Addicted to YA discussion
Stand Alone
>
Before I Fall
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Erika, Dream Thief
(new)
Jul 01, 2012 05:48AM

reply
|
flag


I guess I just wanted everything to be all happy and dandy....
I know
I'm lame
I liked it a lot, maybe even better than Delirium, but they were so different I can't really compare them!


The ending was a little confusing, but I gathered that Juliet lived though I am not sure how Sam's sacrifice would prevent her from just trying to commit suicide on another day.

The book was a bit confusing, and I had the almost the same questions as Katie did~ Honestly it got a little boring towards the middle, just because the story was repeating the same day over and over.

I liked Kent and thought he had an amazing personality and big heart. He saw the real Sam and knew that making new friends and the whole politics of high school can change who you hang out with and your attitude towards others. Sam needed to fit in and feel "cool" by her peers. I guess in retrospect she realized that some of those things don't even matter in the end.
I didn't like how the story kept repeating the day over and over. I know why the author did this but it was quite boring for me. I wish it was written a different way. I was tired of reliving the same day over with Sam. I guess that's why the ending wasn't a big shocker to me. I kept thinking she'll just do it all over again if she needs to.
The ending just wasn't satisfying for me. I wish Juliet could have been saved some other way.



I did like the conversation with Anna in the bathroom and the fact that no matter her efforts sarah was still late.
This book surprised me a lot because I read Delirium before and was expecting something similar to Delirium (well, not really similar, but in the same realm, if you know what I mean), but it turned out to be completely different! I can comfortably say that if I didn't know the author of the books I would have said that they were two different authors. Which I think is great of Lauren Oliver because I don't like authors who all of their books are the exact same.


Her realization kicks in, which I like. At least she learned a lesson. But like I said, she should have correct things earlier. Time is precious and shouldn't be wasted.

She accepted it all.












For a lot of people, this book was terribly stretched and drawn out. It was repetitive, I'll admit, but I kind of like that.
I haven't gotten a chance to see the movie, though I want to.

Oh! Here in Italy is not available yet eheheehh ;)