From the Bookshelf of Ranters and Reviewers…
Find A Copy At
Group Discussions About This Book
November 2021 Series BOTM Suggestions
By Sofia , duckish things · 9 posts · 19 views
By Sofia , duckish things · 9 posts · 19 views
last updated Oct 21, 2021 11:56PM
October 2021 Continuation BOTM: The Wicked King
By Sofia , duckish things · 9 posts · 16 views
By Sofia , duckish things · 9 posts · 16 views
last updated Oct 21, 2021 11:55PM
showing 1 of 1 topics
view all »
Other topics mentioning this book
Share Your Reviews
By Sofia , duckish things · 2737 posts · 344 views
By Sofia , duckish things · 2737 posts · 344 views
last updated Jan 20, 2025 12:32PM
What Members Thought

(after reread: still 5/5 >:D)
Buddy-read with Layla! Go check out her review here !!and yes, for the record, i 100% agree that cardan's tail deserved more
So.
Funny story.
Somehow, I got it into my head that this book was about (view spoiler) , and that alone. In my head, the first book was the first book, the second book was about (view spoiler) , and the third book was about (view spoiler) ...more
Buddy-read with Layla! Go check out her review here !!
So.
Funny story.
Somehow, I got it into my head that this book was about (view spoiler) , and that alone. In my head, the first book was the first book, the second book was about (view spoiler) , and the third book was about (view spoiler) ...more

Apr 08, 2021
Anushka
rated it
it was amazing
Shelves:
ya,
lgbtq,
read-in-2021,
favorites,
fantasy,
strong-female-leads,
fantasy-series,
buddy-read,
fae
Dear Holly Black,
I'm very mad at you right now.
You think it's okay to mess with my heart? To make me fall in love with characters that don't exist? To make me fall for an absolute jerk? To make me root for a power-hungry devil of a girl?
Also, remember that ending you wrote? Yeah, I'm not happy about that either. It's just not polite to do that to a reader!
And yet, thank you.
Thank you for bringing this masterpiece of fantasy into my life, even if it shattered my heart into pieces. Thank you for ...more
I'm very mad at you right now.
You think it's okay to mess with my heart? To make me fall in love with characters that don't exist? To make me fall for an absolute jerk? To make me root for a power-hungry devil of a girl?
Also, remember that ending you wrote? Yeah, I'm not happy about that either. It's just not polite to do that to a reader!
And yet, thank you.
Thank you for bringing this masterpiece of fantasy into my life, even if it shattered my heart into pieces. Thank you for ...more

Woah.
I was a little hesitant to read this book because I didn't really like The Cruel Prince , but boy was I wrong.

IT WAS AMAZING!!!!😍😍😍
Definitely a huge difference compared to the first book. I loved The Wicked King .
Jude is sooooo much cooler and funnier than I expected.
"She frowns at the knife in my hand, the freshness of the wound. "Did you do that to yourself?"
That snaps me out of my daze for a moment. "Yes, I shot myself with an arrow."
I love Jude.😂
And that ending....... omg I can't be ...more
I was a little hesitant to read this book because I didn't really like The Cruel Prince , but boy was I wrong.

IT WAS AMAZING!!!!😍😍😍
Definitely a huge difference compared to the first book. I loved The Wicked King .
Jude is sooooo much cooler and funnier than I expected.
"She frowns at the knife in my hand, the freshness of the wound. "Did you do that to yourself?"
That snaps me out of my daze for a moment. "Yes, I shot myself with an arrow."
I love Jude.😂
And that ending....... omg I can't be ...more

“Pain makes you strong, Madoc once told me, making me lift a sword again and again. Get used to the weight.”
read dates
First read - August 2019
Re-read - May 2020
Okay wow , let me first talk about that ending , THAT ENDING. This ending was honeslty so unexpected and such a twist on the story [ where holly black is like the master off lets be honest ] and while i readed it , i was so shocked , like how could this happen and those endings are actually the best even tho you hate them you can't ...more
read dates
First read - August 2019
Re-read - May 2020
Okay wow , let me first talk about that ending , THAT ENDING. This ending was honeslty so unexpected and such a twist on the story [ where holly black is like the master off lets be honest ] and while i readed it , i was so shocked , like how could this happen and those endings are actually the best even tho you hate them you can't ...more

This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.

Jan 22, 2019
Kaya Lynch
rated it
it was amazing
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
all-timefavorites
Here's my five month late review because I suck at this Goodreads thing! So um yeah sorry...
What was that ending.
Okay. I shall lose my mind over the ending of the book at the end of this review because why the heck not??? Anyways, I want to start with an extremely nit-picky complaint:
the titles.
You see, the titles sorta give things away. Not completely but it does take the shock factor off of certain twists. THERE’S A REASON TITLES AREN’T RELEASED UNTIL THE PREVIOUS BOOKS ARE RELEASED.
But with t ...more
What was that ending.
Okay. I shall lose my mind over the ending of the book at the end of this review because why the heck not??? Anyways, I want to start with an extremely nit-picky complaint:
the titles.
You see, the titles sorta give things away. Not completely but it does take the shock factor off of certain twists. THERE’S A REASON TITLES AREN’T RELEASED UNTIL THE PREVIOUS BOOKS ARE RELEASED.
But with t ...more

CARDANNNN
Okay, seriously this was such a great sequel. I can’t wait to see what happens next!
Completed for the 2021 Popsugar Reading Challenge; prompt #12—a book you have seen on someone’s bookshelf
Okay, seriously this was such a great sequel. I can’t wait to see what happens next!
Completed for the 2021 Popsugar Reading Challenge; prompt #12—a book you have seen on someone’s bookshelf

Was this better than The Cruel Prince? Yes.
Was it epic? Almost but not really.
Okay, so I enjoyed this one much more than I did the first one. Truth be told, I was getting bored at the beginning, I find that the books in this series take a little to kick off, but once I passed the 35-40% mark I couldn't stop reading. I mean, I finished this last night at 3am.
I liked that there was more court politics in this book and I really like the story in general, but there are just things missing for me to ...more
Was it epic? Almost but not really.
Okay, so I enjoyed this one much more than I did the first one. Truth be told, I was getting bored at the beginning, I find that the books in this series take a little to kick off, but once I passed the 35-40% mark I couldn't stop reading. I mean, I finished this last night at 3am.
I liked that there was more court politics in this book and I really like the story in general, but there are just things missing for me to ...more

4.25 stars
I tried to insert a gif, but it's not working, so imagine a very confused anime girl instead.
I am not going to attempt to write a proper review, so, instead, I'm going to compose a list of things I can't believe:
(view spoiler) ...more
I tried to insert a gif, but it's not working, so imagine a very confused anime girl instead.
I am not going to attempt to write a proper review, so, instead, I'm going to compose a list of things I can't believe:
(view spoiler) ...more

It's perfect.
...more

sooooo... i finished this within a day, despite uni deadlines piling up. i don’t think i’ve ever finished a book so quickly. the first 100 pages bored me slightly, but boy, did the rest of the book make up for that. i am OBSESSED. i LOVE cardan and jude. the world of faerie and the storyline has me completely enchanted. the plottwist had me every. single. time... i know this is one of those book series that’s going to leave me feeling empty and depressed after finishing it.

Nov 21, 2021
꧁༺ L̴E̴X̴I̴E̴ ༻꧂
rated it
it was amazing
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
fantasy,
fae-ry-tale
FIVE STARS!!!!
This book had me like

This book must be full of glamour because I immediately fell into Elfhame and found myself appreciating all the characters, even Madoc.
Jude remains one of the best political strategists I've ever read, whether fantasy or fiction but even she learns in this book that keeping power is harder than acquiring it. Plus, her growing relationship with Cardan was so fun to follow as she alternatively finds herself wanting to strangle him and kiss him.
We also get to le ...more
This book had me like

This book must be full of glamour because I immediately fell into Elfhame and found myself appreciating all the characters, even Madoc.
Jude remains one of the best political strategists I've ever read, whether fantasy or fiction but even she learns in this book that keeping power is harder than acquiring it. Plus, her growing relationship with Cardan was so fun to follow as she alternatively finds herself wanting to strangle him and kiss him.
We also get to le ...more

*4,5
"You must be strong enough to strike and strike and strike again without tiring. The first lesson is to make yourself that strong.
It will hurt. Pain makes you strong." ...more
"You must be strong enough to strike and strike and strike again without tiring. The first lesson is to make yourself that strong.
It will hurt. Pain makes you strong." ...more

Jan 02, 2019
Tina Haigler
marked it as to-read

Feb 15, 2019
Melissa
marked it as to-read

May 16, 2019
Bryan Cayangcang
marked it as to-read