about her was so well done. And Mam-wynn was my absolute favorite. I love when Roseanna puts prophetic characters into her books and this is the second one that I can remember noticing it so strongly.
I grew up reading and loving books by a certain author who wrote in the early 1900’s and was not only an author, but a naturalist. Her work in nature carried over so beautifully into her books and I adored and read every single one. This book reminded me of them and transported me back to when I had read the antique books that I still own. I loved all of the nature details and Libby’s fascination with creation.
Oliver. Aside from the fact that he has one of my all time favorite names, is a lovely character and I loved how the author portrayed his own struggles and weaknesses. I enjoyed getting to see his immaturity as well as his faith and the way that they all mixed into his character to make him who he was. I also enjoyed the bit of rivalry between him and Casek.
This book gave me more than one romance and I was entirely here for it!
Aside from all this, I related with Libby very much in the matter of her social situation. I’ll never forget this part of the story and how it touched me so deeply. I know that feeling. I’ve been there and it’s been something I have been feeling more of late.
“I grow so weary of being alone.” The whisper, pitiful, even to her own ears, scalded the night like the tears did her eyes.
HIs hand left her elbow, and for one eternal second she felt so incredibly bereft that she thought she might splinter, fracture, fall to pieces. But then, then his warm hand was cupping her cheek, and those fissures closed. “My sweet Libby, You’re not alone. You’re never alone. Even if your family were gone, even if we here who would be proud to be counted as your true friends were never to see you again- even then, you wouldn’t be alone. — He knows you, and he calls you by name. You, in all your uniqueness. You, in everything that differentiates you from others. You, in all you have in common with them. He knows you, and He calls you by name. He knows how you fit into this world.”
This book was just what I needed and I devoured it in a few days.
If you love historical romances, biblical messages and mystery wrapped up with nature, you will love this book!
The characters were absolutely charming and I adored every single one of them. The mystery was intense, the drama real, and the protagonist’s dreams so real.
Libby’s struggle to understand a God who knows her name, her innermost thoughts and cares deeply about her was so well done. And Mam-wynn was my absolute favorite. I love when Roseanna puts prophetic characters into her books and this is the second one that I can remember noticing it so strongly.
I grew up reading and loving books by a certain author who wrote in the early 1900’s and was not only an author, but a naturalist. Her work in nature carried over so beautifully into her books and I adored and read every single one. This book reminded me of them and transported me back to when I had read the antique books that I still own. I loved all of the nature details and Libby’s fascination with creation.
Oliver. Aside from the fact that he has one of my all time favorite names, is a lovely character and I loved how the author portrayed his own struggles and weaknesses. I enjoyed getting to see his immaturity as well as his faith and the way that they all mixed into his character to make him who he was. I also enjoyed the bit of rivalry between him and Casek.
This book gave me more than one romance and I was entirely here for it!
Aside from all this, I related with Libby very much in the matter of her social situation. I’ll never forget this part of the story and how it touched me so deeply. I know that feeling. I’ve been there and it’s been something I have been feeling more of late.
“I grow so weary of being alone.” The whisper, pitiful, even to her own ears, scalded the night like the tears did her eyes.
HIs hand left her elbow, and for one eternal second she felt so incredibly bereft that she thought she might splinter, fracture, fall to pieces. But then, then his warm hand was cupping her cheek, and those fissures closed. “My sweet Libby, You’re not alone. You’re never alone. Even if your family were gone, even if we here who would be proud to be counted as your true friends were never to see you again- even then, you wouldn’t be alone. — He knows you, and he calls you by name. You, in all your uniqueness. You, in everything that differentiates you from others. You, in all you have in common with them. He knows you, and He calls you by name. He knows how you fit into this world.”
This book was just what I needed and I devoured it in a few days.
If you love historical romances, biblical messages and mystery wrapped up with nature, you will love this book!
June 15, 2023
Secrets abound in this delightful gilded-age romance set in the beautiful isles of Scilly off the coast of Great Britain, as naturalist Lady Elizabeth Sinclair plans a “summer holiday” that turns out to be more than she expected. A mystery develops with an islander’s missing sister; then a budding romance as Elizabeth and a handsome man from her past begin to navigate the dangerous twists and turns to find the “other Elizabeth” who disappeared and discover why. I loved the Regency feel to this inspirational story, while author Roseanna M. White’s lively cast of characters kept me turning the pages. This is the first in her “The Secret of the Isles” series, and I look forward to reading the next!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 502 reviews