The Fall of Five discussion

I wasn't so surprised with the twist on Five but the loss of one Garde member shocked me. I didn't suppose that they all would make it out alive but I was stunned with how suddenly it happened.

I agree, that was not very surprising but when "he" died I was shocked! He was my favorite character, and I should have saw it coming with the whole prophecy thing, but it still took me like a week to get over ;-;

Same here. I was suspicious of 5 all the time and I didn't think that 8 would be the one to die.

He was my favourite character and i was just stunned by his death. That shouldn't have happened.

Shocked... SHOCKED... I WAS LIVID AT 8 DYING...

I was very surprised that everything people had been discussing on here made it into the book. Mostly, as fun as speculation is on a series, it never touches the author for imagination. It kinda killed my enjoyment of the series, because there were no surprises. None.