Read A Song Of Ice And Fire 2016 discussion

A Dance With Dragons ~ 46. A Ghost in Winterfell *Discuss only this chapter and anything prior

A chapter ending in confusion. I just want answers. Who are these people!? Could they be Catelyn's people? That would be interesting. I have to remember them.

Could it be Mance?

I love seeing more of winter showing up. It does seem to be a crazy winter though! I couldn't handle it. lol

These deaths so seem suspicious.

I seriously feel so bad for Theon as Reek. He made some poor choices, but not to where he deserved what he's gotten.

Brianna wrote: "I seriously feel so bad for Theon as Reek. He made some poor choices, but not to where he deserved what he's gotten. "

Then again, he did double-cross the family who raised and cared for him, and he went against the orders of his own true father in order to seek glory for himself by storming Winterfell, and he killed or ordered killed people for pretty trivial reasons including people who helped care for him as a child. He might not have deserved everything that has happened to him but he sure doesn't deserve a happy ending. I wonder what Abel/Mance wants with him?

And Stannis is here with his army...or what's left of it after that brutal march. I think he will prevail in the battle for Winterfell, but at what cost? And I think Ramsey will get away - it seems like his story is going to continue for a while.