From the Bookshelf of The Roundtable…
Find A Copy At
Group Discussions About This Book
No group discussions for this book yet.
What Members Thought

What an extraordinary story. It captures something saga-like in the space of a novella. In the beginning the story is mired in the machinations of petty people trapped in long-static relationships, and then, somehow, with the help of aerial bombardment, the story breaks free and spirals into an ever more remarkable and ever more intimate love story. The story captures a moment in history that's too large to imagine, and clarifies it, by bringing the focus onto to the most intimate human level im
...more

Currently spinning:
Li Xianglan
Old-Shanghai-Mix
Before Amy Tan, there was Eileen Chang. Chang did in the early 20th century what Tan wants to do today - write stories that convey the relationships between men and women, old traditions vs. new, traditional vs. modernity. Chang did it with substantial grace. I've liked Tan, but I realize now what I was missing. (Not that it's fair to make comparisons, so I won't here.)
These six stories included in this collection are hard at times to read due to the ...more
Li Xianglan
Old-Shanghai-Mix
Before Amy Tan, there was Eileen Chang. Chang did in the early 20th century what Tan wants to do today - write stories that convey the relationships between men and women, old traditions vs. new, traditional vs. modernity. Chang did it with substantial grace. I've liked Tan, but I realize now what I was missing. (Not that it's fair to make comparisons, so I won't here.)
These six stories included in this collection are hard at times to read due to the ...more

Bad men, bad marriages, and intergenerational clashes. Chang has captured a certain socioeconomic malaise, but too many of the characters and situations are interchangeable.

Jul 13, 2013
Rosana
marked it as to-read

Sep 02, 2014
Kai Coates
marked it as to-read


Dec 12, 2017
Susan
marked it as to-read

Aug 12, 2018
Pamela
marked it as to-read
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
short-stories,
kindle-owned-to-read

Sep 16, 2022
Lauren
marked it as to-read