Kindle British Mystery Book Club discussion

A Song for the Dying (Ash Henderson, #2)
This topic is about A Song for the Dying
4 views
Book Club Monthly Read > Spoiler Discussion March 2022 Group Book Read - A Song For The Dying by Stuart MacBride

Comments Showing 1-4 of 4 (4 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

Beth Stewart | 644 comments Why doesn’t Ash just go to the police to extricate himself from the evil talons of the criminal world? Why, as a former policeman, would he even think of becoming a murderer?


message 2: by Pat (last edited Mar 08, 2022 10:41PM) (new) - added it

Pat Cody | 160 comments Beth, Ash really doesn't seem to be a sympathetic character, does he? I wonder if more revelations about his past will improve my opinion of him as I read further. I also wonder if his daughter's demise is behind his need for revenge.

The author's writing style and plotting is a bit too gritty for me. Too many sentence fragments. Too brutal. I can admire his constant use of action verbs. Not my favorite read so far, as characters are difficult to want to know.


Beth Stewart | 644 comments I agree Pat. One doesn’t want to think of Ash as being your typical law enforcement person (
Current or previously) — he so easily fits in with the grittier side of the world And because he is breaking fingers and dumping people in the boot, he isn’t exactly a likeable
Character.


message 4: by Pat (new) - added it

Pat Cody | 160 comments Beth, so far I haven't found anyone in the book I can support or wish well. Alice is the most attractive character, but no more fully developed than the others. Characters seem more caricatures than real people. Disappointing.


back to top