YA Bookaholics discussion

Allegiant (Divergent, #3)
This topic is about Allegiant
64 views
Archives > Thoughts on Allegiant: Was it Good or Bad?

Comments Showing 1-8 of 8 (8 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

Kate (kaitlins16) WARNING: THERE MAY BE SPOILERS IN THIS DISCUSSION

I spend a lot of time on Twitter, and so many people have been reading Allegiant since it came out on the 22nd. I haven't been looking very much into the specifics, but apparently, a lot of people are upset or at least disappointed.

Here are my questions for you (you don't need to answer them; they're just there to give you something to comment on if you feel like it):

-Did you like Allegiant?
-Do you think it was a good conclusion to the series?
-What did you rate it and why?
-How does it compare to the other books in the series?
-What did you think of the ending?

I haven't read the book yet, and I probably won't get to for a very long time, so . . . I'm going to leave the discussion to you guys. I'll come back and check on the discussion after I read the book.

In the meantime, enjoy the discussion!


message 2: by Damini (new)

Damini I too haven't read the book yet!
And I'm a bit confused about after reading several reviews as some of them are praising the book but most of the reviews are discouraging.

It'd be great to hear from those who have read the book.


message 3: by .chel. (new) - added it

.chel. (itschel) | 5 comments Loved Divergent & Insurgent. I just finished it & I'm speechless. I'm not quite sure how I feel about Allegiant yet.


Jackie - Fire & Ice Book Reviews (jackiefireicebookreviews) I am currently reading it, but I have been reading other peoples reviews, and they are saying they don't like it. Thanks to some people for not marking their spoilers, I know what happens at the end, and I believe that is why everyone is upset.


American Wolf | 5 comments im read it and it explains a lot and i like how she went back and forth for the charactors and aww its so goood


message 6: by Leonie (new)

Leonie I liked allegiant in general, but i didnt like how it ended. I think its one of the best fantasy-series existing and if the end would've been different i could say that it is the best series. Dont get me wrong, I really understand Veronicas decision and why it had to end how it did (we all knew sthing like that HAD to happen, just didnt expect it to be Tris) but I think she should write an alternative end for all those who grieve for a loved character and hoped for a happy end.


message 7: by A (new) - rated it 2 stars

A H Loved this book...the ending was, like, tragic, but I think as a book, and as an ending to the entire series, this book was definitely good. In fact, I found it to be better than Insurgent!


message 8: by btwthesepages, Living and Breathing Books (new) - rated it 5 stars

btwthesepages | 266 comments Mod
Liked it better than the first two books. The tragic ending made me shed s few tears and all the while I was like No, no, no, please no. This can't be happening. But I like the books that make me cry.I'm crazy like that ;)


back to top