Challenge Corner discussion

100% (view spoiler)[ the ending for this was as I expected. I wish the other woven stories weren’t quite so all over the place. It felt a little disjointed. We shall see where we go next! (view spoiler)[ (hide spoiler)] (hide spoiler)]

i like the first few books but these seem to be going off course. like at least Lundy's story made sense to me. but who is this Regan?

33% (view spoiler)[ this is a very modern storyline and that's kind of cool. horse world seems a bit odd and makes me question where the pull of the door is based in. (view spoiler)[ (hide spoiler)] (hide spoiler)]

50% (view spoiler)[ kidnapped at the fair, not surprising. oh ye foolish kids (view spoiler)[ (hide spoiler)] (hide spoiler)]

83% (view spoiler)[ the kelpie sounds cool although terrifying. I would struggle so fiercely with traveling through the cracks of a castle into creepy dark tunnels. (view spoiler)[ (hide spoiler)] (hide spoiler)]

100% (view spoiler)[ not my favorite that's for certain. it felt like a lot of it was building up to Regan being a hero but the adventure/challenge was so minute. i'm wondering if this was just groundwork for something happening in a future book? (view spoiler)[ (hide spoiler)] (hide spoiler)]

Melanie wrote: "
Literally all my comments for this one got deleted and I'm so sad now. I'll try to remember them.
25% [spoilers removed]
50% [spoilers removed]
75% [spoiler..."

we had very similar thoughts on this last book!

***************************************************************
***************************************************************

RESTARTING MARCH 17TH, 2022

*******************************************************************
*******************************************************************

I think I'm going to start with Beneath The Sugar Sky since I reread book 1 this month already.

Kade wrote: "I think I'm going to start with Beneath The Sugar Sky since I reread book 1 this month already."

Sounds good
I was gonna start with Down Among the sticks and bones since it is on Kindle unlimited.

Part 1 chapt 1-3
(view spoiler)[I read book 1 awhile ago so some of the characters I only remember vaguely. I like learning about Cora and the place she went to. She felt so much better there than at home kinda sad really. I'm glad so found a friend in Nadya. The Rini situation is weird but she was so funny. I was laughing at how every dealt with her nakedness. I'm also trying to figure out how the whole put Sumi back together plan is gonna work out (hide spoiler)]

Part 2 chapt 4-6
(view spoiler)[Wow lots going on. Raising Sumi's skeleton traveling to where Nancy is and finding Sumi's soul. I thought Christopher would stay behind but was surprised when Nadya decided to stay. I was sad for Cora though because that was her only friend the person she related the most to. Then on to Confection I wonder what they will find there. Will they be able to find the last part of Sumi? I'm also wondering why people get chosen to go to places with no logic or heavy logic. Does it have to do with them having a less stuctured life? Or more structured? (hide spoiler)]
I'm already 50% done I forgot these are pretty short

@Kade have you started yet?

Delitealex wrote: "@Kade have you started yet?"

Sorry. We had a death in the family, so i haven’t gotten around to posting notes.

Kade wrote: "Delitealex wrote: "@Kade have you started yet?"

Sorry. We had a death in the family, so i haven’t gotten around to posting notes."

Sorry to hear that.

Started this one. :). Will be posting later / tomorrow for part one.

Finished
(view spoiler)[Confection is such a strange place. I really liked Layla she really seemed to love baking. I was worried Rini would end up disappearing. I'm glad the baker could figure out how to help get Sumi all the way back I wonder how this is gonna affect her later. How do you people get chosen for each door/world? Maybe random? Most of the kids wanted to go back except Kade. Looking forward to the next one. (hide spoiler)]

I'm starting today need it for a team challenge.

Part one
(view spoiler)[

I honestly love seanan’s way with words. They have such talent with making things sound so whimsical and intriguing.

I also love that this involves Kade and christopher from the first book. I’m so interested in Christopher’s day of the dead world.

Ohhh Cora is a mermaid from a water world. I love that idea. But I hate that she considers herself ugly as she is now. And only beautiful in the water world.

Nadya’s world doesn’t sound as nice. MAybe it’s the drowned part of the title. Lol

Oohh. Sumi’s daughter is here. But I still don’t understand how sumi had a daughter.
Wow. Nonsense worlds are truly confusing. 😂. So she exists in her world. But is now ceasing to exist because sumi’s real world death is catching up to her?!
Christopher’s plan sounds amazing, which means this book is going to be super interesting.

(hide spoiler)]

chapt 1-5
(view spoiler)[ Wow Jack and Jills parents are so aweful. Having the Grandmother take care of the twins then tell her to leave 5 years later without being able to say goodbye. Telling people she is the nanny. We now get to see the world they fall into the first dude is suspicious definitely. I wonder what the twins are going to think of the person they end up with. (hide spoiler)]

Chapt 6-9
(view spoiler)[Jack seemed to know the castle wasn't a place she wanted to be early on but Jill was blinded by all the pretty things. Their parents really did them a disservice by pitting them up against each other. I was glad Jack was able to find someone that she enjoyed being with. Jill was so alone and bitter. I'm looking forward to seeing how they ended up at the school and their regular world. (hide spoiler)]

Part two - halls of dead


(view spoiler)[

Does Kade have a crush on Nancy? Aww

I’m seriously so impressed at how the author was able to think of all these stories and have such an amazing imaginatiom. Who would have ever thought of this stuff?

(hide spoiler)]

Finished
(view spoiler)[Jill was so horrible she did all of that craziness and didn't end getting what she want. I hope we get to see what happens when Jack goes back to the Moors in a later book. I can't believe Jack saved Jill after she murdered her girl. I really liked this Jack is one of my fave characters. (hide spoiler)]

Part three - bake me a mountain

(view spoiler)[
Oof. Confection seems horrible. Does that make me logic? lol

I’m so glad we get to learn about all of these kids. And not just rini
Christopher’s story is sad and so intriguing. The bone flute is his cancer?!

And kade? His story has my heart. I’m so grateful this author included the lbgtq+ in her stories. we deserve representation in everything too.

Ponder seems so very kind.
(hide spoiler)]

I'm looking forward to reading more about Kade.

Part four - the end - where we change the world / what came after

(view spoiler)[
I’ll repeat. Confection seems so crazy. lol. It’s also odd that people can end up / go to confection without it being their “home” or whatever the term was.

And holy cow. Sumi is back!
And Nadya found her Door!!! Yay
(hide spoiler)].

Delitealex wrote: "I'm looking forward to reading more about Kade."

I can’t remember - does he have his own book?

I don't think he has one yet I'm just hoping

Delitealex wrote: "I don't think he has one yet I'm just hoping"

Which are you reading next?

Jumping into book 1 today! I never made it past book 1 in this series. Hoping to change that this year.

Do it!! It’s definitely not everyone’s cup of tea, but honestly, I’ve enjoyed them. And they’re quick!

1%: (view spoiler)[Okay, it has been a while since I've read this. Let's see if I remember anything lol. (hide spoiler)]

20%: (view spoiler)[So far, I forgot a lot. Like Nancy being asexual. It's also really interesting to hear about where they were and how they got there. Oh, and I really like Sumi lol. (hide spoiler)]

45%: (view spoiler)[Kind of sad how Jack and Jill's parents would treat them. Pretty vs smart. Also, I would end up liking the one person who died. Ugh. (hide spoiler)]

53%: (view spoiler)[Spiders and wasps? Yeah, no, don't put me down for that door. It's interesting that her door truly did exist just not where she was looking. Also, who is killing them? (hide spoiler)]

78%: (view spoiler)[Okay, but, what if there was someone in that "blank" space? I have so many questions!! (hide spoiler)]

100%: (view spoiler)[So she got through her door and she's back in that world? Sounds pretty cool. Also, wasn't pegging Jill for the murderer! Holy crap. (hide spoiler)]

I liked book 1 it made me want to know more about the doors and definitely about Jack and Jill. How do the worlds pick the people. Who gets logic or nonsense. I hope you keep reading the series and tell us what you think about them.

@Kade what book did you want to read next?

I think I’m going to do in an absent dream next. I’ve already read book 1, beneath the sugar sky, across the green grass fields I’ve read down among the sticks years ago, but may reeeas jr too. .

I will read in an absent dream next its available at the library.

Perfect. I can start it tomorrow.

Part 1: (view spoiler)[Laughing at the dad asking the doctor to guess the gender of the second baby. Like what? (hide spoiler)]

Part 2: (view spoiler)[Well, I'm excited for Jack to learn things. I like how she's growing more in this world. (hide spoiler)]

Part 3: (view spoiler)[That fight between them was interesting. Not sure how I feel about her apologizing so quickly though. (hide spoiler)]

Part 4/Finished: (view spoiler)[So, are her parents not going to fun and hug them? Ask if they are okay? No? Okay. (hide spoiler)]

Parts 1 and 2
(view spoiler)[Lundy seems kinda lonely. Her dad went to the same world when he was young too wow. The rules and debt system is crazy too much debt you will turn into a bird. It's weird she can choose to leave and come back. II can't believe Moon's mom left her there. (hide spoiler)]

Starting book 3 now!

I've definitely read these out of order since I know i read most of them in the past, so don't mind my chaos. h aha. I had already read and reviewed book1 and across the green grass fields, - so i won't be rereading those. This will likely be my reading order from here:
1- in an absent dream
2- where the drowned girls go
3- reread of down among the sticks
4- come tumbling down

it looks like they're releasing a new book in the series in 2023!

Part 1: (view spoiler)[Wait a hot minute, she had a daughter? (hide spoiler)]

Part 2: (view spoiler)[Well shit. Also, candy world? Sign me up. (hide spoiler)]