Goodreads Librarians Group discussion

Hello everyone,

I've read the Librarian Manual after adding this book as a different edition of Siddhartha and I was going to change it. Now I know I shouldn't have combined this edition with the others, but I have some questions:

1. Should I change the name of this book to Demian/Sidarta as these are the two titles in one book?

or

2. Should I make two differet books, one Demian and another Sidarta, with the same ISBN?

The first way people would not be able to rate each title separated. So intuitively I would go for the second option but I don't know if that's possible.

What should I do?

You can't make two editions with the same isbn. your option 1 is correct, the data should be as the book is.
If people want to rate the two works separate, they can add an other edition of the books to their shelves.

Thanks, I'm going to do it right now.