Franny and Zooey in The Dusty Bookshelf

Jul 04, 2010 Anne (Booklady) Molinarolo rated it it was amazing

Shelves: spring-2012, favorites, great-literary-fiction, classics, permanent-library, literary-fiction

When people think of J.D. Salinger, almost everyone's thoughts automatically turn to his The Catcher in the Rye (one of my least favorite books). Why, when Franny and Zooey is perhaps his greatest work. It is certainly his favorite. Written in 1955 and 1957 as separate short stories published in the eminent New Yorker, they are thought provoking. But combined together, they are a powerful novel.

Franny serves to set the scene and introduces the second, Zooey. Two Ivy League students meet for a When people think of J.D. Salinger, almost everyone's thoughts automatically turn to his The Catcher in the Rye (one of my least favorite books). Why, when Franny and Zooey is perhaps his greatest work. It is certainly his favorite. Written in 1955 and 1957 as separate short stories published in the eminent New Yorker, they are thought provoking. But combined together, they are a powerful novel.

Franny serves to set the scene and introduces the second, Zooey. Two Ivy League students meet for a date. The guy is an insensitive intellectual jock who only wants an audience for his loud intellectual pretensions and to have sex. Highly sensitive Franny is struggling at college while going through a spiritual crisis. She wants to be herself, have integrity, wonders why people play so many games and act out so many unauthentic roles. She wants to feel accepted, and to know the meaning of life. Feeling the pain of having no answers to life’s biggest questions, she suffers a nervous break-down clutching her copy of Journey of the Pilgrim, chanting “the Jesus Prayer” as her life saving mantra. Franny returns home to recover.

We find Zooey her older brother and actor, is in the bath tub reading a script. Their mother, a remarkable character in her own right, is worried, and rightly so. She thinks Zooey should be helping his sister. He does in his own particular and unique way; telling her that if she's going to pray "The Jesus Prayer," she needs to understand who Jesus was, and not picture Him as St. Francis of Assisi, somebody's grandmother, and their dead eldest brother, Seymour, all rolled up into one. Philosophies and religious doctrines are batted around, but it all boils down to a difficult brother caring for his difficult sister.

The characters are all wonderfully described. The jock, the mother, Franny and Zooey all make you laugh and scream at them. Salinger’s themes revolve around the dialogue, mostly verbal fencing between Franny and Zooey. Does he help or hinder? Yes; perhaps. Each reader will make his or her choice. And this is why when I think of J.D. Salinger, I always turn to Franny and Zooey. ...more

6 likes · Like · see review

Dec 22, 2010 Kevin Xu rated it liked it · review of another edition

kind of hard to get into then his other books

2 likes · Like · see review

Jan 30, 2019 Kristina rated it really liked it · review of another edition

Shelves: classics-club, fiction, short-stories-and-novellas

Cross-posted from my blog: quietandbusy.blogspot.com

With the end of January quickly approaching, I decided to tackle another book from my Back to the Classics Challenge list. For some reason, Franny and Zooey by J.D. Salinger was calling to me, so I decided to give it a shot. This book is also on my Classics Club list, so it's another opportunity for me to make more progress on that. I hadn't read any Salinger since I was assigned Catcher in the Rye back in high school. I liked that novel back t Cross-posted from my blog: quietandbusy.blogspot.com

With the end of January quickly approaching, I decided to tackle another book from my Back to the Classics Challenge list. For some reason, Franny and Zooey by J.D. Salinger was calling to me, so I decided to give it a shot. This book is also on my Classics Club list, so it's another opportunity for me to make more progress on that. I hadn't read any Salinger since I was assigned Catcher in the Rye back in high school. I liked that novel back then, so I went into reading Franny and Zooey with high hopes.

This book is split up into two sections, a short story called "Franny" and a novella called Zooey. Franny and Zooey are siblings in the Glass family, a fictional group consisting of a mother, father, and seven children. Salinger used these characters in some of his other stories as well, but this was my first introduction to the Glass brood. As it turns out, they are quite the quirky bunch.

"Franny" comes first in the collection. At the beginning of the short story, Franny Glass, an undergraduate college student, has traveled to see her boyfriend Lane at Yale University. As soon as she gets off the train, it is clear that something is wrong. She seems to be annoyed with nearly everything Lane says, doesn't eat the food she orders when they stop at a restaurant, and appears pale and sweaty. She eventually reveals that she's feeling extremely dissatisfied with what she sees as a lack of authenticity in the people and places around her. She's having an existential crisis and doesn't see much point in pursuing the academic and career goals she once had.

She also reveals that she's been coping with these feelings by turning to a religious book that instructs readers to "pray constantly" in order to attain spiritual enlightenment. She's been repeating a short prayer under her breath and in her head over and over in an attempt to reach this enlightened state. As her afternoon date wears on, she eventually faints and Lane takes her to a room to rest.

Zooey picks up soon after this incident. Franny has returned to her family home and set up camp on the couch. Her mother is hovering over her, trying to coax her back into being her normal self, but she isn't meeting with any success. Eventually, Zooey, Franny's elder brother, is enlisted to try and talk her out of her depression. The rest of the novella centers around his attempts to help. Zooey's tactics range from harshly calling out her behavior as selfish, to a much gentler phone call in which he conveys more optimistic ideas about religion and life goals.

This is a very short novel, and not much actually happens in it, but it is still somehow a brilliant read. Salinger's writing is clever and funny, and his characterizations of Franny and Zooey are excellent. The Glass family is pretentious, arrogant, and way too smart for their own good, but they also know this about themselves, try to temper it, and love each other in the meantime. A story full of arguments, depression, religious mania, and existential crises sounds like it would be quite heavy, but Franny and Zooey is actually rather heartwarming. It's a quick read too; it only took me a few hours to finish it.

As I'm not religious myself, I don't always enjoy books with religious themes. For this one, however, it didn't bother me. The novel portrays a rather nice interpretation of religion by the end, isn't remotely preachy, and includes ideas from several different religious texts throughout. Salinger stresses the idea that doing your best, even when no one is watching or cares, is ultimately worth it, which is a message that resonates especially loudly with me.

Overall, I thought Franny and Zooey was a charming, clever, and engaging read. Salinger's writing was impressive and the characters were very unique. It was most definitely worth the little chunk of time it took to read. It's nice to discover a classic that feels meaningful, is easy to understand, and doesn't take ages to get through. I would like to check out more of Salinger's work in the future, and I should probably reread Catcher in the Rye as well. It's been too long!
...more

Like · see review