From the Bookshelf of The Great Conversation 6

Paradise Lost
by
Start date
September 1, 2025
Finish date
September 17, 2025
Discussion
Books
Discussion leader
Caleb Gerber. (RIP CHARLIE)

Find A Copy At

Group Discussions About This Book

Showing 2 of 1 topics — 5 comments total
+ Books
Paradise Lost
By Caleb Gerber.… · 3 posts · 7 views
last updated Sep 06, 2025 10:07AM
Preface to Paradise Lost
By Caleb Gerber.… · 2 posts · 7 views
last updated Sep 03, 2025 06:51PM

What Members Thought

Ruth Donigian
May 24, 2025 rated it it was amazing
Shelves: favorites
Second Read:
After completing and studying the entire book I am still in awe of this great piece. Milton certainly has his flaws but overarching narrative and themes far outweigh his occasional stumbles. It was beautiful and tragic. Epic and comedic. A last sweet taste of medieval beauty.




First Read:
(Excerpts)
I’ve just dipped my feet in the ocean of this masterpiece.
Gabe Herrmann
Sep 18, 2025 rated it it was amazing
Shelves: top-books, philosophy
Cosmic rebellion and cosmic punishment. Human rebellion, cosmic consequences.

Reading Paradise Lost is like standing at the edge of eternity and peering into the architecture of divine purpose. Milton’s epic poem doesn’t just retell the Fall of Man—it interrogates it, philosophizes it, and reframes it through a lens of perspective that is hard to come by without heresy. For anyone drawn to teleology, this work is a masterclass in metaphysical inquiry.

Milton crafts Satan not as a cartoon villain,
...more
Lilly Roepnack
Sep 18, 2025 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Paradise Lost: The last great epic
My best friend is a literature major, and this is one of her favorites. I agree with her, and I want to reread this and Lewis's Preface. I think this book is an excellent 'what if' in that it explores things that, while they didn't expressly happen in the Bible, they very well could have. He does make some changes to the story, two of the most significant and concerning to some being the portrayal of the devil as sympathetic and Adam and Eve's 'sin high' they ha
...more
Ashley Hurst
Sep 18, 2025 rated it really liked it
Well, I started off really disliking the reading because it was a bit of a reach book and slightly confusing. Not an easy read for sure. However by the end of the book I fully want to read it again. I'd love to see the story play out backwards, so maybe in the future i'll do that.

P.S. The gospel message at the end is peak.
...more
Kiara Aldana
Sep 19, 2025 rated it liked it
Sarah Moran
Aug 31, 2025 is currently reading it
Annalise
Sep 16, 2025 rated it really liked it