Matterhorn in DODReads Group

Jul 02, 2022 Rona Simmons rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

“It don’t mean nothin’” is an expression that emerged from the Vietnam War. The refrain was used by American soldiers as a means of coping with the horrors they witnessed and the injuries they sustained while escaping death. In that vein, Marlantes adds, “There it is.” In Matterhorn the men repeat the phrase when they realize how fruitless their efforts are as they fight a ruthless and cruel enemy, and how ignorant the orders from the commanding officers are as they relax with a cocktail or two “It don’t mean nothin’” is an expression that emerged from the Vietnam War. The refrain was used by American soldiers as a means of coping with the horrors they witnessed and the injuries they sustained while escaping death. In that vein, Marlantes adds, “There it is.” In Matterhorn the men repeat the phrase when they realize how fruitless their efforts are as they fight a ruthless and cruel enemy, and how ignorant the orders from the commanding officers are as they relax with a cocktail or two at the combat base far from the action, or incomprehensible the unceasing demand for body counts is regardless of the impact on the men in their shallow holes on the side of a hill.
Lt. Mellas is the protagonist and a stand in for Marlantes. Like Marlantes, Mellas is a graduate of an Ivy League college (Princeton) with a promising career ahead of him if he can make it back to the “world.” At the start, Mellas is, as we imagine Marlantes and most young men sent to the war were, inexperienced, naïve, and frightened. As a “boot” he is determined to learn quickly and later to teach what he has learned to the newly arrived replacements.
With each chapter, Marlantes unveils another troubling aspect of the war.
Commanding officers bark over radios for body counts in the midst of fire fights, the seemingly senseless giving up of a hard won hill only to be asked days later to return to take it again, the racial strife and fragging incidents, units becoming lost, fighting disease and leeches in the jungle which seems always to be in the midst of a downpour. He also tells of the respect and admiration the young lieutenants have for the more experienced enlisted men who know the ropes.
With dozens of combat terms (from arty and dee-dee, to lifer and squid, and on and on) and a constantly switching point of view, the story is jarring and the reader is forced to turn to the dictionary Marlantes provides at the back of the book, then hurry back to the action, perhaps reread a page or two and then rush to catch up with the men climbing through razor-sharp elephant grass, slipping in the mud, and dodging mortar fire to reach their target. It is that disjointed telling that – whether by accident or intent – gives the reader a sense of how difficult and frustrating the war was.
There it is.
A wrenching read, but one that any young man preparing for combat (and for that matter anyone who wants to have an inkling of what war is and how it has been fought) should take time to digest.
...more

1 like · Like · see review

Aug 06, 2019 Allie rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

Shelves: military

A Vietnam War memoir that is quality parts Phil Caputo (Vietnam vet turned journalist), Hampton Sides (deep dove into Chosin as this book does the Matterhorn) and “Catch-22” for its frankness.

1 like · Like · see review