Reading 1001 discussion
This topic is about
The Three Musketeers
Quarterly Read
>
Q3 - Three Musketeers
date
newest »
newest »
Mod
1. What is D'Artagnan's journey like? How does he grow and change throughout the story?
2. What are the bonds between the three musketeers, and what does their motto "All for one, and one for all" mean to them?
3. How does D'Artagnan relate to the queen, Constance Bonacieux, and Milady de Winter? What is the nature of their connections?
4. What are the strengths and weaknesses of Athos, Porthos, and Aramis? How do these differences contribute to their individual stories?
5. How does the relationship between D'Artagnan and the Musketeers evolve, especially as they face challenges together?
6. What is Milady's motivation, and how does it drive her actions throughout the story?
7. How do Dumas's female characters, like Constance and Milady, influence the plot and characters' decisions?
8. How does the novel use historical events and characters, and how does it deviate from historical accuracy?
9. What is the role of destiny and fate in the story?
10. How does Dumas create suspense and excitement? How do the chapter endings contribute to the pacing?
11. What themes are explored in the novel, such as honor, loyalty, friendship, justice, and revenge?
12. How does the novel comment on the social and political climate of France during the time period?
13. Is The Three Musketeers a bildungsroman? Does it follow the typical structure of a coming-of-age story?
14. What is the significance of the king's character? Does he seem like a wise and just ruler?
15. What is the role of the Cardinal Richelieu? How does he shape the events of the story?
16. How does Dumas characterize the Musketeers as well-developed stereotypes? Are there any ways they transcend these stereotypes?
17. How does Dumas portray vice and violence in the novel? Are these scenes arbitrary, or do they serve a purpose in the story?
18. What are the motivations and inner conflicts of D'Artagnan? How does he navigate these conflicts?
19. How do the Musketeers' individual stories contribute to the overall themes of the novel?
20. What are the different perspectives on D'Artagnan's actions? Do they seem justified or not?
21. Discuss D'Artagnan's first meeting with the musketeers and his subsequent challenges.
22. How does the duel between D'Artagnan and Athos, Porthos, and Aramis impact their relationship?
23. What is the significance of the Duke of Buckingham's role in the story?
24. How does Milady's plan unfold, and how does D'Artagnan react to it?
25. What is the climax of the novel, and how does it affect the characters?
Diane wrote: "Review thread: https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...For the movie buffs. Richard Lester’s “The Three Musketeers” (1973) and “The Four Musketeers” (1974) both ..."
Thank you for this tip -- I am working my way through the Criterion Collection, so I can kill 2 (or 3) birds with 1 stone!
Mod
He is young when he starts, so he grows up throughout the story.
2. What are the bonds between the three musketeers, and what does their motto "All for one, and one for all" mean to them?
Loyality to each other and the king or the crown.
3. How does D'Artagnan relate to the queen, Constance Bonacieux, and Milady de Winter? What is the nature of their connections?
4. What are the strengths and weaknesses of Athos, Porthos, and Aramis? How do these differences contribute to their individual stories?
Well these men do like to drink and they are all good swordsmen. Athos is the father figure of the group. Porthos is strong but preoccupied with fashion, appearances, and making a fortune. Aramis is known for his charm, sharp intellect, and romanticism but he wants to become a priest.
5. How does the relationship between D'Artagnan and the Musketeers evolve, especially as they face challenges together?
D’Artagnan starts off as young and inexperienced. Their relationship evolves into mutual respect.
6. What is Milady's motivation, and how does it drive her actions throughout the story?
Oh my goodness this woman drove me crazy. Revenge against Athos, hatred for D’Artagnan and self preservation.
7. How do Dumas's female characters, like Constance and Milady, influence the plot and characters' decisions?
8. How does the novel use historical events and characters, and how does it deviate from historical accuracy?
The real characters are the King, Cardinal Richelieu, Queen Anne, and the Duke of Buckingham (which Buckingham Palace was named after which I thought was cool). I hear D’Artagnan was based off an actual person.
9. What is the role of destiny and fate in the story?
D’Artagnan becomes the hero.
10. How does Dumas create suspense and excitement? How do the chapter endings contribute to the pacing?
“The chapter endings, often featuring dramatic cliffhangers, were originally designed to keep readers hooked on his serialized newspaper stories.”
Mod
12. How does the novel comment on the social and political climate of France during the time period? The Cardinal was in charge that was for sure.
13. Is The Three Musketeers a bildungsroman? Does it follow the typical structure of a coming-of-age story? First of all I had to look up bildungsroman (a novel dealing with one person's formative years or spiritual education). D’Artagnan certainly gets life experience throughout the novel so yes a coming of age story.
14. What is the significance of the king's character? Does he seem like a wise and just ruler? Sometimes Kings are just figure heads and that was true of Louie XIII.
15. What is the role of the Cardinal Richelieu? How does he shape the events of the story? The Cardinal represented the power struggle of the time period.
16. How does Dumas characterize the Musketeers as well-developed stereotypes? Are there any ways they transcend these stereotypes? I would say the stereotype is that this story is a good vs evil plot and all is well by the end of the story.
17. How does Dumas portray vice and violence in the novel? Are these scenes arbitrary, or do they serve a purpose in the story? The Musketeers liked to drink and gamble.
18. What are the motivations and inner conflicts of D'Artagnan? How does he navigate these conflicts? Love vs loyalty. Good vs evil.
19. How do the Musketeers' individual stories contribute to the overall themes of the novel? They are flawed individuals who have a noble job.
**Note: every time I wanted to type Musketeers, I mistakenly typed Mouseketeers. I think I caught all of those, but be patient.1. What is D'Artagnan's journey like? How does he grow and change throughout the story?
He is young and foolhardy in the first few chapters, ready to duel anyone he meets. It’s kind of unbelievable how quickly he learns about court intrigues and takes charge of the Three Musketeers. See question #13 below. I guess he’s more mature at the end, maybe shown by his making peace with Rochefort.
2. What are the bonds between the three musketeers, and what does their motto "All for one, and one for all" mean to them?
I think the motto is self-explanatory – each musketeer will defend the others, and they will all leap in to help a fellow musketeer, even if it means risking their life. It was never clear to me how the original three musketeers became so bonded; they are presented as already inseparable. They immediately bond with D’Artagnan because he’s brave and a good fighter…?
3. How does D'Artagnan relate to the queen, Constance Bonacieux, and Milady de Winter? What is the nature of their connections?
He never really meets the queen but automatically comes to her aid and defense because she is his sovereign. He first meets Constance as a damsel in distress, which may be one reason he falls for her – he likes being the hero/protector of women. And although he loves Constance, this doesn’t prevent him from sleeping with Milady. He is seduced by her, as apparently all men are. When he “wakes” from this sexual stupor and realizes her true character, he loathes her.
4. What are the strengths and weaknesses of Athos, Porthos, and Aramis? How do these differences contribute to their individual stories?
They are all brave, skilled fighters, and loyal to their fellow musketeers and to their country. Porthos is big and tough but kind of dumb…? He puts on a big front of fancy clothing and fine apartment, but it’s a false front (as the belt he is wearing when D’Artagnan first runs into him. Athos seems truly hurt by Milady's betrayal but pretends not to care (just as he pretends that he is not really hurt when when D’Artagnan first runs into him). And Aramis is religious and devout but also having affairs although he is very discreet about them (as he is hiding a lady’s letter to protect her reputation when D’Artagnan first runs into him).
5. How does the relationship between D'Artagnan and the Musketeers evolve, especially as they face challenges together?
See question #1 above. At first, he takes their advice about how to live in Paris. But very quickly, he takes charge of them.
6. What is Milady's motivation, and how does it drive her actions throughout the story?
In chapter 31 we find out that she is a widow and that her child is the heir to Lord de Winter’s estate and title. As it turns out, she is Athos’s wife, presumed dead. In chapter 52, Dumas writes that she hates everything she once loved. Revenge seems her main motivation.
7. How do Dumas's female characters, like Constance and Milady, influence the plot and characters' decisions?
The women seem smarter than some of the men and are certainly as adventurous. D’Artagnan falls in love with Constance so he will do anything to help her and, by extension, the queen. He seems more sexually obsessed by Milady. Milady takes over the plot for about 10 chapters, when she is captured by Lord de Winter. I was surprised how little the Cardinal and Rochefort figured in the last half of the book.
8. How does the novel use historical events and characters, and how does it deviate from historical accuracy?
I am not very familiar with the era, but based on what I’ve read, many of the characters are all based on real people: Richelieu, Louis XIII, Queen Anne, the Duke of Buckingham. There is even a real person who inspired D’Artagnan.
10. How does Dumas create suspense and excitement? How do the chapter endings contribute to the pacing?
The book was initially serialized, so each chapter had to end with a “curtain line” (according to the introduction to the Penguin edition) – what we would call a cliff hanger. The introduction also notes that the serial format also discouraged a lot of exposition or description; Dumas has to get right into the action.
11. What themes are explored in the novel, such as honor, loyalty, friendship, justice, and revenge?
As discussed above, the three musketeers are the clearest illustration of the theme of loyalty and Milady the clearest example of someone motivated by revenge. This is also clear in her death, as all the men who condemn her to death have been wronged by her. Many men in the book would rather die than lose their honor (e.g. Bicarat in the first fight with the cardinal’s guards).
12. How does the novel comment on the social and political climate of France during the time period?
My biggest takeaway was that the king was an idiot and the cardinal a huge hypocrite. So both church and state are critiqued as either useless or false.
13. Is The Three Musketeers a bildungsroman? Does it follow the typical structure of a coming-of-age story?
I don’t think it’s follows the typical structure because D’Artagnan “comes of age” almost immediately. Although he is younger than the three Musketeers and has less experience, they almost immediately start looking to him for ideas and plans.
14. What is the significance of the king’s character? Does he seem like a wise and just ruler?
See question #12 above.
15. What is the role of the Cardinal Richelieu? How does he shape the events of the story?
See question #12 above.
21. Discuss D'Artagnan's first meeting with the musketeers and his subsequent challenges.
As discussed in question #4 above, he gets into a conflict in his first meeting with each of them, and these incidents reveals something fundamental about the character of each musketeer. Their weaknesses are hinted at, challenges D’Artagnan will have to face to get them motivated in the second half of the book (e.g., Aramis saying he is going to take orders and join the church when really, he had his feelings hurt by his lover).
23. What is the significance of the Duke of Buckingham's role in the story?
He starts the war between France and England, primarily to win the heart of the queen…? As such he’s a primary enemy/target of the kind, the cardinal, and by extension Milady. The Musketeers work to protect him but only because of his relationship with the queen.
25. What is the climax of the novel, and how does it affect the characters?
I guess this would be the death of Constance and the capture and subsequent execution of Milady. It primarily affects D’Artagnan, as it is the only real disappointment and loss he faces in the book. And Athos is finally able to get revenge on the wife who duped him.
For the movie buffs. Richard Lester’s “The Three Musketeers” (1973) and “The Four Musketeers” (1974) both have now been restored in 4K part of the Criterion Collection. (Enthusiasts may select a two-disc Blu-ray set or a four-disc 4K UHD/Blu-ray combo pack.)