From the Bookshelf of Easley Library Bookworms…

Forest Child (Vikings of the New World Saga, #2)

Heather Day Gilbert

Find A Copy At

Group Discussions About This Book

No group discussions for this book yet.

What Members Thought

Dec 01, 2016 Werner rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

Shelves: books-i-own, action-heroines, historical-fiction

Note, Oct. Oct. 31, 2024: I've just corrected a typo here (I'd written "Greenland" instead of Vinland in one sentence, which changed the geography drastically!).

This is the long-awaited sequel to the author's God's Daughter, and brings her Saga of the Vikings of the New World to a conclusion. My five-star review of the earlier book is here: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show... ; the background information and many of the evaluative comments in that review would apply here as well, though IMO Note, Oct. Oct. 31, 2024: I've just corrected a typo here (I'd written "Greenland" instead of Vinland in one sentence, which changed the geography drastically!).

This is the long-awaited sequel to the author's God's Daughter, and brings her Saga of the Vikings of the New World to a conclusion. My five-star review of the earlier book is here: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show... ; the background information and many of the evaluative comments in that review would apply here as well, though IMO this book, if anything, is even better than the first. I would strongly advise reading the books in order; they have many of the same characters, and it will help you as a reader to come to this book with the better and deeper understanding of the relationships, personalities and general situation that the first book will give you. Where the first book focused on Gudrid, former pagan priestess (now a Christian) and healer, however, this one focuses on her half-sister-in-law by a previous marriage, Freydis, out-of-wedlock daughter of Eirik the Red.

The fictional element in historical fiction about real-life people (which both these women, and a number of the other characters here, were) uses imagination to reconstruct the details history leaves out, and especially the inner personalities and motivations that history may record imperfectly or not at all. As I already knew from reading some faithful modern re-tellings, our sole historical source for the Viking voyages to Vinland, the Icelandic sagas, don't remember Freydis kindly: she's depicted as a vicious, treacherous psychopath who becomes the New World's first mass murderer. BUT.... 1.) No historians, medieval or modern, are wholly free from biases that shape their reaction to their material. Gender relations in early Scandinavian/Germanic and Celtic society, as reflected in these books, were comparatively more equalitarian and meritocratic than those of the "civilized" states of southern Europe. By the 13th century, though, when the oral sagas were being committed to writing, the more patriarchal and stratified attitudes of the latter were re-shaping thought and practice in the northern lands. To these historiographers, a woman who clearly didn't fit their picture of proper gender roles may well have been seen as an obviously deviant villainess by definition, whose actions called for censorious treatment. 2.) Even some of the details recorded by the saga compilers themselves, if one reads between the lines, cast doubt on the supposedly innocent and pacific intentions of Freydis' adversaries. And 3.), the two key conversations in the sagas that cast Freydis in the worst light, taken at face value, were totally private conversations that none of the original tellers of the material could actually have been privy to. They're imaginative reconstructions, just as much as Gilbert's dialogue is --and they're reconstructions created by writers with an ideological agenda of their own.

Gilbert follows the factual account of events in the sagas faithfully (even including the two conversations I find suspect). But she fleshes out the picture with a more sympathetic vision, and a broader reconstruction of a plausible context, that gives us a very different picture of what (may have) actually happened on the Vineland coast a thousand years ago. The Freydis who emerges here isn't an evil harridan, and isn't psychotic. What she is is a tough-as-nails young woman who's the product of a society that puts a premium on physical courage and fighting ability, who's had to fight tooth and nail for anything she's ever gotten, who didn't feel loved as a child, never knew her birth mother, and doesn't show love or give trust very easily, a female warrior (in her culture, that wasn't a contradiction in terms) who killed men in combat while she was still in her teens, who doesn't readily take orders from any man, woman, or deity, and who isn't a total stranger to the effects of the special kind of dried mushrooms imbibed by Viking "berserkers" --which are as potent as modern-day "angel dust," and just as dangerous. She's also a smart, competent woman (it says something that she's the expedition leader here, not her husband) with principles as strong as steel, and deep reserves of love and loyalty. And like all of us, she's a woman on a spiritual journey ... which might not end where it began. In real life, the Vikings of succeeding generations never forgot her. Modern readers probably won't, either.

Gilbert brings Freydis' world vividly to life here, without employing info-dumps or cluttering the narrative with excessive details. (She includes a family tree for Freydis and a short list of other characters in the back, along with a short glossary of Viking terms used in the text; but I personally didn't need the former, and with my Scandinavian background, the latter only included a couple of words I didn't know --and I'd roughly deduced the meanings of those from the context already. Even readers who haven't read much about Vikings, I think, could guess the definitions of all these terms the same way.) This is a very taut, gripping read, with a lot of suspense in the first part even when you know the general outline of the history, and the plot continues to hold dangers and surprises up to the denouement and beyond. It's written in first-person, present-tense, which puts us inside Freydis' head and bonds us to her quickly. As in the first book, the characterizations are believable and vivid. All told, this is historical fiction at its finest! I give it my highest recommendation, and I'm looking forward to reading more of Gilbert's work.

As a quick footnote, I was gifted with a free copy of this work by the author, just because she knew I wanted to read it, and because she's got a generous heart. (A lot of authors give out e-books, which are relatively cheap --she gave me a signed trade paperback copy!) I wasn't asked to give a favorable review (or, really, any review at all) --that had to be earned, and it was earned in abundance. ...more

25 likes · Like · see review

Group Home Bookshelf Discussions

Photos Videos

Send invite Members Polls