Reddit UES Bookclub discussion

1. What did you think of the book?

2. The book is set in a world where scientists have perfected the art of “filtering” animals, creating them in a lab for human consumption. Is is right for humans to have this ability? Is it ethical for this technology to be used to grow human parts? What about “growing” humans in filtering centers?

3. The animals filtered all have much shorter life spans, yet it is argued that a short life is better than no life. Do you agree with this sentiment?

4. According to Darwinism, only the strongest of a species survives. However, with their technology, scientists are able to bring back many species that have long been extinct. What are the ethical implications of this? Is it right for these animals to exist in a world that may have radically changed since their time on earth?

5. Near the end of the book, we learn that scientists are pushing filtering further, creating new creatures. Discuss the ethics of “playing God” and creating new species. How does this differ from long-term breeding or humans working with genetics?

6. Would you eat filtered animals or wear filtered clothing?

7. Throughout the novel Bellacosa reminisces about his childhood, when crossing the border between Mexico and the U.S. was simple. At the time of the story, there are two border walls, one in each country. There is also talk of a third border wall and U.S. troops patrolling the border in Mexico. How do restrictive borders play a role within the story? How is Bellacosa’s world affected by these restrictive immigration policies?

8. What do you think happened to the Aranaña people? Where do you think the newfound ancestors are from?

9. What do you think happened to Bellacosa at the end of the book?

10. Would you recommend this to others? Would you recommend it as a book club book?