From the Bookshelf of Around the World…
Find A Copy At
Group Discussions About This Book
No group discussions for this book yet.
What Members Thought

A story of a young girl who learns at an insane speed, and seems destined to have a role in late 19th century Turkey's political turmoil.
I enjoyed it but it doesn't really feel all that Turkish, in the end. You could have picked Eleanor up and dropped her into any exotic location with a sultan/king/emperor and the story could have been the same. I think the author wrote the book to get to write Istanbul but it wasn't essential for the story somehow.
And while it isn't classified YA, it had that f ...more
I enjoyed it but it doesn't really feel all that Turkish, in the end. You could have picked Eleanor up and dropped her into any exotic location with a sultan/king/emperor and the story could have been the same. I think the author wrote the book to get to write Istanbul but it wasn't essential for the story somehow.
And while it isn't classified YA, it had that f ...more

Jan 25, 2011
Barbara
rated it
really liked it
Shelves:
published-in-2011,
historical-fiction,
russia,
turkey,
read-in-2011,
politics,
romania,
stamboul,
in-germany,
in-istanbul
Posted 3/20/11 -- Who says you can't judge a book by its cover? Well, the cover of this book is beautiful, and so is the story. This is a wonderful, magical tale, and I absolutely loved it. I will be back to write a full review.
Posted 2/8/11 -- Yay! I won this book in the Goodreads' First Reads giveaway!!! I really wanted this book -- I love stories that take place in Turkey, and I love fables, and I believe this is a fable (based on some reviews that I have seen.) Actually, I read an interview ...more
Posted 2/8/11 -- Yay! I won this book in the Goodreads' First Reads giveaway!!! I really wanted this book -- I love stories that take place in Turkey, and I love fables, and I believe this is a fable (based on some reviews that I have seen.) Actually, I read an interview ...more

In Poisonwood Bible, author Barbara Kingsolver writes, "“I was afflicted with Africa like a bout of a rare disease, from which I have not managed a full recovery.”
This is exactly how I feel about Istanbul, having lived there mid-life for two years - and sorry to have to come home. Thus, I have a very hard time being neutral about any book before I begin. It wasn't long into the book that I had to tell myself to "Let the story be...." and to not try to fit it into what i remembered of Robert's Co ...more
This is exactly how I feel about Istanbul, having lived there mid-life for two years - and sorry to have to come home. Thus, I have a very hard time being neutral about any book before I begin. It wasn't long into the book that I had to tell myself to "Let the story be...." and to not try to fit it into what i remembered of Robert's Co ...more

My opinion goes with the majority on this novel. I wanted to love the novel, but I only ended up liking it. Michael David Lukas is an excellent writer, and he sets a mystical mood with his beautiful descriptions of the city of Stamboul and little touches of magic that fit into the world perfectly. The pacing is pretty slow, but it felt right to me, and the characters were interesting enough.
Many people complained that "nothing happens," which I agree with. This wouldn’t have been so bad in anoth ...more
Many people complained that "nothing happens," which I agree with. This wouldn’t have been so bad in anoth ...more

Great book with a great main character, a young Jewish girl from Romania in the late 1800s who is a child prodigy and her destiny in Istanbul. Hard to categorize, this is historical fiction with a touch of the magical.

Jan 16, 2011
Stephanie
marked it as to-read

Jan 16, 2011
Kimberly
marked it as to-read

Jan 16, 2011
Daisy
marked it as to-read

Feb 01, 2011
Kimberly
marked it as to-read


Feb 10, 2011
Jen
marked it as to-read

Apr 02, 2011
Emily Goenner Munson
marked it as to-read

May 17, 2011
Heather (DeathByBook)
marked it as to-read

3.5 Stars

Jan 04, 2012
Gussie
marked it as to-read

Mar 09, 2012
Linda
marked it as to-read

Aug 03, 2012
Almeta
marked it as to-read

Apr 20, 2013
RinTinTin
marked it as to-read