Harry Potter discussion
Do you think Neville would've defeated Voldemort if he was The Chosen One?
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Reem
(new)
Sep 27, 2014 04:39PM

reply
|
flag



It was Voldemort who gave Harry the gift of Parseltongue.
It was Voldemort who killed Lily giving Harry protection.
It was Voldemort who then killed Harry/his own horcrux and in doing so made it so that he was unable to harm any other wizard/witch at Hogwarts.
It doesn't really matter who was chosen out of Harry and Neville because ultimately the result would have been the same.
Besides, it was also Voldemort who ordered Bellatrix and co to torture Nevville's parents, in doing so he gave Harry one of his most loyal supporters.