Addicted to YA discussion

63 views
Any Questions? > Should I read The Mortal Instruments or The Infernal Devices first?

Comments Showing 1-13 of 13 (13 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Chelsea (new)

Chelsea B | 179 comments Hey guys! I have been wanting to read these books for a long time! I don't know if it's better to start with The Infernal Devices series or The Mortal Instruments. I read The City of Bones a few months back, should I keep going with that? Also, feel free to send me a friend request!


message 2: by Basma (new)

Basma | 152 comments I'm not really sure :p
But whenever you decide to read TID .. Pm me so I could read it with you :)
I have been planning on reading it .. I just need some motivation :p


message 3: by Wren (new)

Wren Figueiro | 66 comments Think either way is fine. Each set has its own story and you won't have a problem understanding them. That said, though, I very much liked already knowing where some of the characters that are in TID would end up in TMI. All the stories are interconnected and I love seeing the interaction. Also, IMHO, TID is better, so if you start with it, you might not get the same impact from TMI (which is also awesome, but not as emotional as TID). Sorry, I'm not much help, lol. But in any case, I read TMI first, then TID.


message 4: by Andrea (new)

Andrea | 1 comments The Infernal devices is much better! then TMI!


message 5: by Chelsea (new)

Chelsea B | 179 comments Basma wrote: "I'm not really sure :p
But whenever you decide to read TID .. Pm me so I could read it with you :)
I have been planning on reading it .. I just need some motivation :p"


I will! I'll probably start it soon!


message 6: by Chelsea (new)

Chelsea B | 179 comments Thank y'all so much!


message 7: by Natasha S ♥ (new)

Natasha S ♥ (tashieareads) TID. Totally. I actully love them more than TMI.


message 8: by cc (new)

cc (caitlinisakittycat) Probably The Infernal Devices. While that trilogy isn't a prequel, it is set before The Mortal Instruments and is complete, whereas that last book in the TMI series has yet to be released. If you start with TID, there's no chance you'll have to wait to complete the series before starting the next.


message 9: by Aisya Raisya (new)

Aisya Raisya (aisyaraisya) | 63 comments If I hv to choose between TMI and TID. I'll definitely choose TID.
I think it 10times better than TMI. not that I said that TMI isn't good. it was really good, but I enjoyed victorian setting genre anyway.
what Im try to say is, who can resist Will's charm !?!


message 10: by Yuki (new)

Yuki | 286 comments I would start with TID because it explains a lot of things that will happen in TMI.


message 11: by Chelsea (new)

Chelsea B | 179 comments Thank y'all!


message 12: by Safiyyah (new)

Safiyyah | 14 comments mortal instruments is better to start with and the infernal devices wont make as much sense if you havent read them


message 13: by Jessica (new)

Jessica Dixon-Langford | 16 comments The Mortal Instruments


back to top