Tournament of Books discussion
2024 ToB
>
Opening round 5 - The Guest v. The Shamshine Blind
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Phyllis
(new)
Mar 07, 2024 06:54AM
Opening round 5 - The Guest v. The Shamshine Blind
reply
|
flag
Great judgment, was wondering if he would be able to highlight anything in Shamshine that redeemed what I saw as numerous deficiencies. But it seemed he saw the same issues as I did. Not really pushed to read The Guest though either, despite the win.
Kip wrote: "Great judgment, was wondering if he would be able to highlight anything in Shamshine that redeemed what I saw as numerous deficiencies. But it seemed he saw the same issues as I did. Not really pus..."I haven't felt compelled to read any of the books discussed thus far, that I haven't yet read. However, I am loving the judgments so much I don't care. Again, I thought today's was excellent.
I thought today's judgement was weaker than the others, though I do think the right book is moving on.
