Romance Readers Reading Challenges discussion
Monthly Challenges
>
2024 April Pick-It-For-Me Challenge

Pickees
✱ To help your picker understand the type of books you like or are currently reading, please make sure your ‘read’ shelf is up to date. You can create shelves for books you DNFed (Did Not Finish) or authors that don’t work for you as well as favorite books and authors. In addition, you might consider updating your profile. You can include info about your favorite books, authors, genres, themes or tropes (or themes/tropes you dislike – i.e. secret baby).
✱ Please do not specify likes/dislikes in the sign-up thread. This information will not be included in the pairings and your pickee may not see your message and does not need to rely on that information when making picks.
Pickers
✱ Please remember this is primarily a romance readers group. Thus, most, if not all, of your picks should be romance. There are various sub genres within the romance category - Contemporary, Historical, Paranormal, Romantic Suspense, Erotica, M/M, Urban Fantasy. If your pickee reads a wide variety, you could add a non-romance as a choice.
✱ You will be using 8 picking rules to select books for you pickee. Choose at least 4 new titles for your pickee. These can be brand new to them (not found on any of their shelves) or a book found on their shelves if they've never read any of the author's work previously. The remaining 4 titles should come from your pickee's tbr, with a minimum of one from their preferred shelves if provided. Be sure to pick at least one book for each picking rule, but please limit your picks to no more than two books per rule as sometimes having too many options is worse than too few.
✱ Please remember when you are giving new recommendations, you are not limited to titles that you have read. You can choose books that are new releases, on your tbr, or titles you looked up on Goodreads or Amazon that you think your pickee would enjoy.
A few hints to help with book selection:
✱ Check the book’s publishing date. Select "date pub" from the checkbox selections and save.
✱ Check pickee's personalized shelves, especially their exclusive shelves. A personalized shelf is one the member has created. (e.g., 'to read next', 'favorites' ‘didn’t like’)
✱ Make sure the books you choose are not on their 'read' shelf. Just because it isn't rated doesn't mean it wasn't read.
✱ Look at your pickee's 'read' shelf and see what genres they have recently read or read the most. Reviewing their ‘read’ shelf might help you in choosing something they are interested in reading right now.
✱ If your pickee reads lots of books in a genre you are not familiar with (erotic romance, GLBT, YA, etc.) Contact the Mods or the month's organizer for guidance.
✱ Include a variety of books (e.g., shorter page count, new addition to their 'to-read' shelf, an older book on their 'to-read' shelf) This variety gives your pickee options when choosing the book or books they will be reading this month. Use the sort feature within their shelves to determine date a book was added, published or read; page numbers, ratings, etc.
If you want to volunteer to make repicks:
✱ We love that you want to help out, but please remember those who need picks have been waiting for a long time already. Please only volunteer if you are able to make the repicks within a few hours of the deadline. Thank you!

If you have a preferred shelf, PLEASE include the link with it when you post it in this thread. It really helps the hosts when listing the participants and pairings. Thank you!!

Please pick for the person beneath you. The last person picks for the first person (that is, Carina picks for Sonja).
*= picks made
*Sonja- PIFM
*MountainKat- to read asap
*Courtney Romance
*NancyH
*KathyD- tbr audios
*LaurLa- 01 pick me please
*Darcy
*♎ Carmen the Bootyshaker Temptress ☼♎- pick for me
*Carrie- current tbr
*Fran- pick it for me shelf
Haney Hayes
*SunnyCAGirl
*Carina- April Garden

Sharpen your tools. Collect your seeds. Prepare your beds. It's time to plant!
April is National Garden Month!
Below are eight different and unique types of gardens. Please select your books for your pickee based upon these eight gardens.
Recommend a book (or two) from each category below:
1.Rock Garden-
*a shorter or low stress book or
*a book with white on its cover
2. Vegetable Garden-
*a book published in a summer month (June, July, August, September) or
*a book with food on the cover
3. Flower Garden-
*a book published in a Spring month (March, April, May, June) or
*a book with flowers on the cover
4. Herb Garden-
*a book with a spicy or sassy character or
*a book with a man on the cover
5. Butterfly Garden-
*a book with a gentle, delicate or shy character or
*a book with a colorful cover
6. Water Garden-
*a fantasy or paranormal book or
*a book with water or a boat or the color blue on the cover
7. Woodland Garden-
*a book set in a small town, rural area or ranch or
*a book with the color brown on the cover
8. Cactus Garden-
*a book with a prickly or difficult character or
*a book with the color green on the cover

Please use my to-read-asap shelf - thanks!

Please use my to-read shelf.


I come from a long line of green thumbs with epic gardening abilities, and I love it. Sadly, apartment living prevents me from having a garden, but I do have houseplants!

https://www.goodreads.com/review/list...

01-pick-me-please

Shelf: https://www.goodreads.com/review/list...

My “to read” shelf is good! Thanks!

☄️ Rock Garden ☄️
Book Love, Debbie Tung — short book with white cover (tbr)
Shy Girls Write It Better, May Sage — short book with white cover (new)
🥕 Vegetable Garden 🥕
Sweet Persuasion, Maya Banks — food on the cover (tbr)
Slave to Sensation, Nalini Singh — published in September 2006 (new)
🌷 Flower Garden 🌷
How Much I Love, Marie Force — published in June 2021 (tbr)
Inheritance, Nora Roberts — flowers on the cover (new)
🌿 Herb Garden 🌿
The Shadows, J.R. Ward — man on the cover (tbr)
The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo, Taylor Jenkins Reid — spicy/sassy main character (new)
🦋 Butterfly Garden 🦋
Check & Mate, Ali Hazelwood — colorful cover (tbr)
The Hard Truth About Sunshine, Sawyer Bennett — gentle main character (new)
⛲ Water Garden ⛲
About a Dragon, G.A. Aiken — blue cover & tagged fantasy (tbr)
End of Story, Kylie Scott — tagged fantasy (new)
🌳 Woodland Garden 🌳
What You See, Cherise Sinclair — set in rural Alaska & brown(ish) cover (tbr)
The Simple Wild, K.A. Tucker — set in rural Alaska (new)
🌵 Cactus Garden 🌵
Encore in Death, J.D. Robb — (sometimes) difficult main character (tbr)
Dial A for Aunties, Jesse Q. Sutanto — green on the cover (new)

















Here are your picks for April....I hope you find a goodie or two here!
1.Rock Garden-
new- Mr. Right Next Door- shorter
new- Ice Planet Barbarians- ridiculous fun
2. Vegetable Garden-
new- Totally Tubular- published in Sept. ( I read it awhile ago but remember really liking it)
new- Going Up- published in July (short and fun)
3. Flower Garden-
tbr- Most of All You- flower on cover
tbr- An Optimist's Guide to Heartbreak - flowers on cover
4. Herb Garden-
tbr-Dear Grumpy Boss- man on cover
new- Uncivilized- man on cover
5. Butterfly Garden-
tbr- The Problem with Dating- colorful cover
new- One Fine Fireman- shy heroine
6. Water Garden-
tbr- Obsidian- fantasy/pnr (so cheesy but so good!)
new- Play with Me- blue on cover (loved this one)
7. Woodland Garden-
tbr- Long Hard Ride- set on a ranch (great series!)
tbr- Small Town Swoon
8. Cactus Garden-
tbr- Collide- green on cover
new- Truth or Beard- prickly character
Happy Reading!

Here are your picks for April - how is it April already?!?! Hopefully I haven't picked these for you before!
1.Rock Garden-
TBR: Touch the Lightning (shorter story)
TBR: Encore in Death (white on cover) Had to get this one on there, cannot believe you're so far in this series! I need to get back into it!


2. Vegetable Garden-
TBR: Selkies are a Girl's Best Friend (published in August)
NEW: The Highland Fling (published in August) This was a fun summer rom-com!


3. Flower Garden-
TBR: How to Love Thine Enemy (pub in April)
NEW: One Night on the Island (flowers on the cover) Enjoyed this one!


4. Herb Garden-
TBR: Bain (Man on cover)
NEW: The Duke Alone (man on cover) Surprised how much I enjoyed this one!


5. Butterfly Garden-
TBR: Forbidden Falls (colorful cover)
NEW: Remarkably Bright Creatures (satisfies both!) I'll recommend this every time! Try to get the audiobook if you can. The narrators did a great job and really made the characters, even Marcellus the octopus, come to life! The synopsis doesn't really do this book justice.


6. Water Garden-
TBR: Under the Christmas Tree (blue/water on cover)
NEW: Tidelands (blue/water on cover) This was a recommendation from someone else in this challenge and I'm glad I read it. Really good!


7. Woodland Garden-
TBR: In Bed with the Duke (brownish cover)
NEW: Part of Your World (rural/small town) Another one someone recommended to me and another that I really enjoyed!


8. Cactus Garden-
TBR: Simply the Best (green cover)
NEW: Identity (green on cover/difficult character) Grabbed this one by chance on my Kindle and ended up hooked to it!


Happy reading! :)

Here are your picks. Happy reading!
🪨Rock Garden
TBR - Writing Mr. Right
New - The Best Friend Bargain


🥦Vegetable Garden
TBR - In a Jam
New - Flawless


💐Flower Garden
TBR - The Bodyguard
New - Ready or Not


🪴Herb Garden
TBR - The Counterfeit Scoundrel
New - Accidentally His


💦Water Garden
TBR - Vacation Wars
New - Mile High


🪵Woodland Garden
TBR - A Hundred Crickets Singing
New - The Letter Tree


🌵Cactus Garden
TBR - Witch Chocolate Fudge
New - Magical Blend



Fran wrote: "Hi Haney Hayes!
Here are your picks for April....I hope you find a goodie or two here!
1.Rock Garden-
new- Mr. Right Next Door- shorter
new- Ice Planet Barbarians-..."

Haney, here’s a different one to replace that one- An Optimist's Guide to Heartbreak - flowers on cover

1.Rock Garden-
New: (Trust) Falling for You (short and low stress)
TBR: Icebreaker (white on cover)
2. Vegetable Garden-
TBR: Cruel Boy (published in September)
New: In a Jam (food on cover)
3. Flower Garden-
TBR: Happily Never After (March)
New: This Could Be Us
4. Herb Garden-
TBR: Toxic Love (spicy character)
New: What Happens at the Lake
5. Butterfly Garden-
New: A Taste of Italian Sunshine (shy character)
TBR: Hello Stranger (colorful cover)
6. Water Garden-
TBR: Vampires of El Norte (paranormal)
New: Shelter by the Sea (water)
7. Woodland Garden-
New: Swift and Saddled (ranch)
TBR: When It Falls Apart (some brown on cover)
8. Cactus Garden-
New: Among the Heather (prickly character)
TBR: Not My Kind of Hero (green on cover)

Here are your picks for April - how is it April already?!?! Hopefully I haven't picked these for you before!"
Thank you for the awesome picks Sonja!! The extra comments are so helpful with the new books, even if they aren't read they do get on my lists for the future! I don't think you have picked any of the new books before before, but it never hurts to pick them again if they were really good - sometimes I need the extra kick to actually read them. 😉

1.Rock Garden
NEW: Big Rock by Lauren Blakely
TBR: Honor's Splendour by Julie Garwood
2. Vegetable Garden
NEW: A Soupçon of Poison: Kat Holloway Victorian Mysteries by Jennifer Ashley
TBR: Him by Sarina Bowen and Elle Kennedy
3. Flower Garden
NEW: Texas Destiny by Lorraine Heath
TBR: An Extraordinary Union by Alyssa Cole
4. Herb Garden
NEW: That Scandalous Evening by Christina Dodd
TBR: First Lady by Susan Elizabeth Phillips
5. Butterfly Garden
NEW: Virgin River by Robyn Carr
TBR: Book Lovers by Emily Henry
6. Water Garden
NEW: Wilde in Love by Eloisa James
TBR: Mine Till Midnight by Lisa Kleypas
7. Woodland Garden
NEW: Simply Irresistible by Jill Shalvis
TBR: Nobody's Baby But Mine by Susan Elizabeth Phillips
8. Cactus Garden
NEW: Agnes and the Hitman by Jennifer Crusie and Bob Mayer
TBR: Daring and the Duke by Sarah MacLean
I've read all but one of these books, listened to all but one of those, and really enjoyed them all. So, I'm hoping you find one to love too!
Happy Reading!

Here are your picks. I hope you can find something you like! I tried to put the links to the audiobook editions, so I hope this works!
Rock Garden: white on cover - The Proposal; Low-stress one for book lovers - The Door-To-Door Bookstore
Vegetable Garden; Two published in August - The Takeover and Wait for It
Flower Garden: published in May - Shelter Mountain; published in April - Annie's Holiday by the Sea
Herb Garden: Spicy character - Two for the Dough; Man on cover- Truth or Beard
Butterfly Garden: Gentle but firm (and excellent!) character- The Banned Bookshop of Maggie Banks; Colorful cover - The Good, the Bad, and the Aunties
Water Garden: Paranormal - Dark Witch; Water on cover - Four Ways to Wear a Dress
Woodland Garden: Two set in rural areas - Wild at Heart and The Sunshine Club
Cactus Garden: two with prickly, difficult characters - The Spanish Love Deception and Flirting With Danger
Happy Reading!

Here are your picks. I hope you can find something you like! I tried to put the links to the audiobook editions, so I hope this works!
Rock Garden: white on cover - [book:The Propos..."
thanks, Nancy! this works great and I see lots of great reads!

☘KathyD☘ wrote: "Nancy H wrote: "Hi Kathy D,
Here are your picks. I hope you can find something you like! I tried to put the links to the audiobook editions, so I hope this works!
Rock Garden: white on cover - ..."

1.Rock Garden-
New: (Trust) Falling for You (short and low stres..."
Thanks Darcy! I'm excited to get to some of these :-)

Here are your picks! I hope you can find something that interests you. I had a GREAT time looking through your shelves and tried to mix it up with things that were new and that I thought would appeal to you. Enjoy!
1: TBR: Season of Blood (short)
NEW: The Love Hypothesis (low stress)
2: TBR: Birthday Cake and Bodies (f00d)
NEW: Hello Stranger (July)
3: TBR: The Proof of the Pudding (flowers)
NEW: The Hidden Letters (flowers)
4: TBR: Get a Life, Chloe Brown (sassy)
NEW: High-Heeled Wonder (spicy)
5: TBR: A Modern Proposal (shy)
NEW: The Summer Book Club (colorful)
6: TBR: The Bookshop by the Bay: A Novel (water)
NEW: The Wishing Game (fantasy)
7: TBR: Kentucky Heat (rural)
NEW: Famous in a Small Town (small town)
8: TBR: Hotel Laguna (difficult character)
NEW:Lavender's Blue (difficult character)

















These look GREAT! I just want to read them all, and I can't wait to get started. I hope I have lots of reading time in April!!
Thank you!!
Courtney wrote: "Hello Nancy!
Here are your picks! I hope you can find something that interests you. I had a GREAT time looking through your shelves and tried to mix it up with things that were new and that I thou..."

Here are your picks. Happy reading!
🪨Rock Garden
TBR - Writing Mr. Right
New - The Best Friend Bargain

Thank you so much for these, Carina! These look great! Already put a few of the new ones on my list this month and the rest on hold at my library. Not sure how many I'll get to, but I"m trying! And thank you for so many KU books! :)

1.Rock Garden
NEW: Big Rock by Lauren ..."
Thanks for the picks MountainKat. It's been a tough year and getting through a couple of these books would be a welcome reprieve

1.Rock Garden-
TBR:

Winning Back His Wife both short and has white on the cover
New:

Summer at the Comfort Food Café white on the cover and low stress
2. Vegetable Garden-
TBR:

Fresh Ink Aug pub
New:

Hetty’s Farmhouse Bakery food on cover
3. Flower Garden-
TBR:

Spite Club June pub
New:

A Secret Cornish Summer flowers on cover
4. Herb Garden-
TBR:

When an Alpha Purrs man on cover
New:

Brutal Prince man on cover
5. Butterfly Garden-
TBR:

Under One Roofcolourful cover
New:

Happy Place colourful cover
6. Water Garden-
TBR:

A Week in New York blue on cover
New:

Emily Wilde's Encyclopaedia of Faeries fantasy with blue on cover
7. Woodland Garden-
TBR:

Shoulda Been a Cowboy ranch
New:

A Rancher's Heart ranch and brown on the cover
8. Cactus Garden-
TBR:

Lovebug green cover
New:

That Time I Got Drunk and Saved a Demon green cover and possibly prickly character
Happy Reading

1.Rock Garden
TBR: Christmas at Applemore - goodly amount of white
NEW: Under One Roof - short and sweet


2. Vegetable Garden
TBR: When in Rome - food on cover
NEW: Role Playing - published July 2023


3. Flower Garden
TBR: The Gamble - I like this new flowery cover!
NEW: By Any Other Name - published March 2022


4. Herb Garden
TBR: Well Played - spicy/sassy fmc
NEW: Mr. Fixer Upper - man on cover


5. Butterfly Garden
TBR: Isabel and the Rogue - lots of colors
NEW: Mouth to Mouth - more sheltered than shy but still sweet


6. Water Garden
TBR: A Villa with a View - water on cover
NEW: Betwixt - paranormal


7. Woodland Garden
TBR: Red, White, & Baby Blue - small town
NEW: Love, Magic & Misfortune - brown on cover


8. Cactus Garden
TBR: Riley Thorn and the Dead Guy Next Door - there's more than one prickly character here
NEW: Disorderly Conduct - Aiden is stubborn which makes him difficult



☄️ Rock Garden ☄️
Book Love, Debbie Tung — short book with white cover (tbr)
[book:Shy Girls Write It ..."
These are super awesome!! Thank-you!

My picks for you. Hope you find some good ones.
1.Rock Garden-
TBR- Nine Rules to Break When Romancing a Rake
New: Sweet Addiction


2. Vegetable Garden-
TBR: Book Lovers
New: A Proposal They Can't Refuse


3. Flower Garden-
TBR: Daughter of the Moon Goddess
New: Secretly Yours


4. Herb Garden-
TBR: Clockwork Angel
New: Wreck My World


5. Butterfly Garden-
TBR: The City of Stardust
New: The Bodyguard


6. Water Garden-
TBR: Witch Please
New: That Second Chance


7. Woodland Garden-
TBR: River Marked
New: Daddy Biker Bear


8. Cactus Garden-
TBR: Voyager
New: You Deserve Each Other


Happy reading! :-)

I am on a trip and having trouble searching your “read” list on my phone. I should be able to check tomorrow and give you any re-picks you need. Enjoy!
1.Rock Garden-
*a book with white on its cover
Snowed in with a Colton by Lisa Childs (tbr)
Royally Screwed by Emma Chase (new)
2. Vegetable Garden-
*a book published in a summer month (June, July, August, September)
Hawaiian Medic to Rescue His Heart by Annie O’Neill (tbr)
The Return of the Duke by Lorraine Heath (new)
3. Flower Garden-
*a book with flowers on the cover
The First Kiss of Spring by Emily March (tbr)
The Bodyguardby Katherine Center (new)
4. Herb Garden-
*a book with a man on the cover
One Fine Fireman by Jennifer Bernard (tbr)
Hothead by Stella Rhys (new)
5. Butterfly Garden-
*a book with a colorful cover
Hotel Magnifique by Emily J Taylor (tbr)
Accidentally Compromising the Duke by Stacy Reid (colorful cover) (new)
6. Water Garden-
*a fantasy or paranormal book or
Dark Lover by J.R. Ward
*a book with color blue on the cover
Too Hot to Handleby Tessa Bailey (tbr)
7. Woodland Garden-
*a book set in a small town, rural area or ranch or
Wife on His Doorstep by Patricia Johnson (brown & small town) (tbr)
*a book with the color brown on the cover
Truth or Beard by Penny Reid (brown on cover & small town)
8. Cactus Garden-
*a book with the color green on the cover
Texas Born by Diana Palmer(tbr)
Not That Duke by Eloisa James (new)
Books mentioned in this topic
Big Rock (other topics)An Extraordinary Union (other topics)
Texas Destiny (other topics)
First Lady (other topics)
Forbidden Falls (other topics)
More...
What is the Pick-It-For-Me Challenge?
The Pick-It-For-Me Challenge (PIFM) is a reading challenge where each participant gives and receives book recommendations based on a given a set of rules. The assignment method and book selection rules change each month so it’s always new and always different.
The idea of the PIFM challenge is that you will get new-to-you books and authors selected for you as well as a push to read some books that have been lingering on your shelves. You may not be interested in the new books recommended, which is why you also get a minimum of four books from your shelf.
You only have to read ONE book to complete this challenge!
After signups are closed, your names and any extra info will go into the super secret PIFM randomizer and it will select someone for you to recommend books to and someone to give you recommendations. This list will be posted along with any specific picking rules for the month.
In order to participate you need to either HAVE YOUR PROFILE SET TO PUBLIC (preferable), or friend the person giving you recommendations. PLEASE NOTE: if you choose to keep your profile private, it is your responsibility to send a friend request to the person picking for you as soon as possible after the matchups are posted. Whether your profile is private or not, it is also very important that your profile be set to receive Private Messages (PMs) in case anyone needs to reach out to you (mods, organizer etc.)
Everything gets done in this thread so be sure to come back often!!!
Repicks:
You can ask for repicks if:
✱ The books picked for you are not yet released.
✱ If you have already read the chosen book(s) and they are on your ‘read’ shelf.
✱ If you did not receive four picks from your ‘to-read’ shelf, with at least one from your preferred shelf.
You may NOT ask for repicks because:
✱ A book is not available at your library.
✱ A genre or author you don’t enjoy.
INFORMATION NEEDED TO SIGN UP
**Do you have a green thumb? (do you like to garden?)**
✱✱ If you have a preferred shelf, please list it along with your pick! ✱✱
IMPORTANT DATES
Sign ups will remain open until March 25, 5 pm (US EDT)
You’ll have until March 30th, 12 pm (US EDT) to make your recommendations.
Please do not start reading your book(s) until the first of the month. You then have the entire month to read your pick(s) and give some feedback.
If you’re new please read the PIFM Guidelines and FAQ . If you have any questions that are not addressed there, please feel free to ask!
✱Please note that late sign ups will be included at the host's discretion and no one will be included after re-picks are assigned!✱