The Procrastinators Book Club discussion
This topic is about
A Perilous Undertaking
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
★Buddy/Group Read Retirement★
>
A Perilous Undertaking (November 2024) Buddy Read Discussion - Brianna & Katie
date
newest »
newest »
A question: can I read this without having read volume 1? For what I see this is the second one in a series.
Sarah-Vanessa wrote: "A question: can I read this without having read volume 1? For what I see this is the second one in a series."I've read both 1 and 2. It may be possible. The second one has it's own mystery that is wrapped up within the book. However, you would be missing a bit of backstory on the two main characters which may cause confusion.
Jen K wrote: "Sarah-Vanessa wrote: "A question: can I read this without having read volume 1? For what I see this is the second one in a series."I've read both 1 and 2. It may be possible. The second one has i..."
@Jen K Thank you for your quick Answer. Alright, I might Jump in later then.
I’m on a road trip for the duration of this trip (great planning I know lol) but I will do my best to post updates and such!through end of chapter 6:
I was a bit worried I wouldn’t remember much from the first book and struggle to get back into this world. Thankfully I’ve been able to get back into things pretty easily despite not remembering much! I am intrigued by this new mystery and currently don’t have many theories as to what I think could have happened. Some of the names in here are super unique and I have absolutely no clue how to pronounce so just making things up in my brain lol.
through end of chapter 12: Getting more pieces to the puzzle and am now intrigued by Stoker’s brothers showing up in various ways. Also this grotto - they mention no one had opened the gate for awhile but there were clearly people on the list within the past year. It’ll be interesting to see how things come together!
through end of chapter 17:I am honestly surprised by how many people we have met who have been fairly open minded in regards to the sexual choices and such - you typically associate this time frame with a vibe of prudeness. I currently still have no hard theories about who did it or why.
I am only on like Chapter 5 or 6 so I haven't actually read any of your thoughts yet, just scrolled right past lol. I did forget some of the finer points from Book 1 (which I knew I would, because I distinctly remember zoning out for a decent portion of the audiobook), but I think I'm following along okay. Enjoying myself so far! Veronica is not just a character, but A Character. And I love her. Top priority this evening is to make some decent progress. Read about 10% just while waiting in line to vote today! Haha
Katie wrote: "I am only on like Chapter 5 or 6 so I haven't actually read any of your thoughts yet, just scrolled right past lol. I did forget some of the finer points from Book 1 (which I knew I would, because ..."She definitely has main character energy but in a good way! There are some good moments in chapters 18-23 so excited to see what you think! I will probably be able to finish tonight but I will use spoiler tag for ya!
@Katie , @Brianna ughh, I‘m so behind on this one. Hopefully I will finish tomorrow or Friday. At the Moment I‘m at chapter 6. And I totally agree Veronica is A Character. I absolutely love her! So definitely agreeing with both of you.
Sarah-Vanessa wrote: "@Katie , @Brianna ughh, I‘m so behind on this one. Hopefully I will finish tomorrow or Friday. At the Moment I‘m at chapter 6. And I totally agree Veronica is A Character. I absolutely love her! S..."
No worries!
Okay I finished! Not sure on my rating quite yet. I thought the characters and setting were fun--bohemian artists, royals, and the combination of them that got into scandalous behavior even by modern standards, let alone the time the book is set in. However, I thought the actual mystery was quite dull. When it came down to the whodunnit, (view spoiler)I thought Lady Wellie was really fun, I'd like to see her come back. (view spoiler)
@Katie I 100% agree with you!Finished it today and it‘s a solid 3 stars. If it wouldn’t be for the outstanding characters of Veronica and Stoker and their unique dynamic of bickering and flirting, and of course Lady Wellingtonia it would be a 2 star.
The mystery isn‘t the most exciting, it‘s really slow paced and not a lot of action/suspense is happening. There are some entertaining situations and moments though, for example in the opium den. And I loved how indirectly open sex was discussed and expressed, considering the time the story plays.
I have to say I struggled a lot getting into the writing style, especially the language used, as a non native English speaking person. But I will probably read the other books as well, as overall it was a fun read.
@Sarah-Vanessa & Katie - I agree the highlight was the characters and the mystery itself was fairly predictable. I didn't quite expect how the mystery ended but still enjoyed it overall! I agree about the very open conversations about sex being a somewhat surprise given the time frame of the story but it certainly made it feel a bit more modern. I'm excited for the next one but primarily around the slow burn with Stoker and Veronica.
@Brianna Totally! Definitely want to read the third book just for that slow burn….
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Each day we will be reading by chapters or page numbers. Page numbers are an approximation based on the hardcover or paperback that is the default on Goodreads. The suggested Buddy Read discussion schedule is as follows:
Week of 11/01
November 1: chapter 1 - 6
November 2: chapter 7 - 12
November 3: chapter 13 - 17
Week of 11/04
November 4: chapter 18 - 23
November 5: chapter 24 - 29
PARTICIPANTS
~ Brianna
~ Katie