The Sword and Laser discussion
Any sci fi books with likeable protagonists?
date
newest »


Hard question to answer though. I was scanning back through my 'read' shelf, going "no, no, no, hell no!, no, ..." Protagonists are often conflicted or flawed people, I guess, which can be what makes their story worth telling.

But if I met them in a bar I'd probably hate them.
But yeah, Watney fits the bill.




For Amos, it would depend on the people he has influencing him. Remember that the Amos you see in the Expanse has a lot of positive influences around him to keep him from being a monster.


Then someone realised that the antihero wasn't actually very good for us, and we started getting the flawed hero - much more complicated, many shades of grey. Similarly, in detective stories we kept on getting the 'hero with personal problems'. (Examples provided on request.)
Those are both good ways to build characters that are worth the effort of reading - but they are now so widespread it is almost impossible to find anything that reads like 'new'. (Except maybe I have seen rather a lot of 'coming of age' stuff recently - I even wrote some!)
So what is the next Big Idea that we are all waiting for?

Dara wrote: "I wouldn't mind hanging out with some of the crew of the Rocinante from the Expanse series. Alex, Amos, and Naomi are cool but I'd want to strange Holden pretty early on."
Ditto.
But Holden likes coffee so...yeah he and I can be best buds.

Well, Naomi would be there and she keeps him in check.
Daniel wrote: "Like C3PO ....Lighthearted and fun people."
You want to hang out with the annoying whiny droid?
That would get old very, very fast ;-)
R2-D2, BB-8 and Chopper are the cool droids.
My choice would be Locke Lamora. I want to be a Gentleman Bastard.
You want to hang out with the annoying whiny droid?
That would get old very, very fast ;-)
R2-D2, BB-8 and Chopper are the cool droids.
My choice would be Locke Lamora. I want to be a Gentleman Bastard.

That's hilarious, because Holden is the first person I thought of. I mean, there might be eyerolls involved, but I love him and his devotion to tilting at ALL the windmills.

Edit: I realised that this book was already mentioned... in the original post! Doh.
However I have one to add: Peter Grant in the Rivers of London series seems like the kind of guy I’d have a beer with.

Echo the Expanse crew and Mark Watney (I would drag him into the lab).
Going for some old stuff, Slippery Jim deGriz, the Stainless Steel Rat would be fun (just check your wallet).

My Number 1 SF hang-out buddy would have to be good old Rogi from Julian May's Intervention. An SF character whose favourite passtime is hanging out and discussing classic SF? Sounds good to me.

I realize that this is about as subjective as it gets, and one persons super best friend might cause you to dive into mol..."
Define “hang out”. I’m such an introvert that hermits tell me I need to get out more. People aren’t really my jam.
So for me it would be animals. Mighty Joe Young. Zabu the sabre-toothed tiger. Pip the minidragon. Old Lace the dinosaur. Or maybe robots. B9, Robbie, Johnny 5.

You want to hang out with the annoying whiny droid?
That would get old very, very fast ;-)
R2-D2, BB-8 and Chopper are the cool droids.
..."
Good point, I'd probably chuck C3PO in the lake of molten lead after 30 minutes. But R2-D2 and BB-8 sound like malfunctioning roombas having sex, so they'd probably follow shortly. :P

If you'r so introverted why are you bothering all these hermits Trike? Also people shouldn't be anyone's jam, its illegal most places and widely regarded as totally immoral. I recommend strawberry, easier to get a hold of and much better tasting... Iv'e heard... from a friend...
Anyway, in cases of introvertism (is that a word?) feel free to replace "hang out with" with "pleasant guest host of the Sword and Laser podcast"
And yes, animals are the best :)


Definitely prime friend material there, just remember to be away when some gray wizard comes knocking :)
Books mentioned in this topic
Powers That Be (other topics)Intervention (other topics)
Rivers of London (other topics)
The Long Way to a Small, Angry Planet (other topics)
The Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Anne McCaffrey (other topics)Julian May (other topics)
Becky Chambers (other topics)
I realize that this is about as subjective as it gets, and one persons super best friend might cause you to dive into molten lead rather than to listen to them for one more minute.
Not someone you learn to like despite their flaws, but someone you like because of their flaws and quirks. Like C3PO or Kizzy (The Long Way to a Small, Angry Planet)
Lighthearted and fun people.
The one I can think of off the top of my head is Bob from the Bobiverse, you got any others?