SCPL Online NonFiction Book Club discussion

Hello everyone!

Following the first chapter where Preston details the dangers of the expedition, he focuses on the historical accounts of the people who have attempted and failed in their quest to re-discover the White City.

I think people are attracted to the idea of lost cultures/civilizations yet to be discovered. With modern technology it feels like every inch of land on Earth has been explored and documented. Yet, the White City remained a mystery waiting to be solved.

In general, what do you think inspires people to embark on expeditions into the unknown? Do you have a similar sense of adventure and willingness to risk life and limb for the possibility of making a monumental discovery?

If you had the opportunity that Preston did, to join the expedition as a writer/observer, would you? Why or why not?

Are you interested in or familiar with any other similar expeditions to discover a lost people, place, artifact, etc?

I hope you’re enjoying the book so far and look forward to hearing your thoughts!

~Nicole~

I completely agree that people are attracted to the idea of lost cultures/civilizations. Just look at Hollywood. That kind of thing almost guarantees box office success. What inspires people? I honestly don’t know. I had the same reaction to reading the February selection – “A History of Canada in Ten Maps” by Adam Shoalts. What inspires (possesses?) people to go off into the wilderness? I guess the “possibility of making a monumental discovery” – be it a lost city or a route to the pacific – that inspires them. I personally don’t feel that. Would I do what Preston did? Highly unlikely. I’m not attracted to adventure like that and the threat of creepy crawlies would put me off. Camping in Algonquin is “roughing” it enough for me!

Thanks for your comment, Heidi!

I think you and I share a similar view on this question. I am definitely intrigued to learn about lost cultures/civilizations but I don't think I'd be willing to actually participate in this expedition. I am more than content to read about the findings in Preston's book.

I tend to be someone who plays it safe in general so I'm always impressed (shocked) by people who are willing to take these kinds of risks - poisonous plants, venomous snakes, deadly insects, drug cartels, disease, torrential rains, etc.

I'm curious to hear whether or not you think their discovery justified the risk? We can discuss this later depending on how far you are in the book.

I like that you mention Hollywood as well. As a kid I definitely played Indiana Jones in my parent's backyard - digging in the garden for fossils, keeping a notebook of my discoveries, etc. Preston mentions some of the criticisms of their archaeological search from other archaeologists who claim they're behaving like "treasure hunters". I'd like to delve into that discussion at some point too.

Lots to discuss!

Thanks again for your feedback.

~Nicole~