From the Bookshelf of The Roundtable…

Strong Poison (Lord Peter Wimsey, #6)

Dorothy L. Sayers

Discussion: Themed Reads

Find A Copy At

Libraries

Group Discussions About This Book

Showing 2 of 12 topics — 991 comments total

Themed Reads

* List of Suggested Themes
By Petra · 10 posts · 73 views

last updated Aug 06, 2016 06:17PM

Nonfiction Wellness Books - 2024
By Lauren · 31 posts · 17 views

last updated Aug 01, 2024 11:45AM

showing 1 of 1 topics view all »

What Members Thought

Mar 30, 2011 Genia Lukin rated it really liked it · review of another edition

Shelves: mystery-and-detective

My fifth Peter Wimsey book, and the first one with Harriet vane in it.

Also, by happenstance, the first one I am writing a review of.

Coincidence? Not quite.

Despite the fact that this is the series' first love-tension filled book, this is not the first book where Sayers branches out of the normal mystery detective framework to occupy a somewhat broader niche. She began doing that much earlier, in Clouds of Witness, and certainly did so in the previous installment: The Unpleasantness at the Bellona My fifth Peter Wimsey book, and the first one with Harriet vane in it.

Also, by happenstance, the first one I am writing a review of.

Coincidence? Not quite.

Despite the fact that this is the series' first love-tension filled book, this is not the first book where Sayers branches out of the normal mystery detective framework to occupy a somewhat broader niche. She began doing that much earlier, in Clouds of Witness, and certainly did so in the previous installment: The Unpleasantness at the Bellona Club, with her commentary about PTSD (then known as shellshock).

This is the first book, however, where Wimsey's character undergoes a true and profound change. That in and of itself is atypical of the standard mystery and detective story, though certainly not unheard of. That is to say, in this day and age. Previously, though, as can be witnessed in the example of the great Sherlock Holmes, great detectives tended to remain a bit static, and pursue their investigation in more or less a similar manner.

I am not going to pick sides on the great rift between Wimsey fans - yes Harriet, no Harriet - at this point, as we've really seen very little of said Harriet, but I do find it interesting to see Wimsey in this somewhat new light. I also find it interesting, albeit I much prefer Wimsey to his spinster assistants - to see that not even the Noble Sleuth can do everything on his own. The fact that Sayers chooses him to employ assistants and allows his investigations to take some time is a point to her credit, especially as she did it before so many others had.

I also confess that, on the sheer level of emotional engagement and writing, I felt this book gripped me less than the previous one had - mostly perhaps because my own romantic struggles are more or less over, but my fascination with The Great War historically, and the topic of PTSD psychologically - remains. I felt, perhaps, a similar sort of emotion in the author who seemed to infuse more energy into the psychiatric than the romantic, but this quibble, which is personal anyway, doesn't detract much from the book. I still swallowed it in a few days.

I plan to restrain myself from further Sayers for the near future, mostly because she tends to take rather largish bites out of my schoolwork, both in terms of time and in terms of inclination. However, I will likely return to her with all due impatience before long, by finding some sort of convenient and pleasant-sounding excuse to take a break. ...more

3 likes · Like · see review

Sep 05, 2022 Kai Coates rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

First off, it's not a good mystery. But fans of Columbo (in which each episode started with the audience witnessing how the murder was committed) will know that the real fun is in how the bad guy is found out. Agatha Christie wrote good mysteries. Dorothy L. Sayers wrote good books.

The structure is bold and at times pure genius, especially the decision to open with the judge's summing-up in Harriet Vane's murder trial. She stands accused of murdering her former lover, Philip Boyes, a man who pur ...more

Like · see review

Oct 03, 2017 Julie marked it as didnt-finish · review of another edition

Shelves: mystery, audiobooks

I gave up before I even finished the second CD. The narrator's voice was putting me to sleep. He either mumbled in his british accent or talked super fast so that I couldn't absorb what he was saying and pay attention to the road at the same time. Either way, it was just droning on....
And after the summary of the first trial was over, the plot started to put me to sleep too. ...more

Like · see review