Lilith's Brood (Xenogenesis, #1-3) in Beyond Reality

Dec 04, 2014 mark monday rated it really liked it

Shelves: earth-journal, scifi-60s-70s-80s

from the Earth Journal of Scientific Analyst SLJLK92349UO,
Earth Invasion Exploratory Unit

one thing became clear to me as I read this trilogy: Octavia Butler is not partial to the human kind. oh, humanity: violent, vengeful, and vicious; petty, pitiful, perpetually proud. avaricious and all too willing to prey on their own. as a fellow visitor to this planet, I can only view Butler's perspective as one that is in line with my own. and so this was quite an invigorating experience given the overab from the Earth Journal of Scientific Analyst SLJLK92349UO,
Earth Invasion Exploratory Unit

one thing became clear to me as I read this trilogy: Octavia Butler is not partial to the human kind. oh, humanity: violent, vengeful, and vicious; petty, pitiful, perpetually proud. avaricious and all too willing to prey on their own. as a fellow visitor to this planet, I can only view Butler's perspective as one that is in line with my own. and so this was quite an invigorating experience given the overabundance of naively pro-human novels in the science fiction genre.

the story, in broad strokes: humanity destroys itself... the starfaring race of the Oankali arrive to pick up the pieces by saving what few humans remain on their blighted planet. these saviors of humanity offer them a sort of bargain: join with us - literally - and be reborn. it is not actually a bargain because humanity does not have much say in the matter. predictably, humans seethe and rebel against this kindly offer. my cynical self can't help but think that the main reason humans resist the compassion of the Oankali is because a large number of tentacles are involved. oh, racist humans! the trilogy follows the lives of three individuals: the woman who paves the way for a joining of the two species, and two of her children - two different kinds of human/Oankali "constructs".

Butler correctly assesses humanity's tragic flaw: a genetic tendency towards hierarchism at every level. a flaw that on the micro level leads to an inability to form relationships based on equality - and in the macro, one that could easily lead to the end of humanity's home world as they know it. oh, humanity. Butler writes in simple, straightforward prose, in what I imagine to be a chilly, neutral monotone. her style of writing makes the reading experience a deceptively simple one. but this is not a simple work. there is so much to contemplate throughout this series, in particular the idea of essentialism in terms of basic human nature: in gender roles, in the propagation of the species, in the ability to form families and other necessary social units, in the ways that humans think and act and react. science fiction as a genre once had at its core the idea of "speculation" - what would happen if this concept was introduced, what would happen if that idea changed a world. Butler's trilogy is a part of that excellent tradition and these books are challenging in the best sort of way: they force the reader to speculate on their own limited natures, on their own individual decisions and on the future of their kind. Lilith's Brood imagines where humanity's ultimate path may lie if they continue to give free reign to their basest genetic impulses - and then she imagines another path.

it should go without saying that Butler is ultimately in favor of the Oankali way. as a race, they are not without their own rather endearing flaws. but compared to humanity? well, that's like comparing a human child's scribblings to the works of the relatively advanced human Da Vinci. it was quite refreshing for me to read an alien invasion saga that is so resolutely on the side of the sensible "aliens". it was also fascinating to witness Butler's iciness gradually melt away, slowly revealing herself to be a rather tender individual who fully endorses the spirit and acts of cooperation and connection and joining that are necessary for any species' ongoing survival. her calm, dry-eyed observational skills are merely the outer shell of a person who values above all else such things as curiosity, compassion, and the concept that to live is to change. all beings are works in progress.

I have observed humanity as well; indeed, that is my entire mission on this planet. I hesitate to say that I am more sympathetic to the species, but my robot heart does have a certain fondness for this stumbling, bumbling race - a sympathy that a being from Butler's own insect species would most likely find quite foreign. well, I have been programmed for both sympathy and empathy while such emotions are often eschewed by her culture. I suppose these differences in perspective will be reconciled once our joint invasion of Earth commences. ...more

158 likes · Like · see review

Sep 30, 2007 John rated it really liked it

Lilith's Brood is actually three novels: Dawn, Adulthood Rites, and Imago, which have since been published in one volume. The basic story is this: humanity has virtually destroyed itself and the earth in a nuclear conflagration. Just after we've done so, a strange and powerful alien race called the Oankali arrive to save us. Sort of.

The Oankali are strange in a number of ways. They have horrifying snake-like sensory tentacles all over their bodies, they have three genders, and one of those ge Lilith's Brood is actually three novels: Dawn, Adulthood Rites, and Imago, which have since been published in one volume. The basic story is this: humanity has virtually destroyed itself and the earth in a nuclear conflagration. Just after we've done so, a strange and powerful alien race called the Oankali arrive to save us. Sort of.

The Oankali are strange in a number of ways. They have horrifying snake-like sensory tentacles all over their bodies, they have three genders, and one of those genders has the ability to perceive, understand, and manipulate life on the genetic level. This alien race is driven from planet to planet looking for new races with which to merge genetic material, essentially finding new ways to evolve themselves. The human survivors of earth are put into a sort of stasis while the Oankali work to repair the damage we've done to the earth. The first novel is the story of Lilith Ayapslo, one of the first humans awakened, who is given the task of awakening other humans, making them aware of the situation, and teaching them to survive back on earth. Lilith--and the rest of humanity--is deeply troubled by the thought of merging with the Oankali and giving up humanity as a separate species.

The remaining novels deal with Lilith's children who are cross-breeds of humans and Oankali, who are living in a milieu that includes Human-Oankali "constructs" and sterile, frustrated humans who are resisting the merger with the aliens.

The series deals with issues of what it means to be human (remember this quotation?), while also developing interesting characters and their relationships. Each installment in the series is pretty good and there's a certain arc to the whole thing that weaves them all together. Nonetheless, I was frustrated to see that one of the major plot threads of the second novel was never really resolved. Not to give away the details of it, but we're brought to consider the question of whether human beings are essentially flawed, essentially doomed. The Oankali suggest that we are, but of course that's not exactly a satisfactory answer for, well, pretty much any of us who might read her novel. Thus, we want to see how the contradictions in our nature might be resolved, and we never get that chance. We're left instead with the possibility that we might save ourselves, but the assurance by the aliens that we will not and the redemption that we do see finally comes from the Oankali themselves, which is a bit disappointing, overall.

Still, the novels were enjoyable in themselves; it was only the overall expectations raised that left me rather unsatisfied. ...more

9 likes · Like · see review

Oct 28, 2008 Coyle rated it really liked it · review of another edition

Well written, but not terribly thoughtful. The real problem of humanity is that we're both intelligent and hierarchical? In other words, all the troubles of mankind come from a combination of reason and order? Apparently, things would be much better if we were emotional and disordered...
But even that doesn't work, since Butler doesn't talk much about emotion ("emotion" seems to be mostly biochemical anyway). Despite all of her talk about mating, marriage, etc, only in the end of the trilogy does ...more

Like · see review

Jun 27, 2007 Wealhtheow rated it really liked it

Shelves: sci-fi

Like

Aug 14, 2007 Gavin rated it really liked it

Like

Mar 30, 2008 Steve rated it liked it

Like

Jul 09, 2008 JuliAnna rated it really liked it

Shelves: science-fiction

Like

Aug 26, 2008 Bill added it · review of another edition

Shelves: science-fiction

Like

Feb 11, 2009 Atlas marked it as to-read

Like

Apr 02, 2009 DivaDiane SM rated it it was amazing

Shelves: buddy-read-book-club-read, feminist-sffu, science-fiction

Like

Apr 19, 2009 Jyn rated it really liked it

Like

May 20, 2009 Sarah rated it really liked it

Like

Nov 29, 2009 Sarah marked it as to-read

Like

Jan 31, 2010 Michelle Johnson rated it it was amazing

Like

May 14, 2010 Shellie (Layers of Thought) marked it as to-read

Shelves: spec-fic-sf-utop-distop-ia-appocaly, spec-fic-science-fiction, spec-fic-sf-aliens-space

Like

Sep 12, 2010 Steve marked it as to-read

Shelves: all-time-list

Like

Jan 11, 2011 Kerry rated it really liked it

Shelves: sf, 8-out-of-10, 2011

1 like · Like

Mar 21, 2011 Roshio marked it as to-read

Like

Apr 03, 2011 Shanshad Whelan marked it as to-read

Like

Sep 30, 2011 Gaijinmama rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

Shelves: fiction, favorites

Like

Oct 16, 2011 MadProfessah rated it it was amazing

Like

Jan 03, 2014 LadyDawn rated it really liked it

Like

Jan 10, 2014 Kevin Xu marked it as to-read · review of another edition

Like

Mar 24, 2014 Nyssa marked it as to-read · review of another edition

Shelves: format-electronic, series-book-1, speculative-fiction, science-fiction, aliens, womens-lit, format-omnibus, dystopian, post-apocalyptic, feminism

Like