101 Books to Read Before You Die discussion
What are you reading?
message 151:
by
Diane S ☔
(new)
Nov 12, 2013 02:45PM



reply
|
flag

I absolutely believe that the disenfranchised, oppressed, abused and all the other voiceless of society should find a place in the pages of fiction. In fact, fiction may be the one place where they may be given a name and a story. So, it is not the subject matter of this novel that I object to. This 15 year old Mumbai prostitute, sold into the sex trade at the age of 9 has as much right to be a star of fiction as any beautiful princess or brilliant detective. My problem is that the writing was inadequate. The narrator writes with a vocabulary rarely used by college students, yet she has only received a few months of education. Similes are employed that do not seem likely given the narrator’s background. I understand that those who are brutalized often become emotionally deadened, but this story and its characters were simply lifeless, flatter than a Gumbie doll.

I did not expect what I found in this book. At times, I felt as if it were as elusive as the ghosts that populated the memories of its characters. I just finished it and am tempted to turn back to the front page and begin again immediately. I skated across the surface of the narrative; now I need to tread the water of its images. Some day, maybe I will have the courage to plunge under the words to dare to encounter the deeper themes.


A daughter given born into the Mumbai slums, given up for adoption for a chance of survival. A childless couple the other side of the world in California adopt her.
3 stars
My Review: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...

I have loved every second of it so far! I would highly recommend this book to someone who wants to more a little more about the American prison system, specifically minimum-security facilities. This memoir is incredible.
My apologies if this book has been covered in this group, as I'm a little new to the group and don't quite know the ins and outs yet!

I liked the second half better than the first part of this spoof on the popular chivalrous legends of the day there are wonderfully laugh-out-loud scenes as well as sarcastic witty observations. The first part contained several lengthy autonomous stories which lacked the humor and sheer entertainment of the Don Quixote sections. I am glad I did not quit during these subsections. It is amazing that so much of what is ridiculed in human nature remains relevant.
Irene, kudos for getting through the whole thing! I read pieces of it in college, in my final semester, meaning we were reading it in the original, rather archaic Spanish, which about like trying to read Deuteronomy, in my opinion. I couldn't handle it after awhile, but I don't know if that's just because I was totally burnt out on Spanish literature at the time or if I just didn't like the book. I'll have to try it another time and give it a fair chance.
How long is it, by the way? I remember it seemed quite lengthy, but maybe that was just my perception?
How long is it, by the way? I remember it seemed quite lengthy, but maybe that was just my perception?

I read the translation by Edith Grosman which was extremely readable for a modern reader.
Yup, that's another reason I haven't gone back to it. I'm not scared of long books, but that one was hard! One day, one day...


Deep issues, psychic night, and chocolate don't quite knit together for me in this one. 2 stars.
here is my review: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...

Generally not a fan of books written from the pov of an animal. But, the writing is so stellar that it overcame my ambivalence.


Beautiful story full of magic, and generations spanning 300 years in the quaint town of Blackwell, MA. If you enjoy a book that spans time and different stories that interlock with each other, this one is for you.
Here's my review: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...

Generally not a fan of books written from the pov of an animal. But, the writing is so stellar that it overcame my ambivalence.
To Siberia by Per Petterson
This is the memories of a childhood in the 1930s & 1940s in a small town in
Denmark, in a fragile family at a turbulent time in the world by a narrator who believes that all her significant living and loving was experienced by the age of 23. Had this not been told by an incredibly gifted pen, the short novel would have fallen very flat. But, this author creates a stunning tapestry out of very slender threads.


Another book to love by Jojo Moyes :) A solid 4 star read. Occupied France during WWI, A Painting with a mysterious past, Enter present day girl that needs to be found...
Here is my review: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...



Alice has early onset Alzheimer's disease. A heartbreaking look into what happens when your brain starts to diminish over time. Really opened my eyes to this, and cannot imagine living with this.
My Review: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...


Another book to love by Jojo Moyes :) A solid 4 star read. Occupied France during WWI, A Painting with a mysterious past, Ent..."
I just picked this up from the library last night. I read Me Before You this year, and it was the best book I read in 2013!


I had opened this book with very high expectations for an amazing read, hopes inspired by the praise surrounding it. I closed the book disappointed. This young adult book is narrated by a 15 year old girl recalling a six month pivotal period during the previous year. Her beloved uncle, the object of an adolescent crush, has just died of AIDS and she transfers her affections to his partner, also dying of the disease. The year is 1986, so fear of this unfolding epidemic and its stigma serves as a backdrop. The book tackles themes crucial to adolescent maturation: the inappropriate first crush, sibling jealousy, and grief’s power to create a sense of isolation. The voice consistently approximates that of a young teen, but it always had the ring of an adult attempting to mirror a teen, never truly that of a teen. Maybe I projected myself into the narration too personally, being close to the age of the narrator, growing up in the same part of the country, but many details just did not feel plausible, such as the interaction between June and Toby, not by my experience of that time and place. As a young adult novel, I am not the target audience. This makes it difficult for me to honestly critique the book. So, I can only admit that it did not impress this adult reader.
Irene wrote: "Tell The Wolves I’m Home by Carol Rifka Brunt
I had opened this book with very high expectations for an amazing read, hopes inspired by the praise surrounding it. I closed the book disappointed. ..."
I felt a lot of that when I read it, too, Irene. Had a hard time "buying" it.
I had opened this book with very high expectations for an amazing read, hopes inspired by the praise surrounding it. I closed the book disappointed. ..."
I felt a lot of that when I read it, too, Irene. Had a hard time "buying" it.


WWII, two best friends, plane crash lands them both in very different circumstances...
3 stars. Here's my review: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...



Murder, Mayhem, Political races, Bribery
3 stars! Was slower than I would've liked...
Here's my review: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...



Set in the early 1300s, this is the story of life in the cathedral town of Kingsbridge where the men are all greedy, the women are all jealous and the powerful are corrupt. This is a sufficient novel; the prose is serviceable, the characters are uncomplicated and the historical research is on prominent display. I found much highly implausible, but I do not think the author expected his reader to think too deeply about the events recounted. In fact, he appears to assume that the reader is paying little attention to the text since many details are repeated over and over as if the reader would haven forgotten what was told 25 pages previous.


Majorly disappointed with this non- fiction read about a couple that owns a zoo and how they managed to hide and ultimately save over 300 Jews in occupied Poland. Writing was too disjointed and the true story did not flow together. Frankly, I'm glad I'm finally done with it.
2 stars



Set in the early 1300s, this is the story of life in the cathedral town of Kingsbridge where ..."
I read the The Pillars of the Earth recently. I found it to be on the shallow and predictable side. I see you think much the same of of its sequel.

I am very partial to oral history, so this book was a good fit for me. The author was born and raised in Connecticut by immigrants from China. Although she had always known that her paternal family was prominent in China prior to the revolution, she was surprised to see her paternal great aunt’s name in a college text book. That unexpected revelation inspired her to interview her great aunt and record her story. I was fascinated with the everyday details of life in China in the early 1900s. I was far less impressed with the accounts of the author’s own life which began each chapter. These short sections did not add anything to the book.
Christmas In Plains by Jimmy Carter

Trite, sophomoric, a pathetic knock-off of the premise for It’s A Wonderful Life.


Here is my review: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...

This is a fun who-done-it populated with quirky characters set in a quaint village of unpretentious artistic geniuses.




A 35 year old man who has become a quadriplegic when hit by a car sees his limited life as pointless. A 26 year old woman, emotionally crippled by a traumatic experience 6 years earlier, lives a life that seems directionless. When she accepts employment as his care-giver, their mutual impact on each other is predictably heart-warming. For the most part, Moyes strove valiantly to keep the wheels of this novel out of the rut of sentimentality. Difficult questions were raised without providing facile answers. For some reason I can’t understand, very short sections through out the novel were told from the voice of a character other than the primary narrator. These added nothing to the story, but managed to distract and to remind the reader that this was merely a piece of fiction and not anyone’s actual story.


Leisel Meminger steals books, and an interesting narrator tells us her story weaving in compassion, Nazi Germany, and friendship. Will not forget this one!



This short volume functions as a character sketch rather than a novel. It is the conversation (more of a monologue) between a man who has suffered some sort of psychotic break and his psychiatrist. It is never clear what is fact and what is fantasy, what is memory and what is delusion. But through this psychotic recounting of this man’s life, the insanity in much of society is brought into question. Andrew is the “holy fool: to a society that is a grand “pretender”. This is less of an engaging read, than a thought provoking experience. The writing is outstanding.


A book for book lovers, 4 stars overall.
Here is my review: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...

Books mentioned in this topic
Persuasion (other topics)It (other topics)
The Immortalists (other topics)
The Hate U Give (other topics)
Timekeeper (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Jane Austen (other topics)Madeline Miller (other topics)
Sarah Henning (other topics)
Sarah McCoy (other topics)
Sarah Pekkanen (other topics)
More...