EVERYONE Has Read This but Me - The Catch-Up Book Club discussion

How I see the vote shaking out...

Books in BOTM Polls:
The Picture of Dorian Gray
A Wrinkle in Time
Slaughterhouse-Five
Murder on the Orient Express


Title Author Recs
The Picture of Dorian Gray Wilde, Oscar 12
A Wrinkle in Time L'Engle, Madeleine 11
Slaughterhouse-Five Vonnegut Jr., Kurt 11
Murder on the Orient Express Christie, Agatha 10
Animal Farm Orwell, George 9
Anne of Green Gables Montgomery, L.M. 9
The Invisible Man Wells, H.G. 7
The Phantom Tollbooth Juster, Norton 6
The Odyssey Homer 5
Their Eyes Were Watching God Hurston, Nora Zeale 5
All Quiet on the Western Front Remarque, Erich Maria 4
Flowers for Algernon Keyes, Daniel 4
Lolita Nabokov, Vladimir 4
The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe Lewis, C.S. 4
The Magician's Nephew Lewis, C.S. 3
Emma Austen, Jane 3
Tess of the D'Urbervilles Hardy, Thomas 3
The Canterbury Tales Chaucer, Geoffrey 3
Auntie Mame: An Irreverent Escapade Dennis, Patrick 2
Charlie and the Chocolate Factory Dahl, Roald 2
On The Road Kerouac, John 2
The Iliad Homer 2
The Godfather Puzo, Mario 2
The Overcoat Gogol, Nikolai 2
Cat's Cradle Vonnegut Jr., Kurt 1
Little Women Alcott, Louisa May 1
Meditations Aurelius, Marcus 1
The Grapes of Wrath Steinbeck, John 1
The Heart Is a Lonely Hunter McCullers, Carson 1
The Three Musketeers Dumas, Alexander 1
Tender Is the Night Fitzgerald, F. Scott 1
The Hunchback of Notre-Dame Hugo, Victor 1
Inferno Alighieri, Dante 1
The Mysterious Affair at Styles (Hercule Poirot #1) Christie, Agatha 1
The Sheltering Sky Bowles, Paul 1
The Towers of Trebizond Macaulay, Rose 1

Name Book Vote
Amy A Wrinkle in Time
Brian A Wrinkle in Time
Cassinator A Wrinkle in Time
Daniela A Wrinkle in Time
Kevin A Wrinkle in Time
Kimberly Gonzales A Wrinkle in Time
Kristin A Wrinkle in Time
Mary A Wrinkle in Time
Radhika A Wrinkle in Time
Rowen A Wrinkle in Time
Sarah A Wrinkle in Time
Kimberly All Quiet on the Western Front
leva All Quiet on the Western Front
Marcos All Quiet on the Western Front
Sofie All Quiet on the Western Front
Janet An American Tragedy
Martina An American Tragedy
Anne-Kathrin Animal Farm
Audre Animal Farm
Cassinator Animal Farm
Irene Animal Farm
Kimberly Animal Farm
Leesa Animal Farm
Marcos Animal Farm
Sarah Suchon Animal Farm
Tori Animal Farm
Ashley Anne of Green Gables
Corinne Anne of Green Gables
Daph Anne of Green Gables
Fibhaa Anne of Green Gables
Gabriella Anne of Green Gables
Innastholiel Anne of Green Gables
Lauriane Anne of Green Gables
Radhika Anne of Green Gables
Tori Anne of Green Gables
Allegra Auntie Mame: An Irreverent Escapade
Rowen Auntie Mame: An Irreverent Escapade
Brian Cat's Cradle
Brian Charlie and the Chocolate Factory
Innastholiel Charlie and the Chocolate Factory
Daph Emma
Jasmine Emma
Stephanie Emma
Carolyn Flowers for Algernon
Hannah Flowers for Algernon
Laura Flowers for Algernon
Sarah Suchon Flowers for Algernon
Corinne Inferno
Lina Little Women
Christine Lolita
Jessica Lolita
Kimberly Lolita
Kyra Lolita
Innastholiel Meditations
Corinne Murder on the Orient Express
Elaine Murder on the Orient Express
Hannah Murder on the Orient Express
Joanna Murder on the Orient Express
Karen Murder on the Orient Express
Kimberly Gonzales Murder on the Orient Express
Kimberly Wendt Murder on the Orient Express
Sarah Murder on the Orient Express
Shivangi Murder on the Orient Express
Vrenzy Murder on the Orient Express
Kimberly On the Road
Kyra On the Road
Amy Slaughterhouse-Five
Cassinator Slaughterhouse-Five
Conner Slaughterhouse-Five
Joanna Slaughterhouse-Five
Karen Slaughterhouse-Five
Kaseadillla Slaughterhouse-Five
Marcos Slaughterhouse-Five
Radhika Slaughterhouse-Five
Sarah Suchon Slaughterhouse-Five
Stephanie Slaughterhouse-Five
Tori Slaughterhouse-Five
Kyra Tender Is the Night
Corinne Tess of the D'Urbervilles
Elaine Tess of the D'Urbervilles
Kimberly Tess of the D'Urbervilles
Corinne The Canterbury Tales
Iethe The Canterbury Tales
Marcos The Canterbury Tales
Janet The Godfather
Zach The Godfather
Isti The Grapes of Wrath
Alissa The Heart is a Lonely Hunter
Brian The Hunchback of Notre-Dame
Innastholiel The Iliad
Melanie The Iliad
Allegra The Invisible Man
Audre The Invisible Man
Kevin The Invisible Man
LobZig The Invisible Man
Melanie The Invisible Man
Sarah The Invisible Man
Tiffany The Invisible Man
Corinne The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe
Rowen The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe
Tiffany The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe
Vrenzy The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe
Iethe The Magician's Nephew
Linda The Magician's Nephew
Tiffany The Magician's Nephew
Elaine The Mysterious Affair at Styles (Hercule Poirot #1)
Cassinator The Odyssey
Gabriella The Odyssey
Innastholiel The Odyssey
Marcos The Odyssey
Rowen The Odyssey
Andy The Overcoat
Marcos The Overcoat
Allegra The Phantom Tollbooth
Ashley The Phantom Tollbooth
Mary The Phantom Tollbooth
Melanie The Phantom Tollbooth
Sarah Suchon The Phantom Tollbooth
Tiffany The Phantom Tollbooth
Abigail The Picture of Dorian Gray
Allegra The Picture of Dorian Gray
Audre The Picture of Dorian Gray
Cheryl The Picture of Dorian Gray
Conner The Picture of Dorian Gray
Irene The Picture of Dorian Gray
Kimberly The Picture of Dorian Gray
Kyra The Picture of Dorian Gray
lucie The Picture of Dorian Gray
Marcos The Picture of Dorian Gray
Melanie The Picture of Dorian Gray
Stephanie The Picture of Dorian Gray
Boradicus The Sheltering Sky
Kyra The Three Musketeers
Bethany Their Eyes Were Watching God
Carolyn Their Eyes Were Watching God
Jasmine Their Eyes Were Watching God
PeekingLlama - Laura Their Eyes Were Watching God
Sofie Their Eyes Were Watching God
Rowen The Towers of Trebizond

Shouldn't The Picture of Dorian Grey be one of the books to be voted on? Looks like it has 12 votes...

Kimberly wrote: "Shouldn't The Picture of Dorian Grey be one of the books to be voted on? Looks like it has 12 votes..."

Yes...

(And The Magician's Nephew is not listed under Title Author recs)

Lethe

lethe wrote: "Kimberly wrote: "Shouldn't The..."
Kimberly wrote: "Shouldn't The Picture of..."

see updated comment above, thanks

I was very much in doubt about the text of Sunny's post, which mentioned some books, but it wasn't clear if it was actually seconding any.

It seems Kasey considered it not a seconding. If it were to be considered a seconding, "Dorian Grey", for instance, would have got one extra vote, going to 13. Same for "Godfather" and so on.

Anyway, excellent, Kasey!