Fantasy Book Club discussion
What are you reading in...
>
What are you reading in October 2012?
message 1:
by
Kevin
(new)
Sep 30, 2012 05:47PM

reply
|
flag
![Adrianna [SypherLily] (sypherlily) | 59 comments](https://images.gr-assets.com/users/1399076174p1/2997955.jpg)










Interesting. I think it was generated by GR as a recommendation based on Daughter of the Forest which I loved, so I'm excited to read it.

Interesting. I think it was generated by GR as a recommendation based on Daughter of the Forest which I loved, so I'm excited to read..."
It's a bit heavier, but I can see the connection.
![Adrianna [SypherLily] (sypherlily) | 59 comments](https://images.gr-assets.com/users/1399076174p1/2997955.jpg)




Howl's Moving Castle is among my favorites! :) Hope you love it!!



Is Terry Brooks worth reading, I tried as a teen, but never got into it.

I loved Brooks as a teen, but I'm a few trilogies behind now.

Thanks! Me too :) I can't say I've read any of your October books, but I'd be interested to hear what you think of Cinder




I like that one, as far as I've read it.....but I put it on hold while I read her stand alone book, "To Ride Hell's Chasm".

How do you like The Name of the Wind so far, Adam? I know a lot of people love book so much. Its one of the highest rate book I have ever seen, but I hate the book because I could not stand Kvothe.

I loved Kvothe! It's funny how characters grab different people. Another one that divided people was Quentin in Magician.

I love him 2..Just cant wait until the 3rd book to work out what he is all about..The books are definitely on my favorite list..


I finished listening to The Lightning Thief and started the audiobook for The Way of Shadows.
If there's time left I'm tending towards Prince of Thorns and Twelve for darker autumn reads.

Just starting King of Thorns now.



Barbm1020 wrote: "@Joseph, I loved The Island of the Mighty and the whole series!Evangeline Walton"
Evangeline Walton - one of the best (and saddest!) kept secrets - I LOVED all of her work.

I know I read at least three of them many years ago -- I was making my way through every book published as part of the Ballantine Adult Fantasy series -- but I don't remember if I read the fourth (fourth written, that is -- I think she worked her way backwards while writing them) since it wasn't actually published as part of the Series. I remember enjoying them, though.

That's enough of a recommendation for me - back up on the to-read shelf it goes. Also I finished Howl's Moving Castle and I thought it was totally charming. I was aware that a lot of stuff was going on that I didn't understand at the time so it definitely warrants a re-read. Really liked it!

That's enough of a recommendation for me - back up on the to-read shelf it goes. Also ..."
Hannah, I read both Cinder and Howl's Moving Castle and loved both of them.

Barbm1020 wrote: "@Joseph, I loved The Island of the Mighty and the whole ..."
Sounds like another TBR for me.
I'm curious, though....why saddest?

Barbm1020 wrote: "@Joseph, I loved The Island of the Mighty ..."
The saddest for two reasons: way too few readers have discovered this work. And the second: she wrote the first book and it was published with a rather off putting title (Why did they pick The Virgin and the Swine???) The book got buried.
It stayed buried - until Betty Ballantine republished it for the Ballantine Fantasy series - then asked Evangeline, who was, by then a very elderly lady - why she had never written any more books? Betty received in the mail two very old, yellowed COMPLETED manuscripts - the sequels that Evangeline had never sold.
They are all lovely stories! One of the better retellings of Welsh myth out there.
It seems Walton's career was further plagued with ill luck - she desperately wanted to write a Theseus story - and was totally eclipsed in that dream by Mary Renault's (very excellent also) The King Must Die and The Bull from the Sea.
No publisher was interested in buying a Theseus story after the tremendous success (deserved) of the Renault series.
By the time Walton was 'rediscovered' by the Ballantine fantasy series - she did finally sell her Theseus proposal - but was in her eighties by then. I am not sure if it was ever finished or published.
But at least we have the Ballantine Fantasy Series to thank for the fact her fantasy work survived and saw print. These are beautiful works. I wish they were more widely read.

Barbm1020 wrote: "@Joseph, I loved The Is..."
I am one of those, that has not read her books. I'll do my best to change that fact.
It is strange that I haven't, though. When I was first discovering my love of fantasy, I read a lot of mythology. There just was not enough of a choice then.
I think one, five foot section of shelves, was all that there was in the book stores then.

Sword Is Forged
I guess it did come out eventually. With a really terrible cover.
I'm guessing "Virgin and the Swine" seemed like an apporpriate title based on the events of the first part of Island of the Mighty -- Gwydion wants to get pigs from Pryderi, and there's also a virgin involved in some fairly crucial events. And it was initially published in 1935 so it's not like they had a fantasy demographic they were aiming for.
And I'm about 100 pages in -- not quite finished with Gwydion's section -- and really liking it; she does an excellent job using elevated but not overblown prose.


I'm starting Life of Pi now.

Books mentioned in this topic
The Great Hunt (other topics)The Dragon Reborn (other topics)
Theft of Swords (other topics)
The Emperor's Soul (other topics)
Shadow Chaser (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Alexey Pehov (other topics)B.J. Whittington (other topics)
Alexey Pehov (other topics)
Katherine Kurtz (other topics)
Evangeline Walton (other topics)
More...