book club ANS 2022-2023 discussion

Loved this sequel sooo much. I honestly expected Ryle to have some major character development but unfortunately he’s still as he was in the last book. Josh and Theo were my favorite characters and I liked the ending alott

I'm really enjoying it so far, This sequel is probably one of my top favorites, and it's really entertaining ill honestly be devastated when I finish it.

I just started a book last week just read 6 chapter till now , loved the book I've already read the first part of the book that was really good hopefully this one is really good as well

I think I'm about 200 pages in. kind of disappointing to say the least. I genuinely expected more plot and interaction between Lily and Atlas seeing as though it's their sequel but so far I think we've gotten more face to face conversation with lily and Allysa then we have Lily and Atlas. I love the new boys (Josh and Theo) I think they really add more fun moments to the book honestly they're the only reason I'm reading it. I still hate Ryle and somehow I hate him even more than in iewu. He's been getting on my last nerve by trying gaslight and manipulate Lily and she does not deserve what he says to her in the slightest seeing that he's already put her through hell. Annotating it has been really fun though because I love annotating but I really hope the book gets better plot wise and character wise <3

hii, i just started i am 68 pages in (20%) so far its fun and i like it & i hope it ends good because i dont like the reviews am seeing :((((

hiiii im 200 pages in, its such a comfort book i like it so far but not obsessed !!

I finished, it was a fun comforting book i liked it not as much as it ends with us but its still so cute i loved it overall !!!

more than halfway done and words cannot express the boiling hatred and disgust I have for Ryle. He is why we can't have nice things. I genuinely believe God gave us Ryle because the world can't always be perfect. Theo and Josh remain my favorite but I'll keep you posted ;)