The Seasonal Reading Challenge discussion

I think you put this in the wromg thread.

Andy P post 1309
Goodreads shows The Labyrinth of Osiris as having 448 pages.

Andy P.
Re Post 1309, regarding big book ticket for book:The Labyrinth of Osiris|13595029] I thought I could claim a big book ticket if the edition I read was over 500 pages which it was, In addition since it was an Advance Reader's Copy it had listed the number of pages in the hardcover edition soon to be published which was also over 500 pages. (Thus the 538 pages and 560 pages I listed.) Sorry if I misunderstood the rules.

the book file here only lists it at 448 pages, so you need to link the correct copy - or if that is it, ask some one to edit the file details to reflect the correct number of pages

Dee wrote: "the book file here only lists it at 448 pages, so you need to link the correct copy - or if that is it, ask some one to edit the file details to reflect the correct number of pages"
I don't know how to link to the correct copy so I guess I'll punt and not get the ticket

I'll send u a pm

Andy wrote: "Andy P.
Re Post 1309, regarding big book ticket for book:The Labyrinth of Osiris|13595029] I thought I could claim a big book ticket if the edition I read was over 500 pages which it was, In addit..."

The problem is not linking to a "correct" copy - there are only two listed, an ebook and a hardback "to be published" copy. You linked to the hardback, and that shows with 448 pages. Perhaps the info GR has is wrong, or perhaps the number of pages listed on your ARC copy is inaccurate for the hardcover edition.

Sandy - it looks like it has been released in the UK and has over 500 pages - so i'll update the record

ETA - done - I added the 2 paperback versions, both of which have 500+ pages

Paul - if you search by the ISBN of the ARC that you have, that will allow you to select the right version for posting in the points thread

Dee wrote: "Sandy - it looks like it has been released in the UK and has over 500 pages - so i'll update the record

ETA - done - I added the 2 paperback versions, both of which have 500+ pages

Paul - if you ..."

Thanks, Dee.

BJ Rose post 1365

task 15.3- Nightborn by Lynn Viehl satisfies the one book option N-N, L-L. You may move the other book if you choose

Peebee post 1363

Please check your total

♥Robin ♥ post 1379

What task number? 5.10?

Please repost

Meghanly post 1400

task 20.2 option 1 requires "Include the cover when you post."
Please repost this task with the required information

yay DLMRose is back!!! Big HUGS!!

Dee wrote: "yay DLMRose is back!!! Big HUGS!!"

Thanks, Dee- but I'm not really back.... still in the dark (and cold *shiver*) Things are bad here, but we are fine. The neighborhood is sharing as best we can- I'm on a borrowed connection. I'll try to get as much updated as I can.

Glad you are safe!!

Dee wrote: "Sandy - it looks like it has been released in the UK and has over 500 pages - so i'll update the record

ETA - done - I added the 2 paperback versions, both of which have 500+ pages

Paul - if you ..."

Thank you so much. I couldn't figure out why the copy I read was 90 pages longer than the one listed on Good Reads
Andy P.

So sorry to hear about your outages dlmrose. Did you sustain damage?

Reposted-Post # 1420

Dlmrose wrote: "Dee wrote: "yay DLMRose is back!!! Big HUGS!!"

Thanks, Dee- but I'm not really back.... still in the dark (and cold *shiver*) Things are bad here, but we are fine. The neighborhood is sharing as b..."

Glad you're safe! Hopefully you'll have power again soon. HUGS!

Janice CA - post 1375

task 30.12 stop 13 The genre War does not appear on the genre list for the book you claimed. Other genres were disallowed by the task creator.

Dlmrose wrote: "Peebee post 1363

Please check your total"


I keep coming up with 810, which is what I have in post 1368. But you have me as 820 on the Readerboard....I know I've shuffled some stuff around, but can't figure out where I missed some points...maybe we can figure out where the problem is.

Dlmrose wrote: "Janice CA - post 1375

task 30.12 stop 13 The genre War does not appear on the genre list for the book you claimed. Other genres were disallowed by the task creator."

Thanks for checking Dlmrose. I didn't realize the book couldn't be shelved under WWII. This marks my first time in three years to end up on the wall of shame. Sorry, I'll post the books under different tasks.

Peebee wrote: "Dlmrose wrote: "Peebee post 1363

Please check your total"


I keep coming up with 810, which is what I have in post 1368. But you have me as 820 on the Readerboard....I know I've shuffled some stu..."

I think I found it- please confirm that these are the tasks you have recorded
5.4, 5.7, 5.9 (15)
10.2, 10.3, 10.4, 10.8, 10.9 (50)
15.2, 15.4, 15.6-15.10 (105)
all 20 (200)
all 25 (200)
30.1, 30.5-30.8, 30.10-30.12 (240)

Dlmrose wrote: I think I found it- please confirm that these are the tasks you have recorded

Confirmed. Sorry for any shifting which led to confusion.

Tanyapt post 1410

task 30.4 4- A Million Suns is not on The Sword & Laser's read shelf If I'm missing it or it is a different group, please let me know

Please put tasks in numerical order- out-of-order posts are difficult

How are YOU doing Donna. Do you have power yet?

Miranda post 1411

task 20.3 option 1 requires "Specify the name of the protagonist and his/her age or indicate that they are still in high school."

Please repost with the required information

Sheila wrote: "How are YOU doing Donna. Do you have power yet?"

We fine, Sheila- we're still without power, but much better off than many of our friends and neighbors. We have no damage that can't be fixed. The damage here was from falling trees and utility poles- most streets have at least one house that had a tree go through the roof or onto their cars. So we're counting our blessings and helping our neighbors. Things in NY and NJ are bad- really bad- but they'll get better- our headline this morning

Dlmrose wrote: "Miranda post 1411

task 20.3 option 1 requires "Specify the name of the protagonist and his/her age or indicate that they are still in high school."

Please repost with the required information"

Do I need to repost the entire 1411 post, or just the 20.3 task? It's been a while since I participated in the group and I don't remember for sure.

Miranda wrote: "Do I need to repost the entire 1411 post, or just the 20.3 task?..."

Just the problem task, not the rest of the post.

Miranda post 1413
Gemma Malley is not noted as being a GR author.

Midu post 1437
Please note that you can only claim one GRA ticket per book.

thanks,Sandy. Shall I repost?

Midu wrote: "thanks,Sandy. Shall I repost?"

No need - I just wanted you to know why your GRA total is lower than the total you posted.

oops I reposted it! Sorry!

Bea post 1482

You already claimed 20.10 Group Reads on Sept 30. Please check your total. I have 225 recorded- 12 tasks
10.6, 15.1, 15.3, 15.6, 15.10. 20.2, 20.6, 20.8-20.10, 25.3, 30.12

Dlmrose wrote: "Bea post 1482

You already claimed 20.10 Group Reads on Sept 30. Please check your total. I have 225 recorded- 12 tasks
10.6, 15.1, 15.3, 15.6, 15.10. 20.2, 20.6, 20.8-20.10, 25.3, 30.12"

Sorry, Dlmrose. I did not have 20.10 marked as posted. I also posted 15.4 yesterday, didn't I?

Bea wrote: "I also posted 15.4 yesterday, didn't I? "

not in 1482

Dlmrose wrote: "Bea wrote: "I also posted 15.4 yesterday, didn't I? "

not in 1482"

Sorry... I must have deleted it by mistake. I do remember typing it out. I will post it later.

Cindy AL post 1513

task 30.4- The books you claimed don't appear on the read shelves of the groups- The Sword and Laser read shelf, Paranormal Romance read shelf
If I am missing them or they appear on the read shelf of a different group please let me know

Leslie K post 1514

Reposts must have complete information including book links

Ritika post 1527

task 30.1 option 2 Any one of the books you claimed would fulfill this option. You may move 2 of the graphic novels to other tasks if you choose
The 500 pg rule applies to children's picture books and collections of comic panels

Dlmrose wrote: "Ritika post 1527

task 30.1 option 2 Any one of the books you claimed would fulfill this option. You may move 2 of the graphic novels to other tasks if you choose
The 500 pg rule applies to childre..."

Should I repost or edit my comment?

Ritika wrote: "Dlmrose wrote: "Ritika post 1527

task 30.1 option 2 Any one of the books you claimed would fulfill this option. You may move 2 of the graphic novels to other tasks if you choose
The 500 pg rule ap..."

just let me know here which book you will use for 30.1

Dlmrose wrote: "Ritika wrote: "Dlmrose wrote: "Ritika post 1527

task 30.1 option 2 Any one of the books you claimed would fulfill this option. You may move 2 of the graphic novels to other tasks if you choose
The..."

The Sandman, Vol. 1: Preludes and Nocturnes

Ritika post 1549

30.11- The options you claimed don't match task 30.11
2B. Song: Where Have You Been?
3A. Singer: Select a book whose author uses three full names

task 30.10 maybe??

Please repost

Ems (Ems Reviews Books) post 1552

task 20.4 requires " State which option you chose when posting." Please repost this task with the required information

Jana post 1555

Please check your total. You claimed 15.6 on September 18. I have your total recorded as 135

Dlmrose wrote: " Ems (Ems Reviews Books) post 1552

task 20.4 requires " State which option you chose when posting." Please repost this task with the required information"

Fixed. Thanks!