Goodreads Librarians Group discussion

Just a random request - Instead of just putting the United States as the setting, please try and be as specific as possible. Some groups do location challenges and it helps to have to the states, provinces, etc.

Fair enough - I'll try to remember - but I'm not a very active librarian so I hope others see and empathize with your request. :)

On the other hand, being too specific sometimes doesn't help. A book with a setting of Tinytown, Nebraska won't show up under "Nebraska" books.

Can't we have two tags for settings? I just did, for One More River, and it seems like it worked fine. I did have to save the first, then go back in and 'edit the details' again to 'add a new setting' for the second. So, you could tag it first for Tinytown, Nebraska, and then again for Nebraska?

You could, but that's unbelievably clunky and just adds to the clutter up there in the book data.

Well, I don't find it overly clunky or cluttery *personally* (though I do respect that you would, Lobstergirl), and I'll put it in if I think it relevant and remember to accede to Heather's request.

I wanna be nice to everyone, but 'you can't please all of the people all of the time.' :)