Fantasy Buddy Reads discussion

41 views
Archive [Retired Buddy Reads] > A Closed and Common Orbit [February 2018]

Comments Showing 1-27 of 27 (27 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Margret, Caladan Brood Face (new)

Margret | 3168 comments Mod
February 25th


message 2: by Seán (new)

Seán | 602 comments I'm in if I haven't read it by that stage myself!


message 3: by RuinEleint (new)

RuinEleint I have been putting this off forever. In


message 4: by Sara J. (new)

Sara J. (kefuwa) (kefuwa) | 137 comments Looking forward to getting to this one!


Diana Stormblessed (dashichka) | 5380 comments Missed this one. Need to put it on my list.


message 6: by Sha (new)

Sha | 1522 comments Innnnn


message 7: by Ann (new)

Ann (ann_davies) Started! Enjoying so far.


message 8: by Sara J. (new)

Sara J. (kefuwa) (kefuwa) | 137 comments I have started early too (Because I have a few other reads lined up end of Feb! xD)! Enjoying it so far as well... even though I do want to get back to the Wayfarer the current focus is intriguing to say the least.


message 9: by Ann (new)

Ann (ann_davies) Finished! Wow, this just pulled me in and I couldn't stop.

End of Book: (view spoiler)

I'll be around to discuss as others get further.


message 10: by RuinEleint (new)

RuinEleint Starting this today. Really liked the first book, so quite excited.


message 11: by Seán (new)

Seán | 602 comments Not quite ready to start this just yet, but hoping to be by the end of the week!


message 12: by Sara J. (new)

Sara J. (kefuwa) (kefuwa) | 137 comments Ann wrote: "Finished! Wow, this just pulled me in and I couldn't stop.

End of Book: I really liked that we knew more or less from the start that Jane was Pepper.

I enjoyed the jump back and forward approach..."


Aaaand I finished it on Sunday! After a certain point in the story I too just got pulled in and couldn't stop til the end! (view spoiler) Really wondering where the story will go from here~

One of my favourite (view spoiler)


message 13: by Timelord Iain, Tech Support (new)

Timelord Iain | 35529 comments Mod
The next book is Record of a Spaceborn Few... it's about (view spoiler)


message 14: by Sara J. (new)

Sara J. (kefuwa) (kefuwa) | 137 comments Iain wrote: "The next book is Record of a Spaceborn Few... it's about [spoilers removed]"

Oh I am definitely in for that! Earmarked it!


message 15: by Sara J. (new)

Sara J. (kefuwa) (kefuwa) | 137 comments Any idea whether there will be any more books beyond the next one?


message 16: by Timelord Iain, Tech Support (new)

Timelord Iain | 35529 comments Mod
I'm pretty new to Becky Chambers... but she doesn't seem to announce very far ahead... I think it's safe to assume, tho... the series is setup as loosely connected standalones...


message 17: by RuinEleint (new)

RuinEleint I am still in the early sections of this one. So I guess this is mainly going to be about Lovelace/Sirda finding a new life?


message 18: by Timelord Iain, Tech Support (new)

Timelord Iain | 35529 comments Mod
I started this a couple hours ago... halfway already... looks like it, Arkadeb...

I thought this was going to be more like the first book, before I started... but what it has been instead isn't bad... just a bit more limited in scope of characters... I'd say there's basically 5 main characters... (view spoiler)

What do you think of the message board interludes? (view spoiler)


message 19: by RuinEleint (new)

RuinEleint Iain wrote: "I started this a couple hours ago... halfway already... looks like it, Arkadeb...

I thought this was going to be more like the first book, before I started... but what it has been instead isn't ba..."


Agree about the characters, as for the message board I am a bit unsure about it, but I think that it could easily be the case.

At the moment my favourite parts are the Jane sections. Watching her learn and develop is really awesome and I can see the inverted reflections in the current storyline.


message 20: by Delitealex (new)

Delitealex | 403 comments Finally got my hold in from the library started this today haven't gotten too far in yet but liking it so far. Pepper is great helping Sidra figuring out her way in the world.


message 21: by Delitealex (last edited Mar 03, 2018 02:34PM) (new)

Delitealex | 403 comments I'm about halfway through this book is more focussed on Sidri and learning more about Peppers past. (view spoiler)


message 22: by Sara J. (last edited Mar 04, 2018 10:56AM) (new)

Sara J. (kefuwa) (kefuwa) | 137 comments Iain wrote: "I'm pretty new to Becky Chambers... but she doesn't seem to announce very far ahead... I think it's safe to assume, tho... the series is setup as loosely connected standalones..."

I wonder how the third book will connect to this one... I have another friend who started reading this one with only vague recollections of the first book and now she finds she can't connect with the characters that she needs to go back and re-read the first. Which made me wonder how the the third was going to connect with this book (and maybe the first one too?) since it seems we are going back into space (yes!)

Iain wrote: "I thought this was going to be more like the first book, before I started... but what it has been instead isn't ba..."
I thought it was going to be more like the first book too but it wasn't long before I got fully invested in the story. And I liked the picnic interludes (view spoiler)

Delitealex wrote: "I'm about halfway through this book is more focussed on Sidri and learning more about Peppers past. [spoilers removed]"

I love the picnic parts! Reminds me of IRC. Haha! (view spoiler)


message 23: by Timelord Iain, Tech Support (new)

Timelord Iain | 35529 comments Mod
This book had a much tighter cast and scope, I think... there's very little connection to the first book... Sidra isn't Lovelace, really... and Pepper was on about 5 pages maybe...


message 24: by Sara J. (new)

Sara J. (kefuwa) (kefuwa) | 137 comments Iain wrote: "This book had a much tighter cast and scope, I think... there's very little connection to the first book... Sidra isn't Lovelace, really... and Pepper was on about 5 pages maybe..."

Indeed. It is a whole different book. I am wondering whether it could have been read as a standalone.


message 25: by Delitealex (new)

Delitealex | 403 comments I'm finished (view spoiler) I'm excited to read the next book to learn more about the exodans.


message 26: by Timelord Iain, Tech Support (new)

Timelord Iain | 35529 comments Mod
Delitealex wrote: "I'm finished [spoilers removed] I'm excited to read the next book to learn more about the exodans."

My only problem with the book is that it ended :)


message 27: by Sha (new)

Sha | 1522 comments I have to say I like the Jane parts more than the Sidra parts so far, and I'm about halfway through. Glad to finally get the time to be back on this.


back to top