A taut, powerful psychological thriller following a mother who must confront a sudden and terrifying change in her daughter after the abrupt death of their babysitter
Charlotte’s daughter Stella is sensitive and brilliant, perhaps even a genius, but a recent change in her behavior has alarmed her mother. Following the sudden death of Stella’s babysitter, Blanka, the once disruptive and anti-social child has become docile and agreeable. But what’s unsettling is that she has begun to mirror Blanka’s personality, from Blanka’s repetitive phrases to her accent, to fierce cravings for Armenian meat stew after being raised a vegetarian.
Charlotte is pregnant with her second child, and depleted and sick with the pregnancy. She is convinced that Blanka herself is somehow responsible for Stella’s transformation. But how could Blanka, dead, still be entwined in their lives? Has Blanka somehow possessed Stella? Has Stella become Blanka? As Charlotte becomes increasingly obsessed, she is sure that only she can save her daughter. . . even though it’s soon clear that her husband believes this is all in Charlotte’s head.
Helena Echlin’s singular, chilling voice holds light to the blurred lines of diagnosis in children and to the vital power of maternal instinct. Kaleidoscopic and tense, pulse-pounding and genuinely creepy, and infused with shades of the supernatural, Clever Little Thing is an ode to motherhood and a nuanced critique of the caretaking industry, a page-turner that will haunt readers long after its epic, surprising finale.
I'm not loving this one so far (view spoiler)[ I'm finding it really hard to get into. I'm finding the MC unlikable. I don't understand her need to hold on to her child so so tight. She seems really stuck not able to help Stella's struggles - her outbursts and her inability to form friendships, have certain fabrics, etc. - and yet she refuses to do anything to change it and caves at every turn. If she'd agree to the help and talk to a doctor, she'd get more resources. Heck, even just googling would give her information.
For how much technology her husband seems to work in, they don't seem to use it much. . .which doesn't seem to jive with the idea of what he does.
and I'm finding the moment with Cherie and the times with Irina - the conversations are really stilted and weird and I'm just not buying any of it (hide spoiler)]
(view spoiler)[ wow, when she was 8 she pulled her pants off and went to the bathroom in front of a room full of people? I would have got her help right then. I would have worried someone was abusing her or something more was going on. I can't believe they just ignored that?!?!
I'm finding this book over the top ridiculous. I can't imagine being this worried about my kid - if she was 3 or 4 maybe - but she's at least, what, 9? 10? - and ignoring her for most of the day when she's home. The book gives us very little in between so the whole story just feels disjointed. and I don't know a single child psychologist that wouldn't talk to a kid with all these symptoms. . .I've never heard one of them say "that's just a little too young for counseling" because, again, any number of abuses or bullying or scary things could be going on. . .and it's good to get them talking about feelings and what's going on.
and I was surprised Irina told Stella all those things even though she'd asked her not to. But, again, she communicates weird and doesn't seem to get full thoughts out before she just kicks her out
I just don't seem to be meshing with this story (hide spoiler)]
(view spoiler)[ I mean, I was shocked by the hubby and the turns his story took and it did seem like Stella was possessed.
but I kept picturing the mom ignoring really glaring signs of Stella not being well and her screaming about how smart her daughter was all the while not helping her with basic emotions. I just couldn't seem to get into this one (hide spoiler)]
Charlotte’s daughter Stella is sensitive and brilliant, perhaps even a genius, but a recent change in her behavior has alarmed her mother. Following the sudden death of Stella’s babysitter, Blanka, the once disruptive and anti-social child has become docile and agreeable. But what’s unsettling is that she has begun to mirror Blanka’s personality, from Blanka’s repetitive phrases to her accent, to fierce cravings for Armenian meat stew after being raised a vegetarian.
Charlotte is pregnant with her second child, and depleted and sick with the pregnancy. She is convinced that Blanka herself is somehow responsible for Stella’s transformation. But how could Blanka, dead, still be entwined in their lives? Has Blanka somehow possessed Stella? Has Stella become Blanka? As Charlotte becomes increasingly obsessed, she is sure that only she can save her daughter. . . even though it’s soon clear that her husband believes this is all in Charlotte’s head.
Helena Echlin’s singular, chilling voice holds light to the blurred lines of diagnosis in children and to the vital power of maternal instinct. Kaleidoscopic and tense, pulse-pounding and genuinely creepy, and infused with shades of the supernatural, Clever Little Thing is an ode to motherhood and a nuanced critique of the caretaking industry, a page-turner that will haunt readers long after its epic, surprising finale.