From the Bookshelf of Clean Reads…
Find A Copy At
Group Discussions About This Book
No group discussions for this book yet.
What Members Thought

After more than 300 pages I finally abandoned this book. Surprised me too! I enjoyed Inkheart and loved how this book started out. But it kept getting darker and more strained as the plot started to unravel under its own weight. I skipped to the end, figured I wouldn't enjoy how we got there and let it go. How this can be an "intermediate" book for 9-11 year olds is beyond me. If I didn't have a bookshelf full that I'm waiting to get to, I might have kept going. But it was obvious that I would h
...more

I listened to it, and the words came alive much better in Inkspell than they did in Inkheart, for me. Perhaps it was the difference of several years, but I'm willing to guess it was Brendan Fraser's wonderful reading of the story.
Now on to the next!
(3 words are the book titles minus ink!) ...more
Now on to the next!
(3 words are the book titles minus ink!) ...more

This series is only okay. I like it, but it's not great. There are some very interesting ideas in there that make me think Funke has a unique imaination.
*After reading it a second time, I had to add another star. I enjoyed the story more than last time. I think the reason I gave it such low marks last time is that the ending sucks. But I have hope for the series overall. I can't wait to find out what happens in the third book. ...more
*After reading it a second time, I had to add another star. I enjoyed the story more than last time. I think the reason I gave it such low marks last time is that the ending sucks. But I have hope for the series overall. I can't wait to find out what happens in the third book. ...more

I enjoyed this book, but not as much as the first one - mostly because it wasn't as fluid as Inkheart. I especially didn't appreciate how it ended - it was a definite cliff-hanger and although I know there is a third book coming soon, it just didn't seem right to end as if there were going to be another chapter right away.
...more

I just couldn't get into this book. I will try again when my present mood changes from wanting to read more "serious" literature to mere imaginative drivel.
...more

Feb 08, 2008
Tam Tam
marked it as to-possibly-read


Nov 12, 2008
Brittany F
marked it as to-read

May 12, 2009
Roni
marked it as to-read

May 31, 2009
Ashley
marked it as to-read