From the Bookshelf of Atheists and Skeptics…

In the Shadow of the Sword: The Birth of Islam and the Rise of the Global Arab Empire

Tom Holland

Discussion: General

Find A Copy At

Libraries

Group Discussions About This Book

Showing 2 of 145 topics — 4,882 comments total

General

* Goodreads/Group policies - Discussion Thread
By Will · 54 posts · 169 views

last updated Nov 07, 2024 11:34AM

"Religion: The Original Pyramid Scheme?"
By Brad · 1 post · 3 views

last updated Aug 16, 2025 12:14PM

What Members Thought

Nov 17, 2019 Rindis rated it really liked it · review of another edition

Shelves: history, middle-ages

At first glance, this is just a new history of the start of Islam, and how the Arabs came to dominate such a large area, one of those parts of history that often defies analysis. And Holland loops this book around that subject a couple of times just to show how and why this is traditionally a tough subject to tackle.

There's a fair amount of myth surrounding the foundation of Islam. And it's so well presented that even when an outsider looks at it, and starts wondering just how likely some of it At first glance, this is just a new history of the start of Islam, and how the Arabs came to dominate such a large area, one of those parts of history that often defies analysis. And Holland loops this book around that subject a couple of times just to show how and why this is traditionally a tough subject to tackle.

There's a fair amount of myth surrounding the foundation of Islam. And it's so well presented that even when an outsider looks at it, and starts wondering just how likely some of it is, the weight of evidence comes down on the side of that myth. General Western views of this period aren't much more critical of the story than Islamic scholars are; that's an amazing intellectual achievement right there.

At the same time, this also is a marker of the change from late Antiquity, where Middle East is dominated by the superpowers of Rome (/Byzantium) and Sassanid Persia, to the early Medieval period where its the Christian world vs the Islamic one. Looking at AD 500 and AD 800, things look very different, and the source of changes seems invisible in AD 500.

Of course, the Middle East was traditionally a bubbling cauldron of different religious beliefs. Things like the Dead Sea Scrolls are the merest tip of the iceberg of religious debate; a snapshot of one place and time. Other sources talk of various other cults, and groups, that were obviously stealing the better ideas from each other. I really wish Holland had gone into that a bit more, and maybe tried to trace some of the currents of religious thought in the area, the groups that were slowly pushed to the fringes by the state-backed power of Christianity and Zoroastrianism. He goes into some, and lists a few oddities from the 5th and 6th Centuries. Oddities that sound really familiar in a religion that was supposed to spring full-formed from the mouth of a person touched by God.

And looking into the history of the Quran and the haddith, things don't look so clear. Despite the claims made, the earliest known examples, and the first biography of Mohammad, which codifies a lot of this story, date to nearly two centuries after his life. Now, these are based on earlier versions, but there's a fair amount of drift possible in that time, and the early history of the Quran is not looking any clearer that the early history of the Gospels. Holland doesn't go into it, but the later parts shows that there is something about the birth of a religion, possibly something forever unknowable. The codified institutions come later; events swept people along, caused a passionate belief... that doesn't get written down in all the excitement.

After that, a closer look at what was actually going on with Rome and the Sassanians helps bring things into focus. The Islamic irruption into the world stage happened at the end of a long conflict between Rome and Persia, and Holland not only points out how this had drained available manpower on both sides, but he goes into a plague that swept through the region just recently, and like the better known Black Death, it was devastating to world population as a whole. He then goes into the current generation of Arab mercenaries, whose sources of money are drying up....

And from there, the rest of the book is a familiar story, but with the emphases changed. He posits, from what is in the Quran, and a few other places, that Mohamed, and his closest companions, were far more aware of the Roman world than is generally understood, and move on to the struggle to define just what had happened over the next few generations, as events of the 630s slipped out of memory, and into history.

Its a well-written book all the way through, and really shakes up the normal perception of this period. I'd say this is among the top 'must reads' for anyone interested in this part of history. Parts of it are a bit vague, and pro tem, but it does reference much more current research than you normally get to hear about. ...more

8 likes · Like · see review

Oct 31, 2016 Paul Perry rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

Shelves: male-author, historical, history, non-fiction, ancient-history, politics, religion, islam, read-in-2016, christianity

This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.

1 like · Like · see review

Jan 07, 2014 Krishan rated it really liked it

Shelves: politics-and-history

A fascinating and long-winded account of the religious and political background to the formation of Islam. Holland stretches out in these pages, giving endless political and theological detail to the various political upheavals in the near East during late antiquity, and the religious changes and caused, and in turn were caused, by them.

His main theme is how established political orders are prone to rewrite their own histories in their own favour, and in turn remake the religions they espouse in ...more

Like · see review

Aug 08, 2012 Leo Horovitz marked it as to-read · review of another edition

Sep 27, 2012 Maphead marked it as to-read

Jun 18, 2013 Aladdin Elaasar rated it it was amazing

Jun 28, 2013 David marked it as to-read

May 25, 2024 Austin Martin marked it as to-read

Group Home Bookshelf Discussions

Photos Videos

Send invite Members Polls