The Procrastinators Book Club discussion

Aha yes it was for that book, thanks for the reply and for setting up the thread! <3

Hi I was wondering if we can read a book for a category that has already been completed by another of our team member and would it add to our points or be considered void since the category had been read for once?

No you can do tasks as many times as you want! :)

✨faith✨trust✨pixiedust✨ wrote: "No you can do tasks as many times as you want! :)"

Awesome! Thank you Faith!

Does the 'book on your tbr over 4 years' have to have been marked on goodreads 4 years ago ish?

I only started using goodreads properly in 2020 so while I have bookshelves filled with things I bought years ago they aren't necessarily marked on goodreads as that old

Amelia wrote: "Does the 'book on your tbr over 4 years' have to have been marked on goodreads 4 years ago ish?

I only started using goodreads properly in 2020 so while I have bookshelves filled with things I bo..."

That's fine—just tell me that's what's going on when you do your completion post so I don't accidentally disqualify it :)

laurel [the suspected bibliophile] wrote: "Amelia wrote: "Does the 'book on your tbr over 4 years' have to have been marked on goodreads 4 years ago ish?

I only started using goodreads properly in 2020 so while I have bookshelves filled w..."

Fab thank you :)

If there's a love square, does it count as a love triangle? 🤔

@Brianna Raquel sure!

Hey, for the own voices disabled or neurodivergent category does the character have to have the same disability as the author for it to count?

Amelia wrote: "Hey, for the own voices disabled or neurodivergent category does the character have to have the same disability as the author for it to count?"

Either the same or one that is very similar :)

It's a hard prompt.

laurel [the suspected bibliophile] wrote: "Amelia wrote: "Hey, for the own voices disabled or neurodivergent category does the character have to have the same disability as the author for it to count?"

Either the same or one that is very s..."

Do you per chance have any suggestions for that prompt?

Laura ☾ wrote: "laurel [the suspected bibliophile] wrote: "Amelia wrote: "Hey, for the own voices disabled or neurodivergent category does the character have to have the same disability as the author for it to cou..."

Try these lists:

https://mhpl.bibliocommons.com/list/s...

https://meeghanreads.com/own-voices-b...

https://cassieshanahan.com/neurodiver...

https://dailydahlia.wordpress.com/wri...

Laura ☾ wrote: "laurel [the suspected bibliophile] wrote: "Amelia wrote: "Hey, for the own voices disabled or neurodivergent category does the character have to have the same disability as the author for it to cou..."

I probably do -

What type of books do you typical read? (fantasy/romance etc)

@Laurel thanks for the lists! I actually have read a bunch of those but didn’t necessarily realise the authors themselves shared those neurodivergent traits!


@Amelia I’m pretty open to whatever!

Laura ☾ wrote: "@Laurel thanks for the lists! I actually have read a bunch of those but didn’t necessarily realise the authors themselves shared those neurodivergent traits!


Me too!

There is also Jenny Lawson (who has several mental illnesses) that wasn’t mentioned on any of the lists. Her books are more like memoirs, but they are hysterically funny.

Leslie wrote: "There is also Jenny Lawson (who has several mental illnesses) that wasn’t mentioned on any of the lists. Her books are more like memoirs, but they are hysterically funny."

They are amazing!

Also, memoirs and autiobiographies totally count for all #ownvoices prompts :)

I read more romance so these will mostly be that but:

Autism I strongly recommend anything by Helen Hoang or Take a Hint, Dani Brown

Fibromyalgia: Get a Life, Chloe Brown

non-fiction - The Lady's Handbook for Her Mysterious Illness

mental illness: It's Kind of a Funny Story - this is part memoir part fiction as the author is writing about his experiences but aged himself down to 15 as the main character

Wheelchair user: Knot My Type or anything by Evie Mitchell as she has Chrons disease

Deaf/hearing impaired: El Deafo (middle grade graphic novel)

I'll add some more later when I'm home and I can see my shelf

Hi! I had a doubt. I am reading a book with disabled MC written by a neurodivergent author. Would it count as #ownvoices?

Kira wrote: "Hi! I had a doubt. I am reading a book with disabled MC written by a neurodivergent author. Would it count as #ownvoices?"

What's the book?

laurel [the suspected bibliophile] wrote: "Kira wrote: "Hi! I had a doubt. I am reading a book with disabled MC written by a neurodivergent author. Would it count as #ownvoices?"

What's the book?"

He's a Brute by Chloe Liese !!

Kira wrote: "laurel [the suspected bibliophile] wrote: "Kira wrote: "Hi! I had a doubt. I am reading a book with disabled MC written by a neurodivergent author. Would it count as #ownvoices?"

What's the book?"..."

Hmm. Technically it's not ownvoices, but because it's a neurodivergent author writing with care about a disabled character and this prompt is so hard, I'll count it.

laurel [the suspected bibliophile] wrote: "Kira wrote: "laurel [the suspected bibliophile] wrote: "Kira wrote: "Hi! I had a doubt. I am reading a book with disabled MC written by a neurodivergent author. Would it count as #ownvoices?"

What..."

Thank you so much!!

Hi Laurel. I'd like to count The Last House on the Street by Diane Chamberlain for Pink Polo Shirts #1 -- Moon on the Cover. The cover art displays moonlight versus a traditional picture of a moon. Just checking to make sure this is acceptable. Let me know.

Melanie wrote: "Hi Laurel. I'd like to count The Last House on the Street by Diane Chamberlain for Pink Polo Shirts #1 -- Moon on the Cover. The cover art displays moonlight versus a traditional picture of a moon...."

Unfortunately it does need to actually represent something celestial. If there was the night sky with stars, it would work, but moonlight alone doesn't count.

Is there a rule about poetry books? I have an poetry book that is disabled Ownvoices and was wondering about the length of it to count

@Laurel It's okay. I can put it in the prompt for a love triangle. It's all good. I just wish I could use the moonlight prompt.

@amelia no hard and fast rule so long as they’re over 150 pages. I’ve had some people count them as half pages and others not. I’d say if you only read one poetry book count full pages, if you plan to read more then count as half pages.

Hi! Would a book set on an entirely different planet count as a book set in space?

@kira unfortunately no because it’s not in space

Hi, would Maybe in Another Life count as a love triangle since two characters had an interest in her even though it was briefly?

jime wrote: "Hi, would Maybe in Another Life count as a love triangle since two characters had an interest in her even though it was briefly?"

Yes I'll count it

thank you!

Hello, should a play, The Merchant of Venice, be treated as graphic novel in regards to the number of pages or is it okay as is? Thanks!!!

@Jen K I’d treat plays like poems: if you’re reading one count it like a book, but if you plan to read more count as a graphic novel

laurel [the suspected bibliophile] wrote: "@Jen K I’d treat plays like poems: if you’re reading one count it like a book, but if you plan to read more count as a graphic novel"

Probably just the one. Thanks so much!

Can we read multiple books for one task? For example I already read a book for Army Pants 2 so I can I read another book that would qualify under this task?

@Lexus yes completing a task multiple times is fine

laurel [the suspected bibliophile] wrote: "@Lexus yes completing a task multiple times is fine"

Thanks!

✼✼✼✼✼✼✼✼✼✼✼✼✼✼✼✼✼✼✼✼✼✼✼✼✼✼✼✼✼✼✼✼✼✼✼✼✼✼✼✼
FINAL UPDATE

Congrats Team 1!

TEAMS:
Full of Secrets: 600
We're a Mouse, Duh!: 355
The Plastics: 381
You Go Glen Coco: 218
Personally Victimized by Regina George: 369

You Can't Sit With Us!

Laurel: 137
Rosky: 21
Allyson: 32
Angelica: 3

And look at that battle for second place! I don't think I've ever seen a grouping so tight. Well done everyone!

Here are some fun stats, but remember: it's not how much you read (for the most part), but how well you strategize with your team, and how many people participate. Team 3 had a lot of Buddy Reads and Group reads spread across their team, in addition to working on completing as many categories as possible as a team.

Read over 20 books

Kira (1) - 118
Laura ☾ (5) - 59
✨ Brianna Raquel ✨ (2) - 55
Laurel (S) - 44
Jen K (3) - 39
Leslie (1) -27
Lexie (4) - 21

Read over 10,000 pages

Kira (1) - 37,003
Laura ☾ (5) - 23,978
✨ Brianna Raquel ✨ (2) - 21,416
Laurel (S) - 15,261
Jen K 93) - 13,567

Most BRs/GRs

Jen K (3) 12 BRs/2 GRs
Mina (3) 9 BRs/2 GRs
Leslie (1) 6 BRs/1 GR
✨ Brianna Raquel ✨ (2) 5 BRs/2 GRs
Rosina (2) 5 BRs/2 GRs
Melanie (5) 5 BRs/2 GRs
Brianna (3) 5 BRs/1 GR

Read all 30 prompts
✨ Brianna Raquel ✨ (2)
Laurel (S)

Thank you for joining us for Spring Fling! We hope to see you in October for Fright Night (sign-ups will open in September)

❤︎ From the Procrastinator Mods