2025 Reading Challenge discussion
ARCHIVE 2014
>
Deborah's List
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Deborah
(new)
Dec 13, 2013 09:06PM

reply
|
flag

10/7
2 Eleanor & Park
3 Code Name Verity
4 This Song Will Save Your Life
5 Firefly Lane
6 The Catcher in the Rye
7 The Hundred-Year-Old Man Who Climbed Out of the Window and Disappeared
8 Looking for Alaska
9 Lolita
10 Divergent

3/5
Touch
Murder is Binding

list
Hidden Gems: YA-Fantasy Novels 10 books (now 11)
1
2Year of the Griffin
3Fire and Hemlock
4The Perilous Gard
5
6Secrets in the Dark
7
8
9The Hawk and His Boy...............
10
11The Goblin Wood
Best for Book Clubs 5 books
1
2
3
4The Sounding
5

None of these are part of the above lists, of course:)
All of these are currently residing at home via purchase from bookstore, on Kindle, and checked out from library.
















11/16 read
UnSouled Done
Fangirl Done
Falling to Pieces Done
Second to None DONE ILL came in. Wasn't originally planned:)
The WarriorDone
Mistress of Mellyn Done
The Devil's FootprintsDone
These Broken Stars Done
Falling Kingdoms Done
Night of the Living Deed Done
Angel Diary, Vol. 05 Done








The Body of Christopher CreedDone
Room with a Clue Done
The Rosie Project Done
Dash & Lily's Book of Dares Done
A Study in Scarlet Done
The Quick and the Thread Done
Go Fetch!Done

















Vicious Done
I Heard the Owl Call My NameDone
BittenDone
A Kiss Before the ApocalypseDone
Never Fall Down Done
The Man from Primrose Lane Done
The Enchanted Done
Night BrokenDone
Strawberry Shortcake MurderDone
Looking for AlibrandiDone

Finished:











The Forgotten Beasts of Eld
Stitch Me Deadly
This Song Will Save Your Life
Thread Reckoning
The Last Templar
It Happened One Autumn
Devil in Winter
Break My Heart 1,000 Times
The Gunslinger
The Sanctuary
Sea of Shadows

Plan:


Finished:










James Potter and the Hall of Elders' Crossing
Eleanor & Park
And Then Came You: Sam's Story
House Of Many Shadows
House of Shadows
The Blood Gospel
Someday, Someday, Maybe
The King's Daughter
Firefly Lane
Freewill

One very popular book that everybody loves, that I couldn't finish. Very cliche, that I can enjoy if it hits me right; and the main characters friendship, where they didn't listen to each other.

And then a book which doesn't have very many ratings at all... and most people who read it seem to hate it. I felt deeply about the main character and really enjoyed.


Have you started The Catcher In the Rye?
I am reading it this month with the Lexington group. But if you are interested you might check out some of the discussion groups around this book here:
https://www.goodreads.com/topic/list_...

Thanks for the link, I've been browsing some of the links, such as the "why" of it being a classic. It helped put some of the earlier chapters in perspective:)

I totally understand. The first time I read it I thought it must be the profanity. I thought it must be a gimic of some sort. But now since I have read it quite a few times it has become a book like Ulysses only more approachable. But I disagree with the consensus that it is about mental illness. I think Holden is pretty sane and I wonder about the adults that are making a game out of life.
But more than this is the first line in the book. He tells you not to focus on Holden like you would David Copperfield because he is not giving you that kind of story. If you read the first page of David Copperfield you will find Caul-(field) explained.
I don't know if you have had any programming but I noticed that the language seemed organized to point to different things by the different descriptive words...such as when he used phoney or grand or vomit. Or where the different words are used. I was think about WW2 and how the code breakers were very popular.
One thing that I just noticed was the use of "fish" on the second page and then the other places that he uses the word fish...(to put together meaning for what the fish might mean).
As an experiment take a name or a word like ducks and Google that name and if nothing relevant comes up put WW2 with it and see if something comes up. Did you figure out how Holden got that good Good-bye? I think that was very confusing. Did you know that Salinger liked Hemingway a lot. Hemingway came up with the ice berg theory (Google that). I think that Salinger has used that to create this "huh?" kind of experience that makes you have to look deeper than just a book like "Anne of Green Gables.
When you get to the end of the book two songs will be mentioned. Be sure and play those as they will totally change the "read" you get on that scene, and perhaps make you question the "official" (cliff notes) interpretation on this book.
I see the book as an allegory rather than a biography of Holden. I would just keep an open mind to possibly looking at it in both ways and see what makes more sense.
If you have any questions and would like my opinion, I hope you will ask!
Thank you for writing back.