Challenge Corner discussion

Team Enola Holmes!
Aly - captain ✔️
Felicia ✔️
Laura ✔️
Melanie ✔️
Jenny ✔️
Bookworm ✔️
Aneta ✔️
Attack Salmon ✔️
Misericordia ✔️
Cindee ✔️
Beth ✔️

Q & A Thread
Team SS
Review:
List of Potential Characters *please remember it will only ever be a character from the first two pages

Please check in by April 1st! :D

I'm here!

Me too

Checking in :)

Got everyone! :)

Checking in! :)

Checking in

Hi I'm here

Checking in.

I think I'm the Jenny mentioned above, and if so I am here!

Whoo Jenny!

Checking In

Celia Buell wrote: "Hi I'm here"

Wrong team girlfriend! Lol.
https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...

Got everyone! We're all checked in! :D

Yaass

Adding Cindee!

Yeah Cindee!

checking in

Adding Beth!

Checking in!

We're all checked in again!! :D

How does the team plan to choose books to make their guesses? Or are you all just winging it? Lol.

Hmm, something we should probably talk about lol

Aly wrote: "Hmm, something we should probably talk about lol"

Probably. For my books I'm just using them for points. No guesses. I think it'd be too difficult to make you choose my guesses for me. And it's not like I read enough to really make an impact on the guessing anyway. Lol.

For this one it would be hard to guess for someone else. Page points always help!

Im Just winging it i looked at the list. Im Making guesses on the books i have read.... If you guys have another way of guessing?

Maybe we want to narrow things down like sex, hair color, age range before we get too specific? Or we can just see how it goes lol

ok i will listen out for them in Future Audio books

TEAMS!

I just wanted to let everyone know that you MUST post a guess with your book. This isn’t a page point challenge. You need to make a guess for every book you post to your teams review thread.

..I think Aly should just post for page points. Just saying.

Alaina wrote: "..I think Aly should just post for page points. Just saying."

#rude

Aly wrote: "Alaina wrote: "..I think Aly should just post for page points. Just saying."

#rude"

Team, I only did a page points post because I didn't start Illuminae in April.

Aly wrote: "Maybe we want to narrow things down like sex, hair color, age range before we get too specific? Or we can just see how it goes lol"

I think we should do the first one...that's how I play the real guess who anyway. I like those first three as starting points for each guess...

For age range, are there categories you were thinking of?

- Youth (up to 15)
- Young Adult (16-25)
- Adult (26-64)
- Senior (65+)

???

I used one of Laura's books for college student.

Maybe we want to do child, teenager, adult, and senior if the college part is wrong

Character One
Correct guesses:
(view spoiler)[
female
teenager
live in the US
fight for her life
worked to be a better person (yes? lmao)
real world setting
(hide spoiler)]

Incorrect guesses:
(view spoiler)[
MC is in college
male
magical abilities
black hair
royalty
have a sister
switch places with someone
on a tv show
goes swimming (I don't believe so)
life involve Angels
(hide spoiler)]

Team, before we guess anything else let's see if we have any guesses for the character after what we've learned

Sounds good.

Takes place in the US, teen girl in a real world setting

Aly wrote: "Takes place in the US, teen girl in a real world setting"

Nope, don't do it

Potential characters: Eleanor from Eleanor & Park
Anna from Anna and the French Kiss (she's from the US but it doesn't take place in the US)
Samantha from Before I Fall (technically tagged Fantasy but mostly real world)
Molly from Orphan Train

Unsure: Lennie from The Sky is Everywhere. Sister died so she technically doesn't have a sister anymore but idk. Also unsure of her age.

I'm taking the real world setting to mean no dystopian or fantasy books

Questions to narrow it down:
Red Hair- Eleanor
Green Eyes- Samantha
Foster Child- Molly
From the South- Anna

Someone else may want to check to see if I missed a potential book from the list

I thought we had black hair as one of the clues so that would rule out Eleanor.

Was the answer "set in the US" or "born in the US"?

Jammin Jenny wrote: "I thought we had black hair as one of the clues so that would rule out Eleanor.

Was the answer "set in the US" or "born in the US"?"

It was "live in the US".

And the black hair was listed as an incorrect guess.

Then I like those questions :)

One of the clues is fight for her life as well so it would definitely rule out Anna. I didn't read rest of these so I'm not sure about them.

Spoke with Felicia, the red hair and green eyes are not correct.

I haven't read Orphan Train and I don't know if she has to fight for her life

I was thinking about Hazel from The Fault in Our Stars. She is from US, has darker hair (but not black), she has a cancer and it could be interpreted as fighting for her life and I don't think she has a sister.

That's a good guess!

She has cancer right? I have a book banked that has cancer in it, I could guess that