Nothing But Reading Challenges discussion
Let's Talk About: Genre
>
Does this genre exist?
date
newest »


I also thought of the Dexter series, but I've never been a fan of reading a series after watching the film/show.




Dystopia is a sub-category of sci fi. Dystopican novels tend to be an alternate reality or futuristic adaptation of what could happen to our society. Very few of them happen in current urban environments. I feel it fits better into the sci-fi category for these reasons then in any type of fantasy. I would say they don't fit urban fantasy specifically because of the futuristic element of the stories.
Urban fantasy to me is that it could be happening right under our noses at this very minute. For example, the Vampire Academy books hide an entire society of vampires that we as humans don't perceive. Or in Harry Potter there's a magical realm they keep hidden from the muggles. That type of thing.
Just my 2 cents. Hope it helps.

I read the first book and the TV show is much better. The book jumps around and if you hadn't watched the show, you really couldn't follow it. I'm not sure how anyone was able to see the potential of this story since it was so poorly written.

A couple of fantasy novels that involve secret identities are The Thief by Megan Whalen Turner, Swordspoint by Ellen Kushner, and Luck in the Shadows by Lynn Flewelling.

Everything else is, in my opinion, just sub-genre.
People here place books wherever they like, which is, more than half percent, wrong (not that you can tell someone´s opinion is wrong)
For example: Paranormal is NOT fantasy, but members here place it under the same word
Books mentioned in this topic
The Thief (other topics)Swordspoint (other topics)
Luck in the Shadows (other topics)
I just think it would be interesting to read about a character that either:
1: Is a con man (or woman) that tries to have a normal life/normal family, but their past keeps coming back
or
2: The main character has a second family or lover they are trying to keep secret but their family is starting to find out.