The Mark of Athena question

I would have saved Bianca because now Nico is the gothiest goth in gothtown. Beckendorf and Silena were replaced by Leo and Piper, and Zoe Nighshade daughter of Atlas was reaplaced when we first met Calypso daughter of Atlas.

Silena!

LUKE!! and maybe Beckendorf AND Silena

If I could bring back one person taht has died in the Percy Jackson books, I would bring back Silena and Beckenford because Beckenford was like the anchor and Silena was a good person.

Luke and Bianca

Zoe, Luke, Bianca, Beckendorf, Silena, Bob, Bianca, Skippy and... Ya, that's everyone.

BECKENDORF!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I would want to save Bianca, if only for Nico, but then I realize that Hazel wouldn't have gotten her second chance. I liked Bianca as a character, and I probably would have grown to love her if she hadn't died so early on.
Maybe I would save Luke, because he turned out to have a good heart after all. But I think he deserves his stay in Elysium (Because we all know that's where he ended up ;)
I liked Zoe, too. Gosh, why did Rick kill of two awesome characters in ONE BOOK?!
So, maybe Bob, then? He was awesome :')

I think Rick kills off his characters for good reason. No one who died in both series died without reason. Bianca, because she unintentionally gave Hazel a second chance, Luke, to prevent Kronos from rising again, Zoe, to complete the prophecy, and Bob to help Annabeth and Percy survive.
Maybe I would leave well enough alone..? :)

Luke!


Alright, I know some of you are probably like..."What the heck are you thinking?" So, the reason I loved Luke, was because the way his character developed and how he was constantly struggling his whole life. He was confused, Hermes never saw him (for reasonable reasons), and he spent his whole confused and in anger with the gods. I guess it was necessary for him to die to defeat Kronos, but I would like him back...

Either Zoe, because she's amazing, or Beckendorf and Silena, because they are also amazing and happen to be one of my favorite couples among the minor characters. I would say Bianca, but then Hazel wouldn't exist and Nico wouldn't be the same character at all.

Beckendorf and BOB!!!!

Zoe definitely. She shouldn't have died.

Beckendorf and Silena. both of them together. they are a package deal

BOB!!! (HOH)

Ooooohhhhhhhh, yes, that would be nice!

Bianca because of how happy it would make Nico. He's way too lonely without Hazel and they barely talk. Zoe is pretty awesome too though

Bianca! oh, and also little Bob :)

Luke, Luke, Luke, and also Luke. He wasn't really bad, it was the vampires that charmespeaked him into doing all of the stuff he did.

Bianca She is awesome

Beckendorf or Luke or Bianca or Selena

Probably Beckendorf. I mean I love Silena and Bianca, but Beckendorf's death really struck me. Luke kinda creeped me out until the end so...

I love Silena and Beckendorf, but it would be sad to make one live without the other...

Think about Nico, he is alone, so I would bring back Bianca.

Bianca for Nico

Beckendorf AND Silena or Bianca.

Bianca..... Nico really didn't deserve to lose a sister, oh and also Beckendorf was cool

Zoe Nightshade.

I don't know, Zoe perhaps, or maybe Bianca, but I would really like Beckendorf and Selena, but you can't bring one back without the other

Mostly I'd bring back Bianca - she is the only thing that will help Nico not be so emo and depressed. Think about it: Nico thinks he doesn't belong anywhere, and Bianca is the only person that can change that thought. Plus she was awesome. xD

I wouldn't choose to bring back Luke - I'd let him just live in Elysium (COME ON RIORDAN WE KNOW HE ENDED UP THERE) and enjoy his afterlife, and then be reborn. I mean, yes, I would bring him back because I am forever grateful for what he did for Olympus, but there's no way to literally stab yourself and then come back to life.

Are we also talking about Heroes of Olympus here? 'Cause I'd save Bob . . . :'(

Bianca, maybe it would help Nico not to feel so depressed.

If we're talking about Heroes of Olympus here as well, then I'd want Skippy to come back.

If we choose Bianca, Hazel would never live again. So maybe, Zoe

Bianca, Luke, Zoe and Silena :(

Agree with all of you. They all end up being good people.